Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 9)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 9) [2010] FCA 1007

Citation: Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 9) [2010] FCA 1007
Parties: DECKERS OUTDOOR CORPORATION INC. v LEAH JANE FARLEY, DUSIA PTY LTD ACN 119 500 186, LEONID MYKHALOVSKYI, HEPBOURNE PTY LTD ACN 080 453 247, VLADIMIR VAYSMAN, JOSEF VAYSMAN, POLINA VAYSMAN, MILLHOUSE PTY LTD ACN 111 765 505, DIANNE SOMMER, SANDY HAZENDONK, HGU PTY LTD ACN 121 922 754, FEDIA PTY LTD ACN 119 500 444, TASKINC PTY LTD ACN 121 919 926, OTK INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 119 498 001, GIHAN EZZAT, JOANNE STRICKLAND, VERNON CO PTY LTD ACN 123 047 138, RASTOV PTY LTD ACN 119 498 547, VICTORIA VAYSMAN, OLIVER DOEDERLEIN, MARGARIT PEDROTTI, SAMBA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 111 968 935 and SANAURIA PTY LTD ACN 123 047 110
File number: VID 1022 of 2007
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 15 September 2010
Catchwords: CONTEMPT - Court’s power to punish contempt -  whether disobedience of court order constitutes contempt of court - whether criminal standard of proof applies to contemnors in breach of court order - service of orders alleged contemnors – rationale of contempt to enforce court’s decisions - standard of proof
Cases cited:

Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 6) [2010] FCA 391, referred to
Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 7) [2010] FCA 560, referred to
Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 8) [2010] FCA 657, referred to
R v Bazley (1993) 65 A Crim R 154, cited, applied
R v Cumberbatch (2004) 8 VR 9, referred to
R v Lowe (1984) 154 CLR 606, cited, applied
R v RLP [2009] VSCA 271, cited, applied
R v Van Boxtel (2005) 11 VR 258, referred to

Date of hearing: 7 & 18 June and 23 August 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 49
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr E J C Heerey
Solicitor for the Applicant: Middletons
Counsel for the Sixth Respondent: Mr R F Edney
Solicitor for the Sixth Respondent: Matthew White & Associates

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 1022 of 2007

BETWEEN:

DECKERS OUTDOOR CORPORATION INC.
Applicant/Cross-Respondent

AND:

LEAH JANE FARLEY
First Respondent

DUSIA PTY LTD ACN 119 500 186
Second Respondent

LEONID MYKHALOVSKYI
Third Respondent

HEPBOURNE PTY LTD ACN 080 453 247
Fourth Respondent/Second Cross-Claimant

VLADIMIR VAYSMAN
Fifth Respondent/First Cross-Claimant

JOSEF VAYSMAN
Sixth Respondent/Third Cross-Claimant

POLINA VAYSMAN
Seventh Respondent/Fourth Cross-Claimant

MILLHOUSE PTY LTD ACN 111 765 505
Eighth Respondent

DIANNE SOMMER
Ninth Respondent

SANDY HAZENDONK
Tenth Respondent

HGU PTY LTD ACN 121 922 754
Eleventh Respondent

FEDIA PTY LTD ACN 119 500 444
Twelfth Respondent

TASKINC PTY LTD ACN 121 919 926
Thirteenth Respondent

OTK INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 119 498 001
Fourteenth Respondent

GIHAN EZZAT
Fifteenth Respondent

JOANNE STRICKLAND
Sixteenth Respondent

VERNON CO PTY LTD ACN 123 047 138
Seventeenth Respondent

RASTOV PTY LTD ACN 119 498 547
Eighteenth Respondent

VICTORIA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 9) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1007
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc. v Farley (No 9) involved the sentencing of Mr Vladimir Vaysman, who had been found guilty of multiple charges related to the manufacture and distribution of counterfeit footwear. The case reached the court with significant medical and personal circumstances presented on behalf of Mr Vaysman, who claimed to have severe health issues and difficulties assimilating in Australia due to his limited English proficiency. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate sentence while considering these mitigating factors alongside the severity of Mr Vaysman's criminal activities.

The primary legal issues before the court were the appropriate sentencing for Mr Vaysman given his health conditions, his lack of remorse, and his repeated disregard for court orders. The court needed to balance these mitigating factors against the seriousness of Mr Vaysman's offences, which included multiple instances of breaching court orders and engaging in the manufacture of counterfeit goods. The court also had to consider the need for general and specific deterrence in imposing a sentence.

The court found that despite Mr Vaysman's health issues, these did not sufficiently mitigate the severity of his criminal conduct. It noted his repeated failure to comply with court orders and his belated and questionable expressions of remorse. The court emphasised the importance of both personal and general deterrence, given the seriousness of the offences. Ultimately, the court imposed a sentence of imprisonment, with the most severe sentence being 18 months for the most serious offence, and other sentences to be served concurrently.

In summary, the court determined that Mr Vaysman's health issues and personal circumstances did not excuse his repeated breaches of court orders and his involvement in significant criminal activities. The court imposed a sentence of imprisonment that reflected the seriousness of the offences and the need for deterrence.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr. Vladimir Vaysman, who was found guilty of various charges related to the manufacture and distribution of counterfeit footwear. Mr. Vaysman, aged 74, has significant health issues, including atrial fibrillation, prostatomegaly, gastritis/duodenitis, impaired hearing and smell, tinnitus, reactive anxiety/depression, and other incidental health problems. Despite his health conditions, Mr. Vaysman continued to manufacture counterfeit products at two different premises, disregarding court orders. He has not made full admissions and his apology is considered insincere due to his exculpatory accounts of his conduct. Mr. Vaysman has consistently ignored court orders since November 2007, showing a dismissive attitude towards compliance.

The procedural history of this case involves multiple hearings, including plea hearings and penalty hearings. At the plea hearing, medical reports from various specialists were tendered to support Mr. Vaysman's health conditions and their impact on his ability to comply with court orders. Mr. Vaysman affirmed an affidavit expressing his remorse and regret for his conduct, as well as his intention not to repeat his actions. The court considered these factors, along with the severity of the charges and the need for deterrence, in determining the appropriate penalties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Shortly before the originally scheduled penalty hearing Mr Vaysman affirmed an affidavit in which he deposed that he was 74 years old, suffered from significant health and physical problems and spoke little English. He also said that he could not read “any English”. Despite this his affidavit was affirmed without translation. He added that, since he came to Australia, he found it very difficult to assimilate and to learn the language and culture. He said that a custodial sentence would be detrimental to his physical and emotional health. For the first time he expressed himself to be deeply remorseful and regretful for his conduct and apologised “to everyone that I have hurt.” He deposed that he would “never repeat this conduct again.”MEDICAL EVIDENCE At the plea hearing counsel for Mr Vaysman tendered and relied on a series of medical reports. They were reports from:·Dr Gregory Belkin dated 10 August 2010 and 20 August 2010.·Dr Patrick O’Brien dated 15 June 2009 and 24 August 2009.·Mr Phillip Dingjan dated 31 July 2009.·Dr Boris Goloub dated 13 April 2009, 17 February 2010 and 3 June 2010.·Mr Jeffrey Cummins dated 16 August 2010. Dr Belkin is Mr Vaysman’s general practitioner. Dr Belkin has been treating Mr Vaysman since 1998. Dr Belkin recorded that Mr Vaysman’s “main problems” over the period which he had been treating him were atrial fibrillation (heart rhythm disorder); prostatomegaly (benign, age related enlargement of the prostate gland); gastritis/duodenitis; impaired feeling of smell, impaired hearing which had worsened after a motor car accident in 2008; tinnitus; reactive anxiety/depression; and incidental acute respiratory, macular and skin problems. Dr Belkin advised that, apart from the tinnitus condition, Mr Vaysman’s conditions had all improved under treatment. Mr Vaysman had been referred to a consultant psychiatrist, Dr O’Brien, and a psychologist, Dr Goloub. He had accepted these referrals but had declined a further referral to a hearing specialist whom Dr Belkin hoped might be able to treat Mr Vaysman’s tinnitus. Dr Belkin had referred Mr Vaysman to the Alfred Hospital with a view to him having an operation on his enlarged prostate. Counsel for Mr Vaysman advised the Court that Mr Vaysman had attended an appointment at the hospital in July. A specialist had told him of the risk of such an operation having regard to his heart condition and age. Mr Vaysman had decided to delay making a decision. He now says that he has decided that he wishes to undergo surgery and proposed to tell the specialist so when he next attends at the outpatients’ clinic at the hospital on 14 September 2010. A notice from the hospital confirming an appointment for Mr Vaysman at the Urology Clinic on 14 September 2010 was tendered. No indication was given of how long it would be before the operation could be scheduled. Dr O’Brien was principally concerned with complaints by Mr Vaysman about having a poor memory. Dr O’Brien referred Mr Vaysman to Mr Dingjan, a neuropsychologist, for further testing and diagnosis. Mr Dingjan reported that the testing did not disclose any evidence of a neurodegenerative disease. There was, however, evidence of stress and some variability of cognitive performance when Mr Vaysman was anxious. Dr O’Brien suggested that supportive measures to assist Mr Vaysman deal with his distractibility and stress, his sleep disturbance and tinnitus would be likely to improve his condition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. How should the court consider Mr. Vaysman's health conditions and their impact on his ability to comply with court orders in determining an appropriate penalty?
2. To what extent should the sincerity of Mr. Vaysman's apology and his exculpatory accounts of his conduct be factored into the sentencing decision?
3. What weight should be given to Mr. Vaysman's consistent history of ignoring court orders and his dismissive attitude towards compliance in determining the appropriate penalties?

Held
1. The court decided that Mr. Vaysman's health conditions and their impact on his ability to comply with court orders should be taken into account, but these were not deemed sufficient to outweigh the need for a penalty of imprisonment.
2. The court concluded that while Mr. Vaysman's late apology and exculpatory accounts of his conduct were considered, they did not significantly mitigate the need for punishment due to their questionable sincerity and timing.
3. The court held that Mr. Vaysman's history of ignoring court orders and his dismissive attitude towards compliance warranted a strong penalty, reflecting the importance of deterrence and the seriousness of his offences.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are further matters which distinguish Mr Vaysman’s offending from that of his daughter. Victoria made full admissions. Mr Vaysman has not done so. Victoria also apologised to those who had suffered because of her misconduct. Mr Vaysman made a belated apology in an affidavit which was filed shortly before the originally scheduled date of the plea hearing. The sincerity of this apology is open to doubt given the exculpatory accounts of his conduct which he has recently provided to Dr Goloub and Mr Cummins. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS I am far from satisfied that Mr Vaysman acknowledges and accepts that he has contravened orders made by the Court. In 2009 he told Dr Goloub that he had breached some Court orders because he did not understand those orders and the requirements they imposed upon him. In June 2010, however, he denied to Dr Goloub that he had ever done anything wrong and sought to lay all the blame on his son. He portrayed himself as “an innocent victim”. As recently as 4 August 2010 Mr Vaysman told Mr Cummins that he hadn’t been told that he could not enter the Christensen Street factory. He so advised Mr Cummins notwithstanding the fact that he had been ordered, on 21 January 2009, not to approach within 100 metres of the premises and that that order had been translated to him in the Russian language. He had also admitted, on affidavit, that, when he attended at the premises on 5 March 2009, he knew that he was acting in breach of the order: see Deckers (No 7) at [4] and [31]. Mr Vaysman has, since November 2007, consistently chosen to ignore orders made by the Court. In November and December 2007 he blatantly continued manufacturing counterfeit footwear at the Roper Street factory until his activities were discovered and he was no longer able to work at that factory. He then contrived to resume manufacturing at the Christensen Street premises and was able to do so for a year before he was again discovered producing fake Ugg products. While I accept that Vladimir Vaysman oversaw the operations at Roper Street and Christensen Street and was the main offender, Mr Vaysman played a central role in the illicit business by applying his skills to the manufacture of counterfeit products. Mr Vaysman’s failures to comply with orders relating to the disclosure of the financial position of himself and companies of which he was a director are of less seriousness but nonetheless reflect his dismissive attitude to compliance with Court orders. As was the case with Vladimir Vaysman, the need for both personal and general deterrence rank highly as considerations in the sentencing of Mr Vaysman. His conduct warrants nothing less than a sentence of imprisonment. So much has been acknowledged by counsel appearing for him.PENALTIES The charges of which Mr Vaysman has been found guilty vary in severity and these variations need to be reflected in the length of the sentences which are to be imposed. I regard the most serious offence to be that covered by Charge 4 of the 2009 charges. It warrants a sentence of imprisonment of 18 months. On the other charges I would impose the following penalties with each sentence to be served concurrently with each other sentence, including that imposed in relation to Charge 4:·Charge 36 – two months’ imprisonment.·Charge 37 – nine months’ imprisonment.·Charge 52 – one month’s imprisonment.·Charge 55 – one month’s imprisonment.·Charge 57 – one month’s imprisonment.·Charge 61 – one month’s imprisonment.·Charge 67 – one month’s imprisonment.·Charge 5 – six months’ imprisonment.·Charge 12 – three months’ imprisonment.