Davies v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

DAVIES v COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

[2025] SASCA 12

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  (ex tempore)

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice S Doyle and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

4 February 2025

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

COURTS AND JUDGES - JUDGES - POWERS AND DUTIES IN RESPECT OF UNREPRESENTED LITIGANTS

The appellant (Mr Davies) commenced proceedings against the respondent (the Bank) in June 2023 seeking relief in relation to the Bank’s possession and sale of a property that Mr Davies had owned with his now deceased wife.  The Bank sought summary judgment, relying upon a deed of settlement and limitation periods which it argued barred Mr Davies’ claims. The primary judge granted the Bank’s application and ordered summary judgment in its favour.

Mr Davies appeals the primary judge’s decision.  He relies upon several grounds of appeal which challenge the Bank’s conduct both in relation to its possession and sale of the property, and in reliance upon the deed of settlement.

Held, per the Court, dismissing the appeal:

1.The appellant has not identified any error in the reasons or conclusion reached by the primary judge.

Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 131.1(5), 144.2(2)(a), referred to.
Atkins v Hughes [2019] SASCFC 49; Reid v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (2022) 109 NSWLR 149; Tomasevic v Travaglini (2007) 17 VR 100; UBS AG v Tyne (2018) 265 CLR 77; Zhengtang Precinct Loft Pty Ltd v The Corporation of the City of Adelaide [2024] SASCA 148, considered.

DAVIES v COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA
[2025] SASCA 12

Court of Appeal – Civil:  Livesey P, S Doyle and Bleby JJA

  1. THE COURT (ex-tempore):     The appellant (Mr Davies) commenced proceedings against the respondent (the Bank) in June 2023 seeking relief in relation to the Bank’s possession and sale of a property that Mr Davies had owned with his now deceased wife.  The Bank sought summary judgment, relying upon a deed of settlement and limitation periods which it argued barred Mr Davies’ claims.  The primary judge granted the Bank’s application and ordered summary judgment in its favour.

  2. Mr Davies appeals that decision.  He relies upon several grounds of appeal which challenge the Bank’s conduct both in relation to its possession and sale of the property, and in reliance upon the deed of settlement.

  3. For the reasons which follow, the appeal should be dismissed. The submissions of Mr Davies seek impermissibly to raise matters not agitated below.  In any event, the matters sought to be raised would be barred by the release in the deed of settlement, and Mr Davies has not otherwise identified any error in the reasons or conclusion reached by the primary judge.

    Background

  4. Mr Davies and his wife were the registered proprietors of a property at Quinns Road, Forreston, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davies v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned proceedings in the Supreme Court of South Australia where Mr Davies sought to bring claims against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. These claims related to the Bank's conduct as mortgagee in possession and its exercise of the power of sale over a property owned by Mr Davies and his wife. The Bank had previously obtained possession of the property and sold it, resulting in a shortfall on the mortgage debt. Mr Davies alleged the Bank had breached its duties, engaged in misconduct, and sold the property for significantly less than its true value.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Mr Davies' claims were valid and could proceed, or if they were barred by a prior settlement. Specifically, the court had to determine if a settlement deed, entered into by Mr Davies, his wife, and the Bank, effectively released the Bank from the claims Mr Davies was now attempting to pursue. The court also considered whether the Bank was entitled to summary judgment on the basis that Mr Davies' claims had no reasonable prospect of success.

The court reasoned that the District Court proceedings, which raised substantially similar allegations to those in the Supreme Court, had been resolved by a settlement deed. This deed contained mutual releases, including a release of all claims relating to the District Court proceedings. The primary judge found that Mr Davies had been represented by counsel during the mediation and at the time of signing the settlement deed, and there was no evidence of unlawful or improper conduct by legal representatives or the Bank. Consequently, the settlement deed stood as a bar to Mr Davies' current claims, as he had not demonstrated any grounds for setting it aside.

The appeal was dismissed. The court concluded that the settlement deed was a valid and binding agreement that precluded Mr Davies from re-litigating the issues covered by the release. Therefore, his claims in the Supreme Court proceedings had no reasonable prospect of success, and summary judgment in favour of the Bank was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the appeal should be dismissed. The submissions of Mr Davies seek impermissibly to raise matters not agitated below. In any event, the matters sought to be raised would be barred by the release in the deed of settlement, and Mr Davies has not otherwise identified any error in the reasons or conclusion reached by the primary judge.Background Mr Davies and his wife were the registered proprietors of a property at Quinns Road, Forreston, in South Australia (the Property). The Property was subject to a mortgage in favour of the Bank. Mr Davies and his wife fell behind in their mortgage payments and, in 2010, the Bank commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court seeking possession of the Property. The Bank obtained an order for possession, and subsequently obtained a warrant for possession. The Bank took possession of the Property in March 2012, and sold it in December 2012. The proceeds from the sale of the Property were not sufficient to discharge the amount owing under the mortgage (and related loan agreements), resulting in a shortfall of approximately $357,000.[1][1] Respondent’s submissions; cf the figure of approximately $394,000 specified in the applicant’s submissions and the pleaded counterclaim. In 2018, Mr Davies and his wife commenced proceedings in the District Court against the Bank (the District Court proceedings). In those proceedings, Mr Davies and his wife sought equitable compensation and damages from the Bank for alleged breaches of its duties as mortgagee in possession (and exercising its power of sale), and other misconduct. The Bank filed a defence in which it denied the alleged breaches and other misconduct, and counterclaimed for the shortfall mentioned above. The central allegations against the Bank in the District Court proceedings were that the Bank had: unlawfully taken possession of the Property; failed to properly market the Property for sale; sold the Property for less than its true value; engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and/or acted unconscionably in its conduct, including in taking possession of the Property; and sold the Property for $740,000 when its true value was between $1.4 million and $1.5 million, causing Mr Davies and his wife to suffer losses of $760,000. Mr Davies and his wife were represented by solicitors in the District Court proceedings. The parties to the District Court proceedings attended court mediations on 23 September 2019 and 7 July 2020. At the second of these mediations, Mr Davies and his wife were represented by counsel. As reflected in the record of outcome, the parties resolved the District Court proceedings, and a formal deed was to be prepared and signed. A settlement deed was signed by Mr Davies, his wife and the Bank (the settlement deed). The settlement deed was not dated, but was signed by around 20 July 2020. Amongst other things, the settlement deed contained mutual releases, including in respect of the Bank’s claim for the shortfall; required the Bank to pay Mr Davies and his wife $7,500; and required the parties to discontinue their claims in the District Court proceedings. Notices of discontinuance were subsequently filed. The settlement deed also contained a warranty from Mr Davies and his wife that they had received independent legal advice in relation to the District Court proceedings, the mediation, the settlement deed and in relation to the dealings between the parties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Davies filed an amended statement of claim prior to the fifth directions hearing. At that directions hearing, the Bank’s application for summary judgment was timetabled for argument. Mr Davies subsequently filed an affidavit in response to the Bank’s application, and in support of an application to set aside the settlement deed.The primary judge’s decision On 30 April 2024, the primary judge heard argument and granted the Bank’s application, ordering summary judgment in favour of the Bank pursuant to r 144.2(2)(a) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA). In his ex tempore reasons, the primary judge explained that the Bank’s position was that there was no reasonable basis for the prosecution of Mr Davies’ claim. The Bank also argued that, in seeking the various forms of relief sought, Mr Davies’ claim was out of time and no basis was disclosed for the Court to exercise any discretion to extend time. In addressing the lack of merit in Mr Davies’ claim in the Supreme Court proceedings, the primary judge explained that it sought to raise matters which largely replicated the matters raised in the earlier District Court proceedings. Further, as the judge explained, those earlier proceedings had been resolved through mediation and entry into the settlement deed. Clause 3 of the settlement deed recorded that the applicant released and discharged the Bank from all actions, suits, claims, demands and liabilities relating directly or indirectly to the District Court proceedings. The judge noted that Mr Davies was represented by counsel throughout the course of the mediation process and the subsequent execution of the settlement deed. The judge concluded that the settlement deed stood as a bar to Mr Davies’ claims in the Supreme Court proceedings, and justified an order for summary judgment in the Bank’s favour:As I informed the applicant, in the course of argument, in circumstances where a party enters into a properly constituted deed, the party will be bound by the matters agreed to in the deed, absent any suggestion of unlawful or improper behaviour on the part of the legal representatives of the parties or, indeed, the other party to the deed.The applicant’s claim in this proceeding, paragraph 1.10, adverts to ‘setting aside the deed of settlement’. However, during the course of his submissions Mr Davies made no complaint to suggest that any of the matters which the courts have acknowledged could lead to the setting aside of a deed, existed in the circumstances of the execution of the deed in question. In short, he did not suggest, for example, that he did not understand what he was signing or that he was misled about the deed by the bank or the respective legal representatives. As I also have explained to the applicant, the courts have, for decades, determined to uphold deeds of this nature where they have been properly entered into and have ‘set their face’ against the re-litigation or re-agitation of claims where a properly constituted deed seeks to resolve all issues between the parties.In my view the respondent’s claim for summary judgment is made out on the basis that the deed as executed stands as a bar to future proceedings and means that there is no reasonable basis for the court to conclude that a successful prosecution of the applicant’s claim can occur.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established