Denehey v Nominal Insurer

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Serial No B53/1991
List “B”

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:              Denehey v Nominal Insurer [1991] TASSC 167; B53/1991

PARTIES:  DENEHEY
  v
  NOMINAL INSURER

FILE NO:  WC408/1988
DELIVERED ON:  24 September 1991
JUDGMENT OF:  Crawford J

Judgment Number:  B53/1991
Number of paragraphs:  20

Serial No B53/1991
File No WC408/1988

DENEHEY v THE NOMINAL INSURER

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  CRAWFORD J

24 September 1991

  1. The defendant stands in the place of the plaintiff's employer because the employer, Richardsons Meat Industries Limited, has been ordered to be wound up. The effect of the Workers' Compensation Act 1927 s16B(1)(b)(i) is that where the employer is a company and its winding–up has commenced, proceedings may be brought against the nominal insurer in respect of the employer's liability under the Act.

  1. On 9 January 1987, in the course of the plaintiff's employment by Richardsons Meat Industries Limited, he fell into a large industrial mincer. He was admitted to the Royal Hobart Hospital and underwent a number of operations. As a consequence, he has lost his right arm from a point between his shoulder and elbow. He was naturally right–handed. On discharge from the hospital as an in–patient, he was referred by a medical practitioner to the Douglas Parker Rehabilitation Centre to undergo physiotherapy and occupational therapy.

  1. The Douglas Parker Rehabilitation Centre has rendered an account for $20,050.00, most of which is for occupational therapy. A portion of it consists of charges for training in literacy skills. The questions for determination are whether that portion can be categorised as reasonable costs of either medical or hospital services, as those expressions are meant in the Workers' Compensation Act 1927 s8A(1), and whether those costs were reasonably incurred by the plaintiff by reason of his injury.

  1. The plaintiff was 44 years old at the time of the accident. He did not go to school as a child. He commenced to work as a truck driver at the age of 16 and worked in that occupation for most of the time following. He commenced working as a truck driver for Richardsons Meat Industries Limited nearly 17 years before the accident. His employment included driving a truck to butchers' shops to collect fat and bone. The only writing required of him in his employment was on what he called fat and bone dockets, on which he wrote the name of the butchers' shops and the numbers of kilograms of fat and bone collected by him. One copy of a docket was left by him with the shop and another copy was given by him to his employer's office. His evidence was that prior to the accident he could only read very slowly and he skipped over long words because he could not understand them. He did not read newspapers. He said he used to try and read children's books. The only writing he did outside work was "mucking around" with his children. He could only write by printing and that is still the case. He did not write letters (correspondence). On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Denehey v Nominal Insurer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] TASSC 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Denehey v Nominal Insurer is a case where the plaintiff, Denehey, sought compensation for costs incurred during his rehabilitation following an industrial accident. The defendant, Nominal Insurer, stood in for the plaintiff's employer, Richardsons Meat Industries Limited, which had been ordered to be wound up. The central dispute in this matter was whether the costs of literacy training, part of the plaintiff's rehabilitation, could be categorized as reasonable costs of medical or hospital services under the Workers' Compensation Act 1927, and if these costs were reasonably incurred by the plaintiff due to his injury.

The court had to determine if the literacy training costs were part of the "usual or necessary hospital services" as defined by the Act, and if they were reasonably incurred due to the plaintiff's injury. The plaintiff, who was close to being illiterate before the accident, had undergone extensive rehabilitation which included literacy training at the Douglas Parker Rehabilitation Centre. The court needed to decide whether this training qualified as a "hospital service" and whether the costs were reasonable and directly related to the injury.

Crawford J concluded that the literacy training was indeed part of the "usual or necessary hospital services" provided by the Douglas Parker Rehabilitation Centre, which operated as an integral part of the Royal Hobart Hospital. The court found that the training was crucial for the plaintiff's rehabilitation and employment prospects. The judge held that the costs were reasonable and directly related to the plaintiff's injury, as the training aimed to improve his literacy and ability to use his left hand for writing, which was essential for his future employment opportunities.

The final orders of the court were that the defendant, Nominal Insurer, pay the plaintiff $20,050, which was the amount claimed for the rehabilitation costs, including the literacy training.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established