DFS Australia Pty Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

DFS Australia Pty Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs [2016] AATA 277 (29 April 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/6388

Re

DFS Australia Pty Limited

APPLICANT

And

Comptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S E Frost

Date 29 April 2016
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................[sgd]................................................

Deputy President S E Frost

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS – import duty – claims for drawback of import duty on goods exported from Australia – whether duty drawback available to Applicant – whether Applicant ‘legal owner’ of goods at time of exportation – meaning of legal owner – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Customs Act 1901 s 4, 168

Customs Regulations 1926 regs 129, 134,

Customs Amendment Regulations 2006 (No. 4)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Explanatory Statement, Customs Amendment Regulations 2006 (No.4)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S E Frost

29 April 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant is the Australian member of a corporate group which operates a duty-free shopping network in Australia, Asia-Pacific, North America and the Middle East.

  2. For about 15 years, between 1997 and 2013, the Applicant lodged more or less monthly claims for drawback of import duty in respect of goods exported from Australia.  The claims were generally approved and paid by the Respondent.

  3. However, in November 2014, the Respondent notified the Applicant that 17 duty drawback claims made by the Applicant in respect of goods exported from Australia between August 2013 and October 2014 had been refused.  The Respondent refused the claims because it considered that the Applicant was not the ‘legal owner’ of the goods at the time they were exported from Australia, considering instead that legal ownership of the goods had by that time passed to the Applicant’s customers.  Since duty drawback is only available to the person who is the ‘legal owner’ of the goods at the time they are exported from Australia, the Respondent refused the claims.

  4. The Applicant has now applied to the Tribunal, under s 273GA(jb) of the Customs Act 1901 (the Customs Act), for review of that decision.

    THE ISSUE

  5. The issue before the Tribunal is whether, for the purposes of regulation 134(6) of the former Customs Regulations 1926 (the Customs Regulations), the Applicant was the ‘legal owner’ of the goods the subject of the claims at the time of their export from Australia. The Applicant says that it was, and that there is no impediment to the Respondent’s paying the drawback amount as claimed. The Respondent on the other hand maintains its position that the mandatory requirement in regulation 134(6) has not been satisfied.

    THE LEGISLATION

  6. Section 168 of the Customs Act provides that the regulations may make provision for and in relation to allowing drawbacks of duty paid on goods imported into Australia.

  7. At the time of the Applicant’s drawback claims, regulation 129 of the Customs Regulations provided as follows:

    (1)  This regulation applies to any imported goods on which import duty has been paid …

    (2)  Subject to these Regulations, drawback of import duty may be paid on the exportation of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DFS Australia Pty Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by DFS Australia Pty Limited against a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs regarding claims for drawback of import duty on goods exported from Australia. The core of the dispute revolved around whether DFS Australia was the "legal owner" of the goods at the time of their exportation, a prerequisite for claiming duty drawback under the relevant regulations. The case was heard by Deputy S E Frost P.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine the meaning of "legal owner" as used in regulation 134(6) of the Customs Regulations, particularly in the context of goods sold to travellers under a "sealed bag regime." DFS Australia contended that it retained legal ownership of the goods until export, based on its role in entering the goods for home consumption, its retention of property under the Sale of Goods Act, and the significant constraints on the traveller's ability to deal with the goods prior to export. Alternatively, DFS Australia argued that even if property passed to the traveller, it retained a beneficial interest sufficient to be considered a legal owner.

Deputy S E Frost P considered the legislative intent behind the 2006 amendments to regulation 134(6), which introduced the singular phrase "the person" who is the legal owner, thereby intending to restrict drawback claims to a single, identifiable legal owner. The court found that for DFS Australia to be the sole legal owner at the time of export, it must have retained property in the goods. The court concluded that the terms of the contract and the sealed bag regime, which prohibited the traveller from accessing or disposing of the goods before export and required their return if not exported within a specified period, did not support the contention that DFS Australia retained property in the goods until export. Consequently, the court determined that DFS Australia was not "the person who is the legal owner of goods at the time the goods are exported" as required by regulation 134(6).

The decision under review was affirmed, meaning that DFS Australia's claims for drawback of import duty were not allowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Nor can the Applicant derive any comfort from the comments in the 2006 Explanatory Statement, to the effect that the amendments were ‘of a minor or machinery nature and do not substantially alter existing arrangements’. Those comments cannot be elevated to such a status as to displace the clear meaning of the language of regulation 134(6). In any event, it may very well be that the comments are accurate in the broad run of cases – even if perhaps not so in the case of goods sold to Travellers under the so-called sealed bag regime. The amendments would be likely, for example, to have had little or no impact in the case of a commercial exporter of goods, whose claims for drawback would appear just as meritorious after the amendments as before.CONCLUSION The Applicant is not ‘the person who is the legal owner of goods at the time the goods are exported’ and therefore regulation 134(6) is not satisfied with respect to the 17 drawback claims refused by the Respondent. The decision under review must therefore be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant submits that it, rather than the Traveller, was in fact the ‘legal owner’ of the goods at the time they were exported from Australia, for the following reasons:(a)the Applicant was the entity who applied to enter the goods for home consumption under s 68(2) of the Customs Act and who received an ‘authority to deal’ in respect of the goods under s 71C of the Act, and in this way the Applicant enjoyed legal authority to deal with the goods that had been imported;(b)the Applicant retained property in the goods until their export, based on the following:(i)the Sale of Goods Act in each relevant jurisdiction, New South Wales and Queensland, provides that property in goods passes at such time as the parties to the contract intend it to be transferred[4], which is to be determined having regard to the terms of the relevant contract, the conduct of the parties and the circumstances of the case[5];(ii)the parties intended that property in the goods did not pass until export – as is evident from the fact that the Traveller was prohibited from accessing the goods prior to export, with the goods instead remaining at all times within a sealed bag, as required by the sealed bag regime; the Traveller was under an obligation to return the goods (still within the sealed bag) to the Applicant if the goods were not exported within 4 days of the original intended export date; by necessary implication, the Traveller was prohibited from selling or otherwise disposing of the goods to any other person prior to their export;(c)alternatively, even if property in the goods did pass to the Traveller upon purchase, the obligations set out in (b)(ii) above meant that the Applicant had a beneficial interest in the goods until the time of export;(d)the legal and practical ability of the Traveller to exercise ownership of the goods was severely constrained, such that the Applicant enjoyed rights of control and disposition sufficient to render the Applicant a ‘legal owner’ of the goods for the purposes of regulation 134(6).[4] Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW), s 22(1); Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld), s 20(1)[5] Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW), s 22(2); Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld), s 20(2)CONSIDERATION The use of the expression ‘the person’ – rather than ‘any person’ – who is the legal owner of goods at the time the goods are exported in regulation 134(6) contemplates that there can be only one such person who answers the composite description. That this expression was introduced in the 2006 amendments indicates a clear intention to confine the availability of duty drawback to a much narrower class of claimant than had been the case before. Before the amendments, any person within the very broad definition of ‘owner’ was potentially able to make a claim for drawback of duty. Now it must be the one person in the world who is the ‘legal owner’ of the goods at the time of export. For the Applicant’s submissions to be accepted, it must be the case that the Applicant retains property in the goods until the goods are exported from Australia, for only in that circumstance would the Applicant be the one person in the world who is the ‘legal owner’ at the time the goods are exported. This is because the alternative circumstance, that property in the goods passes to the Traveller at the time of sale, would (on the Applicant’s alternative submission, as summarised in [39] (c) and (d) of these reasons) make both the Traveller and the Applicant the ‘legal owner’ at the time of export. And there is no room in regulation 134(6) for an outcome that has more than one person in the world answering the description ‘the person who is the legal owner of goods at the time the goods are exported’.