Den Hertog v Construction Occupations Registrar (Occupational Discipline)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



DEN HERTOG v CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR (Occupational Discipline) [2014] ACAT 33

OR 44 of 2013

Catchwords:  OCCUPATIONAL DISCIPLINE – CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATION – eligibility to apply for Class A Builder’s licence – whether applicant’s work activities are activities involving the actual carrying out of building work – relevant practical building work experience – interpretation of exception in definition of building work experience – whether there is verification of the extent, quality, relevance and recency of applicant’s building work experience

Legislation: Building Act 2004, ss 6, 9, 10, 11 and 37

Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004, ss 7, 8, 18 and 19

Legislation Act 2001, s 148

Subordinate

Legislation:Construction Occupations (Licensing) Regulation 2004, ss 5, 11, 12, and 13 and Schedule 1

Construction Occupations (Licensing) (Mandatory Qualifications) Declaration 2012 (No 3) (NI 2012-303), Schedule

Texts/Papers:  ACT Planning and Land Authority, Review of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004, Prepared in accordance with section 131 of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004, August 2007

D C Pearce and R S Geddes, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (7th ed, 2011)

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member
  Mr G. Trickett – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  30 May 2014              

Date of Reasons for Decision:       30 May 2014  

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL          OR 13/44

BETWEEN:BERNARD DEN HERTOG

Applicant

AND: CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

Mr G. Trickett – Senior Member

DATE:30 May 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.The decision under review is confirmed.

………………………………..

Ms. E. Symons – Presidential Member

For and on behalf of the Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Mr Bernard den Hertog (the applicant) applied to the Construction Occupations Registrar (the respondent) for a licence as a Class A Builder on 22 July 2013.

  2. On 7 November 2013, pursuant to section 19 of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (the COLA), Mr Benjamin Green, delegate of the respondent, refused to issue the construction occupation licence applied for (the decision).

  3. The applicant filed an application for review of the decision in the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) on 4 December 2013.

  4. At a directions hearing held on 8 January 2014, a timetable was made for the applicant to provide witness statements from each witness (including himself), on whose evidence he relied in support of his application and any other material relied on. The application was referred for mediation on 21 February 2014.

  5. On 21 February 2014, after the mediation, further orders were made requiring both parties to file a statement of facts and contentions, any witness statements and any other material to be relied on, and the matter was set down for hearing on 14 May 2014.

The hearing

  1. At the hearing on 14 May 2014, the applicant represented himself.  Dr Jarvis, instructed by Ms Law-Jamieson from the ACT Government Solicitor’s Office, represented the respondent.

  2. The applicant gave evidence and was cross-examined. His…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Den Hertog v Construction Occupations Registrar (Occupationa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Tribunal involved an application by Den Hertog for a construction licence. The Construction Occupations Registrar refused the application on the basis that Den Hertog did not meet the mandatory qualifications specified in the Construction Occupations (Licensing) (Mandatory Qualifications) Declaration 2012 (No 3). The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing the Registrar's decision to ensure it was lawful, reasonable, and procedurally fair.

The central legal issue was whether Den Hertog met the mandatory qualifications for a Class A Builder's licence as outlined in the Declaration. This involved interpreting the terms "building work," "specialist building work," and "basic building work" as they appeared in the Declaration and the Building Act 2004. The Tribunal had to determine if the Registrar correctly applied these definitions when assessing Den Hertog's eligibility.

The Tribunal found that the Registrar had correctly interpreted and applied the definitions of "building work," "specialist building work," and "basic building work." It concluded that Den Hertog's experience did not meet the requirements of the Builder Class A qualifications as outlined in the Declaration. The Tribunal determined that the Registrar's decision was lawful and procedurally fair. Consequently, the Tribunal confirmed the Registrar's decision to refuse the licence application.

The Tribunal Orders that the decision under review is confirmed, upholding the Registrar's refusal to issue a licence to Den Hertog.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. The decision under review is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Decision on licence application(1)If an entity applies for a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class, the registrar must issue, or refuse to issue, the licence.(2)However, the registrar may issue a licence other than the licence applied for if—(a)the applicant is not eligible for the licence applied for; and(b)the applicant is eligible for the other licence; and(c)the licence issued is in the same construction occupation as, but a different occupation class from, the licence applied for; and(d)the applicant agrees to the issue of the licence.(3)The registrar must refuse to issue a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class to an applicant if—(a)the registrar is not satisfied that the applicant is eligible to be licensed in the occupation or class; or(b)the applicant is disqualified from holding a licence under section 98 (Licence disqualification).(4)The registrar may refuse to issue a licence for a construction occupation or occupation class to an applicant if—(a)the applicant, a director or nominee of an applicant that is a corporation, or a partner or nominee of an applicant that is a partnership, is a licensee or former licensee (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law who—(i)is prohibited from providing a construction service (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; or(ii)is subject to occupational discipline (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; or(iii)the registrar believes on reasonable grounds surrendered a licence (however described) in circumstances that related to a ground for occupational discipline (however described) under this Act or a corresponding law; and(b)the registrar believes on reasonable grounds that the refusal is necessary or desirable to protect the public.(5)The registrar may issue a licence to an applicant for less than the maximum period for which the licence may be issued if the registrar believes on reasonable grounds that it is necessary or desirable to protect the public.(6)If an application for occupational discipline in relation to an applicant or nominee of an applicant has been made by the registrar under division 5.2 (Occupational discipline—licensees), the registrar need not decide whether to licence the applicant until the application has been dealt with by the ACAT, and any appeal or review arising from the occupational discipline, is finished.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Schedule to the Construction Occupations (Licensing) (Mandatory Qualifications) Declaration 2012 (No 3) (NI 2012-303) (the Declaration), the Registrar has set out the necessary qualifications for an individual to be eligible to be licensed in specified construction occupation classes (including as a Builder, Construction Occupation Class A). In the Schedule to the Declaration, the qualifications for a Builder, Class A, as they relate to this matter, are as follows (the Builder Class A qualifications): 1. The applicant holds:(a)a tertiary qualification in architecture, civil engineering, structural engineering or building that the Australian Qualifications Framework Advisory Board has determined is a bachelor degree, graduate certificate, graduate diploma, masters degree or doctoral degree in the Australian Qualifications Framework system; and(b)not less than 2 years of full time relevant practical building work experience, carried out by the applicant, other than:(i) building work of the kind that an unconditional builder’s licence class C authorises; and(ii) specialist building work; and(iii) basic building work; or... ‘Building work’, for paragraph 1(b)(i) of the Builder Class A qualifications, is not defined in the Declaration or in the COLA. It is defined in section 6 of the Building Act2004 (the Building Act), a related operational act, as follows:6Meaning of building work (1) In this Act:building work means— (a) work in relation to the erection, alteration or demolition of a building, and includes disposal of waste materials generated—(i)by the alteration of a building other than a building excluded under the regulations; or (ii) by the demolition of a building (but not part of the building); or (b) work in relation to repairs of a structural nature to a building.… ‘Specialist building work’, for paragraph 1(b)(ii) of the Builder Class A qualifications, is not defined in the Declaration or in the COLA. It is defined in section 9 of the Building Act as follows:9Meaning of specialist building workIn this Act:specialist building work—(a)means—(i)the installation of a swimming pool; or(ii)the demolition of a building; and(b)includes building work prescribed under the regulations as specialist building work. ‘Basic building work’, for paragraph 1(b)(iii) of the Builder Class A qualifications, is not defined in the Declaration or in the COLA. It is defined in section 10 of the Building Act as follows:10Meaning of basic building work(1)In this Act:basic building work—(a)means the following building work:(i)erecting a prefabricated class 10a building;(ii)erecting a class 10a outbuilding;(iii)installing fireplaces or solid-fuel heaters;(iv)non-structural work; but(b)does not include specialist building work. ‘Non-structural work’, for paragraph (1)(a)(iv) of the definition of ‘basic building work’ in section 10 of the Building Act, is defined in section 11 of the Building Act as follows:non-structural work— (a) means work on a part of a building that does not, or is not intended to, carry a structural load imposed or transmitted by another part of a building; and(b)includes work on non-load bearing walls, doors, partitioning, reticulated pipework, ventilation ductwork and building fit-out items; but(c)does not include the following work:(i)work that may affect the structural integrity of a structural element of a building, or weaken or remove, completely or partly, the structural element, if the element is installed in a way that it carries, or can carry, a load of part of a building;(ii)work that involves the use of a structural element to carry, or to possibly carry, a structural load of part of a building.