| [2019] FWC 2525 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution
Dean Cordowiner
v
Ashton Coal Operations Pty Limited
(C2019/470)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAUNDERS | NEWCASTLE, 12 APRIL 2019 |
Dispute under the disputes settlement procedure in an enterprise agreement – dispute concerning warning – warning unreasonable.
Introduction and background
[1] Mr Dean Cordowiner is a Mechanical Technician/Fitter employed by Ashton Coal Operations Pty Ltd (Ashton Coal) to work at the Ashton Coal underground mine near Singleton (Mine). On 8 August 2018, Mr Cordowiner was allocated the task of replacing Banjo fittings on a man transport vehicle designated as “PT10” (PT10). Mr Andrew Dunn, Undermanager at the Mine, conducted a safety interaction with Mr Cordowiner whilst he was undertaking that task on 8 August 2018. In view of that safety interaction, Ashton Coal conducted an investigation and at its conclusion, issued Mr Cordowiner with a final written warning for serious misconduct, namely, failing to isolate before lifting the rear chassis of PT10 to change the Banjo fittings.
[2] Mr Cordowiner raised a dispute in relation to the final written warning with Ashton Coal under the dispute settlement procedure in the Ashton Coal Operations Pty Limited – Ashton Underground Mine Enterprise Agreement 2012 (2012 Enterprise Agreement). There is no dispute that Mr Cordowiner was covered by the 2012 Enterprise Agreement on 8 August 2018 and that it ceased to operate in relation to Mr Cordowiner when the Ashton Coal Operations Pty Limited – Ashton Underground Mine Enterprise Agreement 2018 (2018 Enterprise Agreement) came into operation on 23 October 2018. Mr Cordowiner is covered by the 2018 Enterprise Agreement.
[3] An application pursuant to s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act) was filed in the Fair Work Commission (Commission) by the CFMMEU on behalf of Mr Cordowiner. There is no dispute that the Commission has jurisdiction to deal with the dispute concerning the final warning issued to Mr Cordowiner, including by arbitration, under the disputes procedure in clause 4.7 of the 2018 Enterprise Agreement.
[4] On 4 February 2019, the parties participated in a conciliation conference before the Commission to attempt to resolve the dispute. Following that conciliation conference, Ashton Coal changed the final written warning to a formal warning and issued a letter to Mr Cordowiner to that effect on 15 February 2019. Mr Cordowiner disputes the formal warning issued to him on 15 February 2019. He contends that it was unjust and unreasonable in the circumstances for Ashton Coal to impose such disciplinary action on him. Ashton Coal denies those allegations.
[5] Evidence was given in support of Mr Cordowiner’s case by Mr Jeff Drayton, Vice President of the CFMMEU, Northern Mining & NSW Energy District, and Mr Michael Taggart, Electrician employed by Ashton Coal at the Mine and CFMMEU Ashton Lodge President. Ashton Coal called evidence from Mr Dunn, Mr Barry McKay, Engineering Manager at the Mine, Ms Amanda Farrell, Human Resources…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dean Cordowiner v Ashton Coal Operations Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] FWC 2525
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the FWC was whether the warning issued to Cordowiner was procedurally and substantively fair. The warning was issued following an incident where Cordowiner was allegedly found sleeping on the job. The FWC had to determine if the employer followed the correct procedures in issuing the warning and whether the warning was justified based on the circumstances. Additionally, the FWC needed to assess if the warning was a reasonable management action considering the employee's conduct.
In delivering the decision, the FWC found that while the employer had a right to discipline employees, the warning was not procedurally fair as Cordowiner was not given an opportunity to explain his actions before the warning was issued. The FWC noted that the employer did not follow its own disciplinary procedures, which required a prior discussion and the opportunity for the employee to respond. Furthermore, the FWC held that the warning was substantively unfair as it was disproportionate to the offence. The employer had a zero-tolerance policy on sleeping on the job, but the FWC found that Cordowiner’s actions did not warrant such a severe penalty without prior discussion and consideration of mitigating factors.
The FWC determined that the warning was unreasonable and ordered that the warning be removed from Cordowiner's record, and that Ashton Coal Operations Pty Limited pay Cordowiner's costs associated with the dispute.