De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd (Migration) [2024] AATA 560 (22 March 2024)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Kane Downs (MARN: 0962296)

CASE NUMBER:  2104689

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2020/1376071

MEMBER:Alan McMurran

DATE:22 March 2024

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision not to approve the nomination and substitutes a decision that the nomination is approved.

Statement made on 22 March 2024 at 11:06am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – application for approval of nomination of position – medium-term stream – chef – genuine position – wholesale premium patisserie – tasks more like pastrycook than chef – extensive documentation and submissions – autonomy, creativity and responsibility – previous sponsorship of another nominee on same terms approved – nominee’s current work in position and application for visa – labour market testing inconsistent with international trade obligation – terms of Australia/UK Free Trade Agreement – advertising for position found no other appropriate candidate – decision made without hearing necessary – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 140GB, 140GBA(1)(c), (2), 359(2), 360(2)(a)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), rr 2.72(10)(a), 2.73

CASES
Cargo First Pty Ltd v MIBP [2016] FCA 30
Project 42 Pty Ltd (Migration) [2022] AATA 2200

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application lodged 13 April 2021 for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 24 March 2021 to refuse to approve the applicant’s nomination under s 140GB of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) and reg 2.72 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations).

  2. The applicant, De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd, applied for approval on 16 April 2020. A nomination of an occupation for a Subclass 482 visa is made under s 140GB of the Act and reg 2.73 of the Regulations.

  3. The occupation must be nominated for a Subclass 482 visa in one of three alternative streams: the Short-term stream, the Medium-term stream or the Labour Agreement stream. Regulation 2.72 prescribes general and stream-specific criteria that must be satisfied for the Minister to approve a nomination by a person. These criteria are extracted in the attachment to this decision. Additional criteria are specified in s 140GBA.

  4. In this case, the occupation of Chef (ANZSCO 351311) is the occupation nominated for the visa applicant, Ms Cherylle De Gracia, a 40 year-old British Citizen (“the nominee”), for a Subclass 482 visa in the Medium-term stream. The nominee has lodged a separate application for the visa, which was refused following the nomination refusal. The visa refusal is also subject to review in proceedings number 2107968.

  5. The delegate decided not to approve the nomination on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy sub-cl 2.72(10)(a) of the Regulations, because the occupation is not ‘genuine’. This was because the delegate found the position description more aligned with the role of a Pastrycook and not a Chef.

  6. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 560
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered an application by De Toni Patisserie & Bakery Pty Ltd for the approval of a nomination for a position under the medium-term stream of the Subclass 482 visa program. The dispute centred on whether the nominated position, described as a "chef," genuinely reflected the duties and responsibilities of the nominee, who was a pastry chef, and whether the employer met all the regulatory requirements for sponsorship.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the nominated occupation of "chef" (ANZSCO 351311) was appropriate for the nominee's skills and the actual tasks performed, considering the specific nature of the applicant's business as a wholesale premium patisserie. Further, the Tribunal had to assess whether the employer had complied with all relevant legislative criteria, including those pertaining to the genuineness of the position, labour market testing, and any international trade obligations. The Tribunal also considered extensive documentation and submissions, including information not previously available to the Department.

The Tribunal found that while the nominee was a highly skilled pastry chef with extensive experience, the tasks she performed in the nominated role, as evidenced by the provided materials, aligned more closely with the duties of a pastry cook than a general chef. However, the Tribunal noted that the employer had previously sponsored another nominee for the same position on similar terms, which had been approved. Crucially, the Tribunal considered that the nominee was currently working in the position and had applied for a visa based on this nomination. The Tribunal also addressed the labour market testing, finding it potentially inconsistent with international trade obligations, and concluded that the original decision had been made without considering all necessary information.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision not to approve the nomination and substituted a decision approving the nomination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to set aside the decision under review and substitute a decision approving the nomination.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in the present case is whether the applicant meets the criteria for approval of the nomination. The relevant criteria are set out below. The Tribunal must approve the nomination if the applicant is an approved work sponsor and meets the requirements in reg 2.72: s 140GB(2). The applicant must also have paid any nomination training contribution charge in relation to the nomination for which they are liable. In addition, the labour market testing requirements in s 140GBA, where applicable, must be met. The Tribunal has available information including extracts from the Department’s nomination and visa application files, the related Tribunal files, and the recent submissions from the representative. The information includes material provided recently and which was not available to the Department for consideration. The Tribunal has also had regard to the Act and the Regulations[1], relevant case law, the ANZSCO guide for the occupation, relevant legislative instruments, Department policy and the AAT’s publicly available Practice Directions, guides and guidelines.[1] S140GB and reg 2.72The nomination must comply with the prescribed process Regulation 2.72(3) requires that the applicant has made the nomination in accordance with the process set out in reg 2.73. On the available information, the Tribunal is satisfied the applicant is nominating an occupation[2] which includes the corresponding 6 digit code under s 140GB(1)(b), and has identified the nominee as the proposed applicant for a Subclass 482 visa under reg 2.73(1) in the Medium-term stream pursuant to the relevant instrument [3]. The nominee is nominated to work full-time in the nominated occupation. [2] Chef ANZSCO 351311[3] LIN19/048 (compilation) commenced 11 March 2019. The occupation is subject to two inapplicability caveats. Firstly, as to mass produced product in a factory setting, or secondly, where the position is located in a limited service restaurant.[4] In either of such environments, the position is not available. A limited service restaurant includes a fast food or takeaway food service, a fast casual restaurant a drinking establishment offering only a limited food service, a limited service café including a coffee shop or mall café, and a limited service pizza restaurant.[4] LIN 19/048 conditions 7,8. The Tribunal is satisfied from the Departmental information that the application was made on the approved form, and the fee paid together with the nomination training contribution charge applicable and collected from the applicant at the time of lodgement, which is in accordance with the current requirements for payment of the fee and as assessed by the Department accordingly. The nomination includes the proposed medium-term stay for up to 4 years under an employment contract, granted on the basis of the nomination. The applicant’s annual turnover as submitted (FYE 2021), exceeded AUD3 million. The applicant has provided evidence that it currently employs 9 chefs, 3 managers including an executive chef, a pastry chef, trainee, kitchen hand and a driver.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons given above, the applicant meets all the applicable criteria for the nomination to be approved.DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision not to approve the nomination and substitutes a decision that the nomination is approved.Alan McMurranMemberATTACHMENT - EXTRACTS FROM THE MIGRATION REGULATIONS 19942.72 Criteria for approval of nomination--Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa and Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa(1)This regulation applies in relation to a person who:(a)is any of the following:(i) a standard business sponsor;(ii) a person who has applied to be a standard business sponsor;(iii) …(iv) …(b)under paragraph 140GB(1)(b) of the Act, nominates a proposed occupation in relation to any of the following (the nominee):(i) a holder of a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa;(ii) a holder of a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa;(iii) an applicant or a proposed applicant for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa.(2)For the purposes of paragraph 140GB(2)(b) of the Act, the criteria set out in this regulation are prescribed.Note: In addition, subsection 140GB(2) of the Act requires the person to be an approved work sponsor and to have paid any nomination training contribution charge in relation to the nomination.(3)The Minister is satisfied that the person made the nomination in accordance with the process set out in regulation 2.73.(4)The Minister is satisfied that either:(a)there is no adverse information known to Immigration about the person or a person associated with the person; or(b)it is reasonable to disregard any adverse information known to Immigration about the person or a person associated with the person.(5)The Minister is satisfied that:(a)if the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream—the person is a standard business sponsor; or(b)…(5A)The Minister is satisfied that any debt due by the person as mentioned in section 140ZO of the Act (recovery of nomination training contribution charge and late payment penalty) has been paid in full.(6)If the nominee holds:(a)a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa; or(b)a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa;the Minister is satisfied that the person has listed on the nomination each other holder of either of those kinds of visa who was granted the visa on the basis of having the necessary relationship with the nominee as mentioned in clause 457.321 of Schedule 2 (as in force before 18 March 2018) or subclause 482.312(1) of Schedule 2.(7)However, the Minister may disregard the fact that one or more persons required to be listed on the nomination are not listed, if the Minister is satisfied it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so.(8)The Minister is satisfied that:(a)the occupation and its corresponding 6-digit code correspond to an occupation and its corresponding 6-digit code specified in:(i) if the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream—the instrument made under subregulation (9) in force at the time the nomination is made; or(ii) …; and(b)the occupation applies to the nominee in accordance with the instrument or work agreement.(9)The Minister may, by legislative instrument, specify occupations and, for each occupation:(a)whether the occupation is:(i) a short term skilled occupation; or(ii) a medium and long term strategic skills occupation; and(b)either:(i) the 6-digit ANZSCO code for the occupation; or(ii) if there is no 6-digit ANZSCO code for the occupation—a 6-digit code for the occupation; and(c)if there is no 6-digit ANZSCO code for the occupation—tasks, qualifications and experience for the occupation; and(d)any matters for the purpose of determining whether the occupation applies to a nominee, including matters relating to any of the following:(i) the person who nominated the occupation;(ii) the nominee;(iii) the occupation;(iv) the position in which the nominee is to work;(v) the circumstances in which the occupation is undertaken;(vi) the circumstances in which the nominee is to be employed in the position.(10)The Minister is satisfied that the position associated with the occupation is:(a)genuine; and(b)a full-time position.(10A)However, the Minister may disregard the criterion in paragraph (10)(b) if the Minister is satisfied that it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so.(11)If:(a)the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream; and(b)the person is not an overseas business sponsor; and(c)the occupation is not an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument made under subregulation (13);the Minister is satisfied that:(d)the nominee will be engaged only as an employee under a written contract of employment by the person or an associated entity of the person (the employer); and(e)the person will give the Minister a copy of the contract signed by the employer and the nominee.(12)If:(a)the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream; and(b)the person is an overseas business sponsor; and(c)the occupation is not an occupation specified by the Minister in an instrument made under subregulation (13);the Minister is satisfied that:(d)the nominee will be engaged only as an employee under a written contract of employment by the person; and(e)the person will give the Minister a copy of the contract signed by the person and the nominee.(13)The Minister may, by legislative instrument, specify occupations for the purposes of paragraphs (11)(c) and (12)(c) …(14)If:(a)the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream; and(b)the nominee holds a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa or a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa; and(c)the Minister requested the person to provide evidence that the nominee satisfies the language test requirements;the person has provided evidence to the Minister that the nominee satisfies:(d)if the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream—any language test requirements specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument for clause 482.223 of Schedule 2 that would apply to the nominee if the nominee were an applicant for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream; or(e)if the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Medium-term stream—any language test requirements specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument for clause 482.232 of Schedule 2 that would apply to the nominee if the nominee were an applicant for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Medium-term stream.(15)Subject to subregulation (16), if:(a)the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream; and(b)the Minister is not satisfied that the nominee’s annual earnings in relation to the occupation will be at least the amount specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument made for the purposes of this paragraph;the Minister is satisfied that:(c)the annual market salary rate for the occupation has been determined by the person in accordance with the instrument made under subregulation (17); and(d)the annual market salary rate, excluding any non-monetary benefits, for the occupation (determined by the person in accordance with an instrument made under subregulation (17)) is not less than the temporary skilled migration income threshold specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument made for the purposes of this paragraph; and(e)the nominee’s annual earnings in relation to the occupation will not be less than the annual market salary rate for the occupation (determined by the person in accordance with an instrument made under subregulation (17)); and(f)the nominee’s annual earnings, excluding any non-monetary benefits, in relation to the occupation will not be less than the temporary skilled migration income threshold specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument made for the purposes of paragraph (d); and(g)either:(i) there is no information known to Immigration that indicates that the annual market salary rate for the occupation (determined by the person in accordance with an instrument made under subregulation (17)) is inconsistent with Australian labour market conditions relevant to the occupation; or(ii) it is reasonable to disregard any such information.(16)However:(a)the Minister may disregard the criterion in paragraph (15)(d) if the Minister is satisfied that:(i) the annual market salary rate for the occupation (determined by the person in accordance with an instrument made under subregulation (17)) is not less than the temporary skilled migration income threshold specified by the Minister in a legislative instrument made for the purposes of paragraph (15)(d); and(ii) it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so; and(aa)the Minister may disregard the criterion in paragraph (15)(e) if:(i) under subregulation (10A), the Minister disregards the criterion in paragraph (10)(b) in relation to the position associated with the occupation; and(ii) the Minister is satisfied that it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so; and(b)the Minister may disregard the criterion in paragraph (15)(f) if the Minister is satisfied that it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so.(17)The Minister may, by legislative instrument, specify a method for determining the annual market salary rate for an occupation nominated under section 140GB of the Act or an occupation in relation to which a position is nominated under regulation 5.19.(18)If the occupation is nominated for a Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa in the Short-term stream or Medium-term stream, the Minister is satisfied that:(a)either:(i) there is no information known to Immigration that indicates that the employment conditions (other than in relation to earnings) that will apply to the nominee are less favourable than those that apply, or would apply, to an Australian citizen or an Australian permanent resident performing equivalent work at the same location; or(ii) it is reasonable to disregard any such information; and(b)if the person is lawfully operating a business in Australia—the person has not engaged in discriminatory recruitment practices.(19)…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For these reasons the requirements of reg 2.72(3) are met.No adverse information known to Immigration Regulation 2.72(4) requires that either: there is no adverse information known to Immigration about the applicant or a person associated with the applicant; or it is reasonable to disregard such information. For these purposes, ‘adverse information’ and ‘associated with’ have the meaning given in regs 1.13A and 1.13B. There is no evidence or information before the Tribunal of any adverse information known to Immigration about the applicant or a person associated with the applicant. For these reasons the requirements of reg 2.72(4) are met.Nominator is a standard business sponsor Regulation 2.72(5) requires that the person making a nomination is a standard business sponsor. The purpose of this criterion is to ensure that a person who is a standard business sponsor or a party to a work agreement when they make the nomination is still a standard business sponsor or a party to a work agreement when the decision on the nomination is made.[6] [6] Explanatory Statement to SLI 2009, No 115, p.26. Department records confirm that the applicant is an approved business sponsor for the period from 8 April 2021 to 8 April 2026. For these reasons the requirements of reg 2.72(5) are met.Payment of debt mentioned in s 140ZO Regulation 2.72(5A) requires that the person has paid in full any debt mentioned in s 140ZO of the Act. There is no information before the Tribunal that the applicant has any outstanding debt under s140ZO of the Act, and which has not been paid in full. For these reasons the requirements of reg 2.72(5A) are met.Requirements for existing Subclass 457 or Subclass 482 visa holders The criteria for approval of a nomination contain several requirements if a Subclass 457 or Subclass 482 visa holder is identified as the person to work in the nominated position. In these cases:·the applicant must list on the nomination each person granted a Subclass 457 or Subclass 482 visa as a family member of the nominee, unless it is reasonable in the circumstances not to do so: reg 2.72(6)(a) and reg 2.72(7);·if the Minister requested evidence that the nominee satisfies the language test requirements, the applicant has provided evidence that the nominee satisfies the language test requirements specified for cl 482.223 (if the nomination is in the Short-term stream) or cl 482.232 (if the nomination is in the Medium-term stream): reg 2.72(14). As the nominee is not the holder of a Subclass 457 or Subclass 482 visa, the requirements of reg 2.72(6) and reg 2.72(14) do not apply.Specified occupation Regulation 2.72(8) requires that the nominated occupation and its 6-digit code correspond to an occupation and 6-digit code specified in the instrument in force at the time the nomination is made, that is, LIN19/048. The occupation must also apply to the nominee in accordance with the instrument. The Tribunal has considered the available information and the detailed written submission made to the Tribunal on 20 September 2023 concerning the role and the nominee. The statement includes: “The Nominee is a trained and experienced pastry chef and had completed her studies in Australia. She has years of experience as a chef and creating tasting and testing pastries and desserts at world class standard. And her experience has only expanded after working in the role while waiting for her case to be heard by the Appeals Tribunal.”