Development Watch Inc v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND


CITATION:

Yorkeys Knob BP Pty Ltd v Cairns Regional Council [2022] QPEC 6

PARTIES:

YORKEYS KNOB BP PTY LTD
(Appellant)

v

CAIRNS REGIONAL COUNCIL
(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2376/2021

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

The Planning and Environment Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

18 February 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7 – 10 February 2022

JUDGE:

Everson DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – APPEAL – appeal against refusal of a development application for a Service Station, Shop and Food and Drink Outlet in the Rural zone.

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – ASSESSMENT – compliance with the planning scheme – whether there is a need for the proposed development.

CASES:

Abeleda & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2020] QCA 257
Wilhelm v Logan City Council & Ors [2020] QCA 273
Zappala Family Co Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2014] QCA 147
Isgrov Gold Coast City Council & Anor [2003] QPELR 414

LEGISLATION:

Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) ss 43, 45(1)(a) and 46(2)

Planning Act 2016 (Qld) ss 45 and 60(3)

Planning Regulation 2017 (Qld) s 31

COUNSEL:

M J Batty and T D Stork for the appellant

B D Job QC and J G Lyons for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Evans Planning Law for the appellant

P & E Law for the respondent

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against the refusal by the respondent of a development application for a development permit for a material change of use (Service Station, Shop and Food and Drink Outlet) and a development permit for Reconfiguring a Lot (Boundary Realignment) (“the proposed development”) on land at 750 Captain Cook Highway and 111L Yorkeys Knob Road, Yorkeys Knob (“the site”).

  2. The site is in a rural area, within an inter-urban break and mapped within an area of High landscape value pursuant to the respondent’s planning scheme, Cairns Plan 2016[1] (“the planning scheme”).  There is a strong intent running through the planning scheme that the site is not to be developed in a manner contemplated by the proposed development. However, the appellant asserts that there is a significant need for the proposed development which over-rides the non-compliances with the planning scheme.[2]

    [1]Version 2.1.

    [2]In submissions on behalf of the appellant, para 17.

    The site and the surrounding area

  3. The site comprises two allotments with a combined area of approximately 22 hectares located at the north-eastern corner of the intersection of the Captain Cook Highway and Yorkeys Knob Road.[3]  The Captain Cook Highway is a state-controlled road comprising four lanes which adjoins the southern boundary of the site.  Yorkeys Knob Road is a major rural road consisting of two lanes and is located along the western boundary of the site.  It is mostly flat and unimproved.  Currently it is not subject to cropping and is covered by grass and weeds.[4]

    [3]Exhibit 5, para 13.

    [4]Ibid.

  4. The site is located amongst low-lying rural land, generally characterised by sugarcane farming.[5]  It has been identified as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Development Watch Inc v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & An... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QPEC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Development Watch Inc appealed against the Sunshine Coast Regional Council’s refusal of a development application for a service station, shop and food and drink outlet on a site zoned Rural. The appellant argued that there was a need for the proposed development and it would not compromise the rural amenity of the inter-urban break. The Council argued that the proposed development would significantly encroach upon the rural and landscape amenity of the area.

The court had to decide whether there was a sufficient planning need for the proposed development to justify it in the exercise of the Council’s discretion. The court also had to consider whether the appellant had discharged the onus of demonstrating a sufficient planning need for the proposed development. The court had to consider the planning strategy evident in the planning scheme which sought to preserve the rural character of the site as part of a significant inter-urban break.

The court held that the planning strategy evident in the planning scheme which sought to preserve the rural character of the site as part of a significant inter-urban break was sound and apparent at every level of the planning scheme. The proposed development would represent a significant and unacceptable encroachment into this area. It was not an appropriate use for the site in circumstances where, although it would be a good location for such a development from a purely functional perspective, a sufficient planning need for it had not been demonstrated to warrant such a comprehensive intrusion into the rural and landscape amenity of the inter-urban break. The appellant had failed to discharge the onus of demonstrating a sufficient planning need for the proposed development and the appeal was dismissed. The appellant had also failed to demonstrate a sufficient planning need for the proposed development and the court found that the remaining relevant matters relied upon by the appellant were insufficient to justify it in the exercise of the Council’s discretion.

The court found that the appellant had failed to demonstrate a sufficient planning need for the proposed development and the appeal was dismissed. The court found that there was no justification for the proposed boundary realignment sought by the development application. The court found that the planning scheme, being the reflection of the public interest, was where community expectations spring from. The court found that the planning scheme made it very clear that rural land was to be protected and used for rural purposes and rural areas in certain circumstances provided an inter-urban break or had scenic landscape value and should be retained in their current form from an amenity perspective. The court found that the site was within such an area and it was mapped as having High landscape value. The court found that the Rural zone code was reflective of this strategy and placed even more restrictions on opportunities for non-rural uses. The court found that the proposed development would compromise the long-term use of the land for rural purposes and have an intrusive effect on the rural or scenic values of the site. The court found that the proposed development would have significant impacts upon the landscape values of the site and fragment Class B Agricultural Land. The court found that the proposed development was not compatible with agriculture, the environmental features and landscape character of the rural area. The court found that the proposed development was not an appropriate use for the site in circumstances where, although it would be a good location for such a development from a purely functional perspective, a sufficient planning need for it had not been demonstrated to warrant such a comprehensive intrusion into the rural and landscape amenity of the inter-urban break.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant has not discharged the onus of demonstrating a sufficient level of need for the proposed development to overcome the fundamental and serious inconsistencies with the planning strategy evident in the provisions of the planning scheme discussed above which, quite simply, is to keep the site in a rural state in order to preserve the rural amenity of the inter-urban break in which it is situated.Conclusion The planning strategy evident in the planning scheme which seeks to preserve the rural character of the site as part of a significant inter-urban break is sound and apparent at every level of the planning scheme. The proposed development will represent a significant and unacceptable encroachment into this area. It is not an appropriate use for the site in circumstances where, although it would be a good location for such a development from a purely functional perspective, a sufficient planning need for it has not been demonstrated to warrant such a comprehensive intrusion into the rural and landscape amenity of the inter-urban break. In failing to discharge the onus of demonstrating a sufficient planning need for the proposed development, the remaining relevant matters relied upon by the appellant are insufficient to justify it in the exercise of my discretion. In these circumstances, there is no justification for the proposed boundary realignment sought by the development application either.[90][90] This is conceded by Ms Morrissy and Mr Schomburgk, Exhibit 5, para 230(g). The appellant has failed to discharge the onus of demonstrating a sufficient planning need for the proposed development and the appeal is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the appellant also raises community expectations as a relevant matter. The planning scheme, being the reflection of the public interest, is where community expectations spring from.Strategic planning and amenity considerations The planning scheme makes it very clear that not only is rural land to be protected and used for rural purposes but relevantly, rural areas in certain circumstances provide an inter-urban break or have scenic landscape value and should be retained in their current form from an amenity perspective. The site is within such an area and it is mapped as having High landscape value. It was not suggested that the relevant provisions of the planning scheme are not soundly based. It is apparent that the extent of the rural land in the inter-urban break and its qualities provides a sound basis for this strategy.[60] Contrary to the submissions of the appellant which disparage the state of the site and its landscape values, I accept both that the site has scenic landscape values in its wider context and that the proposed development will have significant impacts upon them as set out in the evidence of Dr McGowan quoted above.[60]Exhibit 20. The Rural zone code is reflective of this strategy and places even more restrictions on opportunities for non-rural uses. In the purpose, it is stated that they must not only be compatible with agriculture, the environmental features and landscape character of the rural area, but also not compromise the long-term use of the land for rural purposes. Clearly the proposed development with its extensive pad and associated infrastructure will do this. There will also be a fragmentation of Class B Agricultural Land, although I concede that it will not be significant when one has regard to the amount of land in the vicinity of the proposed development. I am satisfied that contrary to PO5 of the Rural zone code that the proposed development will have an intrusive effect on the rural or scenic values of the site despite the presence of the Captain Cook Highway and its attendant infrastructure, including signage and lighting. There will be a similar compromise of the landscape values which are sought to be protected in the Landscape values overlay code. While the appellant emphasises the fact that the land to be repurposed is not currently being used for cropping or any rural activities, it remains suitable caneland that (apart from a small area of filling of approximately 0.45 ha)[61] is readily capable of being cropped in this way. All of the site is suitable for uses contemplated by the Rural zone code.[61]Exhibit 15, p 3. I found the evidence of Mr Schomburgk, the town planner who gave evidence on behalf of the respondent, particularly persuasive in justifying the planning strategy referred to above. He stated:“In my opinion, the policy intent to discourage (prevent) non-rural uses such as this is clear…and…soundly based. While some other non-rural uses had historically developed in parts of the delta/inter-urban (break), that ought not be regarded as a basis for adding other non-rural uses into this locality, especially uses such as proposed that are, by their nature, prominent visual features and attract high visitation. I say it is soundly based because Cairns’ growth is physically constrained by the ocean to the east and the mountain range to the west. Hence, Cairns has developed in a linear form and, without appropriate inter-urban breaks to the north and south, would be in danger of becoming a single, linear metropolis, thereby losing the character that has evolved from a series of discreet villages/townships for the northern beaches…In my opinion there are, then sound town planning reasons to maintain and reinforce this particular inter-urban break…”[62][62]Exhibit 5, para 144.