DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION No. SCGRG-97-1203 Judgment No. S6545

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KENSINGTON & NORWOOD v DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION

Full Court
Cox, Prior & Williams JJ

Williams J:

These proceedings have been referred by a single judge to the Full Court for determination upon a statement of agreed facts.

  1. The nature of the claim

Corporation of the City of Kensington & Norwood (the Council) as plaintiff takes issue with a decision of the first defendant Development Assessment Commission (DAC) by which it gave provisional Development Plan consent to an application by the second and third defendants (Boscaini) to develop a cinema restaurant and retail complex upon land situated at the north eastern corner of George Street and The Parade Norwood.  The Council is concerned that insufficient provision has been made by the developers for car parking on site and that as a result undue pressure will be placed on other parking facilities in the neighbourhood - to the detriment of other traders and their patrons.

The Council asserts firstly that Boscaini’s proposal is seriously at variance with the Development Plan for the area (see s38(2) of the Development Act 1993). Secondly the Council complains about an alleged procedural default by DAC in notice to the Council after Boscaini modified the proposal whilst it was under consideration. Thirdly, the Council contends that the consent in the name of DAC was given on its behalf under an invalid delegation of power to the Chairman of DAC. The Plaintiff seeks declaratory relief and by way of judicial review an order quashing DAC’s decision.

  1. The Essential Facts

On 1 November 1996 the second and third defendants as the site owners and intended developers applied to the Council for planning approval. However, as the Council had an interest in a competing proposal nearby for the development of a cinema complex, the Council (pursuant to a resolution of 20 January 1997) requested that DAC should act as the relevant authority in accordance with s34(1)(b)(iii) of the Development Act. It is not in dispute that the first defendant has been properly appointed by the Minister for Housing and Urban Development as the relevant authority to deal with Boscaini’s application.
         The Boscaini site lies within the retail core policy area of the District Centre zone in terms of the Development Plan for the City of Kensington and Norwood.  Development upon this site is subject to the specific zone requirements of the Development Plan and also the more general policies applicable "Council Wide" as well as the objectives and principles of development control for Metropolitan Adelaide.  Although the Development Plan nominates a Cinema as being appropriate in a fully developed district centre (together with restaurants and specialty shops as well as many other facilities) it does not descend to the same degree of particularity with regard to parking requirements to support a Cinema as it does with other types of development.  Hence in the case of restaurants and shops specific scales of parking are mentioned in the "Council Wide" section of the plan at Principle 46…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION No. SCGRG-97-1203 Judgment... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6545
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Corporation of the City of Kensington & Norwood (the Council) took issue with a decision by the Development Assessment Commission (DAC) to grant provisional Development Plan consent to an application by Boscaini to develop a cinema restaurant and retail complex on land at the north eastern corner of George Street and The Parade Norwood. The Council was concerned that the developers had not provided sufficient car parking on site and that this would put undue pressure on other parking facilities in the neighbourhood, to the detriment of other traders and their patrons. The Council's primary contention was that Boscaini's proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan for the area. The Council also complained about an alleged procedural default by DAC in notifying the Council after Boscaini modified the proposal while it was under consideration. Additionally, the Council argued that the consent in the name of DAC was given on its behalf under an invalid delegation of power to the Chairman of DAC. The plaintiff sought declaratory relief and an order quashing DAC’s decision. The Court found that the issue as to the adequacy of the car parking involved a value judgment where there must be considerable scope for a difference in views. The number of cinema car parks required involved the translation of experience from other places to Norwood. It also involved a judgment as to whether a shortfall thus disclosed was significant bearing in mind the other off-street parking which by custom was available. It had not been demonstrated that the DAC made any error of law as alleged. The Council had already comprehensively voiced its opposition and the Court would refuse relief based upon the alleged procedural irregularities. The Court found that the consent issued by Mr Evans on 12 June 1997 under the authority of the powers delegated to him on 28 May 1997 required Gazettal. However, the Gazette notice which was belatedly published on 23 October 1997 purported to give notice of an act of delegation occurring on that same day. On 14 October 1997 DAC adopted Mr Evans’ decision to approve and the approval issued by Mr Evans on 12 June 1997. Therefore, as from 14 October 1997 there was in place a decision of DAC which by its own force put the matter beyond doubt. The plaintiff was not entitled to relief by reason of the purported delegation of authority by DAC. The Court found that the plaintiff’s application should be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.