De Rose v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

De Rose v State of South Australia [2013] FCA 988

Citation: De Rose v State of South Australia [2013] FCA 988
Parties:

PETER DE ROSE, HUGHIE CULLINAN, TJARUWA ANDERSON AND KARINA LESTER ON BEHALF OF THE DE ROSE HILL COMPENSATION CLAIM GROUP v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA, DE ROSE HILL-ILPALKA ABORIGINAL CORPORATION RNTBC, ICN 4712 and COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

File number: SAD 55 of 2013
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 1 October 2013
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – compensation application – consent determination – consideration of matters relevant to approving proposed determination under s 87(5) Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

NATIVE TITLE – compensation application – consent determination – reasons for order under s 37AG, Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) that amount of compensation not be published

Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13, 20, 50, 51, 51A, 53, 61, 61A, 62, 66, 84A, 87, 87(5), 94
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AG, 38M
Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act (Cth) s 51(xxxi)
Cases cited:

De Rose v South Australia [2002] FCA 1342
De Rose v South Australia (2003) 133 FCR 325
De Rose v South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290
Lander v South Australia [2012] FCA 427
Lovett on behalf of the Gunditjmara People v State of Victoria [2007] FCA 474

Date of hearing: 1 October 2013
Place: Ilpalka
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 84
Counsel for the Applicant: M Pagsanjan
Solicitor for the Applicant: South Australian Native Title Services Ltd
Counsel for the First Respondent: S McCaul and S Hoffmann
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Crown Solicitor’s Office
Counsel for the Second Respondent: M Pagsanjan
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: South Australian Native Title Services Ltd
Counsel for the Intervener: The Intervener did not appear
Solicitor for the Intervener: The Intervener did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 55 of 2013

BETWEEN

PETER DE ROSE, HUGHIE CULLINAN, TJARUWA ANDERSON AND KARINA LESTER ON BEHALF OF THE DE ROSE HILL COMPENSATION CLAIM GROUP
Applicant

AND:

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
First Respondent

DE ROSE HILL-ILPALKA ABORIGINAL CORPORATION RNTBC, ICN 4712
Second Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Intervener

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 OCTOBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

ILPALKA

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

A.On 9 June 2011, the De Rose Hill-Ilpalka Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC ICN 4712 (RNTBC) filed a Compensation Application (No. SAD 140 of 2011) (First Compensation Application) in which it sought a determination of compensation under s 50(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) in respect of compensation payable by the First Respondent for certain acts which had extinguished native title in the areas subject to the native title determination in De Rose Hill v South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290 (De Rose Hill Determination) and in areas that had been excluded from the De Rose Hill Determination because native title had been extinguished in those areas. The First Compensation Application was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Rose v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 988
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of De Rose v State of South Australia, the parties involved were the Nguraritja, represented by the Applicant and the Corporation, and the State of South Australia. The dispute centered around compensation for the extinguishment of native title over certain lands. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the proposed Consent Determination, which included a compensation agreement, should be approved and made into an order. The Consent Determination aimed to settle the compensation claims for the extinguishment of native title by the State of South Australia.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the compensation agreement reached through negotiations was fair, reasonable, and in accordance with the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The Court also had to consider whether the redaction of the compensation amount from the public record was necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. The Court needed to ensure that the compensation amount did not set a precedent or create expectations for other native title compensation claims.

The Court found that the extensive and informed negotiations between the parties, facilitated by Court-ordered mediation, led to a comprehensive agreement. The Court acknowledged the cultural significance of the lands in question to the Nguraritja and considered the importance of the "on-country" mediation sessions. The Court concluded that the compensation agreement discharged all of the State's obligations to the Applicant and the Corporation to date and that the redaction of the compensation amount was necessary to prevent potential prejudice to future negotiations. The Court made orders substantially in accordance with the proposed Consent Determination, with minor drafting alterations, and sealed the unredacted version of the Compensation Agreement to prevent its premature disclosure.

In light of the above, the Court approved the Consent Determination and made orders accordingly, including a redacted copy of the Compensation Agreement in the public record and a sealed, unredacted version for future reference. The orders recognised the cultural significance of the lands and the importance of maintaining confidentiality in the negotiation process to encourage future settlements under the Native Title Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court is satisfied that it is appropriate to make orders in accordance with the proposed Consent Determination. These reasons for judgment explain why it has reached that conclusion.Background The application in which the compensation orders are made was commenced on 19 March 2013. It has a long history. The starting point is an application on behalf of the Nguraritja for a determination of native title pursuant to s 61 of the NTA in Application No SG 6001 of 1996 (the De Rose Hill Native Title Claim). After a lengthy trial and judgment: De Rose v South Australia [2002] FCA 1342 and an appeal: De Rose v South Australia (2003) 133 FCR 325, there was a further evidentiary hearing before the Full Court (the primary judge by then having retired). On 8 June 2005 the Full Court (Wilcox, Sackville and Merkel JJ) determined that the Nguraritja held native title rights and interests over the same area as the “Determination Area” as described in the orders now to be made: De Rose v South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290 (the De Rose Hill Determination). The De Rose Hill Determination excluded those parts of the Determination Area over which extinguishment of native title had occurred, as required by s 61A of the NTA. On 9 June 2011, the Corporation by Application No SAD 140 of 2011 applied to the Federal Court (the First Compensation Application) seeking compensation for acts (as set out in s 20 of the NTA) in the areas subject to the De Rose Hill Native Title Claim together with areas that had been excluded from the De Rose Hill Determination application by reason of the fact that native title had been extinguished in them. Because the Corporation could not validly claim compensation for past extinguishment of native title in land not the subject of the De Rose Hill Determination, the Nguraritja authorised and filed this further Native Title Compensation Application, No. SAD 55 of 2013 (the Second Compensation Application) on 19 March 2013. The Second Compensation Application and the proposed Consent Determination applies to land that, but for prior extinguishment of native title by inconsistent grant, would have been claimed as part of the De Rose Hill Native Title Claim and would likely therefore have formed part of the lands recognised to be the native title lands of the Nguraritja. For the reasons set out below, the Nguraritja are represented by both the Applicant and the Corporation. Negotiations for settlement of the question of compensation between the Nguraritja and the State took place under Court-ordered mediation of the First Compensation Application. Those negotiations related to the entirety of the area covered by the First Compensation Application. Agreement was reached and a Heads of Agreement was signed by the parties on 4 February 2013. That agreement relevantly provided that:… the claimants will accept the settlement sum in full and final settlement of all liability the State may have to them under the Native Title Act for the area of the current compensation claim SAD 140 of 2011.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Schedule 1 to the proposed Consent Determination contains a detailed description of the Determination and Agreement Areas.Conclusion The NTA encourages the resolution by agreement of claims for determinations of native title. For the reasons set out above, in my view it is appropriate to make the orders sought and they should be made in this proceeding. The Orders now made include a redacted copy of the Compensation Agreement in Schedule 3. There is only one redaction, namely the amount of the compensation. I consider that the redaction of that piece of information is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, so as to enliven s 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The disclosure of that figure, where there are presently no decisions addressing in a reasoned way how compensation under the NTA is to be assessed, may create expectations either on the part of other applicants or on the part of other States or Territories in other matters which private consensual agreement should not produce. In addition, the disclosure of that figure may be seen to set a tariff for other compensation claims that it would be quite inappropriate to set as each set of circumstances will necessarily be different. It may therefore impede independent negotiation by the State or by other States or Territories or other compensation claims. Finally, the disclosure of that figure may draw attention to the Nguraritja, and may invite criticism – positive or negative – from other compensation claimants under the NTA in a way which would be unfair. It may also invite criticism – positive or negative – of the State itself. The unfairness would flow from the fact that, as the figure has been agreed in private mediation and negotiations, it is not possible to know the detailed considerations which led to the agreement. All of those factors mean that disclosure of that figure may impede the prospects of satisfactory negotiation of other compensation claims. That would impede and prejudice the proper administration of justice, especially where the NTA encourages the negotiated outcome of applications under it. Order 11 therefore refers to the redacted version of the Compensation Agreement in Schedule 3, and to the unredacted version of the Compensation Agreement which is in a sealed envelope in Schedule 4 with the Orders that it is not to be opened without the leave of the Court. For those reasons, orders are made substantially in accordance with the proposed Consent Determination, with only minor drafting alteration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The State, the Applicant and the Corporation are agreed that the compensation discharges all of the State’s Native Title Compensation obligations to the Applicant and to the Corporation to date. The Agreement does not cover any compensable extinguishment of native title attributable to the State in the period following this determination.Consideration It is important to note the extent of, and the informed nature of, the negotiations leading to the proposed Consent Determination. The State, the Applicant and the Corporation conducted extensive negotiations in Adelaide and on-country. The evidence and negotiations were conducted on a confidential and ‘without prejudice’ basis as part of Court-ordered mediation facilitated by Mr Neal SC, senior counsel with extensive experience in native title matters. Prior to Mr Neal formally convening the mediation, the State and the Applicant in the First Compensation Application filed in Court two documents: a Statement of Agreed Facts and a Further Statement of Agreed Facts. Those documents demonstrated the degree of consensus between the principal parties regarding those acts of extinguishment that were, in principle, compensable by the State. Mediation conferences were held in Adelaide on 26 June 2012 and on-country on 28 and 29 June 2012. In the mediator’s report to the Court dated 3 October 2012, the significance of the on-country mediation is described in the following terms (at [5]-[6]):The two days spent on-country involved various members of the compensation claim group explaining to the State the significance for them of various historical events the effect of which had been to extinguish native title at law. It was agreed between the parties that such presentation by the Applicant would be treated as information for the State to consider. The ultimate legal relevance of such information was a matter about which there was no consensus.In my view, the “on-country” information sessions were conducted admirably on both sides. They undoubtedly ‘brought to life’ particular elements of the compensation claim, the Applicant is contending for and informed subsequent dealings between the parties. The parties to the mediation have agreed to disclose that a number of senior members of the Nguraritja spoke during the on-country mediation about the significance to them of the areas where native title has been extinguished. They refer to De Rose Hill Station as Kalaya (Emu) Country due to the Kalaya Tjukurpa (emu dreaming) that passes through that country. A number of other Tjukurpa, for example, Papa (Dog) and Malu (Kangaroo) also travel within and across the boundaries of De Rose Hill Pastoral Run. The Nguraritja spoke about the Tjukurpa stories associated with each of the areas affected by the extinguishing acts. At all times during the negotiations, the parties were represented by lawyers experienced in the operation of the NTA. It is useful to put into more context the significance to the Nguraritja of the particular areas of land in respect of which, in particular, compensation is to be granted. In doing so, it is also important to note that my comments in [38]-[67] below do not represent an agreed statement of facts, nor do they reflect the position of the State in relation to the issues discussed therein. They reflect the statements made by the members of the compensation claim group during the course of the negotiations and therefore, to some degree, reflect the basis on which those negotiations proceeded. A compromise has been reached between the parties and it has not been necessary for the State to test the statements made by members of the compensation claim group during those negotiations.The Freehold Block