Dimoff and Miclyn Express Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 88 min read

Dimoff and Miclyn Express Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2016] AATA 269 (29 April 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2015/0363

Re

John Dimoff

APPLICANT

And

Miclyn Express Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall
Date 29 April 2016
Place Perth

The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided as follows:

·Liability exists as a result of an injury sustained by the Applicant to the right knee, involving a posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellofemoral ligament.

·For the period 17 July 2014 (the date of injury) to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for incapacity for work as a result of the injury in accordance with section 31 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth).

·For the period 17 July 2014 to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for the cost of medical treatment for the injury sustained by the Applicant on 17 July 2014, in accordance with section 28 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992.

·The Respondent is to arrange for assessment of the Applicant’s capability under section 49 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 and make arrangements under section 50 for provision of a rehabilitation program.

The Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 92(1) of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992, that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant be paid by the Respondent in accordance with section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

............[sgd].................................................

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – whether workplace injury to right knee is an “injury” or a “disease” for the purposes of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 – extent of incapacity post workplace injury – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) – sections 3, 10(7), 26, 28, 50

CASES

Bui and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2016] AATA 135

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter requires the Tribunal to determine whether John Dimoff is entitled to compensation payments under the Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (the “SRC Act”) for an injury to his right knee sustained at work on 17 July 2014.

  2. Mr Dimoff is 54 years of age.  He was employed as a Chief Engineer by Samson Express Offshore (“Samson”) on 30 January 2014.

  3. On 18 July 2014, Mr Dimoff presented to Samson’s medical room with right knee pain and swelling.  He claimed he was injured at 7:30 pm the previous night when he was climbing into his bunk on board the Pacific Installer (an accommodation vessel) (T6 at 35).

  4. On 6 August 2014, Mr Dimoff lodged a claim for compensation under the SRC Act for “internal right knee damage” sustained whilst tying to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dimoff and Miclyn Express Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (Comp... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Dimoff against Miclyn Express Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd regarding compensation for a workplace injury. The dispute centred on whether the injury to Mr Dimoff's right knee constituted an "injury" or a "disease" for the purposes of the *Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992* (Cth) (SRC Act), and the extent of his incapacity and entitlement to compensation. The decision was made by Deputy President Christopher Kendall.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine the nature of Mr Dimoff's right knee condition, specifically whether it should be classified as an "injury" or a "disease" under the SRC Act, and consequently, whether section 10(7) of the Act, which could preclude compensation if a "disease" was not disclosed, was applicable. The Tribunal was also required to assess the extent of Mr Dimoff's incapacity for work and his entitlement to compensation for both incapacity and medical treatment arising from the injury.

The Tribunal reasoned that the injury to Mr Dimoff's right knee, involving a posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint, and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellofemoral ligament, was best characterised as an "injury" rather than a "disease" as defined by the SRC Act. This classification meant that section 10(7) of the Act did not apply. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous decision under review and substituted its own findings.

The Tribunal ordered that liability existed for the injury sustained by the Applicant to his right knee. Compensation was payable for incapacity for work and for the cost of medical treatment from the date of injury, 17 July 2014, to the present. Furthermore, the Respondent was directed to arrange for an assessment of Mr Dimoff's capability under section 49 of the SRC Act and to make arrangements for a rehabilitation program under section 50. The Respondent was also ordered to pay the Applicant's costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided as follows:

· Liability exists as a result of an injury sustained by the Applicant to the right knee, involving a posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellofemoral ligament.

· For the period 17 July 2014 (the date of injury) to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for incapacity for work as a result of the injury in accordance with section 31 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth).

· For the period 17 July 2014 to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for the cost of medical treatment for the injury sustained by the Applicant on 17 July 2014, in accordance with section 28 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992.

· The Respondent is to arrange for assessment of the Applicant’s capability under section 49 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 and make arrangements under section 50 for provision of a rehabilitation program.

The Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 92(1) of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992, that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant be paid by the Respondent in accordance with section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Relevantly, Mr Dimoff’s witness statement reads as follows:1. My date of birth is … 1961 and I am 54 years of age.2. I was born in Adelaide and I am one of 4 siblings.3. I left school at the age of 13½. I am dyslexic and I have difficulty reading and writing.4. After leaving school, I secured work in the commercial fishing industry as a deckhand off the coast of South Australia.5. I attended Swan TAFE and Challenger TAFE in order to pursue a career in the offshore maritime industry.6. I am the holder of a HR and C class driver’s license.7. I have a history of previous injuries as follows.8. In 1975 I had a recreational motor bike fall. I sustained injuries at my right knee and underwent surgery in relation to same. I had a good recovery from this injury and was able to resume working in the commercial fishing industry for many years beyond 1975.9. On 14 December 1998, I underwent a procedure involving reconstruction of my left ACL at Freemantle Hospital under the care of Dr Hardisty.10. In early January 1999, I had a fall 2 weeks after having surgery causing further pain and a delay in my recovery in relation to the left knee surgery.11. On 24 May 1999, I had a further arthroscopy procedure at my left knee.12. On 15 December 2004, whilst employed by Mermaid Marine Group, while working in the thruster room of a vessel I stepped on an unsecured floor plate, which was covered in oil and the retaining screws had not been inserted after access by a co-worker. When I stepped on the plate, it slipped sideways exposing the underlying boat bilge into which I fell twisting my left knee and impacting my right elbow as I braced myself to avoid falling thought the hole.13. I sustained multiple abrasions including lacerations to the right arm and pain and swelling about the right elbow and left knee.14. As a result of this incident, I underwent a left knee lateral release procedure. There was a 6 month delay in having the procedure due to Allianz delay in dealing with my claim.15. In relation to the right elbow, I was treated by hand, wrist, elbow and shoulder surgeon, Dr Alex O'Beirne. I had surgery performed on my right elbow 6 months after the injury again due to Allianz refusing to pay for the associated medical costs.16. The claim eventually resolved by way of settlement.17. In November 2008 my daughter passed away and as a result my wife and myself became the sole carers of her 16 month old son. I suffered from immense grief and depression for a period of time thereafter.18. On 16 February 2009 whilst shopping at Woolworths, I slipped on water that had leaked onto the floor during the course of repairs to an ice freezer, impacting on my right knee to the floor [sic]. As a result of that incident I had immediate pain and swelling to my knee. Under instructions from the Woolworths Store manager, I attended upon my GP at the time, Dr Michael Joyce and at my request I was referred to Dr David Colvin, Orthopaedic Surgeon.19. On 2 March 2009, I underwent an MRI of my right knee on referral from Dr David Colvin. The results revealed mucoid degeneration within the posterior horn of the medial meniscus, fraying and irregularity of the free margin of the body of the medial meniscus without a discreet tear, mild patella and medial compartment chondral pathology and ACL ganglion.20. On 3 March 2009, I had a scan of my right knee. I am unsure as to whether that was an ultrasound or X-ray. The results were relatively normal.21. The doctor indicated that I had sustained a patella-femoral compression injury. The doctor advised that I could have an arthroscopy type procedure in relation to this injury. The doctor indicated that the bulk of my articular wear was probably pre-existing but that it had become symptomatic as a result of my injury. The wear was asymptomatic prior to my injury.22. On 16 March 2009, due to the immense grief induced stress relating to the loss of my daughter I suffered a major heart attack where I required the insertion of a stent.23. Shortly thereafter, I also contracted appendicitis and had to have surgery in relation to that issue also.24. With those issues over the following months, my symptoms during that time came good to the point where I did not require any knee procedure. In fact I have not seen Dr Colvin since 2009 or any other Orthopaedic Surgeon in relation to my right knee, until I sustained the injury the subject of these proceedings.25. In relation to my heart attack, I saw Dr Alan Whelan, Cardiology Consultant.26. I had discussions with Woolworths in relation to the incident, which resolved by way of settlement for a modest amount.27. Prior to the injuries the subject of my current claim, I was in good health and had no issues with my fitness to work.28. On 25 July 2013, I attended a comprehensive pre-employment medical examination at Leighton Health Centre for a pre-employment health assessment for work on the Gorgon Project, through a sub-contracting company, Broad Sword Marine Contractors, who I was employed by at the time. I had to attend the pre-employment medical, even though I was already employed by the company, for the purposes of working on this particular project.29. This was a strenuous medical examination which involved urine analysis, audiogram, spirometry, vision test, a cardiovascular test, a respiratory test, an abdominal examination, testing in relation to neck and back function and testing in relation to upper and lower limb function.30. As part of this examination, I was required to undertake a “heel walk”, a “duck walk”, a “toe walk” and “the plank”, the results of which were all normal. There was also a step test. I was also required to undertake push ups, above shoulder lifting, sustained squats, repetitive squats, kneeling for a protracted period and hovering on my toes. My knee extension was measured on both sides.31. I achieved good results and was certified fully fit to work as a Chief Engineer. The examining doctor certified that I was a low risk in terms of injury.32. The doctor indicated that there was some difficulty with my lung function and advised me to reduce smoking. A copy of the pre-employment health assessment documentation has been produced under Summons in these proceedings.33. I worked for Broad Sword Marine Contractors on Barrow Island for about 6 months immediately prior to commencing my employment with the Respondent, Samson Marine Pty Ltd (“Samson”). Samson approached me to work for them because the contract at the company I was currently working for was coming to completion at the end in February 2014. I had all the qualifications to work at Barrow Island, it was an easy transition for Samson to employ me, rather than to pay for training of a new employee and wait the time required to secure approval for a new employee, who would have to obtain the medical and associated clearances that I already had.34. On 23 February 2014 I undertook another rigorous pre-employment medical examination, for Samson. Once again, I successfully passed the examination.35. I started my swing with Samson at the end of February 2014, working as a Marine Engineer. My rate of pay (NWE) with Samson was $5,224.05 per week. Samson were responsible for anchor positioning, logistics, supplying fuel and water and towing barges to Mangrove Passage which was a safe haven for vessels in cyclones. Whilst at Mangrove Passage we would do the hook-up of the line of the barges to the mooring lines. To go there and back from Barrow Island took a full day.36. We were accommodated in crew compartments (mini cabins) on the barge Pacific Installer which was also used as general crew accommodation.37. 17 July 2014 was my first nights' accommodation on the Pacific Installer, with a twin bunk style beds [sic]. This particular room had not initially been built as a double room. The rooms were only supposed to accommodate 1 person. The bed had been recently modified in July 2014 because of the necessity for increased accommodation and in each small room, an extra bed had been installed by carpenters over the top of the existing lower bed, with a small ladder at the foot of the bed used to access the top bunk.38. I was in the process of getting up onto the top bunk as the lower bunk was to be used by a different worker on a different shift.39. I put my right foot on the bottom bed and then when putting my left foot onto the rail / ladder, I had to turn to the right to get into the bunk, levering myself up with both hands on top of the bunk. My right foot which was meant to pivot got caught on the contoured combing rail of the lower bunk causing my right knee to twist as I launched myself up onto the top bunk. I felt immediate pain. My knee made a crunch sound and immediately swelled up. I was in immense pain, and could not get back down due to the height of the bunk and awkward position of the ladder. With my painful, swollen knee, it was difficult to manoeuvre myself down from the bunk until the following morning. I was forced to try sleep with the light on, as in the haste of having additional bunks installed, light switches above the bunk bed had not yet been installed.40. A photograph of my bunk on the accommodation barge Pacific Installer is attached to the report of Dr Hardcastle filed by the Respondent in the proceedings.41. The incident was reported to my Skipper immediately upon arrival for duty where all incident reports and necessary documents were filed with the company. An appointment was arranged for me to see the medic onboard the Pacific Installer, Julie Robinson. Upon return to Barrow Island I was taken to the Barrow Island Medical centre by Julie Robinson where I was given treatment for pain relief, anti-inflammatory medication and ice with a bandage. I attended the Barrow Island Medical Centre every 2-3 days until my rostered swing finished.42. I was asked by Samson Maritime Management if I was able to finish my swing due to the difficulties in getting a replacement Chief Engineer at short notice. I agreed I could manage using pain relief until my swing finished on 31 July 2014. I did require some help from fellow crew members with my duties as it was a further 12 days until completion of my swing.43. I was flown back to Perth from Dampier through Karratha on 31 July 2014. Shortly prior thereto I was advised that my injury would not be covered by Workers Compensation. On 28 July 2014 I received an email from Ilana Jewson of the Samson HR Department to the effect that the injuries I sustained “were not work related as I did not injure myself on day to day duties as a chief engineer on the vessel” and “if I required medical treatment upon returning home it would be at my own cost”.44. On returning home to Perth, on 1 August 2014, I was sent to have an MRI by the company. The MRI revealed complex tearing to my medial meniscus combined with grade 1 sprain of the superficial medial collateral ligament and the medial patellofemoral ligament, moderate to severe chondral wear in the centre weight bearing portion of the medial femoral condyle.45. On the same day I attended upon Dr Wang-Jetyee at South Street Medical Centre. I was issued with a workers compensation Workcover First Certificate.46. I later came under the care of GP Dr John Hilton who was close to my home at Rockingham, who became my treating GP in relation to this injury.47. I lodged a claim for Seafarer’s compensation benefits. On 12 August 2014 at 11.30am I received an abusive and threatening phone call from an Allianz Representative, Robert Ramage (now deceased). He claimed to be an Allianz Claim Specialist. He attempted to convince me not to pursue the claim. I felt intimidated.48. On 13 August 2014 the Seafarer’s compensation insurer declined liability in respect of my claim.49. At my request of Dr John Hilton I was referred to see Mr Jens-Ulrich Buelow, Orthopaedic Surgeon who I saw for the first time on 20 August 2014. The doctor recommended that I undergo an arthroscopy and partial meniscectomy procedure. The doctor further opined that my condition was a work related injury particularly noting that I was pain and symptom free up until the accident had occurred. He also certified me unfit for work from 11 August 2014 to 30 August 2014. The doctor was the only surgeon who would perform surgery as a self-funded patient.50. On the same day I underwent X-rays of both my knees. The results were relatively normal.51. I again saw Mr Buelow on 25 August 2014. By this time I had decided to proceed with the arthroscopy and partial meniscectomy procedure recommended by the doctor and it was scheduled for the following day. The doctor once again confirmed with me that the meniscal tear was work related.52. On 26 August 2014, I underwent surgery at the hands of Mr Buelow at Bethesda Hospital, which I self-funded from my savings, at a cost of approximately $6500. I didn’t have private health cover. The procedure confirmed complex tearing to my medial meniscal body and posterior horn. There was also generalised grade 2 to 3 cartilage damage in the trochlea and medial femoral condyle. Careful chondroplasties were performed. Loose bodies were removed. I was released from hospital the following day.53. Shortly after having the procedure, I noted the clicking and crunching in my knee was still present and nothing had improved after surgery.54. On 2 September 2014, I attended upon GP, Dr S Sethuraman as Dr John Hilton was away. The doctor certified me unfit to work from 31 August 2014 to 30 September 2014.1 was prescribed Celebrex and Panadeine Forte.55. I saw Mr Buelow on 3 September 2014. The doctor was happy with my progress. He recommended physiotherapy and cycling and swimming at a later time. The doctor again indicated that he believed my condition was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition, caused by the accident at work. He certified me unfit for work from 3 September 2014 to 15 October 2014.56. On 30 September 2014, I attended upon Dr S Sethuraman. The doctor certified me unfit to work from 1 October to 31 October 2014.57. On 15 October 2014, I again attended upon Mr Buelow. At this time I was unhappy with my knee and had significant patellofemoral pain and discomfort. I had no improvement from the surgery. I was still unable to kneel, squat or run. I found it difficult to use my exercise bike. I asked Mr Buelow about my strained ligaments and I was told “they would improve in time”. That has not turned out to be the case. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 15 October 2014 to 30 November 2014.58. Mr Beulow recommended that I see a physiotherapist for a structured quadriceps and strengthening program. The doctor also recommended a Synvisc injection (costing $1000 per injection) and provided me with a referral to see Dr Lionel Lim for these purposes.59. With no income I was unable to afford any treatment at this time. The treatment recommended by Mr Buelow could not be funded under Medicare.60. On 30 October 2014, I attended upon Dr Sethuraman. The doctor certified me unfit to work from 30 October 2014 to 30 November 2014.61. On 1 December 2014, I attended upon Dr Sethuraman again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from l December 2014 to 5 January 2015.62. On 5 January 2015, I attended upon Dr Sethuraman again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 5 January 2015 to 5 February 2015.63. On 4 February 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 4 February 2015 to 30 March 2015.64. On 4 March 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 4 March 2015 to 4 April 2015.65. On 2 April 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 2 April 2015 to 2 May 2015.66. At around this time I commenced on Lyrica medication.67. On 8 April 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. Due to my ongoing symptoms, I asked the doctor for a referral for a second opinion. The doctor arranged a referral to see Dr Tony Robinson, Orthopaedic Surgeon. I was also issued with a further certificate certifying me unfit for work from 8 April 2015 to 8 May 2015.68. On 21 April 2015, I attended upon Dr Robinson for further opinion. The doctor referred me for MRI of my right knee which I had on 22 April 2015.69. The results revealed interim partial medial meniscectomy with several tiny remnant tears in the posterior horn and the posterior horn's body junction, mild medial tibial femoral degeneration, small amount of new high grade chondral fissuring on the posterior third of the lateral tibial plateau, new moderate size high grade chondral flap on the patella with a tiny chondral flap on the upper trochlea and moderate knee joint effusion containing synovitis and lipoma arborescent.70. Ultimately, Dr Robinson indicated that I should be assessed regarding medial collateral ligament reconstruction and chondroplasty of the right patella. The doctor also indicated my ongoing problems were due to my work related injury on 17 July 2014.71. On 8 May 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 8 May 2015 to 8 June 2015.72. On 20 May 2015, I attended upon Dr Phillip Hardcastle at the behest of the solicitors for the Seafarer’s compensation Insurer. The doctor took a history from me and I answered the doctor’s questions to the best of my ability.73. In relation to my past medical history, the doctor discussed with me in great detail the recreational motor bike fall I had had in 1975 as a juvenile. In regards to the fall I had at Woolworths in February 2009, at the time of the examination I had no recollection of the incident. I was not reminded of the incident until documents were produced in these proceedings by Dr Joyce. I believe the incident didn’t come to mind at this time as the fall had not caused any permanent injury to my knee, and the discomfort in relation to the fall had resolved.74. On 4 June 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. I was certified unfit for work from 4 June 2015 to 4 July 2015.75. On 3 July 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. I was certified unfit for work from 3 July 2015 to 23 August 2015.76. On 30 July 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. I was certified unfit for work from 30 July 2015 to 30 October 2015.77. On 30 October 2015, I attended upon Dr Hilton again. The doctor certified me unfit for work from 30 October 2015 to 30 January 2016.78. I continue to suffer from pain, weakness, instability and crunching about the right knee. I am unable to run, squat or kneel. I can climb stairs one at a time but this causes pain and I have to take it slowly. The situation is similar in terms of ladder climbing. As there is a significant amount of stairs and ladder climbing and working in confined spaces in my pre injury role these issues are preventing me from returning to work. I am currently on pain management medication.MEDICAL EVIDENCELetter from Julie Robinson, Paramedic, Leighton Contractors (undated) (T9 at 40)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, having found that Mr Dimoff is entitled to compensation for his injury, and in light of the provisions of sections 49 and 50 of the SRC Act, the Tribunal finds that the Respondent is required to arrange an assessment of Mr Dimoff’s capacity under section 49 of the SRC Act and make arrangements under section 50 for the provision of a rehabilitation program.DECISION On 17 July 2014, Mr Dimoff suffered an injury (other than a disease) as that term is used in section 3 of the SRC Act - that being an injury to the right knee, involving posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellar-femoral ligament. In the circumstances, as Mr Dimoff’s injury does not constitute a “disease” for the purposes of the SRC Act, section 10(7) of the SRC Act does not apply to these proceedings. Accordingly, the decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided that:·Liability exists as a result of an injury sustained by the Applicant to the right knee, involving a posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellofemoral ligament.·For the period 17 July 2014 (the date of injury) to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for incapacity for work as a result of the injury in accordance with section 31 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth).·For the period 17 July 2014 to the present date, compensation is payable to the Applicant for the cost of medical treatment for the Injury sustained by the Applicant on 17 July 2014, in accordance with section 28 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992. ·The Respondent is to arrange for assessment of the Applicant’s capability under section 49 of the Seafarers Compensation and Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 and make arrangements under section 50 for provision of a rehabilitation program.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In that regard, the Tribunal has reviewed the contents of the following documents: ·Pre-Employment Medical Questionnaire dated 25 July 2013 (R2)·Report of Dr Colvin dated 3 March 2009 (R3)·Letter from Dr Colvin to Dr Whelan dated 7 July 2009 (R4)·Letter from John Dimoff to Tracy Warwick dated 2 July 2009 with attachment (R5)·Letter from Brennan and Associates to Dibbs Barker dated 15 April 2009 (R6)·Draft unsigned statement of John Kenand Dimoff (R7)·Report of Dr McCarthy dated 22 January 2007 (R8)·Claim for Rehabilitation/Compensation dated 23 March 2005 (R9)·Report of Dr Michael Bloom dated 2 July 2005 (R10)·Report of Dr Barrie Slinger dated 19 September 2006 (R11)·Bundle of WorkCover Workers’ Compensation Progress Medical Certificates – pages 435-487 (R12)·Settlement and Release Agreement dated October 2008 (R13)·Report of Dr Colvin dated 2 March 2009 (R14)·Clinical notes from Grange Medical Centre (R15)CONSIDERATIONDiagnosis of Mr Dimoff’s Right Knee Injury In its written submissions dated 4 March 2016, counsel for the Respondent described the nature of Mr Dimoff’s injury as “posteriorhorn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion and an injury to the medial patellofemoral joint”. In written submissions dated 14 March 2016, counsel for Mr Dimoff wrote as follows:13.... The nature of that injury is best appreciated by reference to [T7], an entirely objective assessment, which highlights:(1)a tear “involving the posterior horn of the medial meniscus extending into the root and with probable involvement of the root ligaments”;(2)“grade 1 sprain of the superficial medial collateral ligament and the medial patellofemoral ligament”;and also mentions chondral wear and effusion.14.Dr Hardcastle’s report [Exhibit Al, pp7 and 8], provides substantial corroboration of that.…16.It is accordingly submitted that on the evidence, the summary of injury at submission 3.1 of the respondent’s submissions would be better described as:“injury to the right knee, involving posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellar-femoral ligament.” Having reviewed the evidence before it, the Tribunal agrees that the best description of the nature of Mr Dimoff’s workplace injury is “injury to the right knee, involving posterior horn tear of the medial meniscus, knee joint effusion, injury to the medial patellofemoral joint and possible sprain of the medial collateral ligament and medial patellar-femoral ligament.”“Injury” or “Disease” There was considerable disagreement between the parties in relation to this issue. Not surprisingly, given the significance of section 10(7) of the SRC Act to this matter, the Respondent was keen to stress that Mr Dimoff’s injury was a “disease” as that term is defined in section 3 of the SRC Act. This is particularly relevant because, as noted above, to the extent that Mr Dimoff’s right knee condition is a “disease” then any evidence that he failed to disclose relevant medical evidence to his employer would mean that he is not entitled to any compensation of any sort under the SRC Act. If, however, the right knee condition is an “injury” then compensation may result.