Deane and City Of Mandurah

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   DEANE and CITY OF MANDURAH [2014] WASAT 165

MEMBER:   MR J JORDAN (MEMBER)

DR A HINWOOD (SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   16 SEPTEMBER 2014

DELIVERED          :   8 DECEMBER 2014

FILE NO/S:   DR 226 of 2013

BETWEEN:   GRAEME JAMES DEANE

LILLIAN DEANE
Applicants

AND

CITY OF MANDURAH
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Development application ­ Preliminary issue ­ Whether plan identified as Annexure A was a plan tendered by or on behalf of applicants ­ Whether approval of respondent to the plan in that form renders application for review nugatory ­ Planning consultant acting as agent for applicants ­ Orders issued for s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) reconsideration ­ Whether principal bound by action of planning consultant as agent throughout the process ­ Annexure A plan prepared by applicants' planning consultant ­ Silence of planning consultant and applicants on acceptance of plan after plan sent to respondent ­ Custom and practice of agents in town planning review matters ­ Implied authority of agent ­ Carve out of agent's authority ­ Whether respondent was alive to questions about scope of agent's authority ­ Was express ratification of Annexure A plan by applicants necessary ­ Whether endorsements on Annexure A plan agreed by applicants

Legislation:

City of Mandurah Town Planning Scheme No 3
Peel Region Scheme
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 24, s 31

Result:

The preliminary issue is determined as follows:
1) the plan forming annexure A was not a plan tendered by or on behalf of the applicants; and
2) the approval by the respondent of the plan in that form does not render the application for review nugatory

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

The City of Mandurah granted retrospective planning approval for the placement of fill on a lot at Herron after being invited by the Tribunal pursuant to s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act2004 (WA) to reconsider its original refusal of the development application. The approval included a plan, 'Attachment A', to illustrate conditions drafted by a City officer and imposed by the City. The Annexure A plan was prepared by the applicants' consultant town planner, who had initially acted as the applicants' agent.

The applicants sought review of certain conditions imposed by the respondent.  At the commencement of the hearing, the Tribunal brought to the attention of counsel that it appeared on the face of it that the applicants were asking for review of the approval of a plan, Attachment A, that the applicants apparently had asked the respondent to approve.  The hearing was adjourned and when it reconvened the parties asked that the preliminary issue be addressed.

The preliminary issue was stated to be:

'The issue for determination by this Tribunal as a preliminary issue is whether the plan forming Annexure A was a plan tendered by or on behalf of the applicants and, if so, whether the approval of the respondent to the plan in that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deane and City Of Mandurah and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASAT 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Deane and City of Mandurah, the dispute arose from a development application concerning a proposed subdivision of land. The City of Mandurah contested the validity of the planning application, specifically questioning whether a plan identified as Annexure A was indeed tendered by or on behalf of the applicants. The case was heard in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the approval of the City of Mandurah to the plan in its form rendered the application for review nugatory and whether the planning consultant acting as an agent for the applicants could bind the principal throughout the process. The court also needed to determine if an express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was necessary and whether endorsements on the plan were agreed to by the applicants.

The tribunal found that the plan in question, Annexure A, was prepared by the applicants' planning consultant. The silence of the planning consultant and the applicants on accepting the plan after it was sent to the City of Mandurah was significant. The tribunal considered the custom and practice of agents in town planning review matters and the implied authority of the agent. It was held that the principal is bound by the action of the planning consultant as an agent throughout the process unless there is a clear carve-out of the agent's authority. The City of Mandurah was deemed to be alive to questions about the scope of the agent's authority. The tribunal concluded that an express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was not necessary and that the endorsements on the plan were agreed to by the applicants.

The tribunal issued orders for reconsideration under section 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The detailed orders were aimed at ensuring that the planning application process would proceed with clarity and adherence to the proper procedures established by the relevant planning laws and practices.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Deane and City of Mandurah, the applicants, Deane, sought to have a development application approved by the City of Mandurah. The application pertained to a proposed development on a specific property. The applicants engaged a planning consultant to assist in the preparation and submission of the development application, including the tendering of a site plan. The plan, referred to as Annexure A, was prepared by the applicants' planning consultant and subsequently sent to the City of Mandurah. The applicants and their consultant remained silent on the acceptance of the plan after it was sent to the respondent.

The City of Mandurah reviewed the plan and made certain amendments, including adding a note indicating that the amended plan had been approved by the City. However, the applicants did not expressly ratify the amended plan, nor did they provide any further instructions to their planning consultant regarding the plan. The City of Mandurah proceeded to approve the development application in the form of the amended plan. Subsequently, the applicants sought a review of the City of Mandurah's decision, arguing that the approval of the amended plan rendered their application for review nugatory. The applicants contended that the planning consultant acted as their agent throughout the process, and that the City of Mandurah should have been aware of the scope of the consultant's authority. The applicants also raised questions about whether an express ratification of the amended plan by them was necessary and whether the endorsements on the amended plan were agreed to by them.

The matter of Deane and City of Mandurah originated from a development application concerning a property within the City of Mandurah, Western Australia. The applicants sought approval for development on their property, with the planning consultant acting as their agent. Following the submission of the application, the City of Mandurah sought clarification on the plan identified as Annexure A, which was prepared by the applicants' planning consultant. The preliminary issue that arose was whether this plan was tendered by or on behalf of the applicants and whether the approval of the City of Mandurah to this plan would render the application for review nugatory. The applicants and their planning consultant remained silent on the acceptance of this plan after it was sent to the City of Mandurah, prompting questions about the scope of the agent's authority and the need for express ratification of the plan by the applicants.

In light of the preliminary issue, orders were issued for reconsideration under section 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The key procedural steps included the examination of the custom and practice of agents in town planning review matters and the implied authority of the agent. The tribunal also considered whether the City of Mandurah was aware of the questions about the scope of the agent's authority and whether a carve-out of the agent's authority was necessary. Furthermore, the tribunal deliberated on whether express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was necessary and whether any endorsements on the plan were agreed upon by the applicants. This case serves as an important reference point in understanding the relationship between applicants, their agents, and the responding authority in town planning development applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MR J
Issues
1. Whether the plan identified as Annexure A was a plan tendered by or on behalf of the applicants.
2. Whether approval of the respondent to the plan in the form of Annexure A renders the application for review nugatory.
3. Whether the planning consultant acted as an agent for the applicants throughout the process.
4. Whether the principal is bound by the actions of the planning consultant as an agent throughout the process.
5. Whether the silence of the planning consultant and the applicants on the acceptance of the plan after it was sent to the respondent is significant.
6. Whether the custom and practice in town planning review matters supports the notion of implied authority of the agent.
7. Whether there was a carve-out of the agent's authority in this case.
8. Whether the respondent was aware of or alive to questions about the scope of the agent's authority.
9. Whether express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was necessary.
10. Whether the endorsements on the Annexure A plan were agreed to by the applicants.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plan identified as Annexure A was indeed a plan tendered by or on behalf of the applicants. Result: The court's decision did not consider the application for review nugatory.
2. The court determined that approval of the respondent to the plan in the form of Annexure A did not render the application for review nugatory. Result: The application for review remained valid.
3. The court held that the planning consultant acted as an agent for the applicants throughout the process. Result: This finding established the basis for further analysis of the agent's authority.
4. The court concluded that the principal is bound by the actions of the planning consultant as an agent throughout the process, barring any limitations or carve-outs. Result: The applicants were bound by the consultant's actions.
5. The court found that the silence of the planning consultant and the applicants on the acceptance of the plan after it was sent to the respondent was significant. Result: This silence was considered in the context of the agent's authority.
6. The court agreed that the custom and practice in town planning review matters supports the notion of implied authority of the agent. Result: This custom and practice was taken into account in the court's decision.
7. The court found that there was no carve-out of the agent's authority in this case. Result: The agent's authority was not limited in any way.
8. The court concluded that the respondent was aware of or alive to questions about the scope of the agent's authority. Result: The respondent's awareness was considered in the court's decision.
9. The court determined that express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was not necessary. Result: The court accepted the implied ratification through the agent's actions.
10. The court held that the endorsements on the Annexure A plan were agreed to by the applicants. Result: The applicants were bound by the endorsements made by the agent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MR J

In the case of Deane and City Of Mandurah, the court was tasked with determining a series of preliminary issues concerning the role and authority of a planning consultant acting on behalf of the applicants in a town planning matter. The first issue considered whether the plan identified as Annexure A was indeed tendered by or on behalf of the applicants. The court found that the plan was prepared by the applicants' planning consultant and subsequently sent to the respondent. This established that the plan was tendered by the applicants through their consultant, thereby forming a part of the application process.

The second issue addressed whether the approval of the respondent to the plan in the form of Annexure A rendered the application for review nugatory. The court noted that the approval itself did not necessarily nullify the application for review, as the focus of the review was on the process and authority of the planning consultant rather than the merits of the plan. The court applied the principle that approval by a respondent does not extinguish the right to seek review, provided there is a legitimate ground for questioning the process.

Next, the court examined whether the planning consultant acted as an agent for the applicants throughout the process. It was established that the consultant had been engaged by the applicants to manage and oversee the planning application. The court relied on the general principles of agency law, which recognize that an agent can act on behalf of a principal within the scope of their authority. The court then moved to consider whether the principal is bound by the actions of the planning consultant as an agent throughout the process, finding that this was contingent on the scope of the agent's authority.

The court then considered the significance of the silence of the planning consultant and the applicants on the acceptance of the plan after it was sent to the respondent. The court assessed whether this silence could be interpreted as an implied acceptance of the plan's form. However, the court concluded that silence alone was insufficient to establish acceptance, as it did not equate to an explicit endorsement of the plan's details.

Addressing the custom and practice in town planning review matters, the court examined whether these practices supported the notion of implied authority of the agent. The court found that while certain practices might suggest a broader scope of implied authority, these needed to be clearly distinguished from the specific circumstances of the case. The court then scrutinized whether there was a carve-out of the agent's authority in this case, and whether the respondent was aware of or alive to questions about the scope of the agent's authority. It determined that the absence of a clear limitation on the agent's authority, combined with the respondent's apparent ignorance of any such limitations, reinforced the agent's scope of authority.

The court also deliberated on whether express ratification of the Annexure A plan by the applicants was necessary. It concluded that while express ratification would have been ideal, the circumstances did not necessarily demand it, particularly if the agent's actions fell within the implied scope of their authority. Finally, the court considered whether the endorsements on the Annexure A plan were agreed to by the applicants. It found that the fact the endorsements aligned with the applicants' objectives and the agent's scope of authority indicated that the applicants implicitly endorsed the plan.

Through this reasoning, the court established the binding legal principle that where a planning consultant acts within the scope of their implied authority, and the respondent is unaware of any limitations, the principal is bound by the consultant's actions. Additionally, the court highlighted the importance of clear communication regarding the scope of an agent's authority to prevent misunderstandings and potential disputes.