CITATION: Device Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Applied Medical International Inc and Anor [2001] NSWSC 1110 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity
CommercialFILE NUMBER(S): SC 50049/00 HEARING DATE(S): 29 to 31 October, 1, 5 & 6 November, 2001 JUDGMENT DATE:
6 December 2001PARTIES :
Device Technologies Australia Pty Limited [Plaintiff]
Applied Medical International Inc [First Defendant]
Gembro Pty Limited [Second Defendant]JUDGMENT OF: Palmer J
COUNSEL : P.M. Wood [Plaintiff]
I.M. Jackman [Defendants]SOLICITORS: Corrs Chambers Westgarth [Plaintiff]
Mallesons Stephen Jaques [Defendants]CATCHWORDS: CONTRACT - INFORMAL CONTRACT - COURSE OF CONDUCT - EXCLUSIVE DISTRIBUTION - Whether an exclusive distribution contract can arise by course of dealings when supplier has proffered an exclusive distribution on terms contained in a formal contract and the distributor rejects the terms - whether mere fact that parties' continue thereafter to deal with one another sufficient to give rise to exclusive distribution contract - whether Court should be ready to imply a contract from conduct when there is evidence that both parties actually believe that there is no contract - held: no contract to be implied from conduct - CONTRACT - ORAL CONTRACT - Whether negotiations resulted in immediately binding oral contract when terms yet to be agreed and execution of formal contract contemplated - inherent probabilities in substantial commercial transactions - held: no binding contract. LEGISLATION CITED: Trade Practices Act, 1974, s.52, s.51A CASES CITED: - Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
- R.T. & Y.E. Falls Investments Pty Ltd v The State of New South Wales and Ors [2001] NSWSC 1027
- Multi-core Aerators Ltd v Multi-core Aerators Pty Ltd (1997) 40 IPR 462
- F&G Sykes (Wessex) Ltd v Fine Fare Ltd (1967) Ll.L.R. 53DECISION: Plaintiff's claims dismissed with costs. Judgment for the Cross Claimant on the Amended Cross Claim.
1 Device Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (“DTA”) is a distributor of medical devices. Almost all of the products DTA sells are manufactured by overseas manufacturers. Applied Medical International Inc (“AMI”) is a manufacturer of medical equipment based in California. AMI manufactures products in three medical product lines: cardio-vascular, urology, and general surgery. 2 DTA acted as distributor for the products of AMI in Australia. This arrangement commenced in about April 1993 and came to an end between November 1999 and February 2000. In February 2000 AMI entered into a distribution arrangement with Gembro Pty Ltd (“Gembro”), the Second Defendant in these proceedings. 3 DTA claims that it had exclusive distribution rights for AMI’s products in Australia under a contract which is to be implied from the conduct of the parties since 1993. DTA alleges that the contract, initially terminable only upon reasonable notice, was extended for a fixed term of three years by reason of a further immediately binding oral contract made in a meeting on 15 December 1999 between Mr Ord, the Chief Executive Officer of DTA, Mr Ryan, the Managing Director of DTA, and Mr Molloy, the Vice President of Global Sales for AMI. DTA claims that AMI has…Introduction
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Device Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Applied Medical Inte... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 1110
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the Court had to decide were whether an exclusive distribution contract could be inferred from the course of dealings between the parties and whether an immediately binding oral contract had been formed during the negotiations. The plaintiff contended that the defendant's conduct and continued dealings constituted an exclusive distribution agreement, even though a formal contract had not been executed. The defendant maintained that the absence of a formal agreement and the evidence of both parties' belief that no contract existed precluded the implication of such a contract. Additionally, the plaintiff argued that an oral contract had been formed during the negotiations, while the defendant claimed that no binding agreement had been reached because key terms were still to be negotiated and a formal contract was anticipated.
The Court found that there was no basis to imply an exclusive distribution contract from the course of dealings. The mere fact that the parties continued to deal with one another was insufficient to establish such a contract, especially given the evidence that both parties believed no contract existed. The Court also held that no binding oral contract had been formed, as the negotiations were preliminary and key terms had not been agreed upon. The inherent probabilities in substantial commercial transactions indicated that a formal contract was expected before any binding agreement would be reached.
No contract was found to have been formed between the parties. The Court dismissed the plaintiff's claims, and no orders were made in favour of Device Technologies Australia Pty Ltd.
Background
Background to the litigation
The central issue in this case was whether an exclusive distribution contract could arise from the course of dealings between the parties. Device Technologies argued that the continuous business dealings constituted an informal contract for exclusive distribution, while AMI maintained that no such contract existed. Additionally, Device Technologies claimed that the negotiations had resulted in an immediately binding oral contract, despite the fact that the terms had not been finalised and both parties had contemplated executing a formal contract.
The matter was brought before the court following a dispute over the existence of an exclusive distribution agreement between Device Technologies and AMI. Prior to this hearing, Device Technologies had taken action against AMI for breach of an alleged exclusive distribution contract. This led to AMI seeking a declaration from the court that no such contract existed. The case was heard as a first instance matter in the Federal Court of Australia.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether an exclusive distribution contract can arise by course of dealings when the supplier has proffered an exclusive distribution on terms contained in a formal contract and the distributor rejects the terms.
2. Whether the mere fact that parties continue to deal with one another is sufficient to give rise to an exclusive distribution contract.
3. Whether the Court should be ready to imply a contract from conduct when there is evidence that both parties actually believe that there is no contract.
4. Whether negotiations resulted in an immediately binding oral contract when terms were yet to be agreed and the execution of a formal contract was contemplated.
Held
1. The court held that an exclusive distribution contract cannot arise by course of dealings when the supplier has proffered an exclusive distribution on terms contained in a formal contract and the distributor rejects the terms.
2. The court held that the mere fact that parties continue to deal with one another is not sufficient to give rise to an exclusive distribution contract.
3. The court held that it should not be ready to imply a contract from conduct when there is evidence that both parties actually believe that there is no contract.
4. The court held that negotiations did not result in an immediately binding oral contract when terms were yet to be agreed and the execution of a formal contract was contemplated.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering whether an exclusive distribution contract can arise by course of dealings, the court examined the evidence and found that the supplier had proffered an exclusive distribution agreement in a formal contract which the distributor had rejected. The court concluded that since the distributor had explicitly rejected the terms of the exclusive distribution agreement, no such contract could be inferred from the course of dealings. The court found that the mere continuation of dealings between the parties was not enough to establish an exclusive distribution contract without a formal agreement.
Regarding the implication of a contract from conduct, the court noted that both parties had acted on the understanding that there was no formal contract in place. The court held that it should not imply a contract from conduct when there is clear evidence that both parties do not believe a contract exists. This was a crucial factor in the court's decision, as it relied on the principle that contracts cannot be inferred from conduct when both parties' actions and communications suggest no contractual intent.
The court also assessed whether negotiations had resulted in an immediately binding oral contract. It found that the parties had yet to agree on essential terms and had explicitly stated that a formal contract was to be executed. Given these circumstances, the court held that the negotiations did not result in an immediately binding oral contract. The court referred to the inherent probabilities in substantial commercial transactions, reinforcing that without a formal agreement and settled terms, no binding contract was formed.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that an exclusive distribution contract cannot be inferred from course of dealings if the distributor explicitly rejects the terms of such a contract proposed in a formal agreement. Additionally, a court should not imply a contract from conduct when there is evidence that both parties do not believe a contract exists. Finally, negotiations do not result in an immediately binding oral contract if essential terms are yet to be agreed upon and a formal contract is anticipated.