Delta Corporate Identity, Inc v Sky Channel Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Application by Delta Corporate Identity, Inc for a late extension of time in which to file Notice of Opposition to registration of trade mark application 834738(35, 39) - SKY REWARDS - filed in the name of Sky Channel Pty Limited.

Background

Trade mark application number 834738 was filed by Sky Channel Pty Limited ('Sky') on 10 May 2000.  The application was for the word trade mark SKY REWARDS.  The application was advertised accepted in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 3 May 2001 in respect of the following services:

Class 35:         Advertising, marketing, publicity and promotional services including arranging trade and industrial exhibitions; customer loyalty and incentive programs and schemes; supply of benefits in connection with loyalty and incentive programs and schemes; product promotions; operation and administration of loyalty marketing and other sales and promotional incentive and loyalty schemes; sales promotion through frequent buyer incentive programs and customer loyalty programs; arranging the provision by third parties of discounts, complimentary goods and complimentary services

Class 39:         Arranging of passenger transport; booking and reserving of seats for travel by air, road, rail and sea; transport and travel reservation services, including ticketing, in this class; arranging and conducting tours, sightseeing events and cruises; frequent flyer plans, schemes and programs; flyer benefits in connection with transport and travel; tourism services

On 27 July 2001, Delta Corporate Identity, Inc ('Delta') through its agent Peter Maxwell & Associates, Sydney, applied for a one-month extension of time to file Notice of Opposition.  The ground relied on was in terms of regulation 5.2(2)(d) of the Trade Marks Regulations ('the Regulations').  There was no objection from Sky and the extension of time was subsequently allowed. 

Delta filed a second application for an extension of time to lodge Notice of Opposition on 29 August 2001.  This application was for two months from 3 September 2001 to 3 November 2001.  Again, the ground relied on was in terms of regulation 5.2(2)(d).  A statutory declaration of James Vernon Maxwell, attorney for Delta, dated 29 August 2001 ('the second Maxwell declaration'), supported the extension application.  A delegate of the Registrar wrote to the potential opponent, advising that as the statutory period for filing Notice of Opposition had passed, an extension application could only be made on the basis of regulation 5.2(2)(a), (b) or (c).  For this reason, the ground Delta had relied on was invalid.  The delegate told Delta that she intended to refuse the extension of time, but before doing so, would allow 14 days for it to request to be heard.  A copy of the delegate's letter was forwarded to Sky, for information.

On 21 September 2001 Delta requested to be heard.  The matter was not set down for hearing at that stage, however, as the required hearing fee had not been paid.

Delta filed a third application for an extension of time on 5 November 2001.  This application was also for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Delta Corporate Identity, Inc v Sky Channel Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] ATMO 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Delta Corporate Identity, Inc. (Delta) applied for a late extension of time to file a Notice of Opposition to a trade mark application by Sky Channel Pty Limited (Sky) for the mark SKY REWARDS. Delta filed multiple applications for extensions of time, with the initial applications being based on grounds that were later deemed invalid by the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The dispute centred on whether Delta should be granted a further extension of time to file its opposition, despite the prescribed period and an initial extension having expired.

The delegate was required to determine whether Delta had established a valid ground for a late extension of time to file its Notice of Opposition, particularly in light of the expiry of the statutory period for opposition. This involved considering whether Delta had a settled intention to oppose the trade mark application within the original timeframe, and whether an error or omission by its agent constituted a sufficient reason for the delay in filing the opposition. The delegate also had to assess whether the application met the formal requirements of the Trade Marks Regulations and whether both parties had been afforded an opportunity to make representations.

The delegate reasoned that for an extension application made after the prescribed period, the applicant must demonstrate a settled intention to oppose within the original period and a causal link between events and the failure to file. Applying this, the delegate found that Delta had indeed maintained a settled intention to oppose, even if contingent on the outcome of negotiations, citing previous decisions such as *Cognotec Limited and Cognos Incorporated* and *AgDirect Sales v Agro-K*. The delegate also accepted that Delta's agent's misinterpretation of the Trade Marks Regulations constituted an error under regulation 5.2(2)(b), which causally led to the failure to file the Notice of Opposition in time. However, the delegate found that the ground under regulation 5.2(2)(c) was not sufficiently supported.

The delegate granted the extension of time based on the ground of error by Delta's agent under regulation 5.2(2)(b), allowing Delta to file its Notice of Opposition. The delegate treated Delta's second and third extension applications as a single application due to their overlapping periods and similar nature.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established