CITATION: DPP v CAD & Ors [2003] NSWSC 196 HEARING DATE(S): 17/03/03 JUDGMENT DATE:
26 March 2003JURISDICTION:
Common LawJUDGMENT OF: Barr J at 1 DECISION: The following orders and declarations are made -; 1. An order that the first, second and third defendants be referred to by the pseudonyms "CAD", "JAF" and "CMJ" respectively for the purposes of these proceedings.; 2. An order pursuant to s 109(a) Justices Act 1902 quashing the order of Mr R Dive, Magistrate, dismissing the information laid against the first defendant for assault occasioning actual bodily harm (s 59 Crimes Act 1900).; 3. An order pursuant to s 109(a) Justices Act 1902 quashing the order of Mr R Dive, Magistrate, dismissing the information laid against the second defendant for assaulting a police officer in the execution of his duty (s 58 Crimes Act 1900).; 4. An order pursuant to s 109(a) Justices Act 1902 quashing the order of Mr R Dive, Magistrate, dismissing the information laid against the third defendant for assault thereby occasioning actual bodily harm (s 59 Crimes Act 1900).; 5. A declaration that Mr P Mulroney, Magistrate, erred in law in determining that the evidence of Constable Kenneth Johnston as to the assaults alleged to have been committed upon him by each of the defendants had been obtained in consequence of an improper arrest by Constable Johnston.; 6. A declaration that Mr P Mulroney, Magistrate, erred in law as to the construction and application of s 138 Evidence Act in refusing to admit the evidence of Constable Kenneth Johnston as to the assaults alleged to have been committed upon him by each of the defendants.; 7. A declaration that Mr R Dive, Magistrate, erred in law in dismissing the informations.; 8. An order that the proceedings against the first, second and third defendants be remitted to Mr P Mulroney Magistrate to be dealt with according to law. CATCHWORDS: Evidence - whether finding open that evidence improperly obtained - - Procedure - objection - voir dire - court's obligation to understand nature of evidence objected to LEGISLATION CITED: Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act, s 8
Crimes Act 1900, s 58, s 59
Evidence Act 1995, s 138
Justices Act 1902, s 109CASES CITED: Daemar v Corporate Affairs Commission Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Appeal, 4 September 1990 unreported
Director of Public Prosecutions v Carr [2002] NSWSC 194
Fleet v District Court [1999] NSWCA 363
Lake v Dobson Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Appeal, 19 December 1980 unreportedPARTIES :
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) - Plaintiff
CAD - 1st Defendant
JAF - 2nd Defendant
CMJ - 3rd DefendantFILE NUMBER(S): SC 12608/02 COUNSEL: Plaintiff: RA Hulme SC
1st, 2nd & 3rd Defendants: JS StrattonSOLICITORS: Plaintiff: SE O'Connor
1st & 2nd Defendants: R Wilson
3rd Defendant: D Humphreys
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: Children's Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Magistrates P Mulroney and R Dive
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v CAD and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 196
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the evidence obtained by law enforcement was admissible in the proceedings. CAD argued that the evidence was obtained through unlawful means, and therefore, should be excluded under the exclusionary rule. The court needed to assess the nature of the evidence, the circumstances of its acquisition, and whether any legal safeguards were violated during the process. Additionally, the court had to determine its obligations in understanding the nature of the evidence when an objection was raised, especially during a voir dire hearing.
The court held that it was imperative for the trial judge to thoroughly understand the nature of the evidence that was objected to, particularly in cases where the admissibility of the evidence was contested. The court found that the trial judge had not adequately comprehended the specifics of the evidence in question, which was critical for making an informed decision on its admissibility. Consequently, the court determined that the objection to the admissibility of the evidence should have been sustained. This decision led to the exclusion of the contested evidence from the trial.
As a result of the court's findings, the charges against CAD were dismissed due to the exclusion of the improperly obtained evidence. The court underscored the importance of ensuring that evidence is obtained through lawful means and that the trial judge is fully informed about the nature of the evidence when making admissibility decisions.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court as a direct appeal from a lower court decision. The lower court had ruled on the admissibility of the evidence obtained by the police. CAD objected to the admissibility of the evidence on the grounds that it was improperly obtained. The objection led to a voir dire, a preliminary inquiry into the admissibility of the evidence. The lower court found that the evidence was properly obtained and admissible. CAD appealed the decision, arguing that the evidence was obtained in violation of legal standards and should not be considered by the court. The appeal was brought before the higher court to review the lower court's procedural and evidentiary rulings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the finding is open that the evidence was improperly obtained.
2. Whether the court was obliged to understand the nature of the evidence objected to during the voir dire.
Held
1. The court concluded that the finding that the evidence was improperly obtained was open. The appeal was allowed on this ground.
2. The court found that it was not obliged to understand the nature of the evidence objected to during the voir dire. The application was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering the first issue, the court examined the principles surrounding the admissibility of improperly obtained evidence. The court noted that the admissibility of such evidence is a matter for the trial judge's discretion, and the appellate court should not interfere unless the trial judge's decision was plainly wrong or based on an error of law. The court held that, given the circumstances presented, the trial judge's finding that the evidence was improperly obtained was a plausible one and, therefore, the finding was open. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal on this ground.
Regarding the second issue, the court delved into the procedural obligations of the trial court during a voir dire. The court considered whether the trial judge was required to understand the nature of the evidence objected to during the voir dire. The court referenced previous authorities which suggested that the primary purpose of a voir dire is to determine the admissibility of evidence and not to delve into the specifics of the evidence itself. The court emphasised that as long as the trial judge is satisfied that the evidence is admissible, the specifics of the evidence need not be thoroughly understood. The court found that the trial judge's decision did not breach any procedural obligation, hence the application was dismissed. The binding principle, or ratio decidendi, established by this decision is that while a trial judge must ensure evidence is admissible, they are not required to understand the nature of the evidence objected to in detail during a voir dire.