Director of Public Prosecutions v Avalos (a pseudonym)

Link copied
Case Copied 93 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCR 2022 0078
THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Appellant
v
DILAN AVALOS (A PSEUDONYM)[1] Respondent

[1]To ensure that here is no possibility of identification, this judgment has been anonymised by the adoption of a pseudonym in place of the names of the respondent and witnesses.

---

JUDGES: FERGUSON CJ, PRIEST AP and T FORREST JA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 27 March 2023 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 17 May 2023
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2023] VSCA 117
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2022] VCC 722 (Judge Riddell)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Sentence – Rape – Causing injury intentionally – Make threat to kill – Assault – Whether individual sentences, orders for cumulation and total effective sentence are manifestly inadequate – Whether sentencing judge erred by failing to properly apply Part 2A of the Sentencing Act 1991 – Whether sentencing judge erred by failing to exercise the discretion in s 6D(b) of the Sentencing Act 1991 – Appeal dismissed.

---

Counsel

Appellant:  Ms RJ Sharp SC with Ms S Clancy
Respondent: Mr PA Chadwick KC with Mr MD Stanton

Solicitors

Appellant: Ms A Hogan, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions
Respondent: Robyn Greensill & Associates

FERGUSON CJ
PRIEST AP
T FORREST JA:

  1. The respondent was tried in the County Court on two indictments which charged him with multiple rapes and other serious offences.

  2. On 4 May 2021, after a 14 day jury trial, the jury convicted the respondent on the first indictment[2] of four charges of rape, five charges of intentionally causing injury, one charge of making a threat to kill and one charge of common law assault. He was sentenced on this indictment to a total effective sentence of 16 years and 7 months’ imprisonment.

    [2]Indictment No H11802169B.4A (‘the first indictment’).

  3. On 11 June 2021, after a 21 day jury trial, the jury convicted the respondent on the second indictment[3] of five charges of rape, five charges of intentionally causing injury, two charges of making a threat to kill and one charge of false imprisonment. He was sentenced on this indictment to a total effective sentence of 18 years and 10 months’ imprisonment.

    [3]Indictment No H11802169C.2 (‘the second indictment’).

  4. Six years and 7 months of the sentence imposed on the first indictment was ordered to be served cumulatively upon the sentence of 18 years and 10 months on the second indictment. The total effective sentence on both indictments was thus 25 years and 5 months’ imprisonment. A minimum non-parole period of 20 years and 10 months’ imprisonment was set.[4]

  5. The table below sets out a more detailed account of the sentences imposed.   

Charge

Offence

Max Penalty

Sentence

Cumulation

Indictment Number H11802169B.4A
1 Rape (contrary to s 38(1) of the Crimes Act 1958) 25 years 3 years 4 months 1 year
2 Rape 25 years 6 years 2 years
5 Causing injury intentionally (contrary to s 18 of the Crimes Act) 10 years
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Avalos (a pseudonym) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] VSCA 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Avalos (a pseudonym) involved the defendant appealing against his sentence, which was handed down after he was found guilty of multiple serious criminal offences, including rape, causing injury intentionally, making threats to kill, and assault. The defendant's appeal focused on the contention that the individual sentences, orders for cumulation, and the total effective sentence were manifestly inadequate. The central issue before the court was whether the sentencing judge erred by not properly applying Part 2A of the Sentencing Act 1991 and by failing to exercise the discretion under section 6D(b) of the same Act. The court had to determine if the sentence imposed was proportionate to the gravity of the offences and adequately served the purposes of sentencing, including community protection, punishment, deterrence, and denunciation.

The court examined the nature and extent of the defendant's criminal history, which spanned two decades and involved multiple victims, all of whom were his intimate partners. The court noted that the defendant's violent and sexually aggressive behaviour was constant and unrelenting, and he had shown a flagrant disregard for the law. Various attempts at therapeutic intervention had failed to prevent reoffending, indicating that only imprisonment had an impact. Despite the defendant's psychiatric diagnosis and medication, the court found that this did not reduce his risk to the community. The sentencing judge concluded that a proportionate sentence could adequately address all sentencing principles, including community protection. The judge noted that the considerable length of the individual sentences, coupled with the scope for cumulation, meant that a disproportionate sentence was unnecessary.

The court rejected the defendant's appeal, finding that the sentencing judge had correctly applied the law and exercised their discretion appropriately. The court emphasised that the defendant's extensive criminal history, the gravity of his offences, and the need to protect the community justified the sentence imposed. The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence stood. The court's reasoning highlighted the importance of considering the totality of the offender's criminal conduct and the need to impose a sentence that adequately reflects the seriousness of the offences and protects the community from further harm.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the appellant, a man identified only as Avalos, who has been convicted of a series of serious offences against multiple women over a period of two decades. These offences include rape, causing injury intentionally, making threats to kill, and assault. The appellant's offending pattern against his intimate partners was extreme, constant, and unrelenting, involving degradation, control, manipulation, and significant acts of violence and sexual aggression. Despite various terms of imprisonment, court orders, and attempts at therapeutic intervention, the appellant continued to offend. He has been diagnosed with a psychiatric condition and is on a medication regime, but this has not reduced his risk of reoffending according to the sentencing judge. The appellant has served nearly five years on remand for these offences.

The case came before the court on appeal against sentence. The appellant argued that the sentences imposed by the primary judge were manifestly inadequate. The appeal focused on whether the sentencing judge erred in not applying Part 2A of the Sentencing Act 1991 and in not exercising the discretion in s 6D(b) of the same Act. The appeal was heard by the court, which reviewed the arguments and the primary judge's assessment of the appellant's risk to the community and the adequacy of the sentences imposed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On this issue the judge stated the following: 474.A disproportionate sentence is very rare indeed. In order to take that step I must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that you will remain a danger to the community even after serving a proportionate sentence.475.According to the Court of Appeal in R v LD, what is required is an assessment of the risk posed to the community to determine how long the prison term needs to be to achieve protection of the community, and a consideration of whether a disproportionate sentence is required to achieve that aim.476.The overall criminality here makes plain that you are an extremely serious risk to the community. Your offending against 4 different women in these trials, and the two other women, all your intimate partners spans two decades. It was extreme. It was constant and unrelenting degradation, control and manipulation punctuated by extreme acts of violence and sexual aggression.477.You met and matched up with those women quickly. They were each vulnerable and your violence began either immediately or very soon after those relationships were formed.478.Various terms of imprisonment, court orders and contact with authorities apparently bounced off you. That is, it seemed to have almost no impact because you continued to offend and to do so in very violent ways. 479.Your flagrant disregard for the law is perhaps best demonstrated by the fact you did parade various of these women at police stations when you reported on bail, even when they were showing injuries which you had caused. You behaved with impunity.480.It is demonstrated by the fact that despite various attempts to have therapeutic intervention, either imposed on you or promised by you, that was apparently of no impact. The only thing which has stopped your offending has been imprisonment. 481.I accept now that you have a formal psychiatric diagnosis and a medication regime. However, given my findings in relation to Verdins limb 1 that fact does not reduce your risk.482.You are still a reasonably young man, now only 43 years of age. You have served just shy of 5 years on remand for this offending. 483.Almost all of the offences reflect serious or very serious examples of serious offences. The objective gravity is very high. The need to impose individual sentences which adequately protect the community, punish and deter you and denounce your conduct, is such that each sentence I impose for the serious offender offences will be of considerable length, even taking into account the mitigating effect of your personal circumstances. Conclusion484.I have no hesitation in being satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that you will continue to pose a serious risk of violent and sexually violent reoffending into the foreseeable future. 485.However, in my view a proportionate sentence here can adequately address all sentencing principles, including the paramountcy of community protection. 486.In my view, an example of where a disproportionate sentence might arise is where a sentencing court is dealing with a serious offender but for a small number of serious offences. The history and personal circumstances of the offender may be such that they will pose a serious risk of reoffending on release from a proportionate sentence. In the face of a limited number of charges where there is therefore limited scope for cumulation it may be necessary for the sentencing Judge to increase the overall sentence to achieve community protection.487.In contrast, I am to sentence you for 24 offences. The gravity of your offending is such that the individual sentences I impose will be long. Further, given there are four separate victims, and almost all of the charged offences occurred on separate occasions, there is considerable scope for cumulation. Where you are to be sentenced as a serious offender the presumption is for entire cumulation.488.In my view it is unnecessary in those circumstances to impose a disproportionate sentence to reflect all sentencing principles. The sentence I impose will be considerable and will consume a significant portion of the rest of your life. It will have at its heart community protection and in particular the protection of any other woman who may come into contact with you. 489.For those reasons I will not impose a disproportionate sentence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal thoroughly examined the gravity and nature of the appellant's offending, which spanned two decades against multiple victims, demonstrating extreme and unrelenting violence and sexual aggression. The court assessed the appellant's risk to the community, noting his persistent offending despite previous interventions, including imprisonment and therapeutic attempts. The court found that the appellant's behaviour exhibited a flagrant disregard for the law, and his offending had only been halted by imprisonment. Despite the appellant's psychiatric diagnosis and medication, the court determined that his risk to the community remained high, and thus, a proportionate sentence was sufficient to protect the community.

The court applied the principles from R v LD, which require an assessment of the risk posed to the community to determine the appropriate length of a prison term. The Court of Appeal found that a disproportionate sentence was unnecessary given the numerous serious offences and the considerable scope for cumulation. The individual sentences were to be lengthy, and the presumption for entire cumulation applied. The court held that the sentence imposed would adequately address all sentencing principles, with community protection at its core.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases involving multiple serious offences by a persistent offender, a proportionate sentence can adequately achieve the objectives of sentencing, including community protection, punishment, deterrence, and denunciation, without the need for a disproportionate sentence. The court's decision followed established principles and did not depart from prior authority on the application of Part 2A and s 6D(b) of the Sentencing Act 1991.