DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
| CITATION: | Delta Packaging P/L v Good & Anor [2000] QDC 335 |
| PARTIES: | DELTA PACKAGING PTY LTD ACN 010 677 282 Plaintiff v ALISTAIR GOOD AND MALCOLM GOOD Defendant |
| FILE NO/S: | D303 of 2000 |
| DIVISION: | Civil jurisdiction |
| PROCEEDING: | |
| ORIGINATING | Brisbane |
| COURT: | |
| DELIVERED ON: | 6 November 2000 |
| DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
| HEARING | 25-26 September 2000 |
| DATES: | |
| JUDGE: | Senior Judge Skoien |
| ORDER: | Injunctive relief; judgment for plaintiff for money owing and for damages. Counterclaim dismissed. |
| CATCHWORDS: | Breach of oral agreement to work under terms of written agreement; restraint of trade clause; injunction; damages. |
| COUNSEL: | Hackett for plaintiff Defendants in person |
| SOLICITORS: | Cleary Hoare Solicitors for the plaintiff |
In this action the plaintiff claims money due and owing under an agency agreement,
damages for breach of the agreement, damages for the loss of an opportunity to sell
the agency and an injunction. There is a counterclaim for commission and
compensation owing under an agreement.
Facts
The plaintiff (Delta) operates the business of distributing packaging products to
retail shops. It does this via licensees who operate in different areas under a written
agreement called a Territory Licence Agreement. Pursuant to that agreement a
licensee is allowed to use the Delta system and Delta property for the sale of Delta
products within a specified territory on the terms and conditions contained in the
agreement.
Delta itself also operated its Delta system and sold Delta products for the purpose of
developing new territories. Once a territory had been adequately developed it
would go about selling the license to operate that territory, as described in para. [2].
One such territory was the Pine Rivers territory which Delta began to operate in its
own name from about May 1996 on. By mid 1999 Delta had worked up the Pine
Rivers Territory sufficiently to be interested in selling the license to operate the
Delta system there.
The defendant Alistair Good had for some years worked as a sales representative
for Dalton Packaging which carried on a similar business to that of Delta, selling its
packaging products in an area which included the Pine Rivers territory. On 14th
July 1999 he and all similarly engaged employees of Dalton were made redundant
as Dalton had decided to abandon serving retailers with its products in favour of
serving wholesalers only. He was told by Dalton that he was free to serve in his
personal capacity the customers he had till then been supplying for Dalton. He
began to do that by arranging supplies for them through a Mr Hatzifotis, a licensee
of Delta (for another area).
On 15 July 1999 Alistair Good spoke to Mr Tsouranakis, Delta’s sales manager
about, among other things, Good buying the Delta licence for the Pine Rivers area.
It was suggested that by working for Hatzifotis Alistair Good would increase his
knowledge of the Delta system and be able to form an opinion of the value of the
Pine Rivers territory. Further conversations took place between Tsouranakis and
Alistair Good during which Good said that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Delta Packaging Pty Ltd v Good and Good and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QDC 335
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether there was a binding oral agreement that the Defendants would operate the business under the terms of the written agreement, and if so, whether the restraint of trade clause in the written agreement was enforceable against the Defendants. The Court also had to determine whether the Plaintiff was entitled to injunctive relief and damages for the breach of the oral agreement and whether the Plaintiff was owed money by the Defendants. Finally, the Court had to consider the Defendants' counterclaim for an account of money.
The Court found that there was a binding oral agreement that the Defendants would take over the business and operate it under the terms of the written agreement. The Court held that the restraint of trade clause in the written agreement was enforceable against the Defendants and granted the Plaintiff injunctive relief. The Court also found that the Plaintiff was owed money by the Defendants and awarded damages for the breach of the oral agreement. The Court dismissed the Defendants' counterclaim. The Court ordered that the Defendants pay the Plaintiff the money owing, as well as damages for the breach of the oral agreement, and that the Defendants refrain from engaging in activities that would breach the restraint of trade clause.
Orders
Orders of the court
Injunctive relief; judgment for plaintiff for money owing
and for damages. Counterclaim dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi