CITATION: DPP v Brown [2005] NSWSC 870
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.HEARING DATE(S): 19/07/2005, 28/7/2005
JUDGMENT DATE :
28 July 2005JUDGMENT OF: Howie J at 1
DECISION: The Court orders: (1) Payment out of the monies held by the Public Trustee of the following sums: (a) $30,800 (incl. GST) in relation to preparation to date and legal costs of committal proceedings (b) $3,500 for a medical report by a neurosurgeon. The applicant is allowed costs of these proceedings.
CATCHWORDS: Forfeiture of assets - application for variation of restraining order in respect of funds arising from a murder suspect selling her version of events to the media while under police investigation - variation granted to permit funding of legal representation.
LEGISLATION CITED: Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act 1989 - ss 4, 43(2), 43(6)
CASES CITED: New South Wales Crime Commission v Younan (1993) 31 NSWLR 44
R v Weightman (NSWSC, unreported, 23 June 2004)PARTIES: Director of Public Prosecutions v Karen Alma Brown
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 12457/2004
COUNSEL: A. Bellanto with G. Jones - Applicant
I. Temby QC - RespondentSOLICITORS: Mark Rumore - Applicant
S. Kavanagh - Respondent
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONHOWIE J
12457/2004 DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS vTUESDAY 30 AUGUST 2005
KAREN ALMA BROWN
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: On 28 July 2005 the Court made orders for the payment of monies held by the Public Trustee to Karen Alma Brown (the applicant) for payment by her on account of legal fees and the preparation of a report of a neurosurgeon in connection with her defence of a charge of murder. The amount of money to be paid to the applicant totalled $34,300. These are the reasons for the making of those orders.
2 By Notice of Motion the applicant sought a variation of a restraining order made by this Court on 3 August 2004 in order to provide her with legal and other expenses pursuant to s 43(6) of the Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act (the Act). The section provides:
(6) A restraining order may be made subject to such conditions as the Supreme Court thinks fit and, without limiting the generality of this, may make provision for meeting out of the property, or a specified part of the property, to which the order applies all or any of the following:
- (a) the defendant’s reasonable living expenses (including the reasonable living expenses of the defendant’s dependants (if any)) and reasonable business expenses,
- (b) the defendant’s reasonable expenses in defending a criminal charge.
3 The background to the restraining order is as follows. On 26 July 2004 the applicant, who was then a security officer, was attacked by a person attempting to rob her of money that she had in her custody in the course of her employment. At the time of the attack she had $45,000 in cash in a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Brown and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 870
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the suspect had a right to legal representation and that it was in the interests of justice for her to have the means to secure such representation. The court found that the suspect was not using the funds for any criminal purpose and that the variation would not interfere with the investigation or trial. The court varied the restraining order to allow the suspect to use the funds to pay for her legal representation, subject to certain conditions.
The court ordered that the restraining order be varied to permit the suspect to use the funds to pay for her legal representation, provided that she did not use the funds for any other purpose and that she kept the court informed of how the funds were being used. The court also ordered that the suspect's legal representatives keep the court informed of the status of the investigation and any potential trial.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court as an application for variation of a restraining order. Brown had initially been subject to a restraining order which prohibited her from accessing certain funds obtained from the media sale of her version of events. The application for variation sought permission to use some of these funds to pay for her legal representation. The application was heard following the initial restraining order and before any trial or conviction in relation to the murder charge. The court had to consider the circumstances under which the funds were obtained and the necessity of the variation for the fair administration of justice.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application for variation of the restraining order should be granted to permit the use of the funds for legal representation.
2. Whether permitting the use of the funds for legal representation would be consistent with the objectives of the forfeiture legislation and the administration of justice.
Held
1. The court granted the application for variation of the restraining order to permit the use of the funds for legal representation.
2. The court found that permitting the use of the funds for legal representation would be consistent with the objectives of the forfeiture legislation and the administration of justice.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the application for variation of the restraining order, focusing on whether it was appropriate to permit the use of the funds for legal representation. In assessing the first issue, the Court recognised the importance of ensuring that individuals have access to legal representation, which is fundamental to the administration of justice. The Court acknowledged that permitting the suspect to use the funds for legal representation would not undermine the objectives of the forfeiture legislation, which primarily aims to prevent individuals from benefiting from criminal activities.
In its reasoning, the Court examined relevant statutory provisions and case law. The Court noted that the forfeiture legislation was designed to prevent criminals from retaining the proceeds of their crimes, but it also recognised the necessity of balancing this objective with the fundamental rights to a fair trial and legal representation. The Court distinguished the current situation from cases where the use of funds for legal representation would directly benefit the criminal enterprise or circumvent the forfeiture order.
Furthermore, the Court highlighted that the suspect's sale of her version of events to the media while under investigation was not itself a criminal activity that would justify forfeiting her right to legal representation. By allowing the use of the funds for legal representation, the Court aimed to uphold the suspect's right to a fair trial, which is integral to the administration of justice.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that, in certain circumstances, the court may permit the use of forfeited funds for legal representation to ensure compliance with the principles of natural justice and the right to a fair trial, provided it does not undermine the objectives of the forfeiture legislation. The Court's decision reflects a balanced approach that recognises the importance of legal representation in the criminal justice system while maintaining the integrity of the forfeiture process.