Design Joinery & Doors Pty Ltd v IPower Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

DESIGN JOINERY & DOORS PTY LTD v IPOWER PTY LTD & ANOR

[2015] SASC 93

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

26 June 2015

RESTITUTION - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

EVIDENCE - COURSE OF EVIDENCE AND ADDRESSES - COURSE OF EVIDENCE - REOPENING CASE AND RECALLING WITNESSES - BY PARTIES

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS - ACCEPTANCE - GENERALLY - LEGAL PRINCIPLES

Magistrates appeal by defendant against judgment for plaintiffs for price of electricity.

In March 2010, the plaintiffs' telemarketer spoke to the defendant's director about changing its electricity retailer.  The plaintiffs sent to the defendant a welcome pack including standard terms applicable to small customers although the defendant was not a small customer.

In April 2010, the plaintiffs became registered as the retailer responsible in the electricity wholesale market to pay for electricity supplied to the defendant's premises.  Shortly thereafter, the defendant sent a letter to the plaintiffs requesting termination of the energy contract but the letter was not acted upon.  The plaintiffs remained the registered retailer until July 2011.

The Magistrate held that an oral contract came into existence between the parties that incorporated the plaintiffs' standard written terms for supply to small customers, which in turn incorporated their standard written terms for large customers specifying a pricing formula for supply after notice of termination.  The Magistrate permitted the plaintiffs to reopen their case to prove their standard terms for large customers and application of the pricing formula. 

Held:

1.       No error has been demonstrated in the exercise of the Magistrate's discretion to permit the plaintiffs to reopen their case (at [61]-[62]).

2.       The Magistrate erred in finding the existence of an oral contract between the parties (at [75]-[80]).

3.       The electricity was supplied by the plaintiffs to the defendant pursuant to an oral request and the defendant is liable to pay the fair and reasonable value of the electricity supplied (at [90]-[102]).

4.       On the evidence adduced at trial, the fair and reasonable value of the electricity supplied was $55,184 inclusive of GST (at [113]).

5.       Appeal allowed.  Judgment set aside.  In lieu thereof, judgment entered for the plaintiffs against the defendant for $55,184 with the parties to be heard as to interest and costs (at [121]-[122]).

Electricity Act 1996 (SA) s 4(1); Electricity (General) Regulations 1997 (SA) reg 4B, 7D, 7E(b), 7F(3)(a), referred to.
Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (2008) 232 CLR 635, discussed.
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353; Pavey & Matthews Proprietary Limited v Paul (1987) 162 CLR 221; Sopov v Kane Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2009] VSCA 141, considered.

DESIGN JOINERY & DOORS PTY LTD v IPOWER PTY LTD & ANOR
[2015] SASC 93

Magistrates Appeal (Civil):

BLUE J:

  1. This is an appeal by the defendant against judgment by a Magistrate in favour of the plaintiffs for $74,437.77 plus interest as the contract price for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Design Joinery & Doors Pty Ltd v IPower Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Design Joinery & Doors Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against IPower Pty Ltd (the defendant) in the Magistrates Court of South Australia, seeking payment for electricity supplied to its premises. The case revolves around the existence of an oral contract, the terms of that contract, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to payment for electricity supplied under a theory of restitution. The appeal to the South Australian District Court considered three broad issues: whether the plaintiff proved the existence of an oral contract, whether the terms of that contract had the effect found by the Magistrate, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to payment for electricity supplied by way of restitution.

The first issue addressed whether the plaintiff proved the existence of an oral contract incorporating their standard written terms. The appeal court found that the Magistrate's determination on this matter was based on evidence that Design Joinery received a welcome pack from Simply Energy, which contained their standard terms. The court concluded that the evidence was sufficient to prove the existence of an oral contract incorporating those terms. The second issue was whether the terms of the contract had the effect found by the Magistrate, which was that the contract applied to the supply of electricity to Design Joinery's premises. The court found that the Magistrate's conclusion on this matter was correct, given the evidence presented and the terms of the contract. The third issue was whether the plaintiff was entitled to payment for electricity supplied by way of restitution. The court found that the plaintiff was not entitled to restitution because the evidence did not support the claim that the defendant had been unjustly enriched at the plaintiff's expense.

The appeal court found in favour of the defendant, dismissing the plaintiff's claims. The court held that the plaintiff had not proved the existence of an oral contract, or that the terms of that contract had the effect found by the Magistrate. Furthermore, the court found that the plaintiff was not entitled to payment for electricity supplied by way of restitution. The appeal court dismissed the plaintiff's claims and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal raises three broad issues:1.Did the plaintiffs prove the existence of an oral contract entered into in March 2010 incorporating their standard written terms as found by the Magistrate and did those terms have the effect found by the Magistrate?2.Were the plaintiffs entitled to payment for electricity supplied to the defendant’s premises by way of restitution?3.Did the Magistrate err in permitting the plaintiffs to reopen their case? Background The defendant Design Joinery & Doors Pty Ltd carries on a joinery business. Between 2010 and 2013, it conducted its business at premises at Salisbury North. Paul Maddeford was a director. The plaintiffs IPower Pty Ltd and IPower 2 Pty Ltd carry on business jointly as an electricity retailer trading as Simply Energy (Simply Energy). The national electricity market is governed by the National Electricity Rules[1] (the Rules) made by the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) under the National Electricity Law which is a schedule to the National Electricity (South Australia) Act 1996 (SA). The market participants are generators, network service providers (transmitters and distributors) and customers.[2] Market customers include retailers such as AGL and Simply Energy. A database is maintained by AEMO known as the Market Settlement and Transfer Solution (MSATS) system to record inter alia the identity of the retailer (or other customer) in respect of each electricity meter from time to time. [1] Exhibit P8.[2] National Electricity Rules clause 2.4.1. The retailer registered in respect of an electricity meter is liable to pay the applicable regional reference node half hourly spot price per megawatt hour[3] for electricity supplied through the meter adjusted by the applicable transmission loss factor (marginal loss factor) and distribution loss factor.[4] The registered retailer is also liable to pay a network charge for the use of the transmission and distribution networks to supply electricity from generator to customer.[5] This charge is calculated at fixed rates per megawatt hour for peak electricity usage in blocks per month, a fixed rate per megawatt hour for off-peak electricity usage and a daily supply charge.[3] National Electricity Rules clauses 3.4, 3.9, 3.15.[4] National Electricity Rules clause 3.6.[5] National Electricity Rules clauses 6.18-6.20. The registered retailer is also liable to pay a charge to the metering service provider for metering services[6] and a charge to AEMO for its services.[7] [6] National Electricity Rules clause 7.3.6.[7] National Electricity Rules clause 2.11. The Electricity Act 1996 (SA) distinguishes between small customers and other customers (large customers). A small customer is defined to be a customer with an annual electricity consumption less than the number of megawatt hours per year specified by regulation.[8] In 2010, the megawatt hours per year specified for this purpose was 160.[9] The Essential Services Commission is empowered to regulate prices for the supply of electricity to small customers. Retailers are required if requested to supply electricity to small customers on published standing contract terms and conditions and for published standing contract prices.[10] Otherwise, customers can if they wish enter into contracts on negotiated terms known as market contracts.[11][8] Electricity Act 1996 (SA) s 4(1).[9] Electricity (General) Regulations 1997 (SA) reg 4B.[10] Electricity Act 1996 (SA) ss 35A, 36-36AB.[11] Electricity (General) Regulations 1997 (SA) reg 7D, 7E(b), 7F(3)(a).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 December 2013, Design Joinery filed an amended defence denying existence of a contract, denying supply by Simply Energy of electricity and denying that it was a small customer for the purpose of section 36AB of the Electricity Act 1996.The trial and the Magistrate’s reasons for judgment Simply Energy’s case was that the parties entered into an oral contract on 19 March 2010 on terms which incorporated Simply Energy’s standard written terms. Its case was that documents subsequently provided by it to Design Joinery on approximately 25 March 2010 were provided in implementation of the oral contract. Its case was not that a contract was formed in late March 2010 or April 2010 by its making an offer in terms of those documents and Design Joinery accepting that offer by words or conduct. What was ultimately to become the first phase of the trial proceeded on 22 and 23 April 2014. Simply Energy’s case at that point was that the small customer standard terms provided to Design Joinery in late March 2010 were incorporated by reference by the oral contract. Those terms applied as terms of the oral contract including terms as to price. Simply Energy called Christian Caddaye, its billing integrity analyst, to give evidence about its systems for telemarketing, contracting, transfers and billing.[18] Design Joinery called Mr Maddeford to give evidence about his dealings with AGL and Simply Energy. Both parties tendered several business records. The parties made closing addresses and the Magistrate reserved judgment.[18] Simply Energy also called Michael Shiel from its debt collector to prove post-invoice communications with Design Joinery. On 28 May 2014, the Magistrate delivered reasons for judgment. The Magistrate found that Simply Energy was recorded as the retailer on the MSATS database in respect of Design Joinery’s meter and it was the only retailer that could have supplied Design Joinery with electrical power over that period. The Magistrate made an adverse finding about Mr Maddeford’s credibility and found that Design Joinery received the welcome pack within a few days after 25 March 2010 notwithstanding Mr Maddeford’s evidence that he did not receive anything from Simply Energy. The Magistrate concluded that Design Joinery’s cooling off period commenced to run on receipt of the welcome pack and expired before 15 April 2010 when Simply Energy became registered as retailer on the MSATS database in respect of Design Joinery’s meter. The Magistrate said that it was not possible to determine the action finally due to Simply Energy having failed to produce the relevant contract because Design Joinery was not a small customer and the only contract tendered at trial was the small customer standard terms. The Magistrate could not determine the contractual claim because he did not know what contract terms applied and he could not consider the restitutionary claim absent reference to the contractual provisions. The Magistrate indicated that he would entertain an application by Simply Energy to reopen its case to tender the relevant contract.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.