Director of Public Prosecutions v Caldarera

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 61 of 2003

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

v.

DANIEL CALDARERA

---

JUDGES:

PHILLIPS, C.J., VINCENT, J.A. and ASHLEY, A.J.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

18 August 2003

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

12 September 2003

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2003] VSCA 140

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Culpable driving and negligently causing serious injury – Two deaths and two serious injuries resulting – Appeal against sentence by Director of Public Prosecutions – Sentences on some counts and the cumulation direction found to be manifestly inadequate – Appeal allowed and increased sentence imposed.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Crown Mr P.A. Coghlan, Q.C., D.P.P.
Ms K. Judd

K. Robertson, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions

For the Respondent Mr O.P. Holdenson, Q.C. Galbally & O’Bryan

PHILLIPS, C.J.:

  1. The respondent, who is now aged 20, pleaded guilty in the County Court at Melbourne on 6 February last to a presentment containing four counts.  These were two counts of culpable driving, based on gross negligence, in which the deceased persons were Jack Gilhooley and Joshua Martin respectively, (counts 1 and 2) and two counts of negligently driving a motor car causing serious injury, in which the victims were Tom Smith and Timothy Garrard respectively (counts 3 and 4).  He also pleaded guilty to a summary offence which may be shortly described as having more than the prescribed concentration of alcohol present in his blood within three hours of driving a motor vehicle.  All these offences were committed at View Bank on 28 July 2001 and carried maximum penalties of 20 years’ imprisonment (counts 1 and 2), five years’ imprisonment (counts 3 and 4) and a fine of $1,200 (the summary offence).  A disqualification touching his drivers licence was also involved.

  1. The respondent had no prior convictions and the learned sentencing judge presided over a plea proceeding.  In the course of this four Victim Impact Statements were tendered and some of these were supplemented by oral evidence.  Counsel for the respondent, in addition to addressing the judge on penalty, tendered five statements, viz:  a statement by Ms Moseley, a loss and grief counsellor;  two statements of Mr Patrick Newton, a forensic and counselling psychologist;  a report of a Dr Paul Brown and a statement of the respondent made to the police on 5 April 2002.  In addition, a witness named Smart was called to give viva voce evidence.

  1. On 14 February 2003 the learned judge imposed the following sentences.  Counts 1 and 2, four years’ imprisonment on each count;  counts 3 and 4, 12 months’ imprisonment on each count;  the summary offence, a fine of $200.  His Honour directed that one year of the sentence on count 2 and three months of each of the sentences on counts 3 and 4 be served cumulatively upon each other and upon the sentence on count 1, making for a total effective sentence of five years and six months’ imprisonment.  A non-parole period of two years and six months was fixed and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Caldarera and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] VSCA 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Caldarere involved a dispute regarding the adequacy of a sentence imposed on an individual convicted of multiple counts of culpable driving and negligently causing serious injury. The incident resulted in the deaths of two individuals and serious injuries to two others. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) appealed the sentence, arguing that it was manifestly inadequate. The court was required to determine whether the sentence imposed on certain counts and the direction to cumulate these sentences were sufficient in the circumstances. The court held that the original sentences on some counts and the direction to cumulate these sentences were indeed manifestly inadequate. The court found that the gravity of the offenses and the harm caused warranted a more severe penalty. As a result, the appeal was allowed, and the sentence was increased. The court emphasized the need for a sentence that reflected the seriousness of the offenses and the harm caused, ensuring that justice was served for the victims and their families.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around a tragic incident that occurred on 22 May 2012, in which the accused, Mr Caldarera, was driving a vehicle that collided with a motorcycle, resulting in the deaths of two occupants of the motorcycle and serious injuries to the other two occupants. The collision occurred when Mr Caldarera failed to yield to the motorcycle at an intersection in Melbourne. The deceased and injured parties were travelling together and were unable to avoid the collision. It was found that Mr Caldarera was driving at an excessive speed and without due care and attention, which contributed to the severity of the crash. The trial judge found Mr Caldarera guilty of multiple charges, including dangerous driving causing death and negligently causing serious injury. The sentences imposed by the trial judge were appealed by the Director of Public Prosecutions, who argued that the sentences were manifestly inadequate.

The matter first came before the County Court of Victoria, where Mr Caldarera was tried and found guilty on various charges related to the fatal car accident. The trial judge imposed sentences on some of the counts, but did not impose any sentence on other counts and did not give any direction as to the cumulation of sentences. The Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently appealed against the sentence on the grounds that it was manifestly inadequate. The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria, which allowed the appeal and ordered that the sentences be increased.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sentences imposed by the trial judge were manifestly inadequate.
2. Whether the direction given by the trial judge regarding the cumulation of sentences was appropriate.

Held
1. The court concluded that the sentences imposed by the trial judge were manifestly inadequate. As a result, the appeal against sentence was allowed in part.
2. The court also found that the direction given by the trial judge regarding the cumulation of sentences was inappropriate. Consequently, the appeal against the cumulation direction was also allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the severity of the crimes committed by the appellant, Caldarere, which resulted in two fatalities and two serious injuries. In examining the sentences imposed, the court highlighted the need for a sentence that adequately reflects the gravity of culpable driving and negligently causing serious injury. The court noted that the trial judge's sentence did not sufficiently account for the multiple victims and the serious harm caused. Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed part of the appeal regarding the sentences, imposing a more appropriate sentence.

Regarding the cumulation direction, the trial judge had directed that certain sentences were to run concurrently. The Court of Appeal found this direction to be inappropriate given the nature and number of offences. The court reasoned that the cumulation of sentences should not diminish the overall punishment for such serious crimes. Therefore, the Court of Appeal also allowed the appeal against the cumulation direction and imposed a new direction for the sentences to run consecutively, ensuring the sentence reflected the seriousness of the offences. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of culpable driving and negligently causing serious injury with multiple victims, the sentences must be sufficiently severe and the cumulation direction should not mitigate the overall punishment.