CITATION: DIRECTOR-GENERAL, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES v. DESSERTAINE & ORS [2003] NSWSC 972 HEARING DATE(S): Friday 10 October 2003 JUDGMENT DATE:
10 October 2003JURISDICTION:
CivilJUDGMENT OF: Greg James J at 1 DECISION: Dismiss the summons. The plaintiff is to pay the first and fourth defendants' costs. As to the other defendants, no order as to costs. CATCHWORDS: Children's Court - care orders - whether necessary for magistrate to determine existence of all reasons asserted for an order - whether Act prevents an undetermined reason being later considered on mkaing of final order - whether insufficient reasons given. LEGISLATION CITED: Children & Young Persons (Care & Protection) Act 1998
Supreme Court Act 1970
Evidence Act 1995CASES CITED: N/A PARTIES :
DIRECTOR-GENERAL, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES v.
DESSERTAINE, Marie-Christine & ORSFILE NUMBER(S): SC No. 12093/03 COUNSEL: Plaintiff: P.J. Saidi
First Defendant: A. Moen
Second Defendant: In person
Third Defendant: ---
Fourth Defendant: Ms. FalloonSOLICITORS: Plaintiff: I.V. Knight
First Defendant: Peter R. Murphy & Co.
Second Defendant: In person
Third Defendant: I.V. Knight
Fourth Defendant: Bowring Macaulay & Barrett
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONGREG JAMES, J.
FRIDAY 10 OCTOBER 2003
No. 12093 of 2003
DIRECTOR-GENERAL, DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES v. DESSERTAINE & ORS
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is an application brought by the Director General of the Department of Community Services against the first defendant, the mother of a child known to these proceedings by reason of a suppression order as Irene (that is not her real name), the second defendant the child’s father, the third defendant the Children’s Court of New South Wales and the fourth defendant, Miss Rachel Ward, the child’s personal representative in proceedings in the Children’s Court of New South Wales who I had directed be joined in the proceedings. The first and fourth defendants opposed the application; the second defendant supported the application but made no separate submissions to those of the plaintiff; the third defendant had notified the court in its appearance that it submitted to such orders as the court might make, except as to costs.
- The orders sought
2 The proceedings are brought by further amended summons, which I gave leave to file in court today. The orders sought in the further amended summons are, firstly, for a declaration that a magistrate sitting as the Children’s Court erred in law in determining an application made for a care order by the plaintiff in respect of the child (under the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998), on various grounds including that the magistrate declined to determine or refused to determine a ground for the order made on the application by the plaintiff in that court that under s.71(1)(c) the child had been or was likely to be physically ill-treated, also that he failed to satisfy himself on full evidence that the child was in need of care and protection pursuant to the provisions of s.71 and s.72 of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director-General, Department of Community Services v Dessert... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 972
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues centred on the interpretation of the statutory framework governing the making of care orders. The Director-General argued that the magistrate should have explicitly determined the existence of all reasons asserted for an order. The court also considered whether the Act precluded a reason that had not been determined by the magistrate from being later considered in the final order. Furthermore, the court examined whether the reasons provided by the magistrate were adequate to justify the care orders.
The court held that the magistrate was not required to determine the existence of all reasons asserted for an order. It was sufficient for the magistrate to find that one reason existed, provided that the finding was adequate to justify the order. The court also found that the Act did not prevent an undetermined reason from being later considered in the making of a final order. In this case, the magistrate had made findings that were sufficient to justify the care orders, and the appeal was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in an appeal against the decision of the Children's Court. The Children's Court had previously heard evidence and arguments from both parties, and made findings of fact and law that led to the issuance of care orders for the children. The respondents, the parents, appealed the decision to the Supreme Court, arguing that the magistrate had erred in making the care orders. The appeal process involved the review of the Children's Court's decision, the examination of evidence and arguments, and the consideration of legal principles relevant to the making of care orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether it is necessary for a magistrate to determine the existence of all reasons asserted for a care order under the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW).
2. Whether the Act prevents an undetermined reason from being later considered when making the final order.
3. Whether there were insufficient reasons given for the making of the care orders in this case.
Held
1. The court held that it is not necessary for a magistrate to determine the existence of all reasons asserted for a care order under the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW).
2. The court held that the Act does not prevent an undetermined reason from being later considered when making the final order.
3. The court held that there were insufficient reasons given for the making of the care orders in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by considering whether it is necessary for a magistrate to determine the existence of all reasons asserted for a care order under the Act. The court examined the statutory language and found that the Act does not require a magistrate to determine all asserted reasons but rather to make a finding on the basis of reasons that are sufficient to warrant the making of a care order. The court held that it is sufficient if the reasons provided are adequate to justify the order, and it is not necessary for the magistrate to determine each and every reason asserted.
In relation to the second issue, the court explored whether the Act prevents an undetermined reason from being later considered when making the final order. The court found that the Act does not prohibit the consideration of an undetermined reason at a later stage. It held that the Act allows for the possibility of additional reasons being considered at the final hearing, as long as they are sufficient to support the making of a care order. This interpretation ensures that the best interests of the child are protected and that all relevant factors are taken into account.
Finally, the court examined whether there were insufficient reasons given for the making of the care orders in this case. The court noted that while the reasons provided by the magistrate were adequate to justify the making of the orders, the reasons were not detailed enough to satisfy the court that all relevant factors had been considered. The court held that the reasons given were insufficient because they did not comprehensively address all the relevant issues that needed to be considered in determining whether the orders were necessary. This decision highlights the importance of providing detailed and comprehensive reasons to support the making of care orders, ensuring that all relevant factors are taken into account in the best interests of the child.