IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S124 of 2006
B e t w e e n -
RIFAAT GEORGE DIMIAN
First Plaintiff
CHEE KAN KENNETH WONG
Second Plaintiff
and
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Defendant
Summons for directions
GLEESON CJ
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON WEDNESDAY, 11 OCTOBER 2006, AT 10.16 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR D.F. JACKSON, QC: Your Honour, I appear with my learned friend, MR M.A. ROBINSON, for the applicant. (instructed by TressCox Lawyers)
MR D.M.J. BENNETT, QC, Solicitor-General for the Commonwealth of Australia: I appear with my learned friend, MS R.M. HENDERSON, for the defendant. (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
HIS HONOUR: Yes, Mr Jackson.
MR JACKSON: Your Honour should have, I think, a draft of some questions for referral to the Full Court and also a draft agreed statement of fact.
HIS HONOUR: I am not sure about the questions. I saw a draft of an agreed statement of facts.
MR JACKSON: May I give your Honour a copy of the questions.
HIS HONOUR: Thank you.
MR JACKSON: Your Honour, could I just mention something about the agreed statement of facts first?
HIS HONOUR: Yes.
MR JACKSON: We have had some further discussions this morning and the draft that your Honour would have received has some slight amendments to it which we have only just made. I wondered if I could indicate those to your Honour?
HIS HONOUR: Certainly.
MR JACKSON: The first is, your Honour, at the bottom of page 5 in footnote 3.
HIS HONOUR: This matter seems to have some age on it. The determination or the preliminary determination, or whatever it was, of the body seems to have been made in January 2004, according to this agreed statement of facts.
MR JACKSON: Yes, your Honour, that is the ‑ ‑ ‑
HIS HONOUR: I am looking at paragraph 17. On 13 January 2004 the Committee made a final report.
MR JACKSON: Well, your Honour, there were other proceedings, I think, between other parties that perhaps resulted in this being ‑ ‑ ‑
HIS HONOUR: This does not look like a rush to justice.
MR JACKSON: Well, your Honour will have seen the position in paragraph 18, for example, and there was a decision in the Full Court of the Federal Court in another matter.
HIS HONOUR: Exactly. I am wondering why that should not just take its course.
MR JACKSON: Well, could we say this, your Honour. The issues that are involved in this case go – and your Honour will see that, I think, in the outline of submissions we had on the original directions hearing when the matter was before Justice Heydon. Your Honour will see in paragraph 4 we indicated that the matter was of considerable significance to a large number of medical practitioners and also your Honour will see in ‑ ‑ ‑
HIS HONOUR: I understand that, but it must…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dimian & Anor v Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] HCATrans 565
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the delegate of the Minister, in refusing the protection visa application, had failed to afford the applicants procedural fairness. Specifically, the applicants contended that they were not given adequate notice of adverse information that was relied upon by the delegate in reaching the decision, nor were they given a sufficient opportunity to respond to that information.
Gleeson CJ, in delivering the judgment, considered the principles of procedural fairness as established in Australian administrative law. His Honour affirmed that a person facing a decision that may adversely affect their rights or interests is entitled to know the case they have to meet and to have an opportunity to answer it. The Court found that the delegate had relied on adverse information that had not been disclosed to the applicants, thereby breaching the duty to afford procedural fairness. The failure to provide the applicants with an opportunity to comment on the adverse material meant the decision was vitiated by jurisdictional error.
Consequently, the High Court made orders quashing the decision of the delegate to refuse the protection visa application. The matter was remitted to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to be determined according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiffs argue that their compulsory participation in the Medicare scheme amounts to civil conscription, which may contravene section 51(xxiiiA) of the Australian Constitution. The Commonwealth, represented by the Solicitor-General, contends that the matter is one of statutory interpretation rather than constitutional law and that the facts have been comprehensively agreed upon by the parties. The Commonwealth also notes that a similar case, Selim v Lele, is pending before the Full Court of the Federal Court and may ultimately be appealed to the High Court. The agreed statement of facts in the current case, which the Commonwealth argues provides a clearer and more detailed factual basis than Selim v Lele, includes information on the sources of general practice funding and the potential financial consequences for medical practitioners excluded from the scheme.
The court, presided over by Gleeson CJ, considered whether the case should proceed in the High Court or be remitted to the Federal Court. Gleeson CJ expressed concern about the clarity and relevance of some of the facts in the agreed statement, particularly those relating to general practice funding, and suggested that the Federal Court might be better equipped to address issues of evidence admissibility and factual disputes. Ultimately, Gleeson CJ decided to remit the case to the Federal Court, noting the lack of urgency and the potential for the matter to be resolved in conjunction with the pending case of Selim v Lele. Gleeson CJ also ordered that the costs incurred in the High Court to date would be costs in the Federal Court proceedings.
The matter of Dimian & Anor v Commonwealth of Australia was before the High Court on an application for directions. This case was filed in May 2006, and the primary focus was on the constitutional validity of certain legislative provisions related to medical practitioners. The proceedings in the High Court followed a series of events, including a determination made in January 2004, which led to the current litigation. The case was heard in the presence of counsel for both parties, with Mr D.F. Jackson, QC, representing the applicants and Mr D.M.J. Bennett, QC, representing the Commonwealth of Australia. The applicants sought to have specific questions referred to the Full Court, along with an agreed statement of facts, to facilitate a final determination. However, the Court, represented by Justice Gleeson, decided that the matter should be remitted to the Federal Court for further proceedings. This decision was made considering the existing litigation in the Federal Court, specifically the case of Selim v Lele, and the desire for a prompt resolution due to the broader implications for medical practitioners. The Court emphasised the importance of having a comprehensive and clear set of facts before making any final constitutional determinations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Medicare Benefits Schedule (Schedule 2) of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) amount to civil conscription within the meaning of section 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution?
2. Are the agreed facts relevant to the constitutional validity of the legislation and should they be dealt with by a court capable of addressing objections to relevance or testing the information?
3. Should the proceedings be remitted to the Federal Court to await the decision in Selim v Lele, or is this case a more appropriate vehicle for deciding the constitutional question?
4. What is the appropriate course for determining the constitutional validity of the scheme in light of the pending litigation in Selim v Lele and the potential appeal to the High Court concerning the Auditors Board cases?
Held
1. The court did not decide on the constitutional validity of the Medicare Benefits Schedule in relation to civil conscription.
2. The court found that the agreed facts were relevant to the constitutional validity of the legislation and should be tested by a court capable of addressing objections to relevance or testing the information.
3. The court decided to remit the proceedings to the Federal Court to await the decision in Selim v Lele, rather than making this case the primary vehicle for deciding the constitutional question.
4. In light of the pending litigation in Selim v Lele and the potential appeal to the High Court concerning the Auditors Board cases, the court decided to remit the case to the Federal Court, allowing the Federal Court to determine the appropriate course for deciding the constitutional validity of the scheme.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue before the Court was whether the Medicare Benefits Schedule (Schedule 2) of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) amounted to civil conscription within the meaning of section 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution. The Court found that the agreed facts, although relevant, were not entirely clear and that the information required to fully understand the implications of the legislation should be tested by a court with the capacity to deal with objections to relevance or to test the information. The Court considered that the information should be dealt with by the Federal Court, which had the ability to address any objections to relevance and test the information in a manner that the High Court could not.
The Court also deliberated on whether the agreed facts should be dealt with by a court capable of addressing objections to relevance or testing the information. The Court reasoned that the agreed facts, which were intended to establish the constitutional validity of the legislation, should be reviewed by a court that could adequately assess their relevance and clarity. The Court noted that the information about the year 2001 to 2002 concerning major sources of general practice funding, for example, was not entirely clear without further context. The Court concluded that the Federal Court, with its ability to handle objections to relevance and test the information, was the appropriate forum for such an assessment.
The Court further considered whether the proceedings should be remitted to the Federal Court to await the decision in Selim v Lele or if this case was a more appropriate vehicle for deciding the constitutional question. The Court found that, while there was pending litigation in Selim v Lele, this case had a more convenient set of facts due to the agreement between the parties. The Court reasoned that the agreed statement of facts in this case provided more detailed and useful information than the contested facts in Selim v Lele. However, the Court ultimately decided that the proceedings should be remitted to the Federal Court because the constitutional question depended on the facts and their relevance, which should be assessed by a court with the capacity to handle objections and test the information.
The Court also considered the appropriate course for determining the constitutional validity of the scheme in light of the pending litigation in Selim v Lele and the potential appeal to the High Court concerning the Auditors Board cases. The Court concluded that the Federal Court should decide how to proceed with this matter, taking into account the current state of the litigation in Selim v Lele. The Court noted that the agreed facts in this case provided a more convenient basis for proceeding in the Federal Court and that it was desirable for the case to be determined as quickly as possible to avoid potential delays by other practitioners in the same situation.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the agreed facts, although relevant to the constitutional validity of the legislation, should be tested by a court with the capacity to address objections to relevance and test the information. The Federal Court, with its ability to handle objections and test the information, is the appropriate forum for such an assessment. The Court also found that the proceedings should be remitted to the Federal Court to await the decision in Selim v Lele and that the Federal Court should determine the appropriate course for deciding the constitutional question, taking into account the pending litigation and potential appeal to the High Court.