Maddock v The Queen
[2020] VSCA 271
Citation 1
…to illustrate (although not define) the possible range of sentences available. [3]Prosecuting counsel referred me to R v Galetta [2007] VSCA 177; Maddock v The Queen (2020) VSCA 271; Melnikas v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to D…
DPP v Caulfield
[2019] VSCA 131
Citation 2
…007] VSCA 177; Maddock v The Queen (2020) VSCA 271; Melnikas v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018] VCC 248; and DPP v Scott [2017] VCC 1907. 49Ultimately, whilst having r…
Thorpe v The Queen
[2016] VSCA 158
Citation 3
…counsel referred me to R v Galetta [2007] VSCA 177; Maddock v The Queen (2020) VSCA 271; Melnikas v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018] VCC 248; and DPP v Scott [2017] VC…
Melnikas v The Queen
[2016] VSCA 112
Citation 4
…sentences available. [3]Prosecuting counsel referred me to R v Galetta [2007] VSCA 177; Maddock v The Queen (2020) VSCA 271; Melnikas v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018…
Markovic v The Queen
[2010] VSCA 105
Citation 5
…rge – guilty plea – substantial reparation – family hardship – impact of COVID-19 Cases Cited: Markovic v The Queen; Pantelic v The Queen [2010] VSCA 105; Boulton v R (2014) 46 VR 308; Sentence: Community correction order for 3 years with unpaid community work…
R v Galletta
[2007] VSCA 177
Citation 6
…that may be able to illustrate (although not define) the possible range of sentences available. [3]Prosecuting counsel referred me to R v Galetta [2007] VSCA 177; Maddock v The Queen (2020) VSCA 271; Melnikas v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defe…
DPP (Cth) v Gaw
[2006] VSCA 51
Citation 7
…s is not an automatic ‘passport to freedom’, but simply one factor that can be taken into account in sentence.[1] [1]See, eg, DPP (Cth) v Gaw [2006] VSCA 51, [21].…
Tsiadis v Patterson
[2001] VSCA 138
Citation 8
…ith deliberate repeated acts of dishonesty, and substantial amounts of money involved.[2] [2]See, eg, Director of Public Prosecutions v Bulfin [1998] 4 VR 114, 132. 46By contrast, the weight which needs to be accorded to the sentencing purposes of specific deterrence and community protection in your case is…
DPP v Howard
[2018] VCC 967
Citation 9
…v The Queen [2016] VSCA 112; Thorpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018] VCC 248; and DPP v Scott [2017] VCC 1907. 49Ultimately, whilst having regard to these cases, I have sentenced you in this case on t…
DPP v Moeller
[2018] VCC 248
Citation 10
…horpe v The Queen [2016] VSCA 158; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018] VCC 248; and DPP v Scott [2017] VCC 1907. 49Ultimately, whilst having regard to these cases, I have sentenced you in this case on the basis of the application of…
DPP v Scott
[2017] VCC 1907
Citation 11
…8; and DPP v Caulfield [2019] VSCA 131. Defence counsel referred me to DPP v Howard [2018] VCC 967; DPP v Moeller [2018] VCC 248; and DPP v Scott [2017] VCC 1907. 49Ultimately, whilst having regard to these cases, I have sentenced you in this case on the basis of the application of the principles to the specific f…