Davies v Gertig No. Scciv-99-462

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

DAVIES v GERTIG
[2001] SASC 290

Civil

  1. PERRY J.

    Background
    The Accident Injuries
    The Course of the Trial and Findings as to Credit
    Sale of Business
    Other Financial Dealings Post-Accident
    Loss of Earning Capacity

    (a)      Pre-Judgment

    (b)      Future Loss of Earning Capacity

    Voluntary Services
    Special Damages
    Non-Economic Loss

    Conclusion

  2. The plaintiff claims damages for injuries suffered by him in a road accident which occurred on 5 May 1996. The plaintiff was riding his motor cycle on the Greenock to Nuriootpa Road at Nuriootpa when it came into collision with an oncoming motor car. The defendant admitted liability, and the trial proceeded as an assessment of damages.

    Background

  3. The plaintiff, whose date of birth is 22 April 1967, was a little over 29 years of age when the accident occurred. He was born in England and came to Australia at the age of 7 years. The plaintiff’s family settled in Whyalla, where he attended primary school and high school. Before completing year 12 he took up an apprenticeship with an electrical contractor at Whyalla. The apprenticeship ran for four years, following which the plaintiff qualified as an A-Class electrician.

  4. He then came to Adelaide and obtained a job with Wormald Fire Systems, installing fire detectors in buildings. After spending some time for that firm at Roxby Downs, he obtained another job in Adelaide with a firm which specialised in the installation of air conditioning systems. Following that he obtained a position as leading hand/foreman with Mayfields on the Myer site.

  5. When that project finished, the plaintiff decided to branch out on his own. He purchased and fitted out his own van, and advertised for work on his own account. This was in about 1990. Thereafter he carried on business under the name “Davies Electrical”.

  6. The plaintiff was hard working and quickly built the business up. At first, the main area of work was domestic, including re-wiring houses, installation of power points and the like. Eventually he attracted industrial work. BankSA became his main customer. The property department of the bank developed an arrangement with him whereby, more or less on call, he would attend at any of their branches to perform break-down and maintenance work. He had a similar relationship with a number of other business houses.

  7. The plaintiff was prepared to put in long hours, and according to his evidence, the work “snowballed”.

  8. As a sideline, the plaintiff became interested in buying properties to develop for re-sale. He first bought a property, with that in mind, at 17 King Street, Glandore, in October 1991. He lived in the house and embarked on major renovations which he largely performed himself. Within a year or two he was advised to form a family trust, and he held that, and eventually other properties, through the trust.

  9. The major part of the renovation of the Glandore house was completed by the time of the accident.

  10. Before the accident occurred, the plaintiff bought a second investment property, at 9 King Street, Glandore. His parents occupied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davies v Gertig No. Scciv-99-462 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 290
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Davies, the plaintiff, sought damages for injuries sustained in a road accident on May 5, 1996. The defendant admitted liability for the accident, which occurred when the plaintiff's motorcycle collided with an oncoming car on the Greenock to Nuriootpa Road at Nuriootpa. The trial was conducted to assess the extent of the damages. The plaintiff, born on April 22, 1967, was approximately 29 years old at the time of the accident. He had a background in electrical work and had established his own electrical business, Davies Electrical, around 1990. The plaintiff also engaged in property development as a sideline, owning several properties through a family trust.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine the appropriate amount of damages to award the plaintiff, considering both economic and non-economic losses. The court had to assess the extent of the plaintiff's pre- and post-judgment loss of earning capacity, unpaid special damages, and voluntary services. The court also needed to decide on the appropriate multiplier for non-economic loss based on the severity and impact of the injuries.

The court determined that the appropriate multiplier for non-economic loss was 20, resulting in an allowance of $30,400. This decision was guided by several precedent cases that provided a framework for assessing similar damages. The court further assessed the plaintiff's pre-judgment loss of earning capacity at $115,000 and post-judgment loss of earning capacity at $225,000. Additionally, the court considered unpaid special damages amounting to $1,224.30 and voluntary services valued at $2,500. After deducting pre-payments of $60,000, the total net judgment awarded to the plaintiff was $314,124.30. The court directed that judgment be entered for the plaintiff against the defendant in this sum and indicated that it would hear the parties regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff claims damages for injuries suffered by him in a road accident which occurred on 5 May 1996. The plaintiff was riding his motor cycle on the Greenock to Nuriootpa Road at Nuriootpa when it came into collision with an oncoming motor car. The defendant admitted liability, and the trial proceeded as an assessment of damages.Background The plaintiff, whose date of birth is 22 April 1967, was a little over 29 years of age when the accident occurred. He was born in England and came to Australia at the age of 7 years. The plaintiff’s family settled in Whyalla, where he attended primary school and high school. Before completing year 12 he took up an apprenticeship with an electrical contractor at Whyalla. The apprenticeship ran for four years, following which the plaintiff qualified as an A-Class electrician. He then came to Adelaide and obtained a job with Wormald Fire Systems, installing fire detectors in buildings. After spending some time for that firm at Roxby Downs, he obtained another job in Adelaide with a firm which specialised in the installation of air conditioning systems. Following that he obtained a position as leading hand/foreman with Mayfields on the Myer site. When that project finished, the plaintiff decided to branch out on his own. He purchased and fitted out his own van, and advertised for work on his own account. This was in about 1990. Thereafter he carried on business under the name “Davies Electrical”. The plaintiff was hard working and quickly built the business up. At first, the main area of work was domestic, including re-wiring houses, installation of power points and the like. Eventually he attracted industrial work. BankSA became his main customer. The property department of the bank developed an arrangement with him whereby, more or less on call, he would attend at any of their branches to perform break-down and maintenance work. He had a similar relationship with a number of other business houses. The plaintiff was prepared to put in long hours, and according to his evidence, the work “snowballed”. As a sideline, the plaintiff became interested in buying properties to develop for re-sale. He first bought a property, with that in mind, at 17 King Street, Glandore, in October 1991. He lived in the house and embarked on major renovations which he largely performed himself. Within a year or two he was advised to form a family trust, and he held that, and eventually other properties, through the trust. The major part of the renovation of the Glandore house was completed by the time of the accident. Before the accident occurred, the plaintiff bought a second investment property, at 9 King Street, Glandore. His parents occupied that house while he renovated it. As his electrical business expanded, he changed accountants and engaged Mr Leslie Jamieson. Initially, Mr Jamieson practised under the name Unité Accounting System, which later became Adelaide Accounting Services. On Mr Jamieson’s advice, the plaintiff incorporated a proprietary company, Davies Electrical Pty Ltd, which conducted the electrical business and became trustee of the family trust.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J
In my opinion, it is appropriate to assign the number 20.[3] The multiplier has been agreed at $1,520. This means that the allowance for non-economic loss should be $30,400.[3] In arriving at this figure, I have had regard to the following cases, not because they are necessarily comparable, but as a guide to the approach to be taken: Devlin v Simcock (2000) 207 LSJS 416; Goonan v Fitzgerald (2000) 207 LSJS 14; Stewart v Jacobsen (No 1) (1999) 202 LSJS 492; O’Reilly v Wilkinson (1999) 201 LSJS 480; Hastings v Fanning (1998) 201 LSJS 26; Panagaris v Chinner (1997) 190 LSJS 336; Murray v Dawson (1995) 184 LSJS 213; Barraza v Birtwistle (1995) 183 LSJS 493; Laparidis v Yates (1994) 179 LSJS 347.Conclusion$Non-Economic Loss 30,400.00Economic Loss: Pre-judgment loss of earning capacity 115,000.00 Post-judgment loss of earning capacity 225,000.00Voluntary Services 2,500.00Unpaid Special Damages 1,224.30 ---------------- $374,124.30Counsel agree that the two advances,each of $30,000 should be deducted 60,000.00 ---------------Net Judgment $314,124.30 ========= I assess damages including interest but less pre-payments in the total sum of $314,124.30, and direct that judgment be entered for the plaintiff against the defendant in that sum. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J

Full text does not contain this section.