Dewcard Australia Pty Limited v El Hajje

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Dewcard Australia Pty Limited v El Hajje [2006] NSWWCCPD 194

APPELLANT:  Dewcard Australia Pty Limited 

RESPONDENT:              Talal El Hajje 

INSURER:QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC13967-05

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          9 March 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  23 August 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                ‘Judicial Observation’ – procedural fairness; Adequacy of Reasons.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Bartier Perry, Solicitors

Respondent:   Keddies Litigation Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  1.   Paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 of the decision

of the Arbitrator dated 9 March 2006 are revoked.

2.   Paragraphs 3 and 5 of that decision are confirmed.

3.   The matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination of the outstanding issues in accordance with these reasons.

4.Dewcard is to pay the costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Talal El Hajje (‘Mr El Hajje) was employed by Dewcard Australia Pty Limited (‘Dewcard’) as a product manager/delivery driver. He claimed that on 1 May 2002 whilst making a delivery to a store, he was unloading boxes and suffered an injury to his back and both legs.

  1. On 18 August 2005, Mr El Hajje lodged an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in the Commission seeking weekly benefits compensation, medical, hospital or related expenses, and permanent impairment/pain and suffering compensation pursuant to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’) and the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’).

  1. Weekly payments of compensation and medical and related expenses were made to Mr El Hajje for all periods of incapacity from 1 May 2002 when liability was denied by QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘QBE’) by correspondence dated 18 September 2003. Weekly payments of compensation ceased on 29 October 2003.

  1. The matter was listed for a Teleconference on 27 October 2005. On that occasion, Mr El Hajje’s claim for permanent loss compensation was referred to Dr James Bodel, an ‘Approved Medical Specialist’.

  1. Dr Bodel provided a ‘Medical Assessment Certificate’ (‘the MAC’) dated 23 November 2005 wherein he assessed Mr El Hajje as having 11% Whole Person Impairment’.

  1. At a further Teleconference on 8 February 2006, the parties agreed that the MAC resolved the permanent impairment dispute, but no agreement could be reached between the parties on the outstanding issues.

  1. The matter proceeded to conciliation/arbitration hearing on 3 March 2006. On 9 March 2006 a ‘Certificate of Determination’ with an accompanying ‘Statement of Reasons’ was issued. The decision of the Arbitrator was as follows:

“1.The Respondent pay the Applicant weekly payments of compensation of $500.00 per week under s.40 of the 1987 Act from 30 October 2003 to date and continuing.

2.The Respondent pay the Applicant’s s.60 of the 1987 Act expenses upon the production of accounts or receipts.

3.The Respondent pay the Applicant lump-sum compensation of $14,000.00 in accordance with s.66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 for 11% Whole Person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dewcard Australia Pty Limited v El Hajje and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dewcard Australia Pty Limited appealed a decision of the Workers Compensation Commission, arguing that the Arbitrator had erred in making certain findings and failing to provide adequate reasons. Talal El Hajje, the respondent, opposed the appeal, asserting that the Arbitrator's decision was correct. The legal issues before the court included whether the Arbitrator's observations of Mr El Hajje influenced his decision and whether the Arbitrator provided adequate reasons for his decision. The court found that the Arbitrator's observations and conversations with Mr El Hajje, which were not disclosed to Dewcard, influenced his determination, leading to a breach of natural justice. Additionally, the court determined that while the Arbitrator's reasons were thorough, they included evidence that was not properly before the Commission, constituting an error of law. Consequently, the appeal was successful in part, and the matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for determination. Dewcard was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Talal El Hajje was employed by Dewcard Australia Pty Limited as a product manager/delivery driver. On 1 May 2002, while making a delivery, El Hajje suffered an injury to his back and both legs. He lodged a claim for workers' compensation on 18 August 2005. Weekly compensation and medical expenses were paid until 29 October 2003 when liability was denied by QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited. The matter was referred to Dr James Bodel, who assessed El Hajje as having 11% Whole Person Impairment. The dispute proceeded to arbitration on 3 March 2006, where an Arbitrator issued a decision on 9 March 2006, awarding El Hajje weekly payments, lump-sum compensation, and other benefits. Dewcard appealed this decision on 4 April 2006, citing several grounds for the appeal.

The case initially came before the Workers Compensation Commission as an appeal against the decision of an Arbitrator. The appeal was filed by Dewcard on 4 April 2006, with extensive grounds focusing on perceived errors in the Arbitrator's decision. Mr El Hajje filed submissions in reply on 28 April 2006, defending the Arbitrator's decision. The appeal was determined by the Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore on the papers, without a formal hearing, due to the absence of a transcript of the arbitration proceedings. The Acting Deputy President found leave to appeal was granted, and the appeal was heard and determined on 23 August 2006.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Arbitrator err in law by taking into account observations and conversations with the respondent outside of the formal hearing?
2. Did the Arbitrator's decision lack adequate reasons?
3. Were the Arbitrator's findings regarding the weekly payments and lump-sum compensation against the weight of evidence?

Held
1. The Arbitrator erred in law by taking into account observations and conversations with the respondent outside of the formal hearing, which led to a re-hearing of the matter.
2. The Arbitrator's decision did not lack adequate reasons, but the inclusion of observations and conversations with the respondent outside the formal hearing constituted an error of law.
3. The Arbitrator's findings regarding the weekly payments and lump-sum compensation were not against the weight of evidence, but the method by which the findings were made was flawed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Acting Deputy President, Deborah Moore, found that the Arbitrator's failure to inform the parties about his observations and conversations with the respondent, Talal El Hajje, outside of the formal hearing constituted a denial of procedural fairness and natural justice. This conclusion was reached by examining relevant legal principles and authorities, including the decision in Kappos v State Transit Authority [1995] 11 NSWCCR 386. The Acting Deputy President noted that while it is acceptable for judges to consider the demeanour of witnesses, including their behaviour outside the witness box, there must be fairness and justice in how these observations are used. In this case, the Arbitrator's observations and conversations with the respondent significantly influenced his decision and were not disclosed to the parties, which amounted to an error of law.

Regarding the adequacy of reasons, the Acting Deputy President held that the Arbitrator's reasons were adequate as they set out the essential grounds upon which the decision was based. However, the inclusion of the unauthorised observations and conversations with the respondent outside the formal hearing constituted an error of law, which led to the revocation of certain paragraphs of the Arbitrator's decision.

Finally, the Acting Deputy President found that the Arbitrator's findings regarding the weekly payments and lump-sum compensation were not against the weight of evidence. However, the method by which the findings were made was flawed due to the unauthorised inclusion of observations and conversations with the respondent outside the formal hearing. This led to the revocation of certain paragraphs of the Arbitrator's decision and the remission of the matter to another Arbitrator for determination of the outstanding issues in accordance with the Acting Deputy President's reasons.