Deleje Pty Ltd v Butterworth

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Deleje Pty Ltd & Anor v Butterworth [2021] QDC 328

PARTIES:

DELEJE PTY LTD

and

DAVIN LEE JOHNSON

(appellants)

V
SIMON BUTTERWORTH

(respondent)

FILE NO:

3380/2020

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court

DELIVERED ON:

10 December 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

8 September 2021

JUDGE:

Richards DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal Dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL PURSUANT TO THE JUSTICES ACT 1886 (Qld) s 222 – APPEAL BY WAY OF REHEARING – where the appellant is the sole director of the appellant company – where the appellant was convicted of breaching a condition of a development approval and non-compliance with an enforcement notice - where the appellant failed to take all reasonable steps to ensure the company complied with executive liability provisions - whether the appellant knew or ought reasonably to have known the corporation’s conduct constituted an offence against the executive liability provision – whether there was actual knowledge of the corporation’s conduct

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016 (QLD) ss 164, 165A, 168(5), 227(1)

Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (QLD) ss224, 243, 335

CASES:

Steendyk v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2016] QPEC 47, followed

COUNSEL:

R Traves, QC with S Spottiswood for the Appellants

K D Cartledge, solicitor with City Legal for the Respondent  

SOLICITORS:

Gadens Solicitors for the Appellants

City Legal for the Respondent

Introduction

  1. On 15 October 2020 the appellants were convicted of offences against the Planning Act 2016. The company was convicted of an offence of breaching a condition of a development approval[1] and an offence of non – compliance with an enforcement notice in respect of that breach.[2]  Mr Johnson was charged as an executive officer of the company with failure to take all reasonable steps to ensure the company complied with its obligations under the Act.[3]  The company has appealed against the conviction for breaching the development approval and Mr Johnson has appealed both convictions.

    [1] S164 of the Planning Act 2016

    [2] S 168(5) of the Planning Act 2016

    [3] S227(1) of the Planning Act 2016

    Background

  2. On 3 July 2015 Deleje Pty Ltd was given a development approval pursuant to s 335 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (‘the Act’).  It was a preliminary approval under s 241 of the Act for a new dwelling house at 45 Bernard St Paddington under the traditional building character overlay.  The nature of the application was a development permit, and the activity was for a dwelling house.  Approval conditions were attached to that notice.  Condition 1 was that the building/premises was to be used for the purpose of a house:

    (a)the lot is only to be used for one house (including secondary dwelling as defined by Brisbane City Plan 2014);

    (b)the main dwelling together with any secondary dwelling is used by a household group comprising:

    (i)one person maintaining a household, or

    (ii)two or more persons related by blood, marriage or adoption, or

    (iii)not more than five persons, not necessarily related by blood, marriage or adoption, or

    (iv)not more…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deleje Pty Ltd v Butterworth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QDC 328
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Deleje Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Johnson, were convicted of breaches of the Planning Act 2016, including non-compliance with a development approval and an enforcement notice. The company was found to have violated a condition of its development approval, which stipulated that the building should be used for a single household. Mr Johnson was charged for failing to ensure the company complied with its obligations under the Act. Both the company and Mr Johnson appealed against their respective convictions. The central legal questions were whether Mr Johnson knew or should have known that the company's conduct constituted an offence under the executive liability provision, and whether there was actual knowledge of the corporation's conduct.

The court examined the evidence presented to determine Mr Johnson's awareness and responsibility in the matter. It considered whether he took all reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the Act and whether his actions or omissions amounted to a breach of his executive duties. The court concluded that Mr Johnson, as the sole director, had a duty to oversee the company's compliance with the planning laws. Given the clear evidence of separate leases, payment of rent, and separate inspections, the court found that Mr Johnson should have reasonably known that the property was being managed as two separate households, which violated the development approval condition. The court held that his failure to prevent this constituted a breach of his executive liability obligations.

The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions were upheld. The court found that Mr Johnson did not take all reasonable steps to ensure the company complied with the Planning Act, and he was thus liable for the breaches. The company's conviction for breaching the development approval was also upheld, as the evidence supported the finding that the property was managed as two separate households, contrary to the approval conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal Dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

On 15 October 2020 the appellants were convicted of offences against the Planning Act 2016. The company was convicted of an offence of breaching a condition of a development approval[1] and an offence of non – compliance with an enforcement notice in respect of that breach.[2] Mr Johnson was charged as an executive officer of the company with failure to take all reasonable steps to ensure the company complied with its obligations under the Act.[3] The company has appealed against the conviction for breaching the development approval and Mr Johnson has appealed both convictions.[1] S164 of the Planning Act 2016[2] S 168(5) of the Planning Act 2016[3] S227(1) of the Planning Act 2016Background On 3 July 2015 Deleje Pty Ltd was given a development approval pursuant to s 335 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (‘the Act’). It was a preliminary approval under s 241 of the Act for a new dwelling house at 45 Bernard St Paddington under the traditional building character overlay. The nature of the application was a development permit, and the activity was for a dwelling house. Approval conditions were attached to that notice. Condition 1 was that the building/premises was to be used for the purpose of a house:(a)the lot is only to be used for one house (including secondary dwelling as defined by Brisbane City Plan 2014);(b)the main dwelling together with any secondary dwelling is used by a household group comprising:(i)one person maintaining a household, or(ii)two or more persons related by blood, marriage or adoption, or(iii)not more than five persons, not necessarily related by blood, marriage or adoption, or(iv)not more than five persons under the age of 18 and not necessarily related by blood, marriage or adoption, together with one or two adults who have care and control of them.(c)the house is to be used strictly in accordance with the dwelling house code (Brisbane City Plan 2014) and is to be strictly in accordance with the approved plans;(d)all future owners or future prospective owners or purchasers of the property are advised of this requirement. The original plans attached to the development approval indicated that this was a two‑storey home with a kitchen and living/dining area, an office and three bedrooms, including a master bedroom on the top floor and on the ground floor a rumpus area, a cellar, a children’s study, two more bedrooms and a guest wing. The property was managed by Belle Properties. Ted Walton, the property manager for the house gave evidence in the trial that the property was managed as one property. Nonetheless, there were two separate leases on the property, the properties were in the computer system as 2/45 Bernard Street and 1/45 Bernard Street, the rent was being paid separately and inspections were done on both the top level and the bottom level of that property with separate reports generated. The Magistrate rejected his evidence that this was not indicative of it being two separate households, and given the other evidence in the trial that finding was entirely reasonable.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.