De Los Santos-Aguilar and Migration Agents Registration Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

De Los Santos-Aguilar and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2016] AATA 295 (9 May 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/0988

Re

Maria Luisa De Los Santos-Aguilar

APPLICANT

And

Migration Agents Registration Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A C Cotter

Date 9 May 2016
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed

.............................[sgd]................................

Senior Member A C Cotter

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION AGENT REGISTRATION – Regulation of migration agents - Fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance – whether breaches of code of conduct – whether penalty excessive – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 278, 280, 287, 290, 303, 312, 314

Migration Agents Regulations 1998 (Cth) reg 3, sch 2

CASES

Allinson v General Council of Medical Education and Registration [1984] 1 QB 750

Cunliffe v Commonwealth (1994) 182 CLR 272
McBride v Walton [1994] NSWCA 199
Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of NSW v Da Rocha [2013] NSWCA 151

Re Peng and Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1998] AATA 12

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Macquarie Dictionary (rev 6th ed, Macquarie Dictionary Publishers Pty Ltd, 2013)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A C Cotter

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mrs Maria Luisa de Los Santos-Aguilar (“Mrs Aguilar”) was first registered as a migration agent on 9 October 2001. Her registration was renewed annually, with her most recent registration having commenced on 11 April 2012.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 2, page 5, Decision Record dated 28 February 2013, [2].

  2. At all relevant times, Mrs Aguilar operated her business as a migration agent under the name “MLA Migration Consultancy” (“MLA”).

  3. In April 2004, Mrs Aguilar’s husband, Martin, also became registered as a migration agent. When he first registered as a migration agent, Mr Aguilar disclosed that he proposed to give immigration assistance as an employee of another individual, nominating MLA as the business under which his employer’s business would be operating.[2] His notice of intention to register as a migration agent likewise indicated that he would be employed by MLA.[3] On renewing his registration the following year, Mr Aguilar indicated that he proposed to give immigration assistance as “an employee or consultant or independent contractor” of another individual, again nominating MLA as the relevant business name.[4] For his 2006 and 2007 repeat registrations,[5] he again described himself as an employee operating under the MLA name, while in 2008 he described himself as a “consultant” to MLA.[6] His 2009 Application for Repeat Registration stated that he proposed giving immigration assistance as an employee, consultant or independent contractor of another individual, again naming MLA.[7] Mr Aguilar did not apply for repeat registration in 2010 and was automatically deregistered as a migration agent on 28 May 2010.[8]

    [2] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 21, page 220, Mr Aguilar’s Application for Registration dated 15 December 2003.

    [3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 21, page 227, Mr Aguilar’s Notice of Intent to Register as a Migration Agent.

    [4] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 22, page 231, Mr Aguilar’s Application for Repeat Registration dated 31 March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Los Santos-Aguilar and Migration Agents Registration Auth... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar against a decision by the Migration Agents Registration Authority (the Authority) to refuse her registration as a migration agent. The Authority's decision was based on findings that Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar was not a person of integrity and was not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance, due to breaches of the Code of Conduct for Migration Agents. The primary dispute revolved around whether Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar was responsible for the conduct of her husband, Mr Aguilar, who provided immigration assistance under her business name. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine the extent of Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's responsibility for Mr Aguilar's actions and whether her conduct, and that of Mr Aguilar acting on her behalf, constituted breaches of the Code of Conduct.

The Tribunal was tasked with determining several key legal issues. Firstly, it had to ascertain whether Mr Aguilar was an employee of Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar or an independent contractor, and the implications of this relationship for Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's liability. Secondly, the Tribunal needed to decide whether Mr Aguilar provided immigration advice on behalf of Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's registered migration business. Thirdly, and crucially, the Tribunal had to assess whether Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's overall conduct, including her alleged failure to adequately supervise Mr Aguilar, her provision of inconsistent information to the Authority, and deficiencies in her practice management, demonstrated a lack of integrity and rendered her unfit and improper to provide immigration assistance.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered the regulatory regime governing migration agents and their specific obligations. It analysed the indicia for determining an employment relationship, as outlined by the Australian Taxation Office, to assess whether Mr Aguilar was an employee or an independent contractor. Despite arguments that Mr Aguilar operated independently, the Tribunal found evidence of delegation of work from Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar to Mr Aguilar, suggesting he undertook work at her direction and under her control. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Aguilar held himself out as acting on behalf of Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's business, and she was aware of this and failed to implement effective controls. Consequently, the Tribunal found sufficient evidence to establish that Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar breached the Code of Conduct, including clause 9.1, and that her conduct, along with Mr Aguilar's actions on her behalf, demonstrated a lack of integrity and fitness to provide immigration assistance.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning Mrs De Los Santos-Aguilar's registration as a migration agent was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is affirmed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I therefore consider there is sufficient evidence to support a breach of clause 9.1 of the Code.Breach of Code of Conduct – Conclusion Having regard to the matters set out above, I consider there is sufficient evidence to establish that Mrs Aguilar breached the Code of Conduct in a number of respects.Did Mr Aguilar provide advice on behalf of MLA? In light of my comments above, it is clear that Mr Aguilar held himself out as acting on behalf of MLA and that he had the necessary authority to speak for, and bind, that firm. Mrs Aguilar was well aware that he was holding himself out and did nothing to discourage or dissuade him from doing so. Nor did she put in place any effective controls over his “use” of the structure. She was also well aware of his assuming the role as a partner from the commencement of her previous period of suspension; he was to effectively carry on the business as proprietor during her suspension. It follows from what I have said that Mr Aguilar did provide advice on behalf of MLA. I therefore do not accept the second of Mrs Aguilar’s submissions.Is Mrs Aguilar a person of integrity and a fit and proper person to give immigration advice?The Authority’s findings The Authority’s delegate concluded, having regard to the totality of Mrs Aguilar’s conduct, that she was not a person of integrity or was otherwise not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance. In particular, the delegate was satisfied that Mrs Aguilar:(a)failed to have due regard to Ms Egnalig’s dependence on her knowledge as a registered migration agent by failing to adequately respond to Ms Egnalig despite being made aware of the subject matter of the allegations against Mr Aguilar (which resulted in substantial financial loss, emotional distress and no visa outcome); (b)provided inconsistent and contradictory information to the Authority about her employment arrangements with Mr Aguilar in order to distance herself from her responsibilities in relation to the matter the subject of the complaint;(c)failed to respond to the Authority’s requests for information and to provide documents, hindering the Authority’s investigations of the complaint in a timely manner; (d)put customers at risk by failing to exercise effective control over her migration practice by not implementing a proper accounting system in relation to the management of client monies and a file management system;(e)engaged in a pattern of conduct over a lengthy period of time, particularly in relation to record-keeping and account-keeping deficiencies in her practice;(f)acted in a manner, both towards Mrs Egnalig and the Authority, which other registered migration agents of good repute and competency would regard as disgraceful or dishonourable, and in so doing, displayed a disregard or indifference to the regulatory framework; and(g)acted in a manner which damaged the reputation and integrity of the profession.[72][72] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 2, pages 31-32, Decision Record dated 28 February 2013, [137]-[138].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I deal with each of those submissions below.CONSIDERATIONWas Mrs Aguilar responsible for Mr Aguilar’s conduct? The primary focus of Mrs Aguilar was establishing that, at the material time, her husband was not an employee of MLA and indeed, was an independent contractor over whom she had no control and for whose conduct she bore no responsibility. Notwithstanding that particular consideration, it is also important not to lose sight of the regulatory regime which governs the way migration agents operate, and the specific obligations cast upon them.Was Mr Aguilar an employee? In asserting that Mr Aguilar was not an employee of MLA but rather an independent contractor, Mrs Aguilar’s counsel undertook an analysis of the relationship using the online guide developed by the Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) for determining whether workers are employees or contactors. Essentially, that guide sets out six indicia which, taken together, are used to determine whether a worker is an employee or a contractor for taxation purposes. They are: the worker’s ability to subcontract or delegate; the basis of payment; whether the worker uses their own equipment or tools or whether they are supplied for them; whether the worker assumes any commercial risk for the work undertaken; whether the principal has a right to direct the way in which the worker does their work; and, whether the worker operates independently of the business. In asserting that Mr Aguilar was in fact an independent contractor and not an employee, Mrs Aguilar’s counsel highlighted the following matters:(a)Mr Aguilar was able to conduct his own business on his own terms and was paid a fixed fee for his service. He operated as a subcontractor to MLA and also conducted his own business, Urlink, when based in the Philippines. It is said that Mrs Aguilar never delegated any of her work to him.(b)Mr Aguilar’s fees were charged on a fixed rate for the work he performed on a subcontract basis for MLA; he was not paid on a time or on a commission basis.(c)As they were husband and wife, it made sense for Mr and Mrs Aguilar to share resources, such as premises, systems, the MLA “business vehicle”, and their professional indemnity insurance. (d)Mr and Mrs Aguilar were each responsible for their own commercial risks.(e)Each of them had total control over their individual work; Mr Aguilar did not seek, nor was provided, direction from Mrs Aguilar, as he ran his own operation.(f)They operated independently of each other, except on occasions when it was implausible and not commercially sensible to operate independently. Sometimes, they undertook work for each other’s clients when the other was unavailable.[27][27] Ibid [5]. Before proceeding further, I pause to reflect on that analysis. First, despite the statement to the contrary, it seems apparent that there was at least some delegation of work from Mrs Aguilar to her husband. While Mr Aguilar may not normally have provided advice directly to Mrs Aguilar’s clients, it is clear that he nevertheless undertook “administrative, migration research and assistance in the submission and application preparation”.[28] In other words, he undertook some work for Mrs Aguilar, presumably at her direction and under her control. [28] See Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 7, page 98, statutory declaration of Mrs Aguilar declared 5 August 2011.