Devere Holdings Pty Ltd v Lopez

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Devere Holdings Pty Ltd v Lopez [2008] FCA 1091

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to appeal – orders to provide further and better particulars of defence – related application for stay – particulars related to positive pleading in defence – evidentiary burden – decision below not attended with sufficient doubt – no substantial injustice would result if leave not granted, supposing the decision to be wrong – application dismissed.  

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24(1A)
Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 120(1)

Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Phillip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170 cited
Custom Credit Holdings Ltd v Creighton Investments Pty Ltd (Unreported NSWSC, 7 March 1985, BC8500943) cited
Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658 cited
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397 cited
Hornsby Shire Council v Yifta Pty Ltd (Unreported, NSWSC, 17 March 1993, BC9301992) cited
Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] FMCA 591 cited

DEVERE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 009 220 615) AND PACKHAM PTY LTD (ACN 056 326 884) v GEORGE AUBREY LOPEZ AND EVAN ROBERT VERGE

WAD 112 OF 2008

GILMOUR J
24 JULY 2008
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 112 OF 2008

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

DEVERE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 009 220 615)
First Applicant

PACKHAM PTY LTD (ACN 056 326 884)
Second Applicant

AND:

GEORGE AUBREY LOPEZ AND EVAN ROBERT VERGE
Respondents

JUDGE:

GILMOUR J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 JULY 2008

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applications for leave to appeal and for a stay be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondents costs of the application.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 112 OF 2008

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

DEVERE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 009 220 615)
First Applicant

PACKHAM PTY LTD (ACN 056 326 884)
Second Applicant

AND:

GEORGE AUBREY LOPEZ AND EVAN ROBERT VERGE
Respondents

JUDGE:

GILMOUR J

DATE:

24 JULY 2008

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BACKGROUND

  1. Devere Holdings Pty Ltd (“Devere”) and Packham Pty Ltd (“Packham”) apply for leave under s 24(1A) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) to appeal from, and to stay, the orders of Federal Magistrate Lucev made on 9 May 2008 requiring them to provide further and better particulars of paras 5, 10.6 and 10.7 of their Proposed Amended Defence (“defence”). It is accepted by counsel for the applicants that the stay application arises for consideration only in the event of leave to appeal being granted.

  2. The application is supported by an affidavit sworn 30 May 2008 by Giacomino Fazio, who is a director of each of the applicants.

  3. The substantive proceeding was commenced by the respondents (“the Trustees”), as trustees in bankruptcy of the bankrupt estates of Arthur…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Devere Holdings Pty Ltd v Lopez and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1091
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Devere Holdings Pty Ltd, sought leave to appeal and a stay of proceedings against the respondents, Lopez and others, in a case concerning the validity of certain property transfers and the consideration provided. The applicants argued that the consideration given for the property transfers was not less than the market value, and therefore did not constitute an undervalue against the bankruptcy trustees under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applicants further argued that the pleadings did not require them to provide particulars of the value of the benefits accruing to the Andonys under the agreements.

The court had to determine whether the applicants had adopted an unduly narrow view of the relevant pleadings and whether the applicants were required to provide particulars of the value of the benefits accruing to the Andonys under the agreements. The court also had to consider whether the positive pleading by the applicants constituted material allegations and whether the evidentiary onus lay with the applicants.

The court held that the applicants had indeed adopted an unduly narrow view of the relevant pleadings. The court found that the effective allegation in the statement of claim was that the consideration given was at most at a value of not more than $45,000, which was less than the market value. The court also held that the positive pleading by the applicants constituted material allegations and that the evidentiary onus lay with the applicants to provide particulars of the value of the benefits accruing to the Andonys under the agreements. The court concluded that the applicants had not demonstrated that they had a reasonable prospect of success on the appeal, and that the stay application was therefore also dismissed.

The court ordered that the applications for leave to appeal and for a stay be dismissed with costs. The applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applications for leave to appeal and for a stay be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondents costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GILMOUR J
As I foreshadowed earlier, given the conclusion to which I have come in relation to the leave application it is not necessary to consider the stay application. CONCLUSION For these reasons the applications for leave to appeal and for a stay will be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GILMOUR J

In my opinion, the applicants have adopted an unduly narrow view of the relevant pleadings. Paragraph [18] of the statement of claim requires to be considered in the context of the discrete claim pleaded in paragraphs [17]-[20] of the statement of claim. The effective allegation found within those paragraphs as a whole is that the consideration given was at most at a value of not more than $45,000 which was less than the market value and therefore void against the Trustees in the applicants bankruptcy by reason of s 120 of the Act. The concepts of “consideration”, “value” and “market value” are essential to the statutory provision. The Trustees case is that the relevant undervalue was the difference between at least $236,606, being the minimum market value of the Andonys’ undivided one-third share of the Land and $45,000 being the value of the consideration agreed to be paid. The applicants themselves plead the matter of “market value” in the context of the two alternative agreements in para 4 of the defence in answer to para 17 of the statement of claim. The applicants, by para 5 of the defence, positively plead that the consideration was not merely $45,000 but also comprised the benefits accruing to the Andonys under either the First Agreement or the November 2000 Agreement. The effect of that plea, in context, is to allege that the value of the consideration was not merely $45,000 but was more than that and “comprised the benefits accruing to them under and pursuant to the First Agreement alternatively the November 2000 Agreement”. In my opinion, that is the only sensible way of understanding the pleadings concerned and the issues raised by them. Where, as here, the applicants have pleaded a positive case then they have an evidentiary onus in that respect. In my opinion, the positive pleading constitutes material allegations and the Court below was correct to order that particulars, in terms of those requested, be given. This includes, relevantly, particulars as to the monetary value of the benefits pleaded. This adopts a common sense approach and ensures that the core issues directed to s 120 of the Act are fully ventilated. Defence: paragraphs 10.6 and 10.7 Paragraphs 10.6 and 10.7 of the defence form part of the applicants’ response to para 45 of the statement of claim. That paragraph is the culmination of preceding paras 41-44 which concern a Deed dated 1 April 2003 which the Trustees allege constitutes an invalid transfer to Packham of Mrs Andony’s interest in the shares in Devere held jointly with her husband. Paragraph 10.6 of the defence is as follows: 10.6say further or alternatively that by reason that Mrs Andony obtained the benefit of the performance of the obligations of the second respondent pursuant to the deed dated 1 April 2003, including the discharge of Mrs Andony's liability to the second respondent with respect to loan funds borrowed by Mrs Andony jointly with Mr Andony from the second respondent, Mrs Andony thereby ratified the conduct of Mr Andony if and to the extent (if any, which is denied) that such conduct was beyond the authority of Mr Andony. (Emphasis added)