Dhir Pty Ltd Atf Dhir Family Trust (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Dhir Pty Ltd Atf Dhir Family Trust (Migration) [2023] AATA 1675 (6 June 2023)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Dhir Pty Ltd Atf Dhir Family Trust

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Jasminkumar Dipaklal Shah (MARN: 1808222)

CASE NUMBER:  2012293

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2018/935681

MEMBER:De-Anne Kelly

DATE:6 June 2023

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review to refuse the nomination.

Statement made on 06 June 2023 at 11.50am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – application for approval of nomination of position – direct entry stream – taxation accountant – need to employ nominee in position – no appearance at hearing – financial capacity to employ nominee for two years – small profit and loss in last two financial years – little evidence of nominee currently working in position – location of position – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 362B(1), (1A), 368, 375
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r 5.19(4)(a)(ii), (d), (h)(ii)

CASES
Bharaj Construction Pty Ltd v MIBP [2016] FCCA 902
Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration [2020] FCCA 3074

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 13 July 2020 to reject the applicant’s application for approval of the nomination of a position in Australia under reg 5.19 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations).

  2. The applicant applied for approval on 27 February 2018. The requirements for the approval of the nomination of a position in Australia are found in reg 5.19 of the Regulations which contains two alternative streams: a Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream (reg 5.19(3)) and a Direct Entry nomination stream (reg 5.19(4)). If the application is made in accordance with reg 5.19(2) and meets the requirements of either stream, then the application must be approved. If any of the requirements are not met then the application must be refused: reg 5.19(5).

  3. In this case, the applicant has applied for approval of a nomination, seeking to satisfy the criteria in the Direct Entry nomination stream.

  4. The delegate refused the application on the basis the applicant’s nomination did not satisfy reg 5.19(4)(a)(ii) of the Regulations because the application for approval had not identified a need for the nominator to employ a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s control. This was based on the lack of an organisational chart to show the day-to-day activity of the business and its staffing as well as evidence that the nominee may have been residing in another state and working for another employer during the time the applicant claimed he was employed and needed. There was insufficient evidence the nominee had been working for the applicant from late March 2018 as the only evidence was a PAYG payment summary for FY 2019 showing his earnings as $25,568 which is less than 50% of the nominated salary.

  5. The applicant was invited to appear before the Tribunal on 5 June 2023…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dhir Pty Ltd Atf Dhir Family Trust (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1675
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Dhir Pty Ltd Atf Dhir Family Trust for approval of a nomination for a Taxation Accountant position under the Direct Entry stream of the Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme. The applicant sought to employ Mr Tarun Kumar in the nominated position in Toowoomba, Queensland, with a proposed salary of $60,000. The decision reviewed was the refusal of this nomination.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met all the requirements for approval of the nomination under regulation 5.19(4) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). Specifically, the Tribunal considered the applicant's financial capacity to employ the nominee for the required period of at least two years, and whether there was a genuine need for the position.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the nomination. It reasoned that it was entitled to consider the financial viability of the applicant's business when assessing its ability to meet the requirement of employing the nominee for at least two years, citing established case law. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had shown a small profit and loss in recent financial years and that there was little evidence of the nominee currently working in the position. The Tribunal also noted that the applicant did not respond to an invitation to comment on a Section 375 Certificate, although it placed no weight on this certificate due to its age. The Tribunal concluded that not all requirements for the nomination's approval had been met.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 27 February 2018, Dhir Pty Ltd, trading as an accounting and financial services business, lodged an application for a Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme employer nomination visa subclass 187 under the Direct Entry Stream for a Taxation Accountant position to be employed in Toowoomba, Queensland, at an annual salary of $60,000. The nominee for the position was Mr. Tarun Kumar. Mr. Abhay Dhir is the director of the company. The application was subject to scrutiny and review, culminating in a decision by the Tribunal to affirm the refusal of the nomination.

The Tribunal's decision was based on several factors, including the financial viability of Dhir Pty Ltd and the terms of employment for the nominee. The company's financial statements showed small profits in the last two financial years, which raised concerns about the company's ability to employ the nominee for the required two years. Moreover, there was little evidence that the nominee was currently working in the specified position. The location of the position was also a point of contention, as the nominee's driver's license and bank records indicated an address in Nundah, Queensland, rather than Toowoomba.

Further complicating the matter was the nominee's employment history. The company had provided documentation that suggested the nominee had been employed since March 2018, but evidence from a state law enforcement agency and passenger records indicated that the nominee was residing in another Australian state during the purported period of employment and was employed with another organisation. The nominee explained that the passenger information related to a trip overseas they had taken together from Sydney, where he had recorded his brother's address as the address because that was where he had resided in Sydney before departure.

The Tribunal also considered a Section 375 Certificate, which contained the report of a site visit by Border Force officers to the premises in Toowoomba and Nerang, and a lease showing an option to extend for the Toowoomba premises. However, the Tribunal deemed this certificate irrelevant to the current decision as it pertained to a site visit conducted four years prior. In the hearing, the Tribunal would have provided the gist of the information covered by the certificate, but since it related to a past site visit, the Tribunal placed no weight on the certificate in making its decision.

This case concerns an application by Dhir Pty Ltd, trading as an accounting and financial services business, for approval of a nomination under the Direct Entry nomination stream of the Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme for the position of Taxation Accountant. The hearing was initially scheduled for 26 May 2023, but the agent requested a postponement due to being overseas and experiencing low internet connectivity. The hearing was rescheduled to 5 June 2023. The primary issue in this case is whether the applicant meets the requirements for approval of the nomination, specifically under regulation 5.19(4) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The applicant must demonstrate that the nominee will be employed on a full-time basis in the nominated position for at least two years and that the terms and conditions of the employment do not expressly exclude the possibility of extending the period of employment. The Tribunal considered the financial viability of the applicant's business, following precedents set in Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2020] FCCA3074 and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 264. Despite the applicant's arguments, the Tribunal upheld the decision to refuse the nomination, affirming the decision under review. The applicant did not respond to the Tribunal's invitation to comment on the validity of a Section 375 Certificate, which pertained to a site visit conducted four years prior and was therefore not given significant weight in the final decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The hearing was originally scheduled for 26 May 2023 however the agent advised that they were overseas and in an area of low internet connectivity and asked for the hearing to be postponed and set down after 3 June 2023 which was granted to 5 June 2023.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether the applicant meets the requirements for approval of the nomination under the Direct Entry nomination stream set out in reg 5.19(4), which is extracted in the attachment to this decision. For the nomination to be approved, all the requirements must be met. On 27 February 2018 the applicant trading as an accounting and financial services business lodged a Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme employer nomination visa subclass 187 in the Direct Entry Stream for the position of Taxation Accountant to be employed in Toowoomba QLD 4350 on $60,000 in favour of Mr Tarun Kumar. Mr Abhay Dhir is the director of the company. The Tribunal has considered the documents in Schedule 1 attached.Term of employment of the visa holder: reg 5.19(4)(d) Regulation 5.19(4)(d) requires the nominee to be employed in the nominated position for at least 2 years full time, and the terms and conditions of that employment do not expressly exclude the possibility of an extension. The Tribunal notes the judgment of Judge Egan in Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2020] FCCA3074 at [5] where his Honour stated that the Tribunal was entitled to consider the financial viability of the applicants business in considering r.5.19(3)(d)(i) which is equally applicable to r.5.19(4)(d)(i) since the wording of the legislation is similar with r.5.19(3)(d) stating “the person will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years’ while r.5.19(4)(d)(i) states “the employee will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years”.Contrary to the applicant’s submissions, the Tribunal was entitled to consider the financial viability of the applicant’s business when considering whether the company was able to meet the requirement that it employ Ms Kaur on a full-time basis, for a period of at least two years, as provided for in r. 5.19(3)(d)(i) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“the Regulations”). In assessing the evidence the Tribunal has taken into account of the remarks of his Honour In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 264 at [22], and [28] – [30], Logan J accepted that a company’s financial viability was a matter to be taken into account when assessing whether or not a business was financially able to support the employment of a person for at least a two (2) year period and that it is not illogical, on the material which the Tribunal had, for the Tribunal not to be satisfied that the position could be supported on business performance for a further two years. Judge Greenwood supported this view in the subsequent case Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs[2022] FCA 660.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to affirm the decision under review to refuse the nomination.Procedural MattersSection 375 Certificate A certificate was provided with the gist of the information being the report of a site visit 23 October 2019 made by Border Force officers to the premises in Toowoomba and Nerang and a lease showing that the former had a lease which had an option to extend to 16 April 2020. The site visit was prompted by the number of business locations and Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme nominations the applicant had lodged. The nominee was assessed as working at the premises in Toowoomba as a Taxation Accountant at the time of the site visit. On 18 May 2023 the Tribunal wrote to the applicant enclosing a copy of the certificate and inviting them to comment on whether it was valid by 25 May 2023. There was no response to this invitation. In the hearing the Tribunal would have given the applicant the gist of the information covered by the certificate but since this related to a site visit undertaken some four years previously the Tribunal places no weight on the certificate in making a decision on this matter and will instead rely upon the material to hand. Postponement The hearing was originally scheduled for 26 May 2023 however the agent advised that they were overseas and in an area of low internet connectivity and asked for the hearing to be postponed and set down after 3 June 2023 which was granted to 5 June 2023.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether the applicant meets the requirements for approval of the nomination under the Direct Entry nomination stream set out in reg 5.19(4), which is extracted in the attachment to this decision. For the nomination to be approved, all the requirements must be met. On 27 February 2018 the applicant trading as an accounting and financial services business lodged a Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme employer nomination visa subclass 187 in the Direct Entry Stream for the position of Taxation Accountant to be employed in Toowoomba QLD 4350 on $60,000 in favour of Mr Tarun Kumar. Mr Abhay Dhir is the director of the company. The Tribunal has considered the documents in Schedule 1 attached.Term of employment of the visa holder: reg 5.19(4)(d) Regulation 5.19(4)(d) requires the nominee to be employed in the nominated position for at least 2 years full time, and the terms and conditions of that employment do not expressly exclude the possibility of an extension. The Tribunal notes the judgment of Judge Egan in Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2020] FCCA3074 at [5] where his Honour stated that the Tribunal was entitled to consider the financial viability of the applicants business in considering r.5.19(3)(d)(i) which is equally applicable to r.5.19(4)(d)(i) since the wording of the legislation is similar with r.5.19(3)(d) stating “the person will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years’ while r.5.19(4)(d)(i) states “the employee will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years”.Contrary to the applicant’s submissions, the Tribunal was entitled to consider the financial viability of the applicant’s business when considering whether the company was able to meet the requirement that it employ Ms Kaur on a full-time basis, for a period of at least two years, as provided for in r. 5.19(3)(d)(i) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“the Regulations”). In assessing the evidence the Tribunal has taken into account of the remarks of his Honour In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 264 at [22], and [28] – [30], Logan J accepted that a company’s financial viability was a matter to be taken into account when assessing whether or not a business was financially able to support the employment of a person for at least a two (2) year period and that it is not illogical, on the material which the Tribunal had, for the Tribunal not to be satisfied that the position could be supported on business performance for a further two years.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review to refuse the nomination.De-Anne KellyMemberATTACHMENT - EXTRACTS FROM THE MIGRATION REGULATIONS 19945.19Approval of nominated positions (employer nomination)…(2)The application must:(a)be made in accordance with approved form 1395…; and(aa) include a written certification by the nominator stating whether or not the nominator has engaged in conduct, in relation to the nomination, that constitutes a contravention of subsection 245AR(1) of the Act; and(b)be accompanied by the fee mentioned in regulation 5.37.…Direct Entry nomination(4)The Minister must, in writing, approve a nomination if:(a)the application for approval:(i) is made in accordance with subregulation (2); and(ii) identifies a need for the nominator to employ an identified person, as a paid employee, to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control; and(b)the nominator:(i) is actively and lawfully operating a business in Australia; and(ii) directly operates the business; and(c)for a nominator whose business activities include activities relating to the hiring of labour to other unrelated businesses — the position is within the business activities of the nominator and not for hire to other unrelated businesses; and(d)both of the following apply:(i) the employee will be employed on a full-time basis in the position for at least 2 years;(ii) the terms and conditions of the employee’s employment will not include an express exclusion of the possibility of extending the period of employment; and(e)the terms and conditions of employment applicable to the position will be no less favourable than the terms and conditions that:(i) are provided; or(ii) would be provided;to an Australian citizen or an Australian permanent resident for performing equivalent work in the same workplace at the same location; and(f)either:(i) there is no adverse information known to Immigration about the nominator or a person associated with the nominator; or(ii) it is reasonable to disregard any adverse information known to Immigration about the nominator or a person associated with the nominator; and(g)the nominator has a satisfactory record of compliance with the laws of the Commonwealth, and of each State or Territory in which the applicant operates a business and employs employees in the business, relating to workplace relations; and(h)either:(i) all of the following apply:(A)the tasks to be performed in the position will be performed in Australia and correspond to the tasks of an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph;(AA)there is a genuine need for the nominator to employ the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii), as a paid employee, to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control;(AAA)the occupation is applicable to the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii) in accordance with the specification of the occupation;(B)either:(I)the nominator’s business has operated for at least 12 months, and the nominator meets the requirements for the training of Australian citizens and Australian permanent residents that are specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-sub-subparagraph; or(II)the nominator’s business has operated for less than 12 months, and the nominator has an auditable plan for meeting the requirements specified in the instrument mentioned in sub-sub-subparagraph (I); or(ii) all of the following apply:(A)the position is located in regional Australia;(B)there is a genuine need for the nominator to employ the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii), as a paid employee, to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control;(C)the position cannot be filled by an Australian citizen or an Australian permanent resident who is living in the same local area as that place;(D)the tasks to be performed in the position correspond to the tasks of an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph;(DA)the occupation is applicable to the person identified under subparagraph (a)(ii) in accordance with the specification of the occupation;(E)the business operated by the nominator is located at that place;(F)a body that is:(I)specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this sub-subparagraph; and(II)located in the same State or Territory as the location of the position;has advised the Minister about the matters mentioned in paragraph (e) and sub-subparagraphs (B) and (C).Schedule 1 – Case number 2012293Documents including the following were provided with the original application.1) Email 6 July 2020 from the Department declining extension of time in response to request from the applicant.2) Acknowledgement of application received 27 February 2018.3) Online application 27 February 2018.4) ASIC registration and business name registration.5) BAS statement FY 2016, FY 2017, FY 2018, FY 20196) Organisation chart.7) Financial flow sheet for Toowoomba and Darwin office for FY 2018.8) Employment contract undated.9) Lease agreement for Toowoomba premises from 17 April 2017 to 16 April 2018 with option for further two (2) years at $750 + GST per month.10) Bank statement 2017 for the applicant.11) Financial statement FY 2017, FY 201912) Trust tax return FY 2019.13) Regional Certifying Body (RCB) approval 25 May 2018 stating “Need proven ?? See attached letter >>ACCEPT.”14) Letter on the need for the position including a. Advertisement online posted on 13 February 2018.b. Recruitment summary showing 4 candidates who were unsuitable.c. Job description.15) Market salary analysis.16) Dhir Family Trust Deed.17) Request from the Department for further information 17 December 2019.18) Lease agreement for the Toowoomba premises from 17 April 2018 to 16 April 2020 with a option for renewal of 2 x 1 years with a final date for exercise of the option as 29 February 2020 at $1,450 + GST per month.19) PAYG payment summary nominee for FY 2019.20) Payslip for the nominee FY 2020 showing address in Nundah QLD 4102.21) Letter from Nominee’s bank.22) Drivers licence nominee issued 29 August 2019 showing address in Nundah QLD 4102.23) Letter from the Department inviting the applicant to comment on adverse information being the contrary to the advice of the director that the nominee commenced employment in March 2018 they had evidence from a state law enforcement agency and passenger records that he was residing in another Australian state during his employment with the business and he was employed with another organisation.24) Email request 30 June 2020 from the agent for extension of time.25) Email form the Department 6 July 2020 declining the extension request.26) Leave request from the nominee to the applicant February 2019.27) Statutory declaration 7 July 2020 from an apparent flat mate of the nominee stating that he lives in shared accommodation in Nundah QLD and that the nominee travels frequently between Brisbane and Sydney.28) The nominee responded to the invitation to comment on the adverse information by stating that he frequently travelled to Sydney to visit his brother and the passenger information related to a trip oversea they had taken together from Sydney and where he had recorded his brothers address as the address because that was where he had resided in Sydney before departure.29) Interview Plan for a Department Site visit to the applicant.Documents including the following were provided after the review application.30) Notice of Decision Nomination Refusal notice 13 July 2020.31) Invitation to provide updated information to the Tribunal 19 October 2022.32) Request 2 November 2022 from the applicant for extension of time of 28 days.33) Extension granted by Tribunal to 30 November 2022.34) Submission 30 November 2022 from the agent including 35) ASIC registration.36) Organisation chart showing the nominee’s position as “waiting visa” and “Position open”.37) Financial statement FY 202138) BAS statements FY 2020, FY 2021 and FY 2022.39) Employment agreement 1 February 2018.40) Employment agreement 30 November 2022 including “Your start date will be AFTER APPOVAL OF The 187 VISA GRANT”. Letterhead shows business addresses as Browns Plains QLD 4118 and Gatton QLD 4343. A probation period of 6 months would apply with the statement “During this time, we will assess your progress and performance in the position”.41) Request 13 May 2023from the agent for a postponement until 3 June 2023.42) Hearing notice advising hearing postponed to 5 June 2023.43) Invitation 18 May 2023 from the Tribunal inviting comment on the validity of the s375 certificate by 25 May 2023.