Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2023] AATA 2909 (13 September 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2022/7107 and 2022/7118

Re:Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones

Date:13 September 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review

.......................[sgd].................................................

Deputy President Britten-Jones

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS – Tariff classification – whether imported pipes fall within the classification of ‘line pipe of a kind used for oil and gas pipelines’ – consideration of the phrase ‘of a kind used for’ - imported pipes do not fall within the genus of line pipe used for oil or gas pipelines – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Customs Act 1901 (Cth)

Customs Tariff Act 1995 (Cth)

CASES

Tridon Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (1982) 4 ALD 615

Chinese Food & Wine Supplies Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (Vic) (1987) 72 ALR 591
Customs v Savage River Mines (1988) 79 ALR 258
Hygienic Lily Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1987) 13 FCR 396

Air International Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs (2002) 121 FCR 149

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Britten-Jones

13 September 2023

  1. The applicant, Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd, seeks review of two decisions of the respondent dated 5 August 2022 to refuse applications for refund of duties paid in respect of steel pipes imported from China and Thailand. The applicant disagrees with the tariff classification given to the pipes which results in a higher level of duty payable by it when compared to the tariff classification contended for by the applicant. The applicant contends that the imported pipes fall within the classification of ‘line pipe of a kind used for oil and gas’ which is a phrase used as a subheading in Schedule 3 of the Customs Tariff Act 1995 (the Act). For the reasons which follow, I do not accept the applicant’s contention.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The applicant imports steel pipes and other equipment for use in fire protection sprinkler systems.

  3. From November 2016 to October 2018, the applicant imported pipes from China and Thailand. The pipes from China were manufactured by Hengshui Jinghua Steel Pipe Co (Hengshui Pipe). The pipes from Thailand were manufactured by Pacific Pipe Public Co Ltd (Pacific Pipe). I will refer to the pipes together as the imported pipes.

  4. The imported pipes are black steel pipes and galvanised steel pipes of various diameters imported in 3.25 metre or 6.5 metre lengths.

  5. A decision was made on 9 July 2019 to classify the imported pipes under the Act. The applicant sought an internal review and a further decision maintaining the classification decision was made on 27 October 2020. The applicant disagreed with the decision made on internal review and arrangements were made between the parties for the applicant to access the Tribunal for merits review.

  6. The Tribunal has jurisdiction by s 273GA(haaa) of the Customs Act 1901 to review a decision made in relation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Cust... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2909
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Direct Fire Supplies Pty Ltd against a decision of the Comptroller-General of Customs regarding the tariff classification of imported pipes. The dispute centred on whether the imported pipes fell within the classification of ‘line pipe of a kind used for oil and gas pipelines’. The court was required to determine the correct tariff classification for these goods.

The legal issues before the court were twofold: first, to interpret the phrase ‘of a kind used for’ in the context of tariff classification, and second, to determine whether the imported pipes possessed the nature, quality, and adaptation to be considered line pipe of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines, irrespective of their intended actual use. This involved considering expert evidence regarding the technical specifications and standards applicable to line pipe for the oil and gas industry.

The court applied the principles of tariff classification, which require consideration of headings and subheadings according to the Schedule 2 Interpretation Rules. Drawing on the authority of *Hygienic Lily Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation*, the court held that the phrase ‘of a kind’ directs attention to the nature, quality, and adaptation of goods within a class or genus, rather than the specific purpose for which particular goods were designed or intended to be used. The court found that the expert evidence, particularly from Dr John Piper, established that the imported pipes lacked essential micro alloying elements necessary for compliance with international standards like API 5L, which are critical for the strength, weldability, and fracture toughness of line pipe used in oil and gas pipelines. Despite containing some common elements, the absence of these crucial micro alloying elements meant the pipes were not of the kind used for oil or gas pipelines.

Consequently, the court concluded that the imported pipes were not line pipe of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines and affirmed the decision under review. The imported pipes were therefore not classified under subheading 7306.19.00, but rather under subheading 7306.30.00.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent says that it would be erroneous for me to interpret a subheading by reference to a lower level of subheading because it is only subheadings at the same level that are comparable.Expert Evidence of Dr John Piper Where the parties do agree is that I must determine the nature, quality and adaptation of the goods in the class of 7306.1. The respondent draws upon the expert testimony of Dr John Piper who was asked to give his opinion in relation to the imported pipes. Dr John Piper has a PhD in materials engineering and about 29 years professional experience regarding linepipe for oil and gas pipelines. There was no issue with respect to his experience and his ability to give expert evidence about the imported pipes in this case. With respect to linepipe within the oil and gas industry he said:The term ‘linepipe’ refers to steel pipe used in the construction of an oil or gas pipeline. The quality of manufacture of the line pipe is important to the industry as the fluids conveyed are hazardous and can cause death or environmental damage if they escape. As such, the industry is highly engineered and regulated to ensure low risk. Meeting the requirements of the Australian design code of practice for construction and operation of oil and gas pipelines is fundamental to pipeline safety. This code, AS2885.1 has much to say about the minimum quality of materials used in the constructions of a pipeline. Indeed, it calls up just 4 types of pipe which may be used without further justification, these being pipe to API Spec 5L, ISO 3183, ASTM A106, ASTM A333 and ASTM A671. Even these grades of pipe may not be used in all applications as they are subject to further caveats, depending on usage, within the standard. It was conceded by the applicant that the pipes as imported do not comply with API 5L, the international standard for line pipes for use in the oil or gas industry.[9][9] Applicant oral opening submissions at Transcript P-20 and oral closing submissions at Transcript P-48 lines 5 to 9. Dr Piper was asked a series of questions about certain features of the imported pipes namely that they were galvanised, had a red painted finish and were groove ended. Dr Piper said pipes with these features are not used in oil and gas pipelines. Dr Piper was also asked to comment on the Australian Standard AS1074 which was marked on the imported pipes. He said:AS1074 steel tubulars are generally used in structural applications, or for the conveyance of non-hazardous fluids such as compressed air or water. This is because the standard does not require the same limits on steel composition, dimensions, weldability or seam weld integrity as found in more stringent standards such as API 5L.Importantly, AS1074 is not a standard listed in the Australian Petroleum Pipeline design code, AS2885, as permissible for oil and gas construction. Tubulars which are only certified to this standard are not used as line pipe in oil and gas pipeline. Under cross examination Dr Piper was asked to consider the Mill Test Certificates that were provided with the imported pipes. There are two certificates, one for the Pacific Pipe[10] and one for the Hengshui Pipe.[11] They provide details, inter alia, of the chemical composition of the pipes by listing the percentages of each of five elements within the pipes. The five elements listed are carbon, silicon, manganese, phosphorus and sulfur. Dr Piper accepted that the percentage levels of these elements were within the required standards including API 5L but he qualified his answer by saying that the certificates did not include three micro alloying elements, namely vanadium, niobium and titanium. He explained that they are:alloying elements which are provided and effective in extremely small amounts. They are deliberately added to many steels and very necessary for controlling strength and weldability and the fracture toughness of steel. … So in order to be conforming with API 5L for Grade B, you need to list the chemical analysis for vanadium, niobium and titanium and demonstrate that those limits are achieved. That information, among that other information, is missing from the Chinese test certificate.[12][10] Exhibit 1 at T22.1 p.375.[11] Exhibit 1 at T22.2 p.418.[12] Transcript P-34.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Piper also noted under cross examination that in terms of containing the necessary elements for compliance with international standards for oil or gas pipelines, the certificates were deficient in many other ways.[13] In his written report, Dr Piper set out the deficiencies in the certificates compared to what is required for compliance with the international standard of API 5L.[14][13] Transcript P-33 lines 16-17.[14] Exhibit 4 at pp.7-8.CONCLUSION The applicant contends that the expert evidence of Dr Piper supports its case because the imported pipes share some of the characteristics of the pipes described in 7306.1. It points to the five elements in the required percentages contained within the imported pipes as evidence of the shared characteristics. The applicant says that ‘the essential character of these goods is of the kind of line pipe that Dr Piper describes.’[15] In my opinion this is where the argument of the applicant falls down. Dr Piper described the missing micro alloying elements as ‘very necessary for controlling the strength and weldability and the fracture toughness of steel’.[16] He said that they were effective ‘in extremely small amounts.’[17] The applicant contends that it is not surprising that these micro alloying elements were not recorded on the certificates because there was no need to. It said that the imported pipes did not need to be certified for use in oil and gas pipelines because they were imported for another purpose. The applicant seemed to suggest that the missing micro alloying elements may in fact be present but simply not recorded. However, there is no evidence that the imported pipes contained the micro alloying elements which, in the opinion of Dr Piper, are a ‘very necessary’ characteristic of a line pipe used in oil or gas pipelines. Absent evidence of the micro alloying elements, one cannot say that the imported pipes share the essential characteristics of the genus of pipes in 7306.1. [15] Transcript P-60 line 31.[16] Transcript P-34 lines 29-30.[17] Transcript P-34 line 28. Further, the applicant did not provide any evidence that the imported pipes or other pipes from the same manufacturers had been used in or were suitable for use in oil or gas pipelines. There is no dispute that the imported pipe is not going to be used for oil or gas pipelines. In fact, the imported pipe is going to be used in fire protection sprinkler systems. Nevertheless, the actual use to which the imported pipe will be put is not determinative of the matter. The inclusion of the words ‘of a kind’ gives the subheading a broader application and potentially covers line pipe not intended to be used for oil or gas pipelines. In other words, it covers line pipe that may be used in other applications potentially even fire protection sprinkler systems. However, the line pipe must be of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines even if it is not so used. The applicant has not established that the imported goods are, to adopt the language of Tamberlin J, ‘within a range of goods of a type which are used’[18] in oil or gas pipelines. As set out above, the applicant relies upon the fact that the imported goods contain certifiable amounts of carbon, silicon, manganese, phosphorus and sulfur but it cannot be said that the presence of these elements brings the imported goods within a range of goods of a type used in oil or gas pipelines. Dr Piper’s evidence was clear that the missing micro alloying elements were ‘very necessary’ and would need to be included in the chemical composition of the pipes for them to be compliant with the international standards for use in oil or gas pipelines. I am not satisfied that the imported goods are within the genus of line pipe used for oil or gas pipelines. I conclude that the imported pipe is not line pipe of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines.[18] Air International Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs (2002) 121 FCR 149 at [53].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The second task of classification requires application of the Schedule 2 Interpretation Rules. Section 7(1) of the Act provides that the Schedule 2 Interpretation Rules must be used for working out the tariff classification under which goods are classified. This involves, firstly, a consideration of the headings into which the goods as identified may fall so as to determine the correct classification of the goods at the four-digit heading level by reference to the Interpretative Rules[3] and, secondly, a determination of the correct subheading under which the goods are classified.[3] Not in dispute in this case as the parties agree the appropriate heading is 7306.CONSIDERATION The pipes imported from Thailand are welded black steel pipes with red painted finish. The pipes from China are welded galvanised steel pipes. This description of the goods is common ground and a more detailed description is set out in the respondent’s written submissions dated 13 February 2023 at [8] and [9]. The applicant conceded that the pipes were imported for use in fire protection sprinkler systems and that they do not comply with the international standard for line pipes for use in the oil or gas industry.[4][4] Transcript P-20. The correct classification of the goods at the four-digit heading level is not in dispute. Both parties agree that the appropriate heading in Schedule 3 is 7306. Where the parties differ is at the subheading level of tariff classification. The applicant contends for a broad interpretation such that the imported pipe is line pipe of a kind used for oil or gas pipeline and therefore comes within the subheading at 7306.1 and should be classified under the next level of subheading at 7306.19.00. The respondent contends for a narrower interpretation such that the pipe is not of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines and that it should be classified under the subheading at 7306.30.00.Case Law I turn now to consider the authorities that bear upon the crux of the dispute, namely whether the imported pipe is line pipe of a kind used for oil or gas pipelines. In Hygienic Lily Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1987) 13 FCR 396 (Hygienic Lily), the applicant manufactured paper cups on which were printed designs particular to customers. The question of tariff classification in that case was whether the goods were ‘of a kind ordinarily used for household purposes’. The Deputy Commissioner argued that the cups in question were manufactured solely or substantially for the purpose of McDonald’s restaurants to contain beverages for customers. When in this way, one looks to the purpose of manufacture, the conclusion, so submitted by the Deputy Commissioner, was that the cups were not ‘of a kind ordinarily used for household purposes’. Gummow J said at 399:… the setting in which the phrase “goods of a kind” appears suggests it is directed not to the use for which the particular goods in question were designed or manufactured, nor to the purpose to which it is intended those particular goods shall be put, but rather to the nature, quality and adaptation of goods in the class or genus in question. Thus, goods are “of a kind ordinarily used for household purposes” if they are to be recognised as members of a class or genus which commonly or regularly (albeit not necessarily exclusively or principally) is used for household purposes.(citations omitted)