Della-Franca v Autosports Leichhardt Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Della-Franca v Autosports Leichhardt Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 180

File number(s): NSD 94 of 2021
Judgment of: GOODMAN J
Date of judgment: 9 March 2022
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to set aside notice to produce – application dismissed  
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Harman v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1983] 1 AC 280

National Employers’ Mutual General Insurance Association Ltd v Waind & Hill [1978] 1 NSWLR 372

Seven Network Limited v News Limited (No 11) [2006] FCA 174

Townsend v General Motors-Holden’s Ltd (1983) 4 IR 358

Vehicle Builders Employees’ Federation of Australia v Ford Motor Co. of Australia Pty Ltd (1962) 3 FLR 198

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 26
Date of hearing: 28 February 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr G Fredericks
Solicitor for the Applicant: Paul Almond Employment Law Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms B Byrnes
Solicitor for the Respondent: FCB Lawyers and Consultants
Table of Corrections
9 March 2022 In paragraph 26, the words “with costs” has been deleted.

ORDERS

NSD 94 of 2021
BETWEEN:

MICHAEL FRANCIS DELLA-FRANCA

Applicant

AND:

AUTOSPORTS LEICHHARDT PTY LTD ABN 38 161 160 765

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

GOODMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 MARCH 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent’s interlocutory application dated 7 December 2021 is dismissed.

2.Costs reserved.

3.The applicant’s Notice to Produce addressed to the respondent dated 21 October 2021 is returnable before the Registrar at 9:30am on 23 March 2022.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

GOODMAN J

  1. By way of interlocutory application dated 7 December 2021, the respondent seeks an order setting aside two paragraphs of a Notice to Produce dated 21 October 2021 served upon it by the applicant (alternatively, an order providing dispensation from compliance with the Notice to Produce). The order is sought on the basis that the documents likely to be caught by those paragraphs are not of apparent relevance to the issues in the proceeding.

  2. The respondent also seeks, in the event that it is required to produce the documents sought in those paragraphs, an order providing dispensation from any requirement to produce personal information of employees contained within such documents.

    BACKGROUND

  3. Immediately prior to the events the subject of this proceeding, the applicant was employed by the respondent as dealer principal of the respondent’s Leichhardt Volkswagen dealership and its Five Dock service and parts business. The respondent is a company within the Autosports Group of companies.

  4. It is common ground that the respondent stood down the applicant from his employment on 25 March 2020 and that the respondent terminated the applicant’s employment on 11 September 2020.

  5. The applicant’s claims in the proceeding include a claim that he was entitled to be remunerated during the period from 25 March 2020 to 11…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Della-Franca v Autosports Leichhardt Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Della-Franca v Autosports Leichhardt Pty Ltd involved an application by the respondent to set aside a notice to produce documents. The applicant, who was previously employed by the respondent, had initiated proceedings claiming entitlement to remuneration during a period of stand down. The respondent argued that it could lawfully stand down the applicant without pay due to a stoppage of work caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, as per section 524 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The applicant sought production of documents that would provide evidence regarding the employer’s decision-making process and the circumstances leading to the stand down.

The court had to determine whether the respondent's application to set aside the notice to produce should be granted. Specifically, it needed to consider the relevance of the documents sought and whether they were necessary for the applicant to establish his claims. The court also had to decide whether the respondent had discharged the onus of proving that the stand down was lawful under section 524 of the Act.

The court found that the documents sought by the applicant were relevant to the employer's decision to stand down the employee and the broader context in which that decision was made. The court noted that the onus was on the respondent to prove that the stand down was lawful, and the documents in question could potentially assist in that regard. The court held that the documents were necessary for the applicant to establish his case and dismissed the respondent's application to set aside the notice to produce. The court also ordered that the respondent must comply with the notice to produce and that costs were reserved for a later determination.

In conclusion, the court ruled that the respondent’s application to set aside the notice to produce was dismissed, and the respondent was required to produce the documents as requested by the applicant. The court emphasized the importance of the respondent proving the lawfulness of the stand down, and the necessity of the documents for the applicant to establish his claims. The matter was set for further proceedings, with costs to be determined at a later stage.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent’s interlocutory application dated 7 December 2021 is dismissed.

2. Costs reserved.

3. The applicant’s Notice to Produce addressed to the respondent dated 21 October 2021 is returnable before the Registrar at 9:30am on 23 March 2022.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent also seeks, in the event that it is required to produce the documents sought in those paragraphs, an order providing dispensation from any requirement to produce personal information of employees contained within such documents.BACKGROUND Immediately prior to the events the subject of this proceeding, the applicant was employed by the respondent as dealer principal of the respondent’s Leichhardt Volkswagen dealership and its Five Dock service and parts business. The respondent is a company within the Autosports Group of companies. It is common ground that the respondent stood down the applicant from his employment on 25 March 2020 and that the respondent terminated the applicant’s employment on 11 September 2020. The applicant’s claims in the proceeding include a claim that he was entitled to be remunerated during the period from 25 March 2020 to 11 September 2020. Part of the respondent’s answer to the applicant’s claim is that during that period the applicant could not usefully have been employed by the respondent because of a stoppage of work for a cause for which the respondent cannot reasonably be held responsible, and as such the respondent was not required to make payments to the applicant for that period. The respondent relies upon s 524 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) which provides insofar as is presently relevant:(1) An employer may, under this subsection, stand down an employee during a period in which the employee cannot usefully be employed because of one of the following circumstances:…(c) a stoppage of work for any cause for which the employer cannot reasonably be held responsible.…(3) If an employer stands down an employee during a period under subsection (1), the employer is not required to make payments to the employee for that period. The parties have filed outlines of evidence to be given by various witnesses, ahead of a hearing scheduled to commence on 30 May 2022. In particular:(1)the outline of evidence of the applicant foreshadows that he will give evidence that:11.There were, as at 24 March 2020, approximately 30 employees employed by the respondent and Group at the levels of Dealer Principal and General Manager. As at 24 March 2020, the applicant was the only person at his (Dealer Principal) level of the respondent to be stood down. No General Managers were stood down.(2)the outline of evidence of Mr Scaife, served by the applicant, foreshadows that he will give evidence that:6.The Five Dock site managed by Mr Scaife reopened during May 2020, stood down staff returned to work at Five Dock and Rushcutters Bay, but his stand down continued. James Chen took over Mr Scaife’s responsibilities when the sites managed by Mr Scaife reopened.(3)the outline of evidence of Mr Pagent, the Chief Executive Officer and Managing Director of the Autosports Group, foreshadows that he will give evidence on matters including:1.Autosports Group comprises a portfolio of 40 retail businesses throughout Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and the Gold Coast representing automotive brands including Alpina, Aston Martin, Audi, Bentley, BMW, BMW Motorrad, Honda, Jaguar, Lamborghini, Land Rover, Maserati, McLaren, Mercedes-Benz, MINI, Rolls-Royce, Volkswagen and Volvo.…34.A discussion between him and the Applicant and other employees on 23 March 2020 where he advised that the business was intending to implement stand downs. During this discussion, Mr Pagent informed all employees on the call, including the Applicant, that employees in the organisation would be stood down without pay, including having their commission packages suspended and they had to return all company property.35.On 24 and 25 March 2020, the Board discussed the impacts of COVID - 19 on the business and a staged plan to reduce costs, which included standing down employees effective at 5pm on 25 March 2020. The Board had a number of Board meetings around this time and into the stand down period, many of which were solely focussed on mitigating the effects that the pandemic was having on the Autosports Group. Those discussions included reduction of costs, including employee costs which is approximately 40% of Autosports’ expenses in running its business.…42.His letter to the Applicant on 25 March 2020 confirming that he would be stood down. Mr Pagent, in his role of CEO and with the support of the Board, had decided that the stand down would occur for the reasons in the 25 March 2020 letter.43.That 20% of its employees were initially stood down in March 2020. The business then stood down a further 15% of its employees in April 2020. The business also stood down other senior managers in the same position as the Applicant (i.e. where multiple sites in the same position had been amalgamated), including in Victoria, the General Manager of the BMW site in Bundoora, Mr Mark Taylor, the Dealer Principal of two Volvo Sites in Sydney, including Mr Rob Scaife and the General Manager of one of our panel sites, Mr Alan MacNamee. (4)the outline of evidence of Ms Lintott, the former General Manager, People, Culture & Strategy for the Autosports Group foreshadows that she will give evidence on matters including:5.Her correspondence with employees who were stood down, including the Applicant, between March and September 2020, including correspondence that was sent to stood down staff and their managers with respect to matters pertaining to the stand down. Her written correspondence on the following dates is contained in the Respondent’s bundle of documents and was sent to the Applicant:a.25 March 2020;b.30 March 2020;c.3 April 2020;d.9 April 2020;e.15 April 2020;f.16 April 2020;g.23 April 2020;h.12 May 2020;i.5 June 2020;j.19 June 2020;k.10 July 2020;l.24 July 2020;m.29 July 2020; andn.17 August 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent's application to set aside the Notice to Produce should be granted.
2. Whether the applicant is entitled to remuneration during the period from 25 March 2020 to 11 September 2020.

Held
1. The court dismissed the respondent's application to set aside the Notice to Produce.
2. The court did not decide on the applicant's entitlement to remuneration during the period from 25 March 2020 to 11 September 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent’s submissions may be summarised as follows:(1)under s 524 of the Act, an employee can be stood down without pay if they cannot be usefully employed because of a stoppage of work for any cause for which the employer cannot reasonably be held responsible. The onus rests on the employer to establish that it brings itself within the power to invoke such provisions: Townsend v General Motors-Holden’s Ltd (1983) 4 IR 358 at 363-367 per Morling J;(2)in the present case, the “stoppage of work” is the reduction in customer demand for motor vehicles which meant that the work of two dealer principals across two dealer sites could be performed by one dealer principal. The applicant does not dispute that the management of the Leichhardt dealership and the Castle Hill dealership was consolidated and Mr Stevens, General Manager of Volkswagen Castle Hill, performed a new role being the consolidated dealership role overseeing both dealerships. This arrangement was approved by Volkswagen on a temporary basis only. This led to the applicant being stood down;(3)when identifying the “cause” of a stoppage of work, the search is not for the immediate “cause” of the stoppage but rather a more broadly based factual inquiry directed to the sequence of events which ultimately led to the stoppage of work: Vehicle Builders Employees’ Federation of Australia v Ford Motor Co. of Australia Pty Ltd (1962) 3 FLR 198;(4)the sequence of events which led to the reduction in client demand leading to the Autosports Group’s decision to amalgamate the management of the Leichardt and Castle Hill dealerships, was: the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic; the ban on non-essential travel announced by Australian and New South Wales governments; and health directives requiring the community to social distance, avoid non-essential work and movement and ultimately stay at home in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia. The respondent had no control over these events;(5)the details of when and how other employees in various sites operated by entities owned by Autosports Group, namely Five Dock Volkswagen owned by Autosport Five Dock Pty Ltd or Leichardt Volkswagen owned by the respondent (paragraph 7); and Rushcutters Bay Volvo operated by the respondent, Five Dock Volvo owned by Autosports Castle Hill Pty Ltd and the Bundoora BMW site owned by ASG Melbourne Pty Ltd (paragraph 8) were notified of their stand downs will not establish whether there was a ‘stoppage of work’ at the respondent’s site in Leichardt which meant the applicant could not be usefully employed. Further, documents showing the dates these employees were stood down and were therefore absent from the workplace at these sites owned and operated by entities of Autosports Group will not establish that the applicant could have been performing work at the Leichardt site. The reduced level of work these employees had originally been employed to do was being performed by other employees; and(6)similarly, the genuineness of the standing down of employees by other entities owned by Autosports Group, including other senior employees, such as Mr Scaife and Mr Taylor, is not relevant to the Court’s determination of whether the respondent has discharged its onus under s 524 of the Act with respect to the applicant’s stand down and rather suggests a collateral purpose for the documents being sought.Consideration