Desira and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 32

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)        No    V99/622

GENERAL        APPEALS       DIVISION       )          

Re      Sandra DESIRA     

Applicant

And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS    

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs Joan Dwyer, Senior Member 

Date24 January 2000

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

(Sgnd)     Joan Dwyer
  Senior Member
CITIZENSHIP - application to resume citizenship under s 23AA - applicant born in Australia of Maltese parents - dual nationality acquired at birth - moved with parents to live in Malta at age eight – renunciation of Australian citizenship required before age 19 in order to retain Maltese citizenship - declaration of renunciation of Australian citizenship lodged before age 19 - application to resume Australian citizenship made and refused - whether applicant satisfies statutory preconditions in s 23AA - whether applicant "acquired" foreign citizenship as a result of renunciation or whether she retained Maltese citizenship - meaning of "acquires" - decision affirmed

Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Gugerli (1992) 15 AAR 483

Re Allan and Department of Foreign Affairs (1986) 5 AAR 432

ReGugerli and Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1990) 13 AAR 40

Australian Citizenship Act 1948 ss 17 and 23AA(1)

Constitution of Malta ss 25(2) and 27(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

24 January 2000     Mrs Joan Dwyer, Senior Member 

  1. This is the hearing of a legal issue arising in respect of an application under s 52A(1)(e) of the Australian Citizenship Act 1948 ("the Act") for review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs made 14 May 1999. The reviewable decision refused Ms Desira's application to resume Australian citizenship under s 23AA, 23A, or 23B of the Act.

  2. At the request of the parties, the Tribunal agreed to deal with the legal issues as to the construction of s 23AA of the Act, 'on the papers'. The applicant's solicitor by letter dated 18 October 1999 proposed that the legal issues be dealt with on the papers as a "threshold" issue, and that the matter only proceed to a hearing concerning the nature and extent of Ms Desira's ties to Australia if she succeeded on the threshold issues as to the application of s 23AA. The respondent consented to that proposal by letter dated 3 November 1999. The Tribunal had before it the material lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and the written submissions of the parties contained in the Statements of Facts and Contentions lodged on behalf of the applicant on 21 October 1999 and by the respondent on 3 November 1999.

  3. Section 23AA of the Act, so far as relevant provides:

    Persons may resume citizenship lost in certain circumstances

    23AA.  (1)       Where:
    (a)       a person:

    (i)has done a voluntary and formal act, other than marriage, by virtue of which the person acquired the nationality or citizenship of a country other than Australia; or

    (ii)       has done any act or thing:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Desira and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Desira, an Australian citizen, applied for review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to refuse to grant her permanent residency on the grounds that she did not satisfy the criteria under section 23AA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The dispute involved the interpretation of section 23AA of the Migration Act, specifically concerning whether Desira's renunciation of Australian citizenship before her nineteenth birthday allowed her to retain "full" Maltese citizenship, thus satisfying the criteria for permanent residency.

The primary legal issue was whether Desira's renunciation of Australian citizenship before her nineteenth birthday resulted in her acquiring "full" Maltese citizenship. This required the court to interpret section 23AA of the Migration Act, which considers the evidence of an applicant's ties to Australia, and to determine whether Desira's renunciation met the conditions set forth in the Act. The court also needed to resolve the conflicting evidence regarding Desira's Maltese citizenship status, particularly in light of the differing opinions expressed in various letters from Maltese officials.

The court examined the full context of the letter from the Head of the Immigration and Nationality Branch, Malta, which indicated that Desira's renunciation procedures under Australian law, completed before her nineteenth birthday, would result in her retaining Maltese citizenship. The court noted the confusion in the subsequent letter from the Consul-General of Malta, but affirmed that it had no jurisdiction to determine Desira's nationality under Maltese law. The court also highlighted the solicitor's reliance on a partial quotation of the letter, which contradicted his submission. Ultimately, the court concluded that Desira did not satisfy the criteria under section 23AA of the Act, and dismissed the application for review.

The court dismissed the application for review, affirming the Minister's decision. The court held that Desira did not meet the criteria for permanent residency under section 23AA of the Migration Act, as her renunciation of Australian citizenship did not result in her acquiring "full" Maltese citizenship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is a matter of concern that in making that submission the applicant's solicitor relied on parts of a letter dated 10 February 1983 from the Head of the Immigration and Nationality Branch, Malta (T docs p36) as support for his proposition, but if he had quoted the whole letter it would have clearly contradicted his submission. The letter reads in full:I am to refer to your letter of 31st January 1983 regarding the renunciation of Australian citizenship prior to a person's nineteenth birthday.Provided such a person will have finalized all the renunciation procedures under Australian law to your complete satisfaction before his nineteenth birthday, it does not matter if his renunciation declaration is registered after that day, that is, he would be deemed to have retained his citizenship of Malta. (emphasis added) On 7 April 1999 the Director of the Department for Citizenship and Expatriate Affairs of the Ministry for Home Affairs, Malta confirmed that the letter of 10 February 1993 still set out the position according to Maltese Law (T docs p35). That would indicate that Ms Desira did not automatically cease to be a citizen of Malta on her nineteenth birthday as she had renounced her Australian citizenship and finalised all the renunciation procedures under Australian law, so far as they were under her control, before her nineteenth birthday. The T documents do include a document which conflicts with the letters at T docs pp35 and 36. It is a letter dated 23 February 1999 from the Consul-General of Malta to Ms Desira (T13 p38). It states that Ms Desira ceased to be a citizen of Malta when she "reached the age of 18 years." There does seem to be some confusion in that letter but this Tribunal has no power to make any determination as to the nationality of Ms Desira according to Maltese Law. Davies J said in Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Gugerli (1992) 15 AAR 483 at p492:The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has no general jurisdiction to declare what is or is not a person's citizenship. The solicitor for Ms Desira submitted in his Statement of Facts and Contentions, contention 2 that the "approach of the decision-maker….involved an unnecessarily narrow construction of s 23AA of the Act." He submitted:[P]rior to her renunciation, the applicant did not have "full" Maltese citizenship. This is because her ability to maintain her Maltese citizenship was subject to her renouncing her foreign citizenship. Assuming a valid renunciation before her nineteenth birthday, following that renunciation the nature of the applicant's Maltese citizenship changed and she obtained "full title". Until then, her Maltese citizenship was merely conditional or "inchoate" and depended upon her making a choice between Australian and Maltese nationality. As a result of the renunciation of Australian citizenship, the applicant acquired "full" Maltese citizenship. Accordingly, the terms of s 23AA apply and the evidence of the applicant's ties to Australia should be considered by the Tribunal.Finally it is submitted that it is unclear whether the legislature intended a distinction to be made between a person whose actions have the effect of "acquiring" a foreign nationality and one who must renounce Australian citizenship in order to retain a second nationality that was also acquired by birth. Indeed, it would appear that a person's actions in being forced to renounce Australian citizenship in order to retain a second citizenship, which they have also acquired at birth, is less "disloyal" to Australia than the actions of a person who, having been born with only Australian citizenship subsequently, as an adult, does something to acquire the nationality or citizenship of a foreign country.