Depisch v Doral Mineral Sands Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   DEPISCH -v- DORAL MINERAL SANDS PTY LTD [2022] WASC 87

CORAM:   MASTER SANDERSON

HEARD:   25 JANUARY 2022

DELIVERED          :   15 MARCH 2022

PUBLISHED           :   15 MARCH 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2129 of 2021

BETWEEN:   MARTIN DEPISCH

Plaintiff

AND

DORAL MINERAL SANDS PTY LTD

Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application for pre-action discovery - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Application dismissed

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : ML Bennett
Defendant : C Hicks & A D Roberts

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Bennett + Co
Defendant : Herbert Smith Freehills

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

BWS v ARV (No 2) [2021] WASCA 62

MASTER SANDERSON:

  1. This is the plaintiff's application for pre‑action discovery. It is brought under O 26A r 4 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) (RSC). The application is supported by an affidavit of the plaintiff sworn 26 October 2021. The defendant has not filed any affidavit material. It did file written submissions opposing the plaintiff's application. Before detailing the grounds of opposition of the defendant I should summarise the relevant facts, none of which were in dispute.

  2. As at 30 June 2018, the plaintiff was a major shareholder of MZI Resources Limited (in liquidation) (MZI).  MZI was a listed company whose subsidiaries (including the wholly owned Keysbrook Leucoxene Pty Ltd (KLPL)) specialised in the mining and processing of high value minerals including leucoxene.  MZI's flagship operating asset was the KLPL's Keysbrook Minerals Sands Mine (Keysbrook Mine) which is located some 70 kilometres south of Perth.  At the Keysbrook Mine, mineral sands were mined and processed to produce a heavy metal concentrate which was processed into a final product at Doral's Mineral Separation Plant in Picton. 

  3. In or about April 2019, MZI and Doral entered into a processing agreement.  Pursuant to this agreement, Doral was to treat Keysbrook's heavy mineral concentrate at Doral's Mineral Separation Plant.  Production commenced in late 2015.  From about June 2017, MZI experienced a decrease in total production and sales of leucoxene with MZI failing to deliver sustained recovery levels.  These recovery levels were the key driver of value for MZI, accounting for about 2/3 of its revenue.  The under recovery was attributed to amongst other things, the highly variable physical characteristics of the leucoxene particles in the orebody, and the effectiveness of certain equipment to deal with this element within the flowsheet configuration: See affidavit of the plaintiff, paragraph 12.4.

  4. As at 30 June 2018, MZI reported a consolidated loss of $7 million and a net liability position of $36 million.  In about June of 2018, MZI engaged metallurgical experts, METS Engineering Group (METS), to identify the potential to improve recovery of leucoxene.  This involved a detailed engineering study and point scale test to be conducted at the Picton site.  This was done in agreement with the defendant.  As at December 2018, achieving a targeted recovery of leucoxene remained a challenge for MZI, notwithstanding the work undertaken…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Depisch v Doral Mineral Sands Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Martin Depisch brought an application for pre-action discovery against Doral Mineral Sands Pty Ltd, seeking access to certain documents to assist him in deciding whether to commence proceedings. The dispute revolves around the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct by Doral in relation to the Keysbrook Mine, which was purchased by Doral after MZI Resources Ltd went into voluntary administration. The plaintiff claims Doral may have withheld information that could have improved leucoxene recovery rates at the mine.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff had established that he "may" have a cause of action against Doral, a key requirement for an application under O 26A r 4 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). The plaintiff argued that Doral's conduct, either by failing to implement improved recovery processes or by withholding information, could constitute misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The defendant argued that the plaintiff's potential cause of action was flawed and speculative, and that the plaintiff had not established sufficient grounds for the discovery order.

The court found that the plaintiff's allegations were speculative and lacked objective evidence. The plaintiff could not demonstrate how Doral's alleged conduct could be considered misleading or deceptive, nor could he show that Doral had a duty to disclose information to MZI or its shareholders. The court emphasised that mere suspicion or conjecture is not sufficient to meet the jurisdictional threshold for an order of pre-action discovery. The court also noted that even if the plaintiff could establish a potential cause of action, the application would likely be refused in the exercise of discretion.

The plaintiff's application for pre-action discovery was dismissed. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the action, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Martin Depisch, a former major shareholder of MZI Resources Limited (MZI), applied for pre-action discovery against Doral Mineral Sands Pty Ltd. MZI, which specialized in mining and processing minerals, experienced a decline in leucoxene production and sales from about June 2017. The decrease in production was attributed to the variable physical characteristics of the leucoxene particles and the effectiveness of certain equipment within the flowsheet configuration. As of 30 June 2018, MZI reported a consolidated loss of $7 million and a net liability position of $36 million. In about June 2018, MZI engaged METS Engineering Group to identify the potential to improve recovery of leucoxene. Despite the efforts, achieving a targeted recovery of leucoxene remained a challenge for MZI. In January 2019, MZI initiated a process to explore the sale of the Keysbrook Mine. MZI received an offer for the Keysbrook Mine from Doral on or about 15 March 2019. However, the offer was insufficient to repay secured lenders in full. On or about 16 April 2019, MZI went into voluntary administration. In or about June 2019, the administrators entered into an agreement with Doral for the sale and purchase of the Keysbrook Mine by Doral.

This is the plaintiff's application for pre-action discovery, brought under O 26A r 4 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). The application is supported by an affidavit of the plaintiff sworn on 26 October 2021. The defendant filed written submissions opposing the plaintiff's application but did not file any affidavit material. The case was heard by Master Sanderson on 25 January 2022 and delivered on 15 March 2022.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff have a cause of action against the defendant?
2. Are there reasonable grounds for believing that the defendant has in its possession documents that may assist in making a decision?
3. Should the application for pre-action discovery be granted, considering the established principles in BWS v ARV (No 2) [2021] WASCA 62?

Held
1. The plaintiff does not have a cause of action against the defendant.
2. There are no reasonable grounds for believing that the defendant has in its possession documents that may assist in making a decision.
3. The application for pre-action discovery should not be granted, as the plaintiff has not demonstrated the necessary threshold of having a cause of action against the defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the plaintiff's application for pre-action discovery under O 26A r 4 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), the court examined whether the plaintiff could establish a potential cause of action against the defendant. The plaintiff, Martin Depisch, sought documents from Doral Mineral Sands Pty Ltd that he believed might reveal misleading or deceptive conduct by Doral, which he argued could form the basis of a cause of action under the Australian Consumer Law. However, the court found that the plaintiff's submissions were speculative and lacked objective evidence to support a potential cause of action. The court relied on the principles established in BWS v ARV (No 2) [2021] WASCA 62, which emphasised that mere assertion, conjecture, or suspicion was insufficient to ground an order for discovery. The plaintiff's claims were deemed flawed as they did not establish that Doral engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct that caused him loss or damage. Furthermore, the court noted that even if such a cause of action existed, it would likely belong to MZI Resources Ltd, the company of which Depisch was a shareholder, and not Depisch personally. Without leave to bring representative proceedings, Depisch lacked standing to pursue such a claim. Therefore, the application for pre-action discovery was dismissed.