Desta v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Desta v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 1199

File number: MLG 2105 of 2024
Judgment of: JUDGE SYMONS
Date of judgment: 31 July 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for judicial review – application for Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa – where the Tribunal was not satisfied that the visa applicant was a “carer” as defined in reg 1.15AA of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) – whether the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error by failing to consider the nature and extent of the sponsor’s care requirements – whether the Tribunal made findings in ignorance of significant material or mandatory considerations – whether the Tribunal made findings that were irrational, illogical or unreasonable – where identified error not material – application dismissed
Legislation:

Social Security Act 1991 (Cth)

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules2021 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), regs 1.03, 1.15AA; Sch 2, cll 116.211, 116.221

Cases cited:

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 236 FCR 593; [2003] FCAFC 184

BHL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2020) 277 FCR 420;[2020] FCAFC 94

CYW21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 1084

El-Chahini v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 74 AAR 224; [2018] FCA 202

Mariam v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FedCFamC2G 436

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW (2018) 264 CLR 541; [2018] HCA 30

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZRKT (2013) 212 FCR 99; [2013] FCA 317

MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2021) 273 CLR 506; [2021] HCA 17

Qazizada v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 250

Valencia v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 165 ALD 28; [2019] FCA 397

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 113
Date of last submissions: 22 October 2024
Date of hearing: 22 October 2024
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Kenneally
Solicitor for the Applicant:  BTT Lawyers Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms K McInnes
Solicitor for the First Respondent:  Sparke Helmore Lawyers
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

MLG 2105 of 2024

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

HELEN DESTA

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE SYMONS

DATE OF ORDER:

31 JULY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

2.The name of the second respondent be amended to the “Administrative Review Tribunal”.

3.The application filed on 28 June 2024 and amended on 26 September 2024 be dismissed.

4.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Desta v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Desta v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, the court was asked to review a decision made by the Tribunal regarding an application for an Other Family (Residence) visa. The key issue in the case was whether the applicant was classified as a "carer" under the relevant migration regulations, specifically in accordance with the definition provided in regulation 1.15AA. The applicant, Ms. Helen Desta, sought to establish that she was eligible for the visa based on her role as a carer for her niece, Mrs. Mihret Kahsay Hadush. The Tribunal, however, did not find that Ms. Desta qualified as a carer because it determined she did not meet the regulatory definition of the term.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of whether Ms. Desta was a carer. This involved examining whether the Tribunal appropriately considered the nature and extent of the care requirements of Mrs. Hadush, and whether it made any findings in ignorance of significant material or mandatory considerations. Additionally, the court had to determine if the Tribunal's findings were irrational, illogical, or unreasonable. The applicant argued that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the extent of care needed by Mrs. Hadush, which she claimed necessitated a 24/7 care arrangement, thereby qualifying her as a carer under the regulations.

The court examined the Tribunal's reasoning and found that it had considered the necessary evidence, including a Care and Welfare Assessment conducted by an examining doctor, the applicant's own statements, and the third Mohammad letter from the applicant’s GP. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant required assistance with specific activities of daily living, but did not find her to be fully dependent on others for such care, thereby not meeting the regulatory definition of a carer. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision, affirming that there was no jurisdictional error in its assessment and that the Tribunal's findings were neither irrational nor unreasonable. Consequently, the application for judicial review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 3 June 2024, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate and produced a written statement of decision and reasons (R) (CB 370-384).THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal identified the issue in the case as whether the visa applicant was a carer of the applicant at the time of decision and noted that resolution of this question directed attention to the definition of “carer” in reg 1.15AA of the Regulations. The Tribunal considered whether reg 1.15AA(1)(e) could be satisfied by firstly assessing “the level and particulars of the assistance required by [the applicant]” (R [20]). The Tribunal did so by reference to the CVAC dated 20 February 2024 and noted findings recorded by the examining doctor, as well as the applicant’s overall impairment rating of 40 points (R [21]-[27]). The Tribunal also referred to and reproduced parts of the third Mohammad letter, a letter from the applicant’s GP dated 24 January 2024 (R [28]-[29]), evidence given orally and in writing by the applicant, and the oral testimony of the visa applicant and the visa applicant’s husband (R [31]-[33]). The Tribunal recorded the following at R [35], with references to “the resident” being a reference to the applicant:The Tribunal has considered the information in front of it, including the above information and testimony, when assessing the level and particulars of the assistance required by the resident. While it notes information from the resident and others about her requiring “24/7” or “full-time” care, and specifically that she requires assistance overnight, it gives more weight to the contents of the CVAC in finding that the resident is partially dependant on other people to undertake activities of daily living. It considers that if she required assistance overnight as was assessed by her in the “Statement of assistance” dated 31 January 2024, then she would have been assessed as being “fully” dependent on others by the examining doctor in the CVAC. It concluded about the level and particulars of the assistance required by the applicant at R [36]:The Tribunal finds that the resident requires assistance with some mobility activities due to her inability to abduct or flex her shoulder joint beyond 90 degrees or bend forward to pick up objects at knee level. it finds that she required assistance with bathing and showering, and specifically washing her hair given shoulder limitations. It finds that she requires assistance dressing herself (again given her shoulder limitations). It finds that she requires assistance with eating and feeding although no particulars were given in the CVAC. It finds that she requires assistance with supervision for personal safety. The examining doctor noted that she requires assistance with supervision for personal safety. The examining doctor noted that she was unable to concentrate on tasks and often forgets her medical appointments and medications. It finds that she requires assistance with transportation, and notes that she was found not to be able to drive. Finally, although the resident has said by her GP in his letter of 24 January 2024 to have developed glaucoma that has resulted in ongoing issues with her vision, it finds that this condition would have been considered by the examining doctor in the CVAC given that the CVAC makes reference to the GP’s letter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 31 May 2024, the applicant’s representative sent an email to the Tribunal which attached the following documents (CB 345-366):·a statutory declaration from the applicant;·a statutory declaration from a community leader Mr Tesfahun Wubneh (identified as the President of Tigrian Community Association in Victoria) dated 30 May 2024 (the Wubneh declaration);·a statutory declaration from the applicant’s ex-husband dated 5 March 2024;·a BUPA Carer certificate (the BUPA certificate);·a letter from the applicant’s general practitioner;·a letter from the applicant’s psychologist;·a support letter from the applicant’s social worker, Ms Adams; and ·submissions by the applicant’s representative. The Wubneh declaration read (CB 362):1.I am a community leader in the applicant (Ms Helen Desta’s) community. 2.I was approached regarding the situation involving Ms Desta’s nieces and nephew. 3.I contacted Ms Desta’s niece (Mrs Mihret Kahsay Hadush) on 4th April 2024_who confirmed she was unable to assist in this matter or provide ongoing full-time assistance to Ms Desta. 4.I contacted Mrs Desta’s niece (Mrs Mebruit Kahsay Hadush) on 4th April 2024 who confirmed she was unable to assist in this matter or provide ongoing full-time assistance to Ms Desta. 5.I understand Ms Desta’s Nephew (Mr Ephrem Berihu Mahari) is unable to assist in this matter or provide support as he is currently in incarceration. 6.There has been no contact with Helen for many years, specifically for approximately 13 years. On 3 June 2024, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate and produced a written statement of decision and reasons (R) (CB 370-384).THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal identified the issue in the case as whether the visa applicant was a carer of the applicant at the time of decision and noted that resolution of this question directed attention to the definition of “carer” in reg 1.15AA of the Regulations. The Tribunal considered whether reg 1.15AA(1)(e) could be satisfied by firstly assessing “the level and particulars of the assistance required by [the applicant]” (R [20]). The Tribunal did so by reference to the CVAC dated 20 February 2024 and noted findings recorded by the examining doctor, as well as the applicant’s overall impairment rating of 40 points (R [21]-[27]). The Tribunal also referred to and reproduced parts of the third Mohammad letter, a letter from the applicant’s GP dated 24 January 2024 (R [28]-[29]), evidence given orally and in writing by the applicant, and the oral testimony of the visa applicant and the visa applicant’s husband (R [31]-[33]). The Tribunal recorded the following at R [35], with references to “the resident” being a reference to the applicant:The Tribunal has considered the information in front of it, including the above information and testimony, when assessing the level and particulars of the assistance required by the resident. While it notes information from the resident and others about her requiring “24/7” or “full-time” care, and specifically that she requires assistance overnight, it gives more weight to the contents of the CVAC in finding that the resident is partially dependant on other people to undertake activities of daily living. It considers that if she required assistance overnight as was assessed by her in the “Statement of assistance” dated 31 January 2024, then she would have been assessed as being “fully” dependent on others by the examining doctor in the CVAC.