Department of Human Services (Cth) v Fitzpatrick

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (CTH) v FITZPATRICK

[2018] SASC 180

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis

30 November 2018

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - PRINCIPLES ON WHICH COURT ACTS - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - PROCEDURE

Appeal against the dismissal of an application for a non-party intervention order by a Magistrate in the Adelaide Magistrates Court. The appellant sought an intervention order pursuant to s 20 of the Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) (the IO Act) prohibiting the respondent from assaulting, threatening, harassing or intimidating its workers at different Human Service office locations throughout South Australia.

The Registrar of the Court did not accept the application for filing and invited the appellant to provide reasons in support of its filing. The application and supporting materials were ultimately rejected for filing following an oral application. The Magistrate found that the intervention order attempted to protect a class of persons rather than an individual person and dismissed the application.

The appellant appeals on two grounds. The first ground contends that the Magistrate erred in holding that the protected person or persons must be a particular individual or individuals and not a class of persons, the members of which may change from time to time. The second ground contends that the Magistrate erred in refusing to admit into evidence the affidavit sworn 6 July 2018 by Mr Robinson, filed in support of the intervention order application.

Held, per Kourakis CJ, allowing the appeal:

1. An intervention order which identifies a class of persons by reference to objective readily apparent characteristics properly ‘identifies’ the persons protected by the order for the purposes of s 18(3) and s 21(7) of the IO Act. An application for an intervention order which can be so expressed is an application for the purposes of the Act (at [28]).

2.  The intervention order application be received by the Registrar of the Adelaide Magistrates Court and proceed to a hearing in the ordinary way (at [34]).

Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA) s 3, s 6, s 12, s 18, S 20, s 21, s 23; Magistrates Court Rules 1992 (Criminal) r 18.20, referred to.
Police v Giles [2013] SASC 11, considered.

DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (CTH) v FITZPATRICK
[2018] SASC 180

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. KOURAKIS CJ:       This is an appeal against the dismissal of an application for an intervention order by a Magistrate in the Adelaide Magistrates Court.  The appellant is the Commonwealth Department of Human Services (the Department).  The Department sought an intervention order prohibiting the respondent, Mr Allan Fitzpatrick, from assaulting, threatening, harassing or intimidating its workers at different Human Service office locations throughout South Australia.

  2. Section 20 of the Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (SA)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Department of Human Services (Cth) v Fitzpatrick and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Department of Human Services (Cth) v Fitzpatrick concerns an appeal by the Department of Human Services against a decision of the Adelaide Magistrates Court to refuse to accept an intervention order application. The Department sought an intervention order to protect its employees from alleged physical aggression by Mr Fitzpatrick, who suffers from schizophrenia and receives a disability support pension. The application sought to restrict Mr Fitzpatrick from contacting or communicating with the employees in any way, except through specific written means, and to prohibit him from entering or remaining near the Department's offices. The appeal focused on the legality of the application's form and the Department's standing to bring the application.

The legal issues before the court were whether the application sufficiently identified the protected persons and whether the Department had the legal standing to bring the application. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and the interpretation of these provisions in light of the application. The key statutory provisions included sections 6, 20, and 21 of the Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009, which set out the grounds for issuing an intervention order, the definition of a protected person, and the necessary elements of an interim intervention order.

The court found that the Department's application, while not naming each individual employee, sufficiently identified the class of protected persons by describing them as "workers of the Department of Human Services" and specifying the locations where they work. The court noted that the purpose of identifying protected persons is to clarify who the defendant's conduct is restrained against. Given that the application clearly defined the scope and locations, the court held that the application met the statutory requirements. Furthermore, the court found that the Department had the legal capacity to bring the application as a suitable representative of the protected persons, pursuant to sections 7(2) and 20(1)(b) of the Act. The court also noted that it was in the public interest and more efficient for the Department to bring the application on behalf of its employees.

The court concluded that the application complied with the necessary statutory requirements and that the Department had standing to bring the application. The appeal was therefore allowed, and the intervention order application was ordered to be received by the Registrar of the Adelaide Magistrates Court and proceed to a hearing. The court emphasized the importance of considering issues such as consultation and notification processes when a class of people is proposed to be protected by an intervention order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The second ground is that the Magistrate erred in refusing to admit into evidence the affidavit sworn 6 July 2018 by Mr Shane Robinson, an employee and representative of the Department, filed in support of the intervention order application. The second ground was not pursued on the appeal because it was accepted that if the appeal were successful on the first ground, the matter should be remitted to the Magistrates Court and that, on that remittal, further material may be filed and relied upon. On the other hand, if the appeal on the first ground failed, the admissibility of the affidavit was moot.Background Mr Fitzpatrick suffers from schizophrenia and receives a disability support pension. The Department alleges that, on many occasions since 2011, Mr Fitzpatrick has been physically aggressive towards its workers and poses an ongoing risk them. On 15 October 2017 the Department implemented a Managed Services Plan (MSP) which restricted Mr Fitzpatrick’s access to Human Service office locations. From 15 October 2017 to 10 October 2018 he was fully restricted from face to face contact and telephone contact. The MSP required him to interact with various office locations by written communication only. The Department alleges that the police have been called to provide assistance on occasions on which Mr Fitzpatrick has breached the MSP.The Intervention Order Application On 6 July 2018 the appellant attempted to file an application for an intervention order in the Adelaide Magistrates Court. The application sought a non‑domestic abuse order prohibiting Mr Fitzpatrick from assaulting, threatening, harassing or intimidating the Department’s workers (which were collectively described as the Protected Persons) in 24 specified suburban and regional offices. The application also sought ancillary orders that Mr Fitzpatrick:4.Contact or communicate with the Protected Persons directly or indirectly in any way (including by telephone) except:(a) In writing by mail to Medicare Services, GPO Box 9822, Adelaide, SA 5001;(b) In writing by mail to Centerlink, Reply Paid 7800, Canberra BC, ACT 2610; or(c) In writing by fax to 1300 786 102.5.Enter or remain within 50 metres of the boundary of the Protected Persons place of work, namely the DHS Locations. 6.Damage or interfere with the premises where the Protected Persons work, namely the DHS Locations. … The Registrar of the Adelaide Magistrates Court did not accept the application for filing and invited the Department to provide reasons in support of its filing. On 13 July 2018, the Department wrote to the Registrar of the Adelaide Magistrates Court providing reasons in support of the filing of the application and requesting that the matter be dealt with by a Magistrate pursuant to r 18.20 of the Magistrates Court Rules 1992 (Criminal). The Department included the following:1. The Department submits that:(a) pursuant to section 6 of the Intervention Orders (Prevention of Abuse) Act 2009 (Act) it is reasonable to suspect (based on the information stated in the Application and accompanying Affidavit) that the Defendant will, without intervention, commit an act of abuse against a worker of the Department; and (b) the Defendant poses a serious imminent risk to the health and safety of Department workers and it is therefore in the public interest to ensure the Application is brought before a Magistrate.2.There is no section, rule or authority (in the Act, the Rules nor any other applicable legislation or case law) that requires each individual protected person to be specified in the Application.3.The purpose of a ‘protected person’ being identified in an application for an intervention order is so that it is clear to a defendant (and to the Police, should there be a breach of an order), the persons in relation to whom the defendant’s conduct is restrained. This purpose if satisfied in this case as the terms of the intervention orders sought by the Department are limited to workers in connection with their work for the Department whilst undertaking their duties at Service Centres. The locations of the Service Centres are clearly stated in the Application.4.The Department was successful in obtaining a restraint order against an aggressive customer in the Tasmanian Magistrates Court (Action number 90268/2018) on 28 February 2018 in similar circumstances, whereby:(a) the Department was granted leave by the Tasmanian Magistrates Court to make the application in its own right, as a ‘third party’;(b) the ‘persons to be protected’ were successfully named in the application as ‘workers of the Department of Human Services’;(c) the application was supported by contemporaneous written incident reports completed by the relevant frontline staff (or their direct manager) at the time of the incident; and(d) all Department workers were only identified in evidence by their employee ID and staff names were redacted from incident reports.The circumstances of that case are analogous to this Application and there are no relevant differences in the applicable statutory regime.5.The Department, on behalf of the Commonwealth, has legal capacity to make an application for an intervention order pursuant to:(a) section 7(2) of the Act which states that an intervention order may be issued for the protection of a person even if that person is not the application for the order and the application is not made on his or her behalf;(b) section 20(1)(b) of the Act which states that an application for an intervention order may be made by a suitable representative (with permission of the Court) or a person against whom it is alleged a defendant may commit an act of abuse; and(c) the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) and the Crown Proceedings Act 1992 (SA) which enables the Commonwealth to bring proceedings in its own right.6.Section 20(4) of the Act contemplates that a single application may be made for the protection of a number of persons. If the Application is granted, we note that either a single order or multiple orders may be made pursuant to section 7(3).7.As multiple workers of the Department are at risk of abuse, it is more efficient that the Application be brought by the Department than each of those workers individually. The Department is also better resources and able to bring an Application than any of the individual workers involved.8.The Defendant may not already be aware of the names of the relevant workers of the Department and to name them personally in the Application could expose them to a greater risk of abuse than is currently the case.9.Rule 5.01 of the Rules provides that ‘it is sufficient compliance with these Rules, as to the form of any document, if the document is substantially in accordance with the Form’. The Application is substantially in accordance with the prescribed Form and therefore, for the reasons stated above, should be accepted for filing by the Registry.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, I observe that the Department brought the application claiming to be a suitable representative of the protected persons but offered no evidence as to whether consent was given by those persons. I do not wish to suggest that the consent of every existing member is necessary. Evidence of a broad consultation, or at least a notification process, may be sufficient. In this case, the general support which the application would attract from the Department’s workers is obvious enough. However, in some cases, some members of a proposed class may wish to be excluded. It suffices to say that attention should generally be given to these issues.Conclusion The Department’s intervention order application properly sought an order with respect to persons even though they were identified as members of a class. The orders sought, with appropriate amendments, could satisfy the requirements of certainty. I would therefore allow the appeal. I would order that the intervention order application be received by the Registrar of the Adelaide Magistrates Court and proceed to a hearing in the ordinary way.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Fitzpatrick submitted:·It is accepted that s 20(4) of the IO Act contemplates that a single application against the same defendant can be made for the protection of a ‘number of persons’.·While Mr Fitzpatrick also accepts that it is possible in theory for a (clearly delineated) class of people to be afforded the protection of an intervention order, and there is authority that such orders can extend protection to (named) third parties in addition to the express complainants; Mr Fitzpatrick does not concede that s 21(7) of the IO Act can afford protection through an intervention order, to any class of people however described, when the individuals within it are not readily identifiable as such, by reference to that class description.·Many of the Department’s staff proposed to be a ‘protected person’ under the application have never had, nor will have any knowledge, contact or interaction with Mr Fitzpatrick.·Mr Fitzpatrick submits that the application is outside Parliament’s intention and as such is brought in error.Consideration It is convenient to refer to some further provisions of the IO Act. A protected person is defined by s 3 of the IO Act to be a person for whose protection an intervention order is issued. The grounds for issuing an intervention order are prescribed by s 6 of the IO Act. The necessary and sufficient grounds for the issuing of an intervention order are:(a)it is reasonable to suspect that the defendant will, without intervention, commit an act of abuse against a person; and (b)the issuing of the order is appropriate in the circumstances. Section 12 sets out the prohibitions which may be included in an intervention order. Most obviously, an intervention order may prohibit the defendant from contacting, harassing, threatening or intimidating the protected person. An intervention order may also prohibit the defendant from being in the vicinity of premises at which a protected person resides or works, or in the vicinity of specified premises frequented by that protected person. Importantly, s 12(1)(e) of the IO Act allows for an order prohibiting the defendant from intimidating any other person at a place where the protected person resides or works. Section 18 of the IO Act authorises a police officer to issue an interim intervention order. Section 18(3) of the IO Act prescribes the following necessary elements of an interim intervention order:(3) An interim intervention order issued by a police officer must— (a) be in a form approved by the Commissioner of Police; and(b) identify the defendant and the persons protected by the order; and (c) specify the prohibitions and requirements imposed by the order; and (d) require the defendant to appear before the Court at a specified time and place (within 8 days after the date of the order or, if the Court will not be sitting at the place within that period, within 2 days after the Court next commences sitting at the place). The Magistrates Court may also issue an interim intervention order on an application made directly to it. Section 21(7) of the IO Act prescribes the necessary elements of an interim intervention order issued by the Court and they include the identification of the defendant and the persons protected by the order.