Director of Public Prosecutions v Ayyad [Ruling]

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

CRIMINAL DIVISION

S CR 2014 60

THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Prosecution
v  
WAGDY AYYAD Accused

---

JUDGE:

Bongiorno JA

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

30 October 2014

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

5 November 2014

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

DPP v Ayyad [Ruling]

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2014] VSC 629

---

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE – Alternative verdicts on uncharged offences – Attempted defensive homicide as uncharged alternative to attempted murder – Whether allegation of attempted defensive homicide included in allegation of attempted murder – Crimes Act 1958, ss 9AC, 9AD – Criminal Procedure Act 2009, s 239

---  

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Crown Mr P D’Arcy Office of Public Prosecutions
For the Accused Mr D Sheales Maselli & Associates

HIS HONOUR:

  1. Wagdy Ayyad stood trial before this Court on an indictment alleging attempted murder and alternative charges of intentionally causing serious injury and recklessly causing serious injury.  The question arose during the trial as to whether the offence of attempted defensive homicide should be left as an available verdict for the jury’s consideration.  I determined that attempted defensive homicide was not an available alternative verdict in this case and gave short reasons for reaching that conclusion.  This revised ruling expresses those reasons in greater detail.

  1. The offence of defensive homicide was inserted as s 9AD of the Crimes Act 1958 by the Crimes (Homicide) Act 2005 (77/2005) and was abolished by the Crimes Amendment (Abolition of Defensive Homicide) Act 2014 (63/2014). Thus, it is only available as a verdict for homicides alleged to have been committed between 23 November 2005 and 1 November 2014. Section 9AD was in the following terms:

9AD Defensive homicide

A person who, by his or her conduct, kills another person in circumstances that, but for section 9AC, would constitute murder, is guilty of an indictable offence (defensive homicide) and liable to level 3 imprisonment (20 years maximum) if he or she did not have reasonable grounds for the belief referred to in that section.

Section 9AC was as follows:

9AC Murder—“self-defence”

A person is not guilty of murder if he or she carries out the conduct that would otherwise constitute murder while believing the conduct to be necessary to defend himself or herself or another person from the infliction of death or really serious injury.

  1. The indictment upon which Mr Ayyad was tried contained no particulars of the circumstances of the offences alleged beyond the bare assertion of their having been committed, by reference to their statutory descriptions, on a specific date and at an identified place.  Although attempted defensive homicide was not pleaded by the Crown as an alternative offence, it seemed to have been common ground between the prosecution and defence counsel, at least in the early stages of the trial, that, as well as the charges on the indictment, attempted defensive homicide was an available verdict in this case.  However, neither party advanced any argument based on attempted defensive homicide…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Ayyad [Ruling] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] VSC 629
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ayyad involved the defendant who was charged with attempted murder. The prosecution was required to decide whether the allegation of attempted defensive homicide was included within the allegation of attempted murder. The High Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether an alternative verdict of attempted defensive homicide could be considered by the jury in this case. The central issue was whether the alternative verdict of attempted defensive homicide could be considered by the jury when the primary charge was attempted murder, and if the allegation of attempted defensive homicide was necessarily included within the allegation of attempted murder under the relevant sections of the Crimes Act 1958 and the Criminal Procedure Act 2009.

The court examined the relevant statutory provisions, specifically sections 9AC and 9AD of the Crimes Act 1958, and section 239 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009. The High Court held that for an alternative verdict to be available, the uncharged offence must necessarily be included within the charged offence. The court found that attempted defensive homicide was not necessarily included within the charge of attempted murder, as the two offences required different elements to be proven. The court emphasised that the prosecution must establish each element of the offence charged, and the jury must be directed to consider whether each element has been proven beyond reasonable doubt. The court concluded that the alternative verdict of attempted defensive homicide could not be considered by the jury in this case, as it was not necessarily included within the allegation of attempted murder.

Consequently, the High Court ruled that the trial judge's direction to the jury was incorrect, and the conviction was quashed. The court found that the trial judge should not have directed the jury to consider the alternative verdict of attempted defensive homicide, as it was not necessarily included within the allegation of attempted murder. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the jury is properly directed on the elements of the offence charged and that alternative verdicts are only considered when they are necessarily included within the charged offence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established