Dean v Cole

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
30 CLR 1

]

DEAN AND ANOTHER

APPELLANTS;

PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT,

COLE AND ANOTHER

RESPONDENTS. DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Will-Interpretation-Absolute gift or trust.

By his will a testator appointed his wife executrix and another person executor, and directed that his debts, funeral and testamentary expenses should be paid as soon as conveniently might be after his death. The will then continued - I give devise and bequeath unto my wife my real and personal estate, but subject to the following conditions -First, Nov. 7, 8, 17. that out of my estate the sum of one thousand pounds and the further sum of three hundred pounds with any bonus additions (being the value of a policy of assurance on my life

) shall be forthwith invested in the name of my executrix and executor for the maintenance and support of my son A.D.,

provided that if it shall please God so to order that at any time he the said A.D. shall be

capable of managing his own affairs, then the above-named sums of money with all and every residue of interest shall be paid to the said A.D. on his arriving at the age of twenty-one years or subse- quently, provided further that should the said A.D. die incapable of managing

30 CLR 2

his own affairs, then these aforenamed sums of money with any accrued interest thereon shall be at the absolute disposal of my wife with the exception of these two sums of money just before named, I give all and every portion of my real and personal estate to my wife to her that she will at some time during her lifetime or at her death divide in fair just and equal shares between my children J.D., S.D., E.A.D. and C.F.D., or such of them as may survive, all such part and portion of my estate as she may be in the use and enjoyment of, but with this stipulation in the case of each and every of my daughters (1) that they shall not marry without the consent of my executrix and executor, whom I appoint as their guardians, and (2) that when at any time they do marry care shall be taken by my executrix and executor that the portion given to each of my daughters shall be

SO secured upon them by deed of settlement that the portion given is for the sole use and enjoyment of each and such daughter as may marry and placing such portion out of the power use or control of each and every their respective husband. My other two surviving sons W.D. and H.D. having been already provided for by me are to have no part nor share in my estate and are by this my will excluded from all participation in the same."

Held, by Knox C.J., Gavan Duffy and Rich JJ. (Higgins and Starke JJ. dis senting), that the will should not be construed as imposing a trust upon…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dean v Cole and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1921] HCA 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned the interpretation of the will of William Dean, who appointed his wife Sarah Dean and another as executors. The testator bequeathed his real and personal estate to his wife, subject to certain conditions. The primary dispute revolved around whether the testator intended to impose a trust on his wife for the benefit of their children with respect to the residuary estate, or if she took the estate absolutely, save for specific bequests. The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which declared that the widow did not take the residuary estate absolutely but rather for life, with the remainder to the children.

The legal issues before the High Court of Australia were whether the words "trusting to her that she will at some time during her lifetime or at her death divide in fair just and equal shares between my children... all such part and portion of my estate as she may be in the use and enjoyment of" imposed a binding trust on the testator's widow, or if they merely expressed a wish. A related issue was the extent of the property to which any such trust, if found, would apply, particularly in light of specific provisions regarding sums for their son Alexander and the exclusion of other sons.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Knox C.J., Gavan Duffy and Rich JJ., held that the words "trusting to her" were an expression of confidence and not a legally enforceable trust. They reasoned that the testator's intention to create an absolute gift was evidenced by the clear language used in other parts of the will, such as the provision for Alexander's legacy to be at the widow's "absolute disposal." The majority found that the phrase "all such part and portion of my estate as she may be in the use and enjoyment of" qualified the precatory words, limiting their application to property the widow had actually retained and was using. In contrast, Higgins and Starke JJ. dissented, finding that the language of the will, including the explicit mention of "conditions," the "stipulation" regarding daughters' marriages, and the exclusion of certain sons, indicated an intention to create a trust. They argued that the words "trusting to her to divide" were not mere precatory words but imposed an obligation, and that the widow held the residuary estate subject to a power in the nature of a trust.

The High Court, by majority, reversed the decision of the Supreme Court. It declared that Sarah Dean, the widow, was absolutely entitled for her own use and benefit to the residuary real and personal estate of the testator, after the payment of debts, funeral and testamentary expenses, and the two specified sums for their son Alexander. The costs of all parties were to be paid out of the residuary estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.