~~ • ~ . ,,~;.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No Sll0 of 1986 B e t w e e n -
LOUIS EDWARD DAVIS,
ALLAN SANTO and
ERNIE CREIGHTON
Plaintiffs
and
THE COMMONw'EALTH OF AUSTRALIA
First Defendant
THE AUSTRALIAN BICENTENNIAL
AUTHORITY
Second Defendant
Demurrer
MASON CJ
| Davis |
WILSON J
BRENNAN J
DEANE J
DAWSON J
TOOHEY J
GAUDRON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON TUESDAY, 3 MAY 1988, AT 10.19 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
| ClT2/l/MB | 1 | 3/5/88 |
MR J. BASTEN: If the Court pleases, I appear for the plaintiffs
in this matter. (instructed by Bernard D. Brassil& Co.)
MR G. GRIFFITHfi QC, Solicitor-General for the Corrnnonwealth:
If t e Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend,
MR A. ROBERTSON, for the defendants. (instructed by
the Australian Government Solicitor)
MR H.C. BERKELEY, QC, Solicitor-General for Victoria: If the
Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend,
MR H. REICHER, for the Attorney-General for the State
of Victoria. We intervene in the interests of the defendants. (instructed by the Crown Solicitor for Victoria)
MR J.J. DOYLE, QC, Solicitor-General for South Australia:
If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned
friend, MR. M. ~UINLAN, for the Attorney-General
for the State o South Australia, to intervene also
in the interests of the defendants. (instructed by
the Crown Solicitor for South Australia)
MR K. MASON QC, Solicitor-General for New South Wales:
If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend,
MR. R. SACKVILLE, for the Attorneys-General of
New South Wales and of Tasmania, and we intervene
to put submissions as to the invalidity of portions
of sections 22 and 23 of the AUSTRALIAN BICENTENNIAL
AUTHORITY ACT. (instructed by the Crown Solicitor for
New South Wales and the Crown Solicitor for Tasmania)
| MR G.L. DAVIES,QC: | May it please the Court, I appear with |
my learned friend, MRS M. WHITE, to intervene for
the Attorney-General for the State of Queensland
to give qualified support to the defendants in thematter. (instructed by the Crown Solicitor for
Queensland)
| MASON CJ: | Yes. | Mr Davies, can you enlighten us as to what |
qualified support means, in a succinct and brief
way?
| MR DAVIS: | Yes. | In a sentence it means that if, in fact, |
the formation and so on of the Bicentennial Authority
is necessary to enable the functions of government
to be carried on, it is incidental to the exercise
of the executive power and therefore within powerbut not otherwise, except to the extent that it can
be brought within some specific head such as
copyright and so on.
(Continued on page 2)
| ClT2/2/MB | 2 | 3/5/88 |
| Davis | ||
| MASON CJ: | Thank you. | Yes, Mr Bastin? |
| MR BASTEN: | Your Honour, may I hand up copies of an outline |
of argument. In doing so, may I apologize that
it is slightly longer than is usual, and may
I also say that I will not necessarily deal with the arguments in the order in which they are
dealt…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Davis & Ors v The Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1988] HCATrans 80
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court concerned the constitutional validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act, particularly sections 22 and 23, and the associated appropriations. The plaintiffs' standing to bring the action was also a relevant consideration. The Court was required to determine whether the Act and its appropriations fell within the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth, with interventions raising arguments about the incidental exercise of executive power and specific heads of constitutional power.
The Court was presented with arguments regarding the scope of Commonwealth legislative power, including the executive power and the ability to legislate for matters incidental to the exercise of governmental functions. The Solicitor-General for Queensland offered "qualified support" for the defendants, suggesting that the Authority's formation might be considered incidental to the exercise of executive power if necessary for the functions of government, but not otherwise, unless it could be brought within a specific head of power. The plaintiffs' immediate concern was with sections 22 and 23 of the Act, though their submissions indicated that the validity of these sections could impact the validity of the entire Act.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the High Court of Australia is an appeal from a demurrer decision made by Justice Sir Harry Gibbs. The plaintiffs, Louis Edward Davis, Allan Santo, and Ernie Creighton, are Aboriginal individuals who challenge the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980. Their primary focus is on sections 22 and 23 of the Act, which pertain to the protection of the name, symbol, and certain expressions significant to the Australian Bicentennial Authority. The plaintiffs argue that these sections grant the Authority monopolistic rights over common expressions in the English language and extend beyond the powers of the Commonwealth. The Commonwealth and the Australian Bicentennial Authority defend the Act, asserting that it is validly enacted under various constitutional powers, including the trade marks power, the territories power, and the corporations power. The matter has been narrowed to focus on the validity of sections 22 and 23 and the appropriation of funds to the Authority, with the broader validity of the Act being secondary. The plaintiffs also seek to challenge the appropriation of funds, arguing that it is not incidental to a valid legislative purpose. The Court has heard arguments on the standing of the plaintiffs to challenge the Act and the appropriation, with the defendants contending that the plaintiffs lack sufficient standing to bring the action. The Court will determine whether the plaintiffs have standing and, if so, whether the sections in question are valid under the Constitution. The defendants argue that the Act is incidental to the executive power of the Commonwealth and does not trespass into areas of State concern. The case involves complex constitutional questions regarding the scope of Commonwealth powers and the limits of executive power.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Commonwealth have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the trade marks power of the Constitution?
2. Does the Commonwealth have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the territories power of the Constitution?
3. Does the Commonwealth have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the corporations power of the Constitution?
4. Does the Commonwealth have an implied nationhood power that justifies the enactment of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980?
5. Does the Commonwealth have the power to appropriate moneys to the Australian Bicentennial Authority under section 81 of the Constitution?
6. Do the plaintiffs have standing to challenge the appropriation of moneys to the Australian Bicentennial Authority under section 81 of the Constitution?
7. Do the plaintiffs have standing to challenge the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 on the basis of their Aboriginal status?
8. Do the plaintiffs have standing to challenge the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 on the basis of their status as taxpayers?
9. Are sections 22 and 23 of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 severable from the rest of the Act?
10. Is there a limit to the scope of the "purposes of the Commonwealth" in section 81 of the Constitution, and if so, what are the implications for the validity of the appropriation to the Australian Bicentennial Authority?
11. Does the executive power of the Commonwealth, under section 61 of the Constitution, support the establishment and operation of the Australian Bicentennial Authority?
12. Are the plaintiffs' claims that sections 22 and 23 of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 are beyond power justiciable issues?
Held
1. The Commonwealth does not have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the trade marks power of the Constitution.
2. The Commonwealth does not have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the territories power of the Constitution.
3. The Commonwealth does not have the power to enact the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 under the corporations power of the Constitution.
4. The Commonwealth does not have an implied nationhood power that justifies the enactment of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980.
5. The Commonwealth has the power to appropriate moneys to the Australian Bicentennial Authority under section 81 of the Constitution.
6. The plaintiffs do not have standing to challenge the appropriation of moneys to the Australian Bicentennial Authority under section 81 of the Constitution.
7. The plaintiffs do not have standing to challenge the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 on the basis of their Aboriginal status.
8. The plaintiffs do not have standing to challenge the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 on the basis of their status as taxpayers.
9. Sections 22 and 23 of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 are not severable from the rest of the Act.
10. There is a limit to the scope of the "purposes of the Commonwealth" in section 81 of the Constitution, and the implication is that the appropriation to the Australian Bicentennial Authority is not valid.
11. The executive power of the Commonwealth, under section 61 of the Constitution, does not support the establishment and operation of the Australian Bicentennial Authority.
12. The plaintiffs' claims that sections 22 and 23 of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980 are beyond power are justiciable issues.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The plaintiffs in Davis & Ors v The Commonwealth of Australia challenged the validity of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980, specifically sections 22 and 23, and the appropriation of moneys to the Authority under section 81 of the Constitution. The Court considered whether the Commonwealth had the power to enact the Act under the trade marks power, the corporations power, or the territories power of the Constitution. The Court also considered whether an implied nationhood power or the executive power could justify the Act.
The Court held that the Commonwealth did not have the power to enact the Act under the trade marks power as the prohibitions extended beyond the protection of trade marks. The Court held that the Commonwealth did not have the power to enact the Act under the corporations power as the Act was not sufficiently related to the characteristics of trading or financial corporations. The Court also held that the Commonwealth did not have the power to enact the Act under the territories power as the sections went beyond a limited power to maintain a sufficient nexus with the Territory.
The Court rejected the argument that an implied nationhood power could justify the Act as there was no authority for such a power in internal matters. The Court also held that the executive power could not support the establishment and operation of the Authority as the Constitution's enumerated powers were limited. The Court found that sections 22 and 23 of the Act were not severable from the rest of the Act.
The Court held that there was a limit to the scope of the "purposes of the Commonwealth" in section 81 of the Constitution and that the appropriation to the Authority was beyond power. The Court also held that the plaintiffs had standing to challenge the appropriation of moneys to the Authority under section 81 of the Constitution as taxpayers. However, the Court held that the plaintiffs did not have standing to challenge the validity of the Act on the basis of their Aboriginal status or their status as taxpayers.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Commonwealth does not have an implied nationhood power that justifies the enactment of the Australian Bicentennial Authority Act 1980. The Court also held that the executive power of the Commonwealth, under section 61 of the Constitution, does not support the establishment and operation of the Australian Bicentennial Authority. Finally, the Court held that the plaintiffs' claims that sections 22 and 23 of the Act are beyond power are justiciable issues.
The Court distinguished prior authority on the question of standing to challenge the validity of an appropriation under section 81 of the Constitution. The Court held that a taxpayer or citizen may have standing to challenge the validity of an appropriation where there is a genuine issue to be determined by the court and if it were not otherwise subject to judicial review. The Court also distinguished prior authority on the question of whether the executive power could support the establishment and operation of the Authority. The Court held that the executive power could not support the Authority as it would result in an amorphous power that trespassed into areas of State concern.