DE PASQUALE v CSR LIMITED & ORS
[2003] SADC 20Judge Lowrie
Civil
In September 1998 the plaintiff, Daniel De Pasquale, commenced proceedings in this court against CSR Limited (“CSR”) as the first defendant and CSR Humes Pty Ltd (“Humes”) as the second defendant alleging that at all material times he was an employee of Select Staff Pty Ltd (“Select”) whose business was to provide labour to both the first and/or second defendants and in the period May to September 1995 Select provided the plaintiff’s services to the first and second defendants. During the course of this employment in September 1995 the plaintiff suffered a work injury which the plaintiff alleged arose because of the negligent work practices of the defendants.
The defendants subsequently appeared and denied the relevant allegations of negligence.
On 7 February 2000 the plaintiff commenced a further action being number 207 of 2000 against Select in effect reiterating the material allegations that he had made in the prior action, and, then alleging that Select was in breach of the duty of care that it owed to the plaintiff in and about allowing him to perform the labouring duties with Humes.
On 8 May 2001 Master Norman made an order consolidating the actions and directed that the original action was to have the carriage of the proceedings.
Following this consolidation there have been considerable contested interlocutory matters.
An issue that arose in the defendant’s pleadings was the allegation:
“.... that the plaintiff was its employee of the second defendant by implication attending either at common law or pursuant to the provisions of section 3 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986’.”
Section 54(1) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1987 provides that “.... no liability attaches to an employer in respect of a compensable disability arising from employment by that employer....”. In effect CSR was claiming statutory immunity.
No doubt this pleading caused much concern to the plaintiff who at all times believed he was an employee of Select, which Select at all times, had acknowledged. Consequently, the plaintiff then commenced action number 207 of 2000 against Select.
At that time the legal debate was ongoing concerning the position of what I would refer to as “hire” and “host” firm liability for an employee. Although there are some decisions in point the legal debate was continuing. I refer to York Civil Pty Ltd v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation [1998] SAWCT 30 and on appeal [1999] SASC 173; Mason & Cox Pty Ltd v McCann (1999) 74 SASR 438; McMahon Services Pty Ltd v Cox (2001) 78 SASR 540. One can appreciate the plaintiff’s dilemma with both the hire and host firms claiming immunity. These matters were pre-eminent in the reasoning of the learned Master when he made the order consolidating the proceedings, and, directing that the principal action carry the relevant documentation.
On 10 October 2001, the WorkCover Corporation filed an application seeking leave to intervene in the proceedings. It…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read De Pasquale v Csr Limited & Ors No. DCCIV-98-1256 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SADC 20
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the Master's decision to order the defendants to pay WorkCover's costs of intervention was a wrongful exercise of discretion. The defendants argued that the Master's decision was erroneous, as the pleadings indicated that Select Staff Pty Ltd was the employer, and WorkCover had received levies from Select Staff Pty Ltd and paid the plaintiff based on this understanding. The plaintiff's counsel argued that the Master's decision was proper, as CSR had maintained its position that it was the employer for an extended period, causing concern for the plaintiff and WorkCover. The court needed to determine whether the Master's decision to order the defendants to pay WorkCover's costs of intervention was a proper exercise of discretion.
The court found that the Master's decision to order the defendants to pay WorkCover's costs of intervention was a proper exercise of discretion. The court noted that the defendants had maintained their position that they were the employer for an extended period, which caused concern for the plaintiff and WorkCover. The court also pointed out that the defendants did not oppose WorkCover's intervention in the proceedings. The court believed that the Master had exercised his discretion in a proper manner in ordering the defendants to pay WorkCover's costs of intervention. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellants to pay the respondent's costs of the matter.
In conclusion, the court held that the Master's decision to order the defendants to pay WorkCover's costs of intervention was a proper exercise of discretion, given that CSR had maintained its position that it was the employer for an extended period. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellants to pay the respondent's costs of the matter.