Delahunty and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Delahunty and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2020] AATA 4857 (3 December 2020)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/6748

Re:Carmel Delahunty

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

Date:3 December 2020

Place:Sydney

The kinds of death suffered by the veteran were sepsis, pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, fibrosing interstitial lung disease and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The concession made by the Repatriation Commission is that the factor at clause 6(b) of the Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease No. 53 of 2013 is met.  

................................[sgd]......................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – claim for war widow’s pension – kind of death suffered by the veteran – whether the death was service related or war caused – preliminary decision 

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) ss 120, 120B

CASES

Collins and Repatriation Commission [2009] FCAFC 90

Roscoe v Repatriation Commission [2003] FCA 1568

Suckling v Repatriation Commission (No. 1) [2004] FMCA 193

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease No. 53 of 2013

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

3 December 2020

The application

  1. Mrs Delahunty claimed a war widow’s pension following the death of her husband, Mr Graham Delahunty (the veteran). The Veterans’ Review Board (VRB) affirmed a decision of the Repatriation Commission (the Commission) that the death of the veteran was not related to service and therefore a war widow’s pension is not payable to Mrs Delahunty under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act). Mrs Delahunty has applied to the Tribunal to review the Commission’s decision (the reviewable decision).

  2. Two issues have to be decided:

    (a)The kind of death suffered by the veteran; and

    (b)Whether the veteran’s death was war-caused.

  3. During the hearing, the parties agreed to have determined as a preliminary question the kind of death the veteran suffered.

  4. The Commission conceded that if a kind of death suffered by the veteran is found to be fibrosing interstitial lung disease (FILD), the factor at clause 6(b) of the Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease No. 53 of 2013 (FILD SOP) is met based on all the available evidence.[1]

    [1] Letter dated 7 August 2020 from Moray & Agnew Lawyers to the AAT.

    Background

  5. The veteran was born on 12 January 1931 and died on 5 January 2015 aged 83.  He served in the Royal Australian Navy from 20 September 1951 to 19 September 1957.  His service in Korea on board HMAS Tobruk from 3 June 1953 to 12 February 1954 is recognised as operational service and is therefore eligible war service for the purposes of the Act.

  6. On 30 June 2015, Mrs Delahunty claimed for a war widow’s pension. On 25 August 2015, a delegate of the Commission decided that the veteran’s death was not war-caused.  Mrs Delahunty applied to the VRB for a review of that decision on 11 November 2015.  On 10 October 2017, the VRB affirmed the decision of the delegate of the Commission.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Delahunty and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlement... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4857
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mrs Delahunty to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) against a decision by the Repatriation Commission that her late husband's death was not war-caused, and therefore she was not entitled to a war widow's pension. The veteran, who had served in the Royal Australian Navy, died in 2015. His death certificate listed sepsis, hospital-acquired pneumonia, and advanced non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) as causes of death. Mrs Delahunty claimed that fibrosing interstitial lung disease (FILD) was also a cause of death, or materially contributed to the terminal event of pneumonia.

The Tribunal was required to determine the "kind of death" suffered by the veteran, applying the standard of reasonable satisfaction on the balance of probabilities. This involved ascertaining the medical cause or causes of death, without drawing a legal distinction between primary and secondary causes. The central legal issue was whether FILD, in addition to NHL, sepsis, and pneumonia, constituted a kind of death for the purposes of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth).

The Tribunal considered the medico-legal evidence, including the opinions of various medical specialists. It noted that the Commission conceded that if FILD was found to be a kind of death, then a specific factor in the relevant Statement of Principles would be met. After reviewing the evidence, the Tribunal concluded that the veteran suffered from multiple kinds of death, including sepsis, pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), FILD, and NHL. The Tribunal found that the evidence of all doctors, regardless of their specialty, supported these findings.

The Tribunal determined that the kinds of death suffered by the veteran were sepsis, pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, fibrosing interstitial lung disease, and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The Repatriation Commission conceded that the factor at clause 6(b) of the Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease was met. The Tribunal indicated that a directions hearing would be listed to address the future progress of the matter, unless agreement was reached between the parties in the interim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commission conceded that if a kind of death suffered by the veteran is found to be fibrosing interstitial lung disease (FILD), the factor at clause 6(b) of the Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease No. 53 of 2013 (FILD SOP) is met based on all the available evidence.[1][1] Letter dated 7 August 2020 from Moray & Agnew Lawyers to the AAT.Background The veteran was born on 12 January 1931 and died on 5 January 2015 aged 83. He served in the Royal Australian Navy from 20 September 1951 to 19 September 1957. His service in Korea on board HMAS Tobruk from 3 June 1953 to 12 February 1954 is recognised as operational service and is therefore eligible war service for the purposes of the Act. On 30 June 2015, Mrs Delahunty claimed for a war widow’s pension. On 25 August 2015, a delegate of the Commission decided that the veteran’s death was not war-caused. Mrs Delahunty applied to the VRB for a review of that decision on 11 November 2015. On 10 October 2017, the VRB affirmed the decision of the delegate of the Commission. On 10 November 2017 Mrs Delahunty applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision. The veteran’s death certificate dated 5 January 2015 sets out the cause of death as: (1) (a) Sepsis, 3 days;(b) Hospital acquired pneumonia, 3 days;(c) Advanced non-hodgkins lymphoma, years; and(2)Advanced non-hodgkins lymphoma, years. Non-hodgkins lymphoma will hereafter be referred to as NHL.The law The standard of proof for determining the “kind of death” is that specified in ss 120(4) and 120B of the Act: reasonable satisfaction/balance of probabilities.[2] [2] Suckling v Repatriation Commission (No. 1) [2004] FMCA 193; Roscoe v Repatriation Commission [2003] FCA 1568. In Collins and Repatriation Commission [2009] FCAFC 90, after considering relevant provisions, the Full Court of the Federal Court said at [82]:Those provisions support the conclusion that the inquiry about the death or the kind of death for the purposes of the VE Act is, in essence, a question of fact about the medical cause or causes of the death. It does not support the proposition on behalf of Mrs Collins that there is a legislative intention that any medical condition which hastens the time of death of a veteran by a measurable period, even a short one, where in medical terms another medical condition is clearly the medical condition which accounts for the pathological changes leading to death, is itself a medical cause of the death. At [88] the Court then said:… We do not consider that the VE Act draws any legal distinction between the ultimate or primary and secondary medical causes of death of a veteran. It requires that the medical cause or causes of death be ascertained…The parties’ contentions Mr Saunders, counsel for Mrs Delahunty, contended that both NHL and FILD were a cause or kind of death suffered by the veteran. The Statement of Facts and Contentions filed by Mrs Delahunty’s solicitors stated that NHL was certified to be a cause of the veteran’s death and FILD caused or materially contributed to the terminal event, pneumonia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, the Commission contended that the kind of death was from NHL. During submissions, Mr O’Brien for the Commission contended that the kind of death was sepsis and hospital acquired pneumonia for three days. He accepted that NHL featured prominently and that there can be more than one kind of death. The evidence The medico-legal evidence addressed the kind of death but focused on linking aspects of the veteran’s service including smoking and exposure to asbestos and benzene, with the medical conditions he suffered of NHL and FILD. Summary of the veteran’s medical history The veteran had a very complex and lengthy medical history. Following is a summary of the history relevant to the consideration of the kind or kinds of death. The veteran was diagnosed with B-cell NHL in February 2007. He was under the care of haematologist Professor Peter Presgrave. Following is his summary of the veteran’s NHL set out in his letter to Mrs Delahunty’s representative dated 2 March 2016:He had originally been diagnosed with diffuse large B cell non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma in 2007. This was treated with intravenous chemotherapy. In 2011 he had a relapse with follicular histology, a more indolent form of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. In early 2013 he developed recurrent fevers complicated by pulmonary oedema. A CT scan performed at the time showed widespread lymphadenopathy. The fevers were felt to be related to recurrent aggressive non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma and he had a dramatic response to oral corticosteroids. His lymphadenopathy resolved and he had no recurrence of his fevers. The expectation was that Graham wold develop a recurrence of his aggressive lymphoma and would die shortly thereafter. However, over a nearly two year period there was no evidence of recurrent lymphoma and his high dose corticosteroids were weaned without obvious recurrence. On 27 December 2012 Dr Simon Marlton, general practitioner (GP), referred the veteran for “non urgent assessment for palliative care”. GP Management plans/Team Care arrangements dated 2 October 2013 and 28 February 2014 state that in relation to NHL and prostate cancer, the veteran was under the care of Dr Marlton and Professor Presgrave and palliative care. On 13 September 2013 Dr Marlton requested “urgent approval” from the Department of Veterans’ Affairs for referral to Bryony Clark, occupational therapist, for “Allied Health” service for the condition “impaired mobility secondary to malignancy”. In a referral to Dr Salmon/Dr Tran dated 21 February 2014 in relation to three suspicious lesions, Dr Marlton wrote:These have been neglected Graham has recurrent Non Hodgkin’s lymphoma and his outlook had looked poor. Dr Marlton’s medical records state that the veteran had a past history of COAD (Chronic Obstructive Airways Disease) on 5 April 2006 and on 30 January 2009. For example, a 2008 GP Management Plan and Team Care Arrangements 2008 does not mention COAD but Dr Marlton’s letter to Dr Timothy Skyring dated 27 May 2009 includes both dates.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Professor Fox was incorrect when he stated that the death certificate stated pulmonary infection on a background of interstitial fibrosis on a background of diffuse large cell lymphoma. Consideration Mr O’Brien submitted that Professor Presgrave, Associate Professor Flecknoe-Brown and Professor Fox are not respiratory physicians and, I infer, therefore their opinions about COPD and FILD should be given little weight. He emphasised COPD as the significant lung condition rather than FILD. I do not agree that such a finding can be made on the medical evidence, summarised above. The evidence of all the doctors, regardless of their speciality, supports findings that the kinds of death suffered by the veteran were:·Sepsis·Pneumonia·COPD·FILD and·NHL. If consideration is confined to the opinions of the respiratory physicians, Dr Johnson and Associate Professor McKenzie, the conclusion is the same.THE KIND OF DEATH The kinds of death suffered by the veteran were sepsis, pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, fibrosing interstitial lung disease and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The concession made by the Repatriation Commission is that the factor at clause 6(b) of the Statement of Principles concerning fibrosing interstitial lung disease No. 53 of 2013 is met. The concession made by the Repatriation Commission did not include the terms of the decision that should be made. While that may have been implicit, I think it is appropriate to list this matter as soon as possible for a telephone directions hearing at a time convenient to the parties to address the future progress of the matter. If agreement is reached in the meantime, the appropriate document can be filed.