Dawson v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Dawson v Public Trustee of Queensland [2025] QSC 115

PARTIES:

CHRISTINE MAREE DAWSON

(applicant)

v

PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND

(first defendant)

AND
CW HOOPER PTY LTD ACN 602 732 409
(second defendant)
AND
JOANNE MARGARET DAWSON
(third defendant)
AND
NEIL ROBERT BLEE
(fourth defendant)
AND
DEBORAH KAREN BLEE
(fifth defendant)
AND
DAVID WILLIAMS
(sixth defendant)
AND
ZACK MACKAY
(seventh defendant)
AND
JASON KERNAGHAN

(eighth defendant)

FILE NO:

SC No. 5 of 2024

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Maryborough

DELIVERED ON:

23 May 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

31 March 2025

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDERS:

1. Pursuant to r 69(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999:

(a)     “Public Trustee of Queensland” be substituted for the first defendant; and

(b)     “CW Hooper Pty Ltd ACN 602 732 409” be substituted for the second defendant.

2.    In respect of the application of the first defendant:

(a)     The Claim against the first defendant is set aside;

(b)     Paragraphs 3(a) to (h) of the Statement of Claim are struck out;

(c)     The first defendant may file and serve written submissions on its entitlement to costs, given the overruling by the High Court of the Chorley principle by 4 pm on 30 May 2025.

3.    In respect of the application of the second defendant:

(a)     The Claim against the second defendant is set aside;

(b)     Paragraphs 4(a) to (e) of the Statement of Claim are struck out;

(c)     The second defendant may file and serve written submissions on its entitlement to costs, given the overruling by the High Court of the Chorley principle by 4 pm on 30 May 2025.

4.    The plaintiff may file and serve any submissions on costs in reply by 4pm on 5 June 2025.

5.    The question of costs will be determined on any written submissions received without further oral hearing.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – STRIKING OUT – DISCLOSING NO REASONABLE CAUSE OF ACTION OR DEFENCE – where the plaintiff brought a claim against the first and second defendants for various relief relating to a property previously owned by a member of the plaintiff’s family – where the claim identified the first and second defendants incorrectly – whether the first and second applicant should be substituted as the first and second defendants – where the plaintiff seeks relief from the first and second defendants which is unidentifiable or unclear – where the statement of claim fails to articulate a cause of action against the first and second defendants – whether the plaintiff’s claim as against the first and second defendants should be set aside – whether the statement of claim as is relates to the first and second defendants should be struck out

Public Trustee Act 1978
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), rr 8, 16, 171

Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow (2019) 269 CLR 333; [2019] HCA 29, cited
Birketu Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dawson v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Dawson v Public Trustee of Queensland, Christine Maree Dawson brought a claim against eight defendants, including the Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd, relating to a property in Gayndah, Queensland. The plaintiff sought various forms of relief, including the handover of a trust, recovery of possession of the property, damages for eviction, compensation from the trust, and immediate use of the trust. The claim against the Public Trustee specifically included orders for handover of a trust, recovery of possession, damages, and compensation. The Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd brought applications to have the claims against them set aside and the relevant paragraphs of the statement of claim struck out, arguing that the claims were unclear, failed to articulate a cause of action, and disclosed no reasonable grounds for proceeding.

The court had to determine whether the first and second defendants should be substituted in the claim, and whether the claims against them should be set aside and the relevant paragraphs struck out. The court also had to consider the entitlement to costs, given the overruling by the High Court of the Chorley principle. The court found that the claims against the Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd were unclear and failed to articulate a cause of action. The court set aside the claims against the Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd, struck out the relevant paragraphs of the statement of claim, and allowed them to file and serve written submissions on their entitlement to costs.

The court made orders substituting the Public Trustee of Queensland for the first defendant and CW Hooper Pty Ltd for the second defendant. The claims against the Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd were set aside, and the relevant paragraphs of the statement of claim were struck out. The Public Trustee and CW Hooper Pty Ltd were allowed to file and serve written submissions on their entitlement to costs, and the plaintiff was allowed to file and serve any submissions on costs in reply. The question of costs would be determined on the written submissions received without further oral hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 69(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999:

(a) “Public Trustee of Queensland” be substituted for the first defendant; and

(b) “CW Hooper Pty Ltd ACN 602 732 409” be substituted for the second defendant.

2. In respect of the application of the first defendant:

(a) The Claim against the first defendant is set aside;

(b) Paragraphs 3(a) to (h) of the Statement of Claim are struck out;

(c) The first defendant may file and serve written submissions on its entitlement to costs, given the overruling by the High Court of the Chorley principle by 4 pm on 30 May 2025.

3. In respect of the application of the second defendant:

(a) The Claim against the second defendant is set aside;

(b) Paragraphs 4(a) to (e) of the Statement of Claim are struck out;

(c) The second defendant may file and serve written submissions on its entitlement to costs, given the overruling by the High Court of the Chorley principle by 4 pm on 30 May 2025.

4. The plaintiff may file and serve any submissions on costs in reply by 4pm on 5 June 2025.

5. The question of costs will be determined on any written submissions received without further oral hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

Each of the first and second defendants bring applications seeking various relief, the effect of which is to conclude the proceedings against them.Background The plaintiff, Christine Maree Dawson, brought a claim against eight defendants. From what can be discerned from the Claim and Statement of Claim, the action concerns a property at 145 The Limits Road, Gayndah, Queensland, which forms part of her father’s estate, and which was ultimately sold to the fourth and fifth defendants, Neil Robert Blee and Deborah Karen Blee. The Claim against the Public Trustee is framed in these terms:“The plaintiff claims:First Defendant: Public Trustee Brisbane1.An order for the handover of a trust including a wage belonging to the Plaintiffs grandfather: Percy Schroder – Schroder & Sons Laidley which the Plaintiff believes she is a sole beneficiary of.2.An order for recovery of possession of the property at 145 The Limits Road, Gayndah Qld 4625. Described as Lot 255 on CPMZ510 Title Reference 12815079 and its contents sold unlawfully by Joanne Dawson to the Blees in February 2023.3.Damages for allowing the sale of the property causing the eviction of the Plaintiff who has every legal right to live on the property according to her fathers will.4.Compensation from the trust dating back to 2007 when the Plaintiff worked out the riddle.5.An order for immediate use of the trust while its being sorted out.6.Costs.7.Such Further orders as this Honourable Court deems fit.”[1][1]Reproduced faithfully, notwithstanding obvious errors. The Statement of Claim asserts that Ms Dawson is the true owner of the “The Limits Road” property and has a right to possession.[2] [2]Statement of Claim, paragraphs 2(a) and (b). Against the Public Trustee, the Statement of Claim alleges:“3. FIRST DEFENDANTS – PUBLIC TRUSTEE BRISBANE(a)The First Defendants failed to stop Joanne Dawson from selling the property illegally to the Fourth and Fifth Defendants, the Blees. All parties knowing that the property is in a trust.(b)The First Defendants allowed the Blees to clear and burn land on which the property sits illegally.(c)The First Defendants allowed the Blees to enter my home by not stopping the sale. In doing this inherited estate and the Plaintiffs personal belongings were turfed out in the weather.(d)The First Defendants have allowed the Blees to have evicted from the property in which I’m legally allowed to be on.(e)The First Defendants have allowed the continued possession of the property by the Blees. In doing so have caused the Plaintiff continuing loss and damage by not being able to access her inherited estate and personal belongings plus animals as well as depriving her of a residence.(f)The First Defendants have failed to look after the trust which belongs to the Plaintiffs grandfather and the property at Gayndah. Under the Trust Act the Plaintiff is allowed to access the trust if she believes she is a sole beneficiary.(g)The Plaintiff wishes to access the trust immediately while this is being sorted out so she has appropriate accommodation for her and her animals. Either by evicting the Blees immediately, paying for property elsewhere or accessing Yaringa at Cairns immediately.(h)The Plaintiff also wishes to access money from the trust immediately till this is sorted out and wants the compensation package that was asked to be put away for her dating back to 2007.”[3][3]Reproduced faithfully, notwithstanding obvious errors.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established