IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S212 of 2011
B e t w e e n -
DIB GROUP PTY LIMITED
Applicant
and
COOLABAH TREE AUST-WIDE PTY LIMITED
Respondent
Application for special leave to appeal
HAYNE J
BELL J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON FRIDAY, 7 OCTOBER 2011, AT 2.52 PM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR D.L. COOK: May it please the Court, I appear for the applicant. (instructed by Macree Law)
MR A.J. GREINKE: If it please the Court, I appear for the respondent. (instructed by Freestone Law Pty Ltd)
HAYNE J: Yes, Mr Cook.
MR COOK: Your Honour, the error made by the Full Court can be found at page 101 of application book in paragraph 93 in the last two sentences of that paragraph where the Court held that:
to obtain that rent, Dib Group would have had to maintain the head lease. Therefore it had to offset against that lost rent the payment for rent it would have made to Kevmark.
No other reason than that primary judge was correct to reason that way was offered by the Full Court for the deduction that was said to be necessary in order to calculate the damages. If your Honours turn to page 70 of the application book you will see the reasons in the trial judge’s second set of reasons as to why the amount had to be deducted at paragraphs (d) and in paragraph (e). At paragraph (d) his Honour held that:
in order to be in a position to derive that rent, Dib Group would have had to maintain its lease from Kevmark. Thus, it would have had to pay rent to Kevmark under the head lease –
He then goes on to calculate what that amount would have been and then in paragraph (e) proceeds to deduct that rent that otherwise would have had to be paid by the applicant to Kevmark from that sum. No reason is given for why that deduction is made. What it seems to suggest though is that the primary judge linked the entitlement of the applicant to receive future rentals under the sublease with a cost, namely, that of maintaining the head lease and an obligation to pay payment under the head lease. In doing so, he was wrong because, as the Full Court recognised, the two lease agreements and the obligations that arose under both of those were separate and distinct matters. Had the applicant in this case been the owner of the premises, there is little doubt that his Honour would have considered deducting from the future rentals due under the sublease, or in this case it would be a lease, the mortgage payments that the applicant otherwise would have to make in order to retain possession of the property.
HAYNE J: If things had been different, things would have been different, I fear, Mr Cook.
MR COOK: Yes, and, your…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dib Group Pty Limited v Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] HCATrans 287
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Full Federal Court had erred in its construction of the settlement agreement, specifically concerning the obligations of the respondent to provide certain information and make payments to the applicant. The applicant contended that the Full Federal Court had misconstrued the plain meaning of the terms of the settlement agreement, leading to an incorrect conclusion that no breach had occurred.
In dismissing the application for leave to appeal, Hayne and Bell JJ held that the Full Federal Court had correctly interpreted the settlement agreement. Their Honours found that the terms of the agreement, when read as a whole, did not impose the obligations that the applicant sought to enforce. The court applied established principles of contractual interpretation, emphasizing the importance of giving effect to the ordinary meaning of the words used by the parties in the context of the entire agreement. The application for leave to appeal was therefore refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the proceedings, the primary judge found Dib Group liable for damages arising from the early termination of the sublease and ordered Dib Group to pay Coolabah $390,000. The primary judge calculated the damages based on the lost future rental income under the sublease, less an amount that the primary judge considered as a "cost saving" to Dib Group resulting from the termination of the head lease. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales upheld the primary judge's decision, but reduced the amount of damages payable by Dib Group to Coolabah to $239,554. Dib Group sought special leave to appeal to the High Court, arguing that the Full Court had erred in law by allowing the deduction of the "cost saving" from the damages.
The material facts that gave rise to the legal dispute in this case include the existence of the sublease and head lease agreements, the termination of both leases, and the calculation of damages by the primary judge and the Full Court. The primary judge found Dib Group liable for the early termination of the sublease and calculated the damages based on the lost future rental income under the sublease. However, the primary judge also deducted an amount from the damages that the primary judge considered as a "cost saving" to Dib Group arising from the termination of the head lease. The Full Court upheld the primary judge's decision but reduced the amount of damages payable by Dib Group to Coolabah. Dib Group argued that the Full Court had erred in law by allowing the deduction of the "cost saving" from the damages.
Dib Group Pty Limited (the applicant) applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal against a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (the Full Court). The matter before the High Court was an appeal from the Full Court's decision which upheld a decision of the primary judge. The Full Court rejected the applicant's contention that the primary judge erred in calculating damages by improperly deducting the amount of rent that would have been payable under a head lease from the damages awarded. The Full Court's decision was made after the applicant had unsuccessfully sought to appeal against the primary judge's decision to the Full Court, and the applicant had applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal against the Full Court's decision.
In the High Court, the applicant's counsel submitted that the Full Court had erred in law by perpetuating an error made by the primary judge in calculating the damages. The Full Court had failed to correct an obvious mistake in its calculation of damages, which the counsel submitted was a basic error. The counsel argued that the error had resulted in the applicant receiving less in damages than it was required to pay its landlord under the head lease, which was illogical and contrary to the principles of damages. The respondent's counsel submitted that the Full Court's decision was correct and that the applicant's appeal had insufficient prospects of success. The High Court ultimately refused the applicant's application for special leave to appeal, finding that the appeal enjoyed insufficient prospects of success to warrant a grant of special leave.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Full Court err in affirming the primary judge's calculation of damages by deducting the rent Dib Group would have owed to Kevmark from the damages awarded?
2. Was the Full Court correct in affirming the primary judge's approach to the calculation of damages, considering the termination of the head lease and its effect on Dib Group's liability to Kevmark?
3. Did the Full Court's failure to address the error pointed out in the appeal constitute a failure to exercise its visitorial jurisdiction, warranting intervention by the High Court?
Held
1. The court held that the Full Court did not err in affirming the primary judge's calculation of damages by deducting the rent Dib Group would have owed to Kevmark from the damages awarded. The Full Court's decision to affirm the primary judge's approach was upheld.
2. The court held that the Full Court was correct in affirming the primary judge's approach to the calculation of damages, considering the termination of the head lease and its effect on Dib Group's liability to Kevmark. The Full Court's approach to the damages calculation was deemed appropriate.
3. The court held that the Full Court's failure to address the error pointed out in the appeal did not constitute a failure to exercise its visitorial jurisdiction, and therefore, intervention by the High Court was not warranted. The Full Court's decision not to correct the error was upheld.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The central issue in Dib Group Pty Limited v Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Limited was whether the Full Court erred in affirming the primary judge's calculation of damages. Specifically, the applicant, Dib Group, argued that the Full Court should not have deducted the rent it would have owed to its landlord, Kevmark, from the damages awarded. Dib Group contended that the primary judge's reasoning was flawed because the two lease agreements were separate and distinct, and thus the obligations under each should not be offset against each other. The primary judge had deducted the rent Dib Group would have owed to Kevmark under the head lease from the damages awarded, reasoning that Dib Group would have had to maintain the head lease to obtain the rent under the sublease. The Full Court affirmed this deduction without providing a distinct rationale for it, leading to the contention that the error should have been corrected.
The legal principle at issue was the proper method for calculating damages in a breach of contract claim, particularly in relation to the offsetting of obligations under separate lease agreements. Dib Group argued that the primary judge's method of calculation was erroneous because it failed to recognize the separate nature of the obligations under the head lease and the sublease. The applicant argued that the damages should be calculated based on the lost profits from the sublease without any offset for the rent owed under the head lease, as there was no cost saving derived from the termination of the head lease. The Full Court's affirmation of the primary judge's approach without addressing the error highlighted in the appeal was seen as a failure to properly exercise its visitorial jurisdiction.
The court relied on the principle that damages in a breach of contract are intended to put the non-breaching party in the position it would have been in had the contract been performed. The court acknowledged that the primary judge's initial approach, which did not offset the rent Dib Group would have owed, was correct. The error lay in the subsequent reasoning that allowed for the offset. The Full Court's failure to address this error and provide a reasoned justification for affirming the primary judge's flawed approach was seen as a significant oversight. The applicant argued that the Full Court should have recognized the error and corrected it, as the Full Court's role includes ensuring the accuracy and fairness of the primary judge's reasoning.
The ratio decidendi of the case is that when the Full Court affirms a primary judge's erroneous reasoning without addressing the error, it constitutes a failure to properly exercise its visitorial jurisdiction. This failure to correct an obvious mistake based on basic legal principles invites the intervention of the High Court. However, in this case, the High Court found that the appeal had insufficient prospects of success because the error, while significant, did not warrant the grant of special leave to appeal. The court concluded that the Full Court's failure to correct the error did not rise to the level of a jurisdictional error that would justify the High Court's intervention. Therefore, the High Court refused special leave to appeal.