DBR16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DBR16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2018] FCCA 1181
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Review of decision by Immigration Assessment Authority – whether Immigration Assessment Authority’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority properly considered whether exceptional circumstances existed in relation to new information provided by the applicant – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority properly considered all the applicant’s claims – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.5, 31, 36, 65, 474, 476, 473BA, 473BC, 473CA, 473CB, 473CC, 473DA, 473DB, 473DC, 473DD
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), reg.2.01, sch.1

Treaties:

Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, opened for signature 28 July 1951, 189 UNTS 137 (entered into force 22 April 1954), Art 1A
Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, opened for signature 31 January 1967 (entered into force 4 October 1967)

Cases Cited:
BVZJ 6 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 958
Applicant: DBR16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
File Number: SYG 2846 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge Emmett
Hearing date: 10 May 2018
Date of Last Submission: 10 May 20118
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 10 May 2018

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Ms Elodie Cheesman, Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Ashok Kumar
FEDERAL CIRCUIT
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 2846 of 2016

DBR16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

EX TEMPORE

  1. On 26 September 2016 the applicant filed an application in this court for judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (“Authority”) which had affirmed a decision of a delegate of the First Respondent (“the Delegate”) to refuse to grant the applicant a Temporary Protection visa (“TPV”).

  2. The background, the applicant’s claims and the Authority’s findings are summarised in the written submissions of the First Respondent as follows:

    “Background

    4. The applicant is a citizen of Sri Lanka who arrived in Australia on 17 September 2012. On 30 September 2015 he lodged an application for a TPV. On 1 August 2016, the Delegate refused to grant the TPV. On 26 September 2016, the IAA affirmed the Delegate's decision.

    5. On 18 October 2016, the applicant commenced the current proceedings.

    The applicant's claims

    6. The applicant is a Tamil Hindu from the Jaffna district, northern province, Sri Lanka. The applicant claimed to fear harm arising from:

    (a) disputes he had with the Sri Lankan Anny (SLA) arising from their reclaiming, and occupation of his land;

    (b) his Tamil ethnicity; and

    (c) as a failed asylum seeker returning illegally from Sri Lanka.

    7. The applicant claimed to fear harm from the SLA, the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) and the Sri Lankan authorities.

    The IAA' s findings

    New information

    8. The IAA noted that it received a submission and further information from the applicant's representative…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DBR16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 1181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of Sri Lanka, sought judicial review of a decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) affirming the refusal of a Temporary Protection Visa. The applicant claimed to fear harm due to his Tamil ethnicity, disputes with the Sri Lankan Army over land reclamation, and his status as a failed asylum seeker returning illegally. The IAA had considered the applicant's claims and the available country information, ultimately finding that he did not face a real chance of persecution or significant harm upon return to Sri Lanka.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the IAA had properly considered the applicant's claims for protection, including those related to his ethnicity, land seizure, and status as a failed asylum seeker. Specifically, the court was required to determine if the IAA had erred in its assessment of the evidence, including the applicant's credibility and the relevance of new information provided. The court also had to consider whether the IAA had adequately addressed the applicant's claims for complementary protection.

Emmett J found that the IAA had conducted a comprehensive review of the applicant's claims, referencing relevant country information and making detailed findings of fact. The IAA had specifically addressed the applicant's concerns regarding his ethnicity, the seizure of his land by the Sri Lankan Army, and the consequences of his illegal departure and status as a failed asylum seeker. The court noted that the IAA had found inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence regarding his land seizure claims and had rejected certain aspects of his account as fabrications. The IAA concluded that while the applicant might face some processing and detention upon return, this would not amount to significant harm or persecution under the Act. The court also considered the provisions of Part 7AA of the Act concerning fast track review decisions and the material that must be provided to the IAA, finding that the IAA had acted within its statutory framework.

The application for judicial review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The background, the applicant’s claims and the Authority’s findings are summarised in the written submissions of the First Respondent as follows:“Background4. The applicant is a citizen of Sri Lanka who arrived in Australia on 17 September 2012. On 30 September 2015 he lodged an application for a TPV. On 1 August 2016, the Delegate refused to grant the TPV. On 26 September 2016, the IAA affirmed the Delegate's decision.5. On 18 October 2016, the applicant commenced the current proceedings.The applicant's claims6. The applicant is a Tamil Hindu from the Jaffna district, northern province, Sri Lanka. The applicant claimed to fear harm arising from:(a) disputes he had with the Sri Lankan Anny (SLA) arising from their reclaiming, and occupation of his land;(b) his Tamil ethnicity; and(c) as a failed asylum seeker returning illegally from Sri Lanka.7. The applicant claimed to fear harm from the SLA, the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) and the Sri Lankan authorities.The IAA' s findingsNew information8. The IAA noted that it received a submission and further information from the applicant's representative on 1 September 2016. To the extent the submission discussed material which was before the Delegate and responded to the Delegate's decision based on that material, the IAA considered that this did not constitute new information and had regard to it. To the extent the submission consisted of references to articles and reports not before the Delegate, the IAA found that s 473DD(b) of the Act was not satisfied because the applicant did not provide any explanation as to why the new information:(i) was not, and could not have been provided to the Delegate; or(ii) why it may be regarded as credible personal information that was not known, and had it been known, may have affected the consideration of the applicant's claims.9. The IAA considered the two untranslated documents provided by the applicant and described in the submission as "immigration documents in relation to the applicants eldest son in France". The IAA noted the applicant's submissions that: the Delegate failed to realistically consider why one of the applicant's sons had fled Sri Lanka and was currently seeking protection in France; the applicant had not had an opportunity to explain and give evidence in regard to this matter; and the information was credible personal information which was not previously known.10. The IAA examined the two documents, and concluded that in their untranslated state they did not assist it in determining whether there were any protection claims by the applicant's son, and only appeared to confirm that he was in France. It was not satisfied that there were exceptional circumstances that justified it considering that information.Findings of fact11. The IAA accepted that:(a) the applicant is a Tamil and Hindu from the Jaffna District, Northern Province of Sri Lanka;(b) having regard to country information, part of the applicant's land was seized by the SLA during the war to form part of the SLA camp at Allarai and that land was still held by the SLA;(c) the applicant's eldest son was in France. However, the IAA did not accept that his son left Sri Lanka due to the CID looking for the applicant;(d) based on the applicant's evidence, his wife was not involved in any action in the District Court in Sri Lanka concerning the sale of his land; and(e) the applicant would be considered an illegal departee and failed asylum seeker on return to Sri Lanka.12. On the evidence before it, the IAA had serious concerns about the credibility of the applicant and the truthfulness of his evidence relating to the seizure of his land by the SLA, noting in particular the inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence as to: where his family was living; the parts of his land alleged to have been reclaimed by the SLA and the dates when it was reclaimed; and what occurred when the applicant was allegedly detained on 5 and 22 August 2012.13. The IAA also noted that the applicant changed his evidence many times as to when he asked for his land back, where he was living at the relevant time, and made exaggerated claims. The IAA rejected as fabrications that:(a) the applicant approached the SLA camp to request the return of his land;(b) the applicant was beaten by the commander of the SLA camp sometime in early August 2012;(c) the CID visited his house in August 2012; and (d) the CID subsequently visited his family seeking the applicant's whereabouts.Refugee claims14. After considering the applicant's evidence and the country information, the IAA was not satisfied that the applicant faced a real chance of persecution now or in the reasonably foreseeable future for any of the claimed reasons.15. Tamil male from the North, and imputed political opinion: The IAA referred to country information indicating that monitoring in the north and east of Sri Lanka had significantly decreased and the situation had generally improved for Tamils. It referred to a DFAT report indicating that there was a moderate level of societal discrimination between ethnic groups resulting largely from the war. However, it also observed that the applicant was living in Jaffna and, despite the SLA seizing part of his land during the war, was able to support himself and his family by working as a farmer and labourer until he left Sri Lanka. It concluded that there was not a real chance that the applicant would, as a Tamil male from the north, face serious harm upon his return to Sri Lanka, now or in the reasonable future.16. The IAA also noted that the applicant did not claim, and it accepted, that he did not have any actual or perceived link to the LTTE (which on the country information might have given rise to a need for international refugee protection). It also noted that while the Jaffna district was, for a time during the war, controlled by the LTTE, mere residence in a former LITE-controlled area does not give rise to a need for protection. The IAA concluded that the applicant was never involved in any adverse incidents with the Sri Lankan authorities, including the SLA, and that he did not have a profile that country information suggested would give rise to a risk to harm. The IAA did not accept that the authorities or current SLA would have any adverse interest in the applicant on his return.17. Land seizure claims: Although the I.AA did not accept that the applicant approached the SLA camp for the return of his land prior to his departure from Sri Lanka, it was prepared to accept that he may seek the land back from the SLA if he were to return to Sri Lanka. However, based on the Sri Lankan government's policy of returning some land held by the military and the availability of legal avenues to challenge seized land, the IAA found that the chance that the applicant would experience any harm for asking for his land back now, or in the reasonably foreseeable future would be remote.18. Failed asylum seeker and illegal departure from Sri Lanka: The IAA referred to country information outlining the procedures adopted by the SLA upon the return of citizens of Sri Lanka, and the penalties for offences under the Immigrants and Emigrants Act 1949 (IE Act). It accepted that the applicant, if returned to Sri Lanka: (i) would face action under the IE Act; (ii) was likely to be detained and questioned at the airport, possibly up to 24 hours, before being taken by the police to the nearest Magistrates Court; (iii) once before the court, and if not dealt with on the spot (if the applicant were to plead guilty) would ordinarily be released unconditionally or be bailed to return to court at a later date; and (iv) if a magistrate was not available, for example due to the weekend or a public holiday, the applicant could be held in a nearby prison for a short time. The IAA concluded, having regard to the applicant’s risk profile that there was not a real · chance that he would face serious harm on return to Sri Lanka as a person who departed Sri Lanka illegally.19. Even having regard to the generally poor prison conditions, the IAA did not consider that a brief period of 1 to 3 days in detention would constitute a necessary level of threat to his life or liberty or to significant physical harassment or ill treatment under section 5J(5) of the Act or otherwise to amount to serious harm to the applicant. Similarly, whether considered separately or together with a brief period of detention, the IAA did not consider any likely questioning of the applicant by any of the authorities, including the CID, at the airport on arrival, any surety imposed, or the imposition of a fine under the IE Act, to constitute a threat to his life or liberty, or to be significant physical harm or ill treatment under section 5J(5) of the Act or otherwise amount to serious harm. The IAA also found that the evidence did not support a conclusion that the IE Act was selectively enforced. It found that the investigation, prosecution and punishment of the applicant under the IE Act would be the result of a law of general application and did not amount to persecution for the purpose of section 5H(l) and 5J(l) of the Act.20. Considering the applicant's circumstances as a whole, the IAA was not satisfied that he faced a real chance of persecution now, or in the reasonably foreseeable future, whether because of his illegal departure, having made a claim for asylum in Australia, as a person who may seek the return of land held by the SLA, or as a Tamil male from the north, or any combination of those factors.Complementary protection claims21. The IAA then considered each of the applicant's claims by reference to the complementary protection criteria. It was satisfied that none of those claims gave rise to a real risk that the applicant would suffer significant harm for the purposes of the Act. In particular, the IAA was not satisfied that the applicant would face a real risk of significant harm during any questioning and processing at the airport or during a brief period of detention. Having regard to its acceptance that the applicant may face some level of societal discrimination as a Tamil male from the north, it specifically found that such discrimination as the applicant may face did not amount to significant harm as defined in sections 36(2A) and 5 of the Act.”(Footnotes Omitted)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Part 7AA of the Act provides for a limited form of review of certain decisions (“fast track decisions”). Under Part 7AA, s.473BA of the Act provides as follows:“Simplified outline of this PartThis Part provides a limited form of review of certain decisions (fast track decisions) to refuse protection visas to some applicants, including unauthorised maritime arrivals who entered Australia on or after 13 August 2012, but before 1 January 2014, and who have not been taken to a regional processing country. These applicants are known as fast track review applicants and decisions to refuse to grant them protection visas are known as fast track reviewable decisions.Fast track decisions made in relation to some applicants are excluded from the fast track review process. These applicants are known as excluded fast track review applicants. Fast track review applicants and excluded fast track review applicants are collectively known as fast track applicants. …” Under s.473BC of the Act, the Minister may determine that a specified fast track decision, or a specified class of fast track decisions, may be reviewed. Pursuant to s.473CA of the Act, the Minister must refer a fast track reviewable decision to the Authority as soon as reasonably practicable after the decision is made. Under s.474(2) of the Act, a decision of the second respondent is a “privative clause decision”. Under s.474(1)(a) of the Act, a privative clause decision is final and conclusive. However, a purported decision of the second respondent which is affected by jurisdictional error is not a decision which is made under the Act and therefore is not a privative clause decision (see Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth (2003) 211 CLR 476). Section 473CB of the Act sets out the material that must be provided to the Authority by the Department when a decision is referred for review:“Material to be provided to Immigration Assessment Authority(1) The Secretary must give to the Immigration Assessment Authority the following material (review material) in respect of each fast track reviewable decision referred to the Authority under section 473CA:(a) a statement that:(i) sets out the findings of fact made by the person who made the decision; and(ii) refers to the evidence on which those findings were based; and(iii) gives the reasons for the decision;(b) material provided by the referred applicant to the person making the decision before the decision was made;(c) any other material that is in the Secretary's possession or control and is considered by the Secretary (at the time the decision is referred to the Authority) to be relevant to the review;(d) the following details:(i) the last address for service provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(ii) the last residential or business address provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(iii) the last fax number, email address or other electronic address provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(iv) if an address or fax number mentioned in subparagraph (i), (ii) or (iii) has not been provided to the Minister by the referred applicant, or if the Minister reasonably believes that the last such address or number provided to the Minister is no longer correct--such an address or number (if any) that the Minister reasonably believes to be correct at the time the decision is referred to the Authority;(v) if the referred applicant is a minor--the last address or fax number of a kind mentioned in subparagraph (i), (ii), (iii) or (iv) (if any) for a carer of the minor.(2) The Secretary must give the review material to the Immigration Assessment Authority at the same time as, or as soon as reasonably practicable after, the decision is referred to the Authority.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 473CB of the Act sets out the material that must be provided to the Authority by the Department when a decision is referred for review:“Material to be provided to Immigration Assessment Authority(1) The Secretary must give to the Immigration Assessment Authority the following material (review material) in respect of each fast track reviewable decision referred to the Authority under section 473CA:(a) a statement that:(i) sets out the findings of fact made by the person who made the decision; and(ii) refers to the evidence on which those findings were based; and(iii) gives the reasons for the decision;(b) material provided by the referred applicant to the person making the decision before the decision was made;(c) any other material that is in the Secretary's possession or control and is considered by the Secretary (at the time the decision is referred to the Authority) to be relevant to the review;(d) the following details:(i) the last address for service provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(ii) the last residential or business address provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(iii) the last fax number, email address or other electronic address provided to the Minister by the referred applicant for the purposes of receiving documents;(iv) if an address or fax number mentioned in subparagraph (i), (ii) or (iii) has not been provided to the Minister by the referred applicant, or if the Minister reasonably believes that the last such address or number provided to the Minister is no longer correct--such an address or number (if any) that the Minister reasonably believes to be correct at the time the decision is referred to the Authority;(v) if the referred applicant is a minor--the last address or fax number of a kind mentioned in subparagraph (i), (ii), (iii) or (iv) (if any) for a carer of the minor.(2) The Secretary must give the review material to the Immigration Assessment Authority at the same time as, or as soon as reasonably practicable after, the decision is referred to the Authority.” Pursuant to s.473CC(1) of the Act, the Authority must review a fast track reviewable decision referred to it under s.473CA of the Act. Section 473CC(2) provides that the Authority may either affirm the decision under review, or remit the decision for reconsideration. The requirements of the natural justice rule are exhaustively set out in Subdivision A, Division 3 of Part 7AA of the Act (s.473DA). That section provides as follows:“Exhaustive statement of natural justice hearing rule(1) This Division, together with sections 473GA and 473GB, is taken to be an exhaustive statement of the requirements of the natural justice hearing rule in relation to reviews conducted by the Immigration Assessment Authority.(2) To avoid doubt, nothing in this Part requires the Immigration Assessment Authority to give to a referred applicant any material that was before the Minister when the Minister made the decision under section 65.”