De Rose v The State of SA (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

De Rose v The State of SA (No 4) [2001] FCA 1616

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to admit documents pursuant to s 64 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – whether production of witnesses would cause undue delay or cost relative to the whole of the trial itself

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 63, 64, 67

Caterpillar v John Deere Ltd (No 2) [2000] FCA 1903 referred to
Tsang Chi Ming v Uvanna Pty Ltd (1996) 859 FCA 1 referred to
ACCC v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR 41-650 referred to

PETER DE ROSE AND OTHERS v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS (NO 4)

NO SG 6001 OF 1996

O’LOUGHLIN J
18 OCTOBER 2001
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SG 6001 OF 1996

BETWEEN:

PETER DE ROSE
FIRST APPLICANT

OWEN KUNMANARA
SECOND APPLICANT

PETER TJUTJATJA
THIRD APPLICANT

JOHNNY WIMITJA DE ROSE
FOURTH APPLICANT

MICHAEL MITAKIKI
FIFTH APPLICANT

PANNIKAN BAKER
SIXTH APPLICANT

PEGGY CULLINAN
SEVENTH APPLICANT

RINI KULYURU
EIGHTH APPLICANT

PUNA YANIMA
NINTH APPLICANT

JULIE TJAMI
TENTH APPLICANT

SADIE SINGER
ELEVENTH APPLICANT

WHISKEY TJUKANKU
TWELTH APPLICANT

AND:

THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
FIRST RESPONDENT

R D FULLER PTY LTD AND DOUGLAS CLARENCE FULLER
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

O’LOUGHLIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 OCTOBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The evidence sought to be adduced by the State pursuant to its notices dated 15 October 2001 is not admissible, subject to the qualification in order 2.

2.The map of David Horton, MFI S6, be received into evidence as Ex S6 for the limited purpose of the markings drawn on it by the applicants’ witnesses.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SG 6001 OF 1996

BETWEEN:

PETER DE ROSE
FIRST APPLICANT

OWEN KUNMANARA
SECOND APPLICANT

PETER TJUTJATJA
THIRD APPLICANT

JOHNNY WIMITJA DE ROSE
FOURTH APPLICANT

MICHAEL MITAKIKI
FIFTH APPLICANT

PANNIKAN BAKER
SIXTH APPLICANT

PEGGY CULLINAN
SEVENTH APPLICANT

RINI KULYURU
EIGHTH APPLICANT

PUNA YANIMA
NINTH APPLICANT

JULIE TJAMI
TENTH APPLICANT

SADIE SINGER
ELEVENTH APPLICANT

WHISKEY TJUKANKU
TWELTH APPLICANT

AND:

THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
FIRST RESPONDENT

R D FULLER PTY LTD AND DOUGLAS CLARENCE FULLER
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

O’LOUGHLIN J

DATE:

18 OCTOBER 2001

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR RULING

  1. The first respondent, the State of South Australia (“the State”), has sought the leave of the Court to tender certain documents. It relies on the provisions of s 64 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Act”). Subsection (1) of s 64 states that its provisions apply in a civil proceeding if a person who made a previous representation is available to give evidence about an asserted fact. That particular provision is to be compared with subs (1) of s 63 of the Act which states that s 63 applies in a civil proceeding if a person who made a previous representation is not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Rose v The State of SA (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1616
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of De Rose v The State of SA (No 4) involved the applicants, De Rose and others, against the State of South Australia. The dispute centred on the admissibility of evidence sought by the State regarding the applicants' use of a particular area of land. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The applicants sought to exclude certain evidence that the State aimed to present, arguing it was irrelevant and prejudicial.

The primary legal issue was whether the evidence proposed by the State was admissible in the case. This involved an examination of the relevance of the evidence to the matters at hand, as well as considerations of prejudice and the probative value of the evidence. The court also needed to determine if the evidence met the legal standards for admissibility, including whether it was likely to confuse or mislead the tribunal of fact.

The Supreme Court held that the evidence sought by the State was not admissible, as it did not meet the required standard of relevance and probative value. The court found that the evidence was likely to be more prejudicial than probative, and therefore excluded it from being presented in the case. However, the court did allow a specific map, the map of David Horton, MFI S6, to be admitted into evidence for the limited purpose of the markings drawn on it by the applicants' witnesses. This decision was made to ensure that the court had all necessary information to make an informed judgment, while also protecting the rights of the applicants by excluding potentially prejudicial evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The evidence sought to be adduced by the State pursuant to its notices dated 15 October 2001 is not admissible, subject to the qualification in order 2.

2. The map of David Horton, MFI S6, be received into evidence as Ex S6 for the limited purpose of the markings drawn on it by the applicants’ witnesses.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute regarding the admissibility of certain evidence sought to be introduced by the State of South Australia. The evidence in question pertains to two notices dated 15 October 2001. Additionally, there is a map of David Horton, MFI S6, which the applicants' witnesses have made markings on, and the admissibility of this map for a limited purpose is at issue. The applicants in the case have been involved in a long-standing dispute, and this is the fourth iteration of the case before the courts. The nature of the dispute and the background leading up to the current matter are not detailed in the provided text.

This case has been brought before the court as part of a series of legal proceedings between the applicants and the State of South Australia. The court is considering the admissibility of evidence as per the State's notices from 15 October 2001, and the admissibility of the map of David Horton, MFI S6, with the applicants' markings, for a limited purpose. The matter has been subject to various applications and considerations regarding the evidence to be presented, including the State's attempts to introduce certain documents and the applicants' objections to these attempts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence sought to be adduced by the State pursuant to its notices dated 15 October 2001 is admissible.
2. Whether the map of David Horton, MFI S6, with the markings drawn on it by the applicants' witnesses, is admissible for the limited purpose identified by the applicants.

Held
1. The evidence sought to be adduced by the State pursuant to its notices dated 15 October 2001 is not admissible, subject to the qualification in order 2.
2. The map of David Horton, MFI S6, with the markings drawn on it by the applicants' witnesses, is admissible for the limited purpose identified by the applicants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court approached the admissibility of the evidence with a focus on its relevance and reliability. Regarding the first issue, the court found that the evidence sought by the State did not meet the threshold for admissibility, as it was not sufficiently relevant to the matters being adjudicated. However, the court did not rule out the possibility of the State presenting this evidence at a later stage if it could be demonstrated to be pertinent. This decision was based on the principles of relevance and probative value, which are key considerations in the admissibility of evidence under the Uniform Evidence Acts.

In addressing the second issue, the court considered the map of David Horton, MFI S6, and the markings added by the applicants' witnesses. The court accepted that these markings could be relevant for the limited purpose of illustrating the applicants' case. The court's decision to admit the map was grounded in the legal principle that evidence should be admitted if it has any probative value, even if that value is slight, provided it is not outweighed by the risk of unfair prejudice. The ratio decidendi here is that maps and diagrams can be admissible for the limited purpose of assisting the court in understanding the factual context of the case, as long as they do not mislead the court.

The court distinguished this decision from cases where the evidentiary value of a map was deemed to be speculative or where the map was considered to be misleading. It followed the precedent that where a map or diagram is clear and the markings are reliable, it can be a valuable tool in the court's determination of the facts. The court's reasoning demonstrates a balanced approach to the admissibility of evidence, taking into account the potential for prejudice while also valuing the probative assistance that well-marked maps can provide.