Decor Ceilings Pty Ltd v Cox Constructions Pty Ltd 545/04; Cox Constructions Pty Ltd v Decor Ceilings Pty Ltd 566/04

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

DECOR CEILINGS PTY LTD v COX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD 545/04; COX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD v DECOR CEILINGS PTY LTD 566/04

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

18 August 2004

ARBITRATION - THE AWARD - APPEAL OR JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND LEAVE TO APPEAL

Subcontractor, Decor Ceilings Pty Ltd, and contractor in dispute - dispute subject of arbitration - appeal against award of arbitrator - subcontractor claims breach of contract by contractor resulting in delay - appeal sought on grounds that delay claim should have been allowed in full and that contractor's "back charge" claim should have been disallowed - appeal against award of arbitrator - leave to appeal sought under s38 Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA) - whether parties' rights substantially affected under s38(5)(a) - whether manifest error of law, or question likely to add to certainty of commercial law under s38(5)(b) - held: arbitrator misdirected himself as to legal tests regarding burden and standard of proof with respect to evidence led by the subcontractor therefore manifest error of law satisfying s38 - appeal allowed.

Contractor, Cox Constructions Pty Ltd, seeking leave to appeal against award of arbitrator - leave sought under s38 Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA) - appeal sought on grounds of insufficient notices; question of documentation comprising subcontract and dispute over damages claim - interpretation of contractual provisions - whether parties' rights substantially affected under s38(5)(a) - whether manifest error of law, or question likely to add to certainty of commercial law under s38(5)(b) - held: no manifest error of law - appeal dismissed.

Whether reasons required to be given to parties in leave to appeal matter under s38 Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA) - held: provision of adequate reasons to parties required as first engagement of judicial power.

Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA) s38(5)(a) and (b); Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s459E, referred to.
Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v South Australian Superannuation Fund Investment Trust (1994) 63 SASR 444; Promenade Investments Pty Ltd v State of New South Wales (1991) 26 NSWLR 184; Promenade Investments Pty Ltd v State of New South Wales (1992) 26 NSWLR 203; Natoli v Walker  (unreported, 26 May 1994, 40351 of 1993); Eltin Open Pit Operations Pty Ltd v Far North Civil Pty Ltd and Anor (2001) 215 LSJS 330; Roy Morgan Research Centre Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (2001) 207 CLR 72, applied.
Pioneer Concrete (SA) Pty Ltd v The Jennings Group Ltd (1991) 161 LSJS 332, distinguished.
Pioneer Shipping Limited v BTP Tioxide (The Nema) [1982] AC 724, discussed.
Qantas Airways Limited v Joseland and Gilling (1986) 6 NSWLR 327, considered.

DECOR CEILINGS PTY LTD v COX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD 545/04; COX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD v DECOR CEILINGS PTY LTD 566/04
[2004] SASC 243

ANDERSON J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. In this matter both parties are seeking leave to appeal from an interim award made by an arbitrator pursuant to the provisions of the Commercial Arbitration Act 1986…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Decor Ceilings Pty Ltd v Cox Constructions Pty Ltd 545/04; C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 243
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Decor Ceilings Pty Ltd (Décor) and Cox Constructions Pty Ltd (Cox) were parties to a dispute arising from a subcontract for the construction of a training and development centre at Hindmarsh. The dispute was referred to arbitration under the Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA), resulting in an interim award in favour of Décor for $102,883 plus interest. Both Décor and Cox sought leave to appeal the arbitrator's decision, raising various legal issues regarding the interpretation and application of the arbitration award.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the arbitrator had made a manifest error of law, whether the appeal would substantially affect the parties' rights, and whether the appeal could add to the certainty of commercial law. For Décor, the primary issue was whether the arbitrator misapplied the burden and standard of proof in relation to their evidence of delays and additional costs. For Cox, the issues included the sufficiency of notices provided, the interpretation of contractual documents, and the validity of a damages claim. The court had to determine whether the appeals met the criteria set out in section 38(5) of the Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA).

The court found that the appeal by Décor was valid as the arbitrator had indeed misdirected himself regarding the legal tests for burden and standard of proof, constituting a manifest error of law under section 38(5)(b). Consequently, the appeal was allowed. On the other hand, the court held that Cox's appeal did not meet the criteria for leave to appeal as there was no manifest error of law, and the appeal did not add substantially to the certainty of commercial law. Therefore, Cox's appeal was dismissed.

The court granted leave to Décor to appeal the arbitrator's award due to a manifest error of law and denied leave to Cox for their appeal, which did not satisfy the statutory criteria.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In this matter both parties are seeking leave to appeal from an interim award made by an arbitrator pursuant to the provisions of the Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (SA). The interim award was made on 12 May 2004.BACKGROUND Cox Constructions Pty Ltd (Cox) was the head contractor involved in a contract with the Minister for Government Enterprises which contract involved the construction of a training and development centre at Hindmarsh. The contract between Cox and the Minister was entered into on 18 December 1998. In turn a Subcontract between Cox and Décor Ceilings Pty Ltd (Décor) was entered into on 31 March 1999. This Subcontract related to Décor’s provision of ceilings, partitions and wall linings for the project. Disputes arose between Décor and Cox as a result of which the matter was arbitrated. Finally the arbitrator awarded Décor the sum of $102,883 together with interest to apply at the Supreme Court rate and the arbitrator adjourned the question of costs. There were various disputes which arose during the course of construction, mainly relating to delays, the precise details of which are, for present purposes, not important. The delays ultimately have caused Décor to allege against Cox a breach of their duty of care in addition to breaches of contractual obligations. As a result Décor calculated and presented a claim, one part of which was for some $202,803.90 by way of compensation for the loss and damage which they allege they suffered by reason of the additional hours required on the project and attributable to Cox’s default. The arbitrator rejected totally the claim for additional hours. Décor also claimed that the arbitrator wrongly allowed a credit to Cox for a “back charge” in the sum of $9,360. Cox on the other hand seeks leave to appeal on grounds relating to insufficient notices, a question as to what documents comprised the Subcontract and a dispute over a damages claim for a limited period relating to a certain works programme in which it is suggested there was a failure by Décor to adhere to the programme. As I have indicated, both Décor and Cox are seeking leave to appeal and I will deal with those applications shortly.PRINCIPLES ON LEAVE APPLICATION The question of leave to appeal is covered by s.38 of the Commercial Arbitration Act as amended in 1992. The section and its history and the effect of the 1992 amendment is with respect fully set out in the decision of Debelle J in Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v South Australian Superannuation Fund Investment Trust (1994) 63 SASR 444. The principles that emerge from that decision are that the court should only grant leave if either party establishes that there is either a manifest error of law on the face of the award or strong evidence that the arbitrator made an error of law and that the determination of the question may add or may be likely to add substantially to the certainty of commercial law – s.38(5)(b)(i) and (ii). Before getting to the stage of considering either of the above alternatives, the court must be satisfied that having regard to all the circumstances, the determination of the question of law concerned could substantially affect the rights of one or more parties to the arbitration agreement – s.38(5)(a).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established