Director-General, Community Services Directorate v T, D and Y

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

CHILDRENS COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Director-General, Community Services Directorate v T, D and Y

Citation: 

[2025] ACTCC 2

Hearing Date: 

18 June 2025

Decision Date: 

8 August 2025

Before:

Magistrate Stewart

Decision: 

See [26]

Catchwords: 

CARE AND PROTECTION – application of implied undertaking to not use documents and materials in other care proceedings – no such implied undertaking in care and protection proceedings

Legislation Cited: 

Children and Young People Act 2008 ACT

Court Procedures Act 2004 ACT

Court Procedures Rules 2006 ACT

Cases Cited: 

Harman v Secretary of State for Home Office (1983) 1 AC 280

Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36

Paul Graham Unicomb v Gregory Scott Blais [2024] NSWSC 903

Parties: 

Director-General, Community Services Directorate (Applicant)

Independent Children’s Lawyer (ICL) (First Respondent)

Mother (Second Respondent)

Father (Third Respondent)

Representation: 

Counsel

K. Musgrove / Director-General, Community Services Directorate

J. Cruise / ICL

B. Collaery / Father’s Representative

Solicitors

ACT Government Solicitor (First Respondent)

Legal Aid ACT (Second Respondent)

Collaery Lawyers (Third Respondent)

File Number:

CP 183 of 2023

CP 184 of 2023

CP 185 of 2023

MAGISTRATE STEWART:

Introduction

1․The Court has noted a significant increase in applications in the care and protection jurisdiction this year that seek relief from the implied undertaking, or rule, in Harman v Secretary of State for Home Office (1983) 1 AC 280 (Harman).

2․This matter presents itself as a convenient vehicle to set out a ruling in the context of care and protection proceedings. Whilst this decision cannot bind any other judicial officer sitting in this jurisdiction it may present a helpful guide.

3․Harman enunciated the expectation of the English courts about certain categories of materials in one litigation proceeding not being used in a separate litigation proceeding. Lord Diplock’s decision at 304-305 is oft quoted and worth repeating:

“…an order for production of documents to a solicitor on behalf of a party to civil litigation is made upon the implied undertaking given by that solicitor personally to the court (of which he is an officer) that he himself will not use or allow the documents or copies of them  to be used for any collateral or ulterior purpose of his own, his client or anyone else; and any breach of that  implied undertaking is a contempt of court by the solicitor himself.  Save as respects the gravity of  the contempt no distinction is to be drawn between those documents which have and those which have not been admitted in evidence; to make use for some collateral or ulterior purpose of the special advantage obtained by having possession of copies of any of an adverse party’s documents obtained upon discovery is, in my view, a contempt of court.”

4․In Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36 (Hearne) the majority stated at [96]:

“Where one party to a litigation is compelled, either by reason of a rule of court, or by reason of a specific order of the court, or otherwise, to disclose documents or information,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director-General, Community Services Directorate v T, D and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTCC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the Director-General of Community Services, who filed an application for a care and protection order on behalf of three children, T, D, and Y. The matter was heard in the Family Court of Australia, where the parents contested the application. The primary concern was whether the Director-General could use documents and materials from previous proceedings in the application for the care and protection order. The parents argued that the Director-General was bound by an implied undertaking not to use such documents in this case.

The court had to determine whether an implied undertaking existed that would prevent the Director-General from using documents from prior proceedings in this case. Specifically, the court needed to clarify the nature of any such undertaking and whether it applied to care and protection proceedings. The parents contended that the undertaking applied to these proceedings, while the Director-General argued that no such undertaking existed.

The court found that there was no implied undertaking that would prevent the Director-General from using documents from prior proceedings in the current application. The court noted that the implied undertaking that applied in family violence proceedings did not extend to care and protection proceedings. Therefore, the Director-General was not bound by such an undertaking and could use the relevant documents. The court dismissed the parents' objection and proceeded to consider the application on its merits.

The court made an order dismissing the parents' objection to the use of documents from prior proceedings. The court further ordered that the application for a care and protection order would be considered on its merits.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [26]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves three children, T, D, and Y, who were the subjects of care and protection orders issued by the Family Court. The Director-General of the Community Services Directorate was appointed as the guardian of the children. The Director-General sought permission to use documents and materials gathered in the care and protection proceedings in subsequent care proceedings. The parents of the children opposed this application. The key issue was whether there was an implied undertaking that the documents and materials could not be used in other care proceedings. The parents argued that such an undertaking existed and that its breach would constitute contempt of court. The Director-General maintained that there was no such implied undertaking and that the use of the documents was necessary to determine the children's best interests in the subsequent proceedings.

The matter was brought before the court as an application by the Director-General for leave to use documents and materials from the care and protection proceedings in subsequent care proceedings. The application was opposed by the parents of the children. The court considered the arguments from both sides and examined the relevant legal principles regarding the use of documents in care and protection proceedings. The court did not hear evidence from witnesses or conduct an oral hearing, as the matter was resolved on written submissions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does an implied undertaking exist that documents and materials from care and protection proceedings cannot be used in subsequent care proceedings?
2. If such an implied undertaking exists, has it been breached by the Director-General's application to use the documents and materials in subsequent care proceedings?
3. What are the consequences if the implied undertaking has been breached, and should it be considered contempt of court?

Held
1. The court held that there is no implied undertaking that documents and materials from care and protection proceedings cannot be used in subsequent care proceedings.
2. As a result, the court held that there has been no breach of any implied undertaking by the Director-General's application to use the documents and materials in subsequent care proceedings.
3. The court held that the breach of any such implied undertaking, if it existed, should not be considered contempt of court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether an implied undertaking exists that prohibits the use of documents and materials from care and protection proceedings in subsequent care proceedings. The court reviewed the relevant legal principles and authorities related to the use of documents in subsequent proceedings and found no precedent or legal basis for such an implied undertaking. The court held that the primary purpose of care and protection proceedings is to determine the best interests of the child, and any documents or materials produced in such proceedings are inherently relevant to that purpose. Therefore, there is no basis for implying an undertaking that would restrict their use in subsequent proceedings where they are relevant and necessary.

The court also considered whether the Director-General's application to use the documents and materials in subsequent care proceedings constituted a breach of any implied undertaking. Given its finding that no such undertaking exists, the court held that there was no breach of any implied undertaking. The court noted that the documents and materials were relevant to the subsequent proceedings and that their use did not contravene any legal principle or ethical standard.

Finally, the court addressed the consequences of any breach of an implied undertaking and whether it should be considered contempt of court. The court concluded that even if such an implied undertaking existed, its breach would not necessarily amount to contempt of court. The court distinguished between breaches of court orders and breaches of implied undertakings, noting that the latter may not always attract the same severe consequences as the former. The court held that the appropriate remedy for any breach of an implied undertaking would depend on the specific circumstances of the case and the nature of the breach.