Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Deano v Health Care Complaints Commission [2011] NSWSC 1570 Hearing dates: 12 December 2011 Decision date: 16 December 2011 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Schmidt J Decision: Motion is dismissed.
The usual order as to costs is that they should follow the event, with the result that Ms Deano must bear the costs of the motion as agreed or assessed. The parties have liberty to approach if they wish to be heard on costs.
Catchwords: APPEAL - notice of motion - order seeking a stay until the determination of the appeal and alternatively, a stay and restoration of conditions on specified conditions, until determination of the appeal - whether the Court has power to order the stay sought - stay refused - discretionary considerations Legislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW)
Medical Practitioners Act 1938
Supreme Court Act 1970Cases Cited: AVS Group Of Companies Pty Ltd v Commissioner Of Police [2010] NSWCA 81
McBride v Walton (New South Wales Court of Appeal, Handley JA, 27 August 1993, unreported)
New South Wales Bar Association v Stevens [2003] NSWCA 95
Wilde v Australian Trade Equipment Co Pty Ltd [1981] HCA 13; (1981) 145 CLR 590Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Nusrat Deano (Appellant)
Health Care Complaints Commission (First Respondent)
Nurses and Midwives Tribunal of NSW (Second Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Mr M Licha (Appellant)
Ms R Graycar (First Respondent)
Solicitors:
Morgan Ardino & Co (Appellant)
File Number(s): 2011/360084 Publication restriction: None
Judgment
The appellant, Ms Nusret Deano, brought an appeal from a decision of the Nurses and Midwifes Tribunal of NSW under s 162 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW) , by way of a summons filed on 10 November 2011. The orders there sought included an order for a stay of the Tribunal's decision. By a motion filed on 9 December 2011, Ms Deano sought a number of orders. Two were pressed at the hearing: an order staying the Tribunal's 14 October 2011 order cancelling Ms Deano's registration as a nurse until the determination of the appeal; and alternatively, a stay and restoration of her registration on specified conditions, until determination of the appeal.
On 14 October 2011, the Tribunal made two orders, one cancelling Ms Deano's registration and the other, that she not apply for a review of that order, for a period of two years.
The orders Ms Deano sought were opposed and the Court's power to make them was challenged by the first respondent, the Health Care Complaints Commission.
The Court's power
Section 162(1) of the Act gives Ms Deano a right to appeal the Tribunal's decision on a point of law. Such an appeal must be made within 28 days of the Tribunal's decision (s 162(3)). The Court has power to 'stay any order made by the Tribunal, on the terms the Court sees fit, until the time the Court decides the appeal' (s 162(4)).
The Tribunal gave reasons for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Deano v Health Care Complaints Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWSC 1570
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether it had the power to order a stay of the Commission's decision. It examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law to determine its discretion in such matters. The court concluded that while it had the power to grant a stay in appropriate circumstances, it was not obligated to do so. The court then evaluated the discretionary considerations, including the likelihood of success on the appeal, the potential prejudice to the parties if a stay was not granted, and the public interest. Ultimately, the court found that the balance of convenience favoured the Commission, and that the proposed conditions for a stay were not acceptable.
The court refused the stay and dismissed the appeal. It held that the Commission's decision to suspend Deano's registration was lawful and that the discretionary factors did not favour granting a stay. The court did not provide any further orders beyond its refusal of the stay.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant had been involved in several complaints regarding his conduct as a medical practitioner, which were investigated by the Commission. The Commission concluded that the appellant's conduct warranted disciplinary action and recommended his suspension. The appellant's appeal against the suspension was based on various grounds, including the contention that the decision-making process was flawed.
The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an application for a stay of registration pending the outcome of the appellant's appeal. The application was made under the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW). The appellant had already appealed the suspension decision to a division of the Supreme Court, and this stay application was made during the pendency of that appeal. The application was heard by a different division of the Supreme Court, which had to determine whether it had the power to grant the stay and, if so, whether it should exercise that discretion in the circumstances of this case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court has the power to order a stay of registration until the determination of the appeal.
2. Whether the Court should exercise its discretion to grant a stay of registration and, if so, on what conditions.
Held
1. The Court concluded that it has the power to order a stay of registration until the determination of the appeal.
2. The Court decided not to exercise its discretion to grant a stay of registration, and therefore the application was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the issue of whether it has the power to order a stay of registration until the determination of the appeal. It was established that the Court indeed has the power to make such an order under the relevant statutory provisions. The Court then proceeded to examine whether it should exercise its discretion to grant the stay.
In evaluating the discretionary considerations, the Court considered the likelihood of the applicant succeeding on the appeal, the potential prejudice to the applicant if the stay was not granted, and the interests of third parties who might be affected by the stay. The Court found that the applicant had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of success on the appeal, nor had they shown that the potential prejudice to them if the stay was not granted outweighed the interests of third parties. The Court also noted that there were no exceptional circumstances that would warrant the granting of a stay.
The Court's reasoning was grounded in the principles that guide the exercise of discretion in such matters, particularly the need to balance the interests of the parties and the importance of finality in legal proceedings. In this case, the Court concluded that the interests of finality and the lack of exceptional circumstances outweighed the discretionary factors in favour of a stay. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while the Court has the power to order a stay of registration, it will not exercise that discretion lightly, especially where there is no strong likelihood of success on the appeal and significant prejudice to third parties. The Court's decision aligns with established principles and authorities regarding the exercise of discretion in interlocutory matters.