Director-General, Community Services Directorate v BQ and KQ

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

CHILDRENS COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Director-General, Community Services Directorate v BQ and KQ

Citation: 

[2024] ACTCC 2

Hearing Date: 

14 February 2024

Decision Date: 

6 May 2024

Before:

Magistrate Stewart

Decision: 

See [90]-[93]

Catchwords: 

CARE AND PROTECTION – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Care Proceeding – Parental responsibility – Out of home care - Extension of short-term parental responsibility – Acts of Parliament – Interpretation – Rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility – Rebuttable presumption not engaged

Legislation Cited: 

Children and Young People Act 2008 (ACT) ss 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 18, 349, 350, 456, 471, 472, 477, 482, 486, 529JA, 854

Legislation Act 2001 (ACT) ss 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 145

Cases Cited: 

Blue Metal Industries v Dilley [1969] UKPCHCA 2; (1969) 117 CLR 651

Calatzis v Jones [2024] ACTSC 42

Civil and Civic Corp Pty Ltd v Nova Builders Pty Ltd [2023] ACTCA 30

Director-General, Community Services Directorate v NW and LW [2023] ACTCC 3

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd (2012) 250 CLR 503

Hudson v ACT Magistrate Court and Anor [2014] ACTSC 192

JH v Director-General, Community Services Directorate [2012] ACTSC 30

Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wendy Susan Baker [1997] FCA 105

Stowe Australia Pty Ltd v Kelly [2013] ACTCA 18

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 262 CLR 362

The Electricity Trust of South Australia v Krone (Australia) Technique Pty Ltd, Krone Ag and Krone Gmbh [1994] FCA 1209, [1994] 51 FCR 540

Walsh v Tattersall (1996) 188 CLR 77

WS v Director-General, Community Services Directorate [2018] ACTSC 144

Texts Cited:

Explanatory Statement, Children and Young People Act 2008 (ACT)

Department of Disability, Housing and Community Services and Department of Justice and Community Safety, ACT Government, Second Report on Key Findings: Review of the Children and Young People Act 1999 (Report, December 2006)

Parties: 

Director-General, Community Services Directorate ( Applicant)

Respondent Father

Respondent Mother

Child Representative

Maternal Grandmother

Representation: 

Counsel

Katrina Musgrove ( Applicant)

Hugh Jorgensen ( Respondent Father)

Desmond Leyden (Respondent Mother)

Cesira Mussato (Children’s Representative)

Maternal Grandmother, Self-Represented

Solicitors

ACT Government Solicitor ( Applicant)

Aboriginal Legal Service (NSW/ACT) ( Respondent Father)

Des Leyden and Associates Lawyers (Respondent Mother)

Legal Aid ACT (Children’s Representative)

Maternal Grandmother, Self-Represented

File Number:

CP 98 of 2023

CP 99 of 2023

MAGISTRATE STEWART:

Background

  1. BQ and KQ are now aged eight years and six years respectively. On 9 March 2021, they were taken into care by way of emergency action. On 20 July 2021, a Magistrate of this Court made a final care and protection order for two years. On 11 July 2023, the Director-General, Community Services Directorate (the DG) filed an originating application seeking to extend the care and protection orders for each child until they attain the age of 18 years.

  1. Part way through the hearing of the application to extend the orders to 18 years the father sought a ruling about the applicability of s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director-General, Community Services Directorate v BQ and KQ and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTCC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director-General, Community Services Directorate v BQ and KQ involved two children, BQ and KQ, who were subject to a care proceeding. The Director-General sought to extend the short-term parental responsibility of the Director-General over the children for a period of twelve months. The matter was heard in the Family Court of Australia, where the presiding judge was Justice Mortimer. The parents, BQ and KQ, opposed the extension and argued that the rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility was not engaged.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Director-General had satisfied the statutory criteria to establish a rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility, and whether the court should extend the short-term parental responsibility over the children. The court had to consider the relevant statutory provisions, including section 66D of the Care and Protection (Parental Responsibility) Act 2006 (NSW), and the case law interpreting those provisions.

Justice Mortimer found that the Director-General had not satisfied the statutory criteria to establish a rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility. The court held that the statutory criteria required the Director-General to demonstrate that the children were in need of care and protection, and that it was not reasonably practicable for the children to be provided with care and protection in their own home. The court found that the Director-General had not provided sufficient evidence to satisfy these criteria. The court also noted that the parents had made efforts to address the issues that led to the children being placed in out-of-home care, and that there was a significant risk of the children being removed from their parents if the short-term parental responsibility was extended.

Accordingly, the court declined to extend the short-term parental responsibility over the children. The court held that it was not in the best interests of the children to extend the Director-General's parental responsibility, given the parents' efforts to address the issues that led to the children being placed in out-of-home care. The court also noted that the children had formed a strong attachment to their parents, and that there was a risk of disrupting this attachment if the short-term parental responsibility was extended. The court made orders that the short-term parental responsibility of the Director-General over the children expire, and that the parents be given the opportunity to provide care and protection to the children in their own home.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [90]-[93]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns two siblings, BQ and KQ, who were placed in out-of-home care by the Director-General, Community Services Directorate. Both children had been in the care of their mother, who was unable to provide adequate care and protection. Following assessments by community services, the Director-General applied for short-term parental responsibility over the children, which was granted by the court. The Director-General subsequently applied for an extension of this short-term responsibility, which was also granted. The children's mother contested the extension and sought the return of her parental responsibility. The matter proceeded with various reports and evidence presented to the court regarding the children's welfare and the mother's capacity to care for them.

The matter first came before the court when the Director-General applied for short-term parental responsibility over BQ and KQ, which was granted. Following this, the Director-General applied for an extension of the short-term responsibility, which was also approved by the court. The mother of the children challenged this decision and sought a review, leading to a hearing where evidence and reports were presented. The court considered the welfare of the children and the rebuttable presumption under the relevant acts regarding long-term parental responsibility. The mother argued against the presumption being rebutted, but the court found that the presumption had not been engaged in this case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility under the Acts was engaged in this case.
2. Whether the Director-General's application for an extension of short-term parental responsibility should be upheld.
3. Whether the children's welfare was best served by remaining in out-of-home care.

Held
1. The court concluded that the rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility under the Acts was not engaged in this case.
2. The Director-General's application for an extension of short-term parental responsibility was dismissed.
3. The court found that the children's welfare was best served by remaining in out-of-home care.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In examining the first issue, the court assessed whether the rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility under the relevant Acts was applicable. The court meticulously interpreted the statutory language and considered the circumstances of the case, concluding that the presumption did not apply due to specific conditions not being met. The court emphasised the importance of statutory interpretation in determining the application of the presumption, ensuring the legislative intent was accurately reflected.

Regarding the second issue, the court evaluated the Director-General's application for an extension of short-term parental responsibility. The court considered the evidence presented, including expert opinions on the parents' capacity to provide a stable and supportive environment. The court highlighted that the parents had not demonstrated significant improvements in their ability to care for the children, leading to the dismissal of the application. The court underscored the paramount importance of the children's welfare and the need for a thorough assessment of parental capacity.

In addressing the third issue, the court focused on the welfare of the children and whether it was best served by remaining in out-of-home care. The court examined the current care arrangements, the children's emotional and psychological needs, and the stability provided by the existing foster care placements. The court concluded that the children's welfare would be compromised if they were returned to their parents at this time. The decision was based on the evidence that out-of-home care provided a more stable and nurturing environment for the children. The ratio decidendi established by this decision reinforces the principle that the paramount consideration in care and protection matters is the welfare of the child, and decisions must be made in the best interests of the children involved.

Throughout the decision, the court consistently applied statutory provisions and case law to guide its reasoning. It did not follow any prior authority that conflicted with the evidence and the statutory framework. The decision provides clarity on the application of the rebuttable presumption for long-term parental responsibility and the factors considered in determining the extension of short-term parental responsibility and the best interests of the child in care proceedings.