Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v Isuzu Australia Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v Isuzu Australia Limited (No 2) [2024] FCA 1198

File number: VID 547 of 2020
Judgment of: ROFE J
Date of judgment: 17 October 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – abuse of process – application for permanent stay of proceeding – where application has been previously stayed until judgment is handed down in another proceeding – where there are concluded proceedings in this Court between the applicant and cross-respondents – where respondent not party to initial proceedings – where both sets of proceedings arise from the same factual circumstances – extent of overlap between the proceedings – whether the applicant could or should have claimed against the respondent earlier – potential for inconsistent judgments – oppression and prejudice – application dismissed
Legislation:

Evidence Act1995 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v Isuzu Australia Limited [2022] FCA 254

Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v OE Solutions Pty Ltd (No 8) [2022] FCA 1404

Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v OE Solutions Pty Ltd (No 9) [2023] FCA 462

Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v OE Solutions Pty Ltd (No 10) [2023] FCA 1656

GLJ v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Lismore (2023) 414 ALR 635

UBS AG v Tyne (2018) 265 CLR 77

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Number of paragraphs: 54
Date of last submissions: 16 August 2024
Date of hearing: 30 August 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: T Cordiner KC
Solicitor for the Applicant: K&L Gates
Counsel for the Respondent/ Cross-Claimant: B Walker SC, M Norton SC, F Shand
Solicitor for the Respondent/ Cross-Claimant: Herbert Smith Freehills
Counsel for the Cross-Respondents: The first, second, third, fourth and fifth cross-respondents did not appear
Table of Corrections
21 October 2024 In paragraph 21 in the second sentence, the word “Directed’s” has been replaced with “Isuzu’s”
21 October 2024 In paragraph 47, the words “As addressed by Isuzu, the issues raised by Directed” has been replaced with “As addressed by Directed, the issues raised by Isuzu”

ORDERS

VID 547 of 2020
BETWEEN:

DIRECTED ELECTRONICS OE PTY LTD ACN 130 647 737

Applicant

AND:

ISUZU AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 006 962 572

Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

ISUZU AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 006 962 572

Cross-Claimant

AND:

HANWHA AUS PTY LTD (ACN 614 943 092) (and others named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ROFE J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 OCTOBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent’s interlocutory application dated 23 June 2021 for a permanent stay or dismissal of these proceedings (Application) be dismissed.

2.The matter be listed for case management hearing on a date to be fixed by arrangement with the Associate to Rofe J.

3.Within 14 days of the date of this order, the parties file and serve short written submissions limited to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v Isuzu Australia Limited (N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v Isuzu Australia Limited (No 2) involves Isuzu Australia Limited applying for a permanent stay or dismissal of proceedings initiated by Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the continuation of the proceedings would constitute an abuse of process or oppression. Isuzu argued that the proceedings were an abuse of process due to the delay in filing, overlap of claims, potential for inconsistent findings, and public interest considerations. Directed contested these claims, asserting that there had been no abuse of process and that the proceedings should continue. The court considered the principles surrounding abuse of process, referencing High Court decisions that highlight the importance of case management and the use of a permanent stay as a last resort. The court concluded that any potential for abuse of process could be managed through appropriate case management measures and that Isuzu could always seek to stay the proceedings again if necessary. The court dismissed Isuzu's application for a permanent stay and ordered a case management hearing to address the concerns raised.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent’s interlocutory application dated 23 June 2021 for a permanent stay or dismissal of these proceedings (Application) be dismissed.

2. The matter be listed for case management hearing on a date to be fixed by arrangement with the Associate to Rofe J.

3. Within 14 days of the date of this order, the parties file and serve short written submissions limited to 4 pages in relation to the costs of this Application.

4. Liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I consider that this Application should be dismissed as the nature and extent of any abuse of process or oppression may be avoided or minimised by appropriate case management. Further, in the event that despite such case management, a material risk of prejudice to Isuzu may materialise, it will remain open for it to file a fresh application for a dismissal or permanent stay of proceedings arising from any putative abuse of process at that time.2. Background I discussed the relevant background to the 2017 Proceeding and the 2020 Proceeding in the Prior Judgment at [10]–[22]. I note that the matters discussed at [6] above have occurred which are relevant to my consideration. 3. Evidence In support of its Application at the initial hearing, Isuzu previously relied on four affidavits of Mark Anthony Farquhar, being those sworn on 22 June 2021, 30 July 2021 and 18 August 2021, and a confidential affidavit sworn on 22 June 2021. In response, Directed relied upon four affidavits of Anthony Brooke Watson affirmed 10 August 2021, 13 August 2021, 18 August 2021 and 20 August 2021. Isuzu has since filed the affidavit of Emma Lee-Anne Iles (a partner of its new firm of solicitors) affirmed on 2 August 2024 and sought to rely on this affidavit. In written submissions, Directed opposed leave being granted to Isuzu to rely upon this additional affidavit, however it did not press this at the hearing. 4. Principles There was no disagreement about the applicable principles between the parties and the same principles apply now as they did for the Prior Judgment. I discussed the relevant principles in the Prior Judgment at [30]–[39]. More recently, the High Court in GLJ v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Lismore (2023) 414 ALR 635 expressed that an order for a permanent stay to prevent an abuse of process is a decision of “last resort”: at [3] (per Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Jagot JJ). The High Court in GLJ considered an application for a permanent stay of proceedings in the context of a criminal justice process, whereby a permanent stay would involve the extinguishment of a right said to have been infringed. While the High Court’s consideration must be viewed in the factual context of that case, their Honours’ statements may also be seen to apply at a level of generality regarding the point in time at which Courts should grant a permanent stay and whether any alternative case management mechanisms can be canvassed in lieu of a permanent stay, and that a stay is a “last resort”. 5. Submissions5.1 Case management issue In its written submissions, Isuzu submitted that several aspects of the 2020 Proceeding render it an abuse of process. These factors, which were also raised when this Application was first heard, include Directed’s delay in bringing the 2020 Proceeding, the overlap of the claims, the likelihood for inconsistent findings and the public interest. The matter was put differently in oral submissions. In oral its submissions, Isuzu advanced that this hearing was to “pick up” the observations from the Prior Judgment at [126], where I expressed that:… the Court will know the result and be in a position to evaluate the likelihood of any abuse of process, and case manage the 2020 Proceeding accordingly to ensure there is no abuse of process or oppression.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note that the matters discussed at [6] above have occurred which are relevant to my consideration. 3. Evidence In support of its Application at the initial hearing, Isuzu previously relied on four affidavits of Mark Anthony Farquhar, being those sworn on 22 June 2021, 30 July 2021 and 18 August 2021, and a confidential affidavit sworn on 22 June 2021. In response, Directed relied upon four affidavits of Anthony Brooke Watson affirmed 10 August 2021, 13 August 2021, 18 August 2021 and 20 August 2021. Isuzu has since filed the affidavit of Emma Lee-Anne Iles (a partner of its new firm of solicitors) affirmed on 2 August 2024 and sought to rely on this affidavit. In written submissions, Directed opposed leave being granted to Isuzu to rely upon this additional affidavit, however it did not press this at the hearing. 4. Principles There was no disagreement about the applicable principles between the parties and the same principles apply now as they did for the Prior Judgment. I discussed the relevant principles in the Prior Judgment at [30]–[39]. More recently, the High Court in GLJ v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Lismore (2023) 414 ALR 635 expressed that an order for a permanent stay to prevent an abuse of process is a decision of “last resort”: at [3] (per Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Jagot JJ). The High Court in GLJ considered an application for a permanent stay of proceedings in the context of a criminal justice process, whereby a permanent stay would involve the extinguishment of a right said to have been infringed. While the High Court’s consideration must be viewed in the factual context of that case, their Honours’ statements may also be seen to apply at a level of generality regarding the point in time at which Courts should grant a permanent stay and whether any alternative case management mechanisms can be canvassed in lieu of a permanent stay, and that a stay is a “last resort”. 5. Submissions5.1 Case management issue In its written submissions, Isuzu submitted that several aspects of the 2020 Proceeding render it an abuse of process. These factors, which were also raised when this Application was first heard, include Directed’s delay in bringing the 2020 Proceeding, the overlap of the claims, the likelihood for inconsistent findings and the public interest. The matter was put differently in oral submissions. In oral its submissions, Isuzu advanced that this hearing was to “pick up” the observations from the Prior Judgment at [126], where I expressed that:… the Court will know the result and be in a position to evaluate the likelihood of any abuse of process, and case manage the 2020 Proceeding accordingly to ensure there is no abuse of process or oppression. Isuzu expressed that it had not received any correspondence from Directed indicating their proposed case management strategy for the 2020 Proceeding which would ameliorate any potential abuse of process. Isuzu submitted that the Court at this stage required specific proposed case management ideas from Directed to ensure that there is no abuse of process moving forward. Isuzu also contended that such case management could be canvassed by exchanges between the parties, but with Directed going first. Conversely, Isuzu admitted that it had not written to Directed requesting proposed case management orders in advance of the hearing of this Application. In the absence of proposed case management orders, Isuzu proposed that there should be a stay of the 2020 Proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Isuzu’s Application is being heard once more in light of the following developments:(a)the handing down of judgments in the 2017 Proceeding listed at (i)−(iii) below;(i)Liability Judgment;(ii)Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v OE Solutions Pty Ltd (No 9) [2023] FCA 462 (Secret Commissions Judgment); and(iii)Directed Electronics OE Pty Ltd v OE Solutions Pty Ltd (No 10) [2023] FCA 1656 (Quantum Judgment);(b)the cross-respondents in the 2020 Proceeding each having entered insolvency, bankruptcy, or formal administration;(c)Isuzu having changed the firm of solicitors representing it in the 2020 Proceeding;(d)Isuzu’s indication that it intends to discontinue its cross-claim dated 18 December 2020 against the cross-respondents; and(e)Directed filing its further amended statement of claim on 22 May 2024 and Isuzu providing its proposed defence dated 12 July 2024 (including new apportionment claims against the cross-respondents) (together, the Amended Pleadings). Isuzu again contends that the 2020 Proceeding is an abuse of process and should be stayed. At the hearing of this Application, Isuzu appeared to no longer press for a dismissal of the 2020 Proceeding. Directed denies that there has been any abuse of process and that the continuation of this proceeding would amount to an abuse of process. For the reasons that follow, I consider that this Application should be dismissed as the nature and extent of any abuse of process or oppression may be avoided or minimised by appropriate case management. Further, in the event that despite such case management, a material risk of prejudice to Isuzu may materialise, it will remain open for it to file a fresh application for a dismissal or permanent stay of proceedings arising from any putative abuse of process at that time.2. Background I discussed the relevant background to the 2017 Proceeding and the 2020 Proceeding in the Prior Judgment at [10]–[22]. I note that the matters discussed at [6] above have occurred which are relevant to my consideration. 3. Evidence In support of its Application at the initial hearing, Isuzu previously relied on four affidavits of Mark Anthony Farquhar, being those sworn on 22 June 2021, 30 July 2021 and 18 August 2021, and a confidential affidavit sworn on 22 June 2021. In response, Directed relied upon four affidavits of Anthony Brooke Watson affirmed 10 August 2021, 13 August 2021, 18 August 2021 and 20 August 2021. Isuzu has since filed the affidavit of Emma Lee-Anne Iles (a partner of its new firm of solicitors) affirmed on 2 August 2024 and sought to rely on this affidavit. In written submissions, Directed opposed leave being granted to Isuzu to rely upon this additional affidavit, however it did not press this at the hearing. 4. Principles There was no disagreement about the applicable principles between the parties and the same principles apply now as they did for the Prior Judgment. I discussed the relevant principles in the Prior Judgment at [30]–[39]. More recently, the High Court in GLJ v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Lismore (2023) 414 ALR 635 expressed that an order for a permanent stay to prevent an abuse of process is a decision of “last resort”: at [3] (per Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Jagot JJ). The High Court in GLJ considered an application for a permanent stay of proceedings in the context of a criminal justice process, whereby a permanent stay would involve the extinguishment of a right said to have been infringed. While the High Court’s consideration must be viewed in the factual context of that case, their Honours’ statements may also be seen to apply at a level of generality regarding the point in time at which Courts should grant a permanent stay and whether any alternative case management mechanisms can be canvassed in lieu of a permanent stay, and that a stay is a “last resort”. 5. Submissions5.1 Case management issue

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.