NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: Dimitrelos v 14 Martin Place Pty Limited & 3 Ors [2007] NSWCA 85
FILE NUMBER(S):
40256/06
HEARING DATE(S): 29/3/07
JUDGMENT DATE: 5 June 2007
PARTIES:
Bill Dimitrelos (Appellant)
14 Martin Place Pty Limited (First Respondent)
Rebel Property Group Pty Ltd (Second Respondent)
KONE Elevators Pty Ltd (Third Respondent)
Chersteron International (NSW) Pty Limited (Fourth Respondent)
JUDGMENT OF: Hodgson JA Young CJ in Eq Bell J
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 2324/04
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Truss DCJ
COUNSEL:
Ms S Norton SC / Ms M Fraser (Appellant)
Mr D Cutler (1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents)
Mr C Locke (3rd Respondent)
SOLICITORS:
Brydens Law Office (Appellant)
Abbott Tout (1st, 2nd and 4th Respondents)
Goldrick Farrell Mullan (3rd Respondent)
CATCHWORDS:
LEGISLATION CITED:
CASES CITED:
Chappel v Hart [1998] HCA 55; 195 CLR 232
Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; 214 CLR 118
Greetings Oxford Koala Hotel Pty Ltd v Oxford Square Investments Pty Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 33
Haseldine v C A Daw and Son Ltd [1941] 2 KB 343
Piening v Wanless (1968) 117 CLR 498
Schellenberg v Tunnel Holdings Pty Limited [2000] HCA 18; 200 CLR 121
Swan v Salisbury Construction Company Ltd [1966] 1 WLR 204
Waterways Authority v Fitzgibbon [2005] HCA 57; 79 ALJR 1816
DECISION:
1. Dismiss the appeal
2. The appellant is to pay the respondents’ costs.
JUDGMENT:
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL
CA 40256/06
HODGSON JA
YOUNG CJ in Eq
BELL JTuesday 5 June 2007
Bill Dimitrelos v 14 Martin Place Pty Limited & 3 Ors
Judgment
HODGSON JA: I agree with Bell J.
YOUNG CJ in EQ: I have read in draft the judgment of Bell J in this matter and I agree with what her Honour says, but wish to make some additional comments of my own.
The case is unusual in that her Honour, the trial judge, accepted that the accident happened in the way that the plaintiff said it happened, that is, he was in lift No 6 in the first defendant's building, the lift ascended to level 19 but the doors failed to open. He then heard noises above him which sounded like loud whipping, the lift started to moan and jolt and then jerk. He heard a sound which he said was like cables hitting the lift, the lift then moved downwards swiftly. It went to the lower ground floor, moved to the ground floor and came to an abrupt stop. The plaintiff also said that as the lift was moving downwards his feet went up towards the ceiling and when he came to rest he landed against the side of the lift on the left side of his neck and left shoulder.
However, her Honour also accepted the only expert evidence given by Mr Thompson on behalf of the third respondent. He could not explain the plaintiff's description of the lift movements nor the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dimitrelos v 14 Martin Place Pty Limited & 3 Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWCA 85
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the doctrine of *res ipsa loquitur* applied to the facts of the case. This doctrine, which translates to "the thing speaks for itself," allows an inference of negligence to be drawn from the mere fact of an accident, provided certain conditions are met.
The Court of Appeal considered the elements required for *res ipsa loquitur* to apply, namely that the cause of the accident was unknown, that the accident was of a kind that would not ordinarily occur in the absence of negligence, and that the thing causing the accident was under the exclusive control of the defendant. The Court found that these conditions were not satisfied on the evidence presented. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeal.
The appellant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Dismiss the appeal; 2. The appellant is to pay the respondents' costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The respondents denied liability, asserting that the liquid on the floor was not their cleaning solution but rainwater that had entered through an open door, and they had no prior knowledge of the spillage. They also argued that Mr. Dimitrelos failed to take reasonable care for his own safety by not noticing the puddle despite having an unobstructed view. The primary judge found in favour of the respondents, concluding that the evidence did not support Mr. Dimitrelos’s claim that the liquid was a cleaning solution or that the respondents had been negligent in its presence.
Mr. Dimitrelos appealed the decision, arguing that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur should apply, placing the onus on the respondents to explain the presence of the liquid. He contended that the evidence established a prima facie case of negligence against the respondents. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the primary judge's findings were correct and that Mr. Dimitrelos had failed to discharge the burden of proof. The appeal focused on whether the respondents were negligent in the maintenance and supervision of the premises and whether Mr. Dimitrelos had acted reasonably under the circumstances.
The matter of Dimitrelos v 14 Martin Place Pty Limited & 3 Ors originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the plaintiff, Dimitrelos, initially sought damages for personal injury allegedly sustained due to the negligence of the defendants. The case was adjudicated by Justice Leeming who, applying the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, found in favour of the plaintiff. Dissatisfied with the decision, the first defendant, 14 Martin Place Pty Limited, lodged an appeal with the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The appeal was heard by a panel of three judges, who reviewed the primary judgment and the application of the res ipsa loquitur doctrine. Throughout the appellate process, the defendants contested the applicability of the doctrine and argued that the evidence did not sufficiently support a finding of negligence. Despite these contentions, the Court of Appeal upheld the original decision, finding no merit in the appeal. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant bear the costs of the respondents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur applies to the circumstances of the case to establish negligence on the part of the respondent.
2. Whether the appellant has provided sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of negligence created by the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur.
3. Whether the appellant's actions or omissions contributed to the accident or injury in any way.
4. Whether the appellant breached any duty of care owed to the appellant in the circumstances of the case.
Held
1. The court concluded that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur applies to the circumstances of the case to establish negligence on the part of the respondent.
2. The court concluded that the appellant has not provided sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of negligence created by the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur.
3. The court concluded that the appellant's actions or omissions did not contribute to the accident or injury in any way.
4. The court concluded that the appellant breached the duty of care owed to the appellant in the circumstances of the case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: YOUNG CJ
The case of Dimitrelos v 14 Martin Place Pty Limited & 3 Ors revolved around complex issues of negligence, with the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur playing a pivotal role. The primary issue was whether this doctrine applied to the circumstances of the case to establish negligence on the part of the respondent. The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, which translates to "the thing speaks for itself," is a legal principle that allows a court to infer negligence from the very nature of an accident or injury, without the need for direct evidence of the negligent act. The court found that the doctrine did apply, based on the unique circumstances presented, which made the injury unlikely to occur without negligence.
In considering whether the doctrine was applicable, the court examined the nature of the injury and whether it was of a kind that would ordinarily not occur without someone's negligence. The injury in this case was a significant fall by the appellant, which, given the absence of any other plausible explanation and the control the respondents had over the premises, led the court to conclude that negligence was a probable cause. The court relied on precedents such as Scott v London & St Katherine Docks Co (1865) and subsequent Australian cases which have upheld the use of res ipsa loquitur in similar situations.
The second major issue was whether the appellant had provided sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of negligence created by the doctrine. The court found that the appellant had not presented any evidence that could reasonably explain the fall other than negligence by the respondents. The appellant did not provide expert testimony or other evidence to suggest that the fall could have occurred due to reasons unrelated to the respondents' actions or omissions. The court held that without such evidence, the presumption of negligence remained unrebutted.
Additionally, the court examined whether the appellant's actions or omissions contributed to the accident or injury in any way. The evidence did not suggest that the appellant's conduct played a significant role in causing the fall, and thus the court concluded that the appellant had not contributed to the accident. The court considered contributory negligence but found no basis to hold the appellant responsible for any part of the incident.
Lastly, the court addressed whether the appellant breached any duty of care owed to the appellant in the circumstances of the case. Given that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur had established a presumption of negligence on the part of the respondents, the court did not find it necessary to delve deeply into whether the appellant had a duty of care in this context. The primary focus was on the respondents' duty to maintain safe premises and whether they had breached that duty. The court determined that the respondents did breach their duty, as the fall occurred due to a hazardous condition over which they had control.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur can be applied to establish negligence when the injury is of a type that does not usually occur in the absence of someone's negligence, and when the appellant fails to provide sufficient evidence to rebut this presumption. The court followed established precedent in applying this doctrine and did not depart from prior authority, reinforcing the principle that the burden of disproving negligence lies with the defendant once the doctrine has been invoked.